Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

Posts

Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

#1

Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

Russ Fairfield

>Keith just brought up a problem with this and every other woodturning site in this modern era of "political correctness". We find the good woodturners having to go out of their way to make sure that they do everything possible to protect everyone from themselves. And that means not talking about sharp tools in specific terms for fear that someone will cut themselves.

They can't describe, and Heaven forbid that they post a picture of an age-old woodturning technique because it might be dangerous. Even worse, they might show how to use a turning tool for something other than its "politically correct" use. Keith or John using a skew on the foot of a bowl would surly bring out the PC Police in force. I was in their sights a couple years ago, and I will never forget the private e-mails I received, all because I dared to post a photo of using my fingers as a steady rest for turning a slender spindle. You got my attention. I deleted the photo and have never posted another photo or description of using a turning tool. Even the AAW is trying to change the name of a perfectly good turning tool because it might be unsafe in the hands of some damn fool who shouldn't be trying to turn wood in the first place.

All I have to say is, LIGHTEN UP, FOLKS. You are missing out on a lot of woodturning education; and you will never advance past being a beginner when you make folks like Keith and John afraid to describe the advanced techniques that will get you there.

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

#2

Agree! Pretty soon you won't even be able to....

Ruth Niles

>use a carving knife in the kitchen without a signed consent form in triplicate! The world is getting dumber and dumber. If you pick up a skew and can't see the "hurt" possibilities, something is wrong.

Darrell Feltmate said it best years ago: (paraphrased) "we put a 50 lb. hunk of wood on a lathe, spin it at 3 miles per hour and poke a sharp pointed tool in it"!

Not just "LIGHTEN UP, FOLKS", rather GET REAL!

Safety, YES. Awareness, YES. Caution, YES. Just like when you're driving a car on an Interstate!!

In Russ's defense with supporting the spindle with his fingers, thousands of turners do that, it's just the way it's done. I've always done it. Watch any video about turning thin bowls and you will see the turner hold his hand on the outside of the bowl for support while using a sharp, pointed, dangerous, killer tool on the inside.

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

#3

Re: Agree! Pretty soon you won't even be able to..

Sean Troy

>Sadly, this is not going to change or go away. There is a whole generation that can't think for themselves and expect everyone else to do it for them. I'm not sure how some of these people even breath.You can see it everywhere you look in todays society.

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

#4

I call it the "softening of America"

Eddie Pacheco, San Jose, Ca.

>I can see how giving electrical information over the internet can be dangerous if not lethal. Turning information,and the photos of a tool in use, on a turning forum shouldn't pick up any heat.

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

#5

I Agree....But.....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I agree with what has been said here, but...Most any experienced turner has tools and uses techniques in his own shop that they probably shouldn't use in a demonstration to an audience of mostly beginners. In a class of advanced turners I would show some of my time-tested methods that I would never show to a class of beginners, because used by a beginner it wouldn't be safe. I agree that in the hands of an experienced turner who knows almost instictively what is truly unsafe, the much discussed roughing tool is okay to use in bowl turning. But, as long as that tool has that very weak tang, it is unsafe to be used by the inexperienced turner on bowls. I have seen several that were bent almost double after being improperly used. An acquaintance ended up in the ER when the tang broke through the handle and injured him.

We have hundred of turners of all skill levels who read the posts on this forum. I feel that we do have to be careful not to push tools and technniques that would be safe for some but not for others.

Wally

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

#6

Steven Antonucci

Not sure what are the legal ramifications of this?

steve antonucci

>If someone reads content on any website that explains how someone does something (regardless of topic), can the original content provider be held liable (as well as the host site and the ISP?) if the reader does something stupid?

I can't imagine that there could be any liability from the original content writer. If there was, no one would be able to write about any process or operation in any capacity without opening themselves up to massive liability.

Even if you don't use the "magic language"- disclaimers, YMMV, etc., I'd have to say that I'm still guessing that you'd be Ok. Because I show you how I use a tool does not mean I recommend that you do the same, nor do I expect that the law would take your side if you chose to do so of your own free will.

I think PC isn't necessarily applicable here- and I don't suggest that we close the doors of sharing information for fear of repercussions.

Steven

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

#7

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi Russ,

No Kidding. When you think of all the variables involved in getting a techique just right, the one with the highest variation and oppertunity for failure is the person holding the tool....and often it's not the technique as much as it's the blind faith they "think" they know what they are doing. There is something to be said for pratice before you put the "Money Wood" on the lathe.

