Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

Posts

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

#26

PARANOID?

robert davis

>

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

#27

Re:ET- quit biting that lead bullet, or....

Jamie Donaldson

>.. after you bleed to death you'll have lead poisoning! Use CA glue to stop the bleeding instead!

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

#28

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

C.W.Stivison

>John,

I just purchased a copy of Fine Woodworking, Woodturning basics, and it has a design in it to build a tool storage carosel and the tools sticking up. They must not be afraid of the police.

CW

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

#29

Barb Siddiqui

Jeez - you guys are being awful hard on

Barb Siddiqui

>some beginners who are "too stooopid to be in a wood shop." I'm a beginner, and I'd probably try something shown by an expert, as Bill G. did watching Raffan screw on a workpiece. After all, Bill did it, and bears the scar.

I don't think it is 'beginners' you should be aiming such criticism at, but rather, the whiners who can't take their lumps when they get beaned for trying something they're not ready for.

My whole woodworking education has been based on, 'Tell me and I might remember; show me and I'll never forget."

Keep on handing out the advice. It's up to the viewer to decide if he/she is ready to try it. And to wear a face shield (Bill.) ;-)

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

#30

Re: Jeez - you guys are being awful hard on

Ron in Drums PA

>I agree with you Barb, I'm still a beginner and more so when I tried Russ's technique.

Everybody has to start somewhere.

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

#31

Spindle Roughing Gouge!!!

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Russ,

You wrote:

"Even the AAW is trying to change the name of a perfectly good turning tool because it might be unsafe in the hands of some damn fool who shouldn't be trying to turn wood in the first place."

When I first heard about this so called "official name change" I was floored. I was seriously taken aback that someone was debating for the better part of a year on changing the name of a "Roughing Gouge" to "Spindle Roughing Gouge"!

I'm sorry, but if someone uses a roughing gouge on a bowl, and gets a huge catch that is their own damn fault. We shouldn't have to rename a tool that has been around longer than I want to think about just to be "safe".

Hey, I have an idea. Why not put disclaimers on ALL turning tools. Then we will can guarantee that no one will ever use a roughing gouge on a bowl. And if you believe that, Tinkerbell will be here in a minute to sprinkle pixie dust all over you so you can fly around the room!!!

This kinda stuff reminds me of the warning on the side of a lawn mower that says not to pick up this machine while it's running for the purposes of using it to trim hedges.

Whew, where's my high blood pressure medicine?

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

#32

Survival of the fitist should be allowed to work

John Veerkamp

>

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

#33

Re:Can't afford a silver one!. NM

ET

>

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

#34

Steven Antonucci

OT:Have you ever tried drinking McDonald's Coffee

steve antonucci

>as soon as they hand it to you? It's got to be like 400 degrees. I buy it and drink it an hour later so I don't scorch my tongue.

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

#35

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

DickAnderson

>It is very unfotunate that this politcal correctness has become the dumbing down of America by people abrogating personal responsibility and others deliberately trying to absolve people of their personal responsibilities.

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

#36

No. Simply annoyed.

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

#37

Keith Tompkins

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

keith tompkins

>Russ, I remember the spindle turning incident well....it was enough to make you resign as moderator.

You probably remember my design incident as well....the emails I recieved in that case were, well....ultimately enough to make me resign as moderator as well.

I now must think twice before contributing anything to any online site.

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

#38

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

>In my day job, I install, wire, program, and write the manuals for gas-fired kilns that can go "BOOM" in the night. All manuals are tested with totally untrained operators. Any new operators read the manuals, are trained, and tested. They then have to sign a document saying that they have been trained and tested. Any problems we have ever had are because they did not follow the instructions.

We have raised a generation of functional, illiterate, idiots that have never been held accountable for anything. Sooner or later they must grow up and realize that mistakes COST and KILL! I have stopped posting to electrical questions because I have seen so many simple things get totally screwed up on the web.

Bill

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

#39

Re: Spindle Roughing Gouge!!!

Bill Neddow

>Domenic, I agree with you. I could not believe people were spending so much time debating changing the name of a roughing gouge to a spindle roughing gouge.

The problem with the tool is the damn fool rat tail tine. I have seen more of these bent spindle turning than I ever have seen bent doing anything else. Even Mike Darlow has pointed out this design fault in various articles he has written. At a Darlow seminar recently, he mentioned that some years ago he bent two roughing gouges while spindle turning -- both made by the same manufacturer. He complained. They replaced the two tools, but the replacements had exactly the same design flaw -- and the manufacturer continued making the tools with this design flaw.

