Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police
Bill Grumbine
>Russ, I show all kinds of stuff with the disclaimer, DON'T TRY THIS AT HOME! But, I agree with Wally, that there are times when we need to be careful, especially here on the web. We don't know who is watching and thinking they can do it because they read about it.
I had an X shaped scar right between my eyes for years because I watched Richard Raffan thread a piece of wood onto a screw chuck on a spinning lathe. I wathced him do it, and not knowing enough to know better, I went right to the lathe and tried it. The wood spun on, it spun off, and smacked me right between the eyes, bending my wire frame glasses, thus causing the X between the wood and the wire. The only person I blamed was myself. I did not track down Richard Raffan, or call up Taunton to complain. I realized very quickly that just because someone else could do it didn't mean that I could or should, at least until I learned more.
This is the crux of the matter. In years gone by, people were taught in schools, or apprenticed. Today it is buy a bunch of tools, go home, and start in on your own. I can't tell you how many people have written me to tell me they are doing it just like I showed them on the video and they still aren't getting it. Well it turns out that they aren't doing it just like I did on the video for whatever reason. Many times it is just a minor adjustment to what they are doing, but the fact remains that any medium of communication is a lesser substitute for being there in person and having an experienced turner there to watch over you.
There is a guy who preaches the use of a roughing gouge on bowls. You can do it, I can do it, Wally can do it, and many experienced people here can do it. The problem is, lots of people can't, and don't even know what to watch for or how to present it to the wood properly. I even managed to break my own last year, on a spindle no less! But people just starting out are not going to be able to do it, and there is great potential for hurting themselves.
The same thing goes for using your fingers as a steady. I do it all the time on spindle work. I even demo it for classes. I think you should be able to show these techniques along with the caveat of knowing when and when not to try them. Unfortunately, there are too many morons who want to blame you, me, or anyone else handy for their own stupidity, not to mention the nannies who shake their fingers and scowl at us for daring to teach something that might get someone hurt.
I don't know where the happy medium lies. I tend to ignore the whining that goes on, public or private. Well, I don't really ignore it, I usually tell the whiner to get lost, but that is just my personality type showing through. But I do tend to temper some of what I show here on the web with the realization that there is often no limit to the amount of stupidity some people are capable of. It reminds me of a line from an old Clint Eastwood movie - "A man's got to know his limitations." If more people would worry about their own limitations and take responsibility for them, the rest of us could be a lot more free and relaxed about showing what we know.
Bill