I will never condem some one for trying, making the effort to TRY is what helps any one learn and I applaude that effort no matter what the result, shooting from an arm chair is a spectator sport.

Take care,

Jim

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

#8

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

Ron in Drums PA

>I remember that photo, I've used that technique since, Thanks Russ!

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

#9

Mike Stafford

Are disclaimers necessary?

Mike Stafford

>Are we going to have say something like "Skill levels vary with the experience of each turner. The author cannot accept legal responsibility for any consequences arising from the application of any information, advice, pictures or instructions in this posting."

I think the most important thing Russ said is "some dang fool who shouldn't be trying to turn wood in the first place."

You cannot protect people from themselves. If people make no efforts to learn a little about something they wish to undertake it is their fault when things go wrong. And go wrong they will...Every person who has worked with a table saw, a band saw, a lathe or any other power tool for an extended length of time has learned how quickly you can be hurt. It takes years of experience and practice to be able to things as well as some of the turners you see on this and other websites.

I shudder every time I read, and I frequently do read it, that people are using a roughing gouge on bowls because they are "roughing down a bowl". Is it any wonder that the turning catalogs now say "Not to be used on bowls"?

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

#10

Just to be pedantic...

wilbur

>...what you are describing is not "political correctness". Political correctness refers to going to great lengths to use "non-insulting" language to avoid offense to groups who might take offense at the use of such language.

The behavior you are describing is meant to avoid being sued by someone with a lawyer and too much time on their hands. There should be a term for this, but in my day job (pediatric oncologist), we call it "defensive medicine" -- ordering of unnecessary tests and procedures so that we can say we covered all possibilities. (Actually, it's not the possibilities that are being covered, if you know what I mean, and I think you do.)

Having said that, I like to think that I don't engage in defensive medicine -- just good medicine. But I tend to use "politically correct" language. Why not? It makes someone else feel better with no effort on my part, like remembering to say "please" and "thank you".

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

#11

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

Bill Grumbine

>Russ, I show all kinds of stuff with the disclaimer, DON'T TRY THIS AT HOME! But, I agree with Wally, that there are times when we need to be careful, especially here on the web. We don't know who is watching and thinking they can do it because they read about it.

I had an X shaped scar right between my eyes for years because I watched Richard Raffan thread a piece of wood onto a screw chuck on a spinning lathe. I wathced him do it, and not knowing enough to know better, I went right to the lathe and tried it. The wood spun on, it spun off, and smacked me right between the eyes, bending my wire frame glasses, thus causing the X between the wood and the wire. The only person I blamed was myself. I did not track down Richard Raffan, or call up Taunton to complain. I realized very quickly that just because someone else could do it didn't mean that I could or should, at least until I learned more.

This is the crux of the matter. In years gone by, people were taught in schools, or apprenticed. Today it is buy a bunch of tools, go home, and start in on your own. I can't tell you how many people have written me to tell me they are doing it just like I showed them on the video and they still aren't getting it. Well it turns out that they aren't doing it just like I did on the video for whatever reason. Many times it is just a minor adjustment to what they are doing, but the fact remains that any medium of communication is a lesser substitute for being there in person and having an experienced turner there to watch over you.

There is a guy who preaches the use of a roughing gouge on bowls. You can do it, I can do it, Wally can do it, and many experienced people here can do it. The problem is, lots of people can't, and don't even know what to watch for or how to present it to the wood properly. I even managed to break my own last year, on a spindle no less! But people just starting out are not going to be able to do it, and there is great potential for hurting themselves.

The same thing goes for using your fingers as a steady. I do it all the time on spindle work. I even demo it for classes. I think you should be able to show these techniques along with the caveat of knowing when and when not to try them. Unfortunately, there are too many morons who want to blame you, me, or anyone else handy for their own stupidity, not to mention the nannies who shake their fingers and scowl at us for daring to teach something that might get someone hurt.

I don't know where the happy medium lies. I tend to ignore the whining that goes on, public or private. Well, I don't really ignore it, I usually tell the whiner to get lost, but that is just my personality type showing through. But I do tend to temper some of what I show here on the web with the realization that there is often no limit to the amount of stupidity some people are capable of. It reminds me of a line from an old Clint Eastwood movie - "A man's got to know his limitations." If more people would worry about their own limitations and take responsibility for them, the rest of us could be a lot more free and relaxed about showing what we know.

Bill

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

#12

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

Russ Fairfield

>When the experienced woodturners won't or are afraid to talk to each other, or share with the less experienced, this forum will be inhabited by nothing but beginners talking to each other about things they know nothing about.