In the old days when roughing gouges were hand forged, most of the tines were a little thicker. It was hand forged and worked, and the blacksmith could "beef up" the weak spot. Now they are simply stamped out of a flat piece of steel and the weak spot has been enhanced.

The flaw is in the tool, not the name. Beef up the tine. If the gouge was an electrical device and there was a flaw in it that injured people, they would be fixing the flaw, not playing with the name. Can it be fixed? P&N has done it -- and at a reasonable price.

I spent 30 years in public relations and saw hundreds of attempts to "fix" problems by changing names rather than fixing the device. It never worked. Yet, people never learn.

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

#40

Re: LOL, Terry!!!

Allen Neighbors

>

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

#41

Indeed. Well said!

nailshooter

>>>We have raised a generation of functional, illiterate, idiots that >>have never been held accountable for anything.

And what generation failed this legion of idiots? Who are their fathers, mothers, grandfathers, and grandmothers? Which generation of family dropped the ball completely that has given us the losers?

I am wondering what generation failed their children and in turn their grandchildren by raising these "illiterate idiots" that are nothing but a danger to themselves and others.

Should you feel the need to castigate a whole generation or two, look hard to see where that generation has its roots. The generation of parents and grandparents that raised those losers should be held equally accountable for their failures as teachers and leaders.

I couldn't agree with you more.

Robert

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

#42

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

Bill Grumbine

>I must be doing something wrong then, because the only nasty emails I get are when I say something about politics or religion, and I don't even get many of them!

Bill

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

#43

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

Bill Neddow

>Bill, what fool is going to argue with you? You might just wrap your little finger around his neck and ask him, politely, what he really means! :-)))))

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

#44

ROTFLOL!!

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

#45

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

jeff myroup

>It is a shame that a few dictate the actions of many. It has always been the rebels, forward thinkers, and visionaries that drive any endevor forward. I am pretty sure I am smart enough to know my limitaions. If I am trying a new technique, and screw up, I don't blame the website, photo, or the guy posting. I have done a few things that have resulted in other than optimal results. Its all part of the learning curve. It is time to put the PC police in the corner and carry on. This is not to say that safety is not important. It should be in the corner of everyones mind, but we can not be so paralized by safety that we don't move forward. I am sorry that a few of you, Russ, Keith etc. Have been forced to remove stuff from your sites. It is truely a loss to the majority of us who want to learn.

Jeff

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

#46

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

Bill Grumbine

>Jeff wrote:

It is time to put the PC police in the corner and carry on.

The problem is, they keep getting back out!

Bill, I am as meek and as mild and a newborn lamb! ;-)

Barb, I agree completely with you. We were all beginners at one time, and if we are going to try something, we need to take full responsibility for what happens next. However, I think it is incumbent on those who teach or want to teach to let those who are beginning know when they are demonstrating something that is a little more on the advanced side. When I was down in GA, I was doing a demo on natural edged bowls as part of an all day affair. I showed all my regular cuts, but then decided to show one more. I warned the people there that this was a difficult cut, and they should not try it at home until they had some serious experience and were fully away of the potential for drastic failure. It is a cut riding the left hand side of the bevel down along the inside of the bowl. One lady taking notes announced she was writing, DANGEROUS, do not do! That was it. Now I call it the DANGEROUS cut, when I demo it, and from time to time I also demo how it can go wrong. (hee hee hee)

Bill

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

#47

Bill, that is my favorite cut

TDaniel

>but the problem is many people put to vertical an angle on the side grind of the gouge and it will not work if the cutting edge contact point is above the centerline (axis) of the tool. It is difficult enough to explain this cut in person...much less in writing. I just show them that it can be done and tell them that it can be dangerous and when they think they are ready to try it they should slow the lathe way down and practice by taking super light cuts until they get the hang of it.....that way they will not be in my class when things don't work. It is a cut that I learned on my own and had never seen anyone do it and I have no idea why I started doing it but it really works well when you get the hang of it (no pun intended).

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

#48

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

Don Orr

>Another interesting, and sadly, controversial topic. It's too bad we have come to a place where PC and CYA is more important than COMMON SENSE! Maybe if we didn't put the warnings on electric hair dryers about not using them in the shower or on the mowers about not picking them up to trim hedges, we could get rid of some of the idiots causing these problems. Disclaimer-I am not advocating causing harm to anyone for any reason in any way, shape or form.

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

#49

Re: Common sense is not common these days!

Jamie Donaldson

>

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

#50

Mostly because we don't let Darwinism take over.

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>