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

#13

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

Don in Central Illinois

>You said "I can't tell you how many people have written me to tell me they are doing it just like I showed them on the video and they still aren't getting it." As I am learning I asked the instructor why I was always getting catches, because I was following his example and he told me very nicely, "You're doing it wrong." And then showed me the correct way. I still get them, just not as often.

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

#14

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

john lucas

>Wow interesting thread that got started while I was teaching a beginner how to hollow. I have a situation right now that is right up this alley. We (Carl, the AAW, Me and others on the board) got chewed out for publishing a tip on a tool storage bin where the points were up. Most turners I know store thier tools this way so you can easily identify which tool is which. I just got a great tip in the mail on tool storage. It's a really nice system, BUT, the points are up. I'm going to ask Carl about it but I'll guarantee they won't publish it.

I'll grant you it isn't the safest way to store tools but sometimes it's just a very good way and the operator of said storage bin is aware of the dangers.

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

#15

Re: Licencing Dangerous Hobbies

ET

>Liberal minded, we had better get the the Government to make a law types will have us applying for a "Sharp Tool Acqusition Certificate" or STAC. At least in Canada! ET

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

#16

It is already worse than you think!

Wilford Bickel

>I was in Bruce Bell's demonstrations at SSS this past April and he was using a special Supra bowl gouge. He made a point of telling us that it was not a P&N product and the only way to purchase it was directly from him. P&N used to make it under their trade name but one turner overhung the tool rest too far and snapped one. At that point P&N changed the way they cut it (still call the new shallower flute cut Supra) and Bruce stated he could not get the new flute to cut no matter what he did to it! He talked to P&N and they refused to change the flute back - they finally agreed to make the old fluted tool under Bruce Bell's name. I won't post here all Bruce said about a tool company changing a tool because of one person that should not be near a lathe!! I looked at both the new flute on one of the dealers tables and looked at the flute Bruce was selling - I saw immediately the problem and bought one of Bruce's and absolutely love it. How long before we cannot buy tools because of companies being fearful of lawsuits from people that don't belong in a wood shop???? How many of us would be as willing as Bruce Bell to put our name on a tool and take the responsibility for it to keep it on the market????

How many more tangs have to be bent and broken before the tool manufacturers quit making "Roughing" - "Spindle Roughing Gouges" because of mistakes made by beginners??? I do believe that we as experienced turners should do all we can to give warnings and proper instructions for tool usage - if we don't we may well be the losers when we can't buy tools!

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

#17

Re: Licencing Dangerous Hobbies

Bill Crommett

>Part of the learning proces we achieve on this forum are due to the pictures that are posted of bloody faces and black eyes and swollen and bandaged fingers. Anyone who can't learn something from those pics deserve to learn the hard way.

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

#18

Mine point up...

keith zimmerman, Normal, IL

>and it was MY decision to do it. The point-up orientation works best for me. No one suggested that I do it. It just seems efficient.

I have discovered how sharp the point of a skew is, so I know the possible dangers involved.

I do not recommend that other orient their turning tools with the points up.

keithz

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

#19

Re: I agree, Steve. I just say, "

Allen Neighbors

>Sue me. You can't get blood out of a turnip." In today's society, in nearly every walk of life, it seems like stupidity rules. And I believe most of it comes from those who have never had to toe the mark and think for themselves.

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

#20

Ric Taylor

Life is Too Short

Ric Taylor

>I just ignore the PC police and move on without them.

Ric

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

#21

Disclaimers?

Jimmy Edwards

>In this context-No

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

#22

I call it "Idiot Proofing"

Thad Parker

>It's this thing we do in Amercia b/c while someone may not be intelligent enough to assume coffee just poured from a pot will probably be hot enough to burn your skin, they are still bright enough to file a lawsuit blaming McD's for not telling them it's hot.

I love other cultures in the world that put telephone poles with-in reach of moving trains and still allow the windows to lower enough to put your body out of it...a non-idiot proof society you might call it.

~ Thad

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

#23

That is a good way to ......

TDaniel

>get ri of the idiots. Good concept; I like it.

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

#24

I think it is the SG, not the PC police

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>To me, politically correct is a term for a currently popular form of censorship.

The Safety Gestapo, as it is called in some places where people can speak freely, is an entirely different story. They seem to believe that: "No one should ever get hurt. Period."

They are the people that insist that tools be stored point down. A true safety person would recognize that this causes dulled tools which are a far greater safety risk.

It seems to boil down to people trying to deny a basic fact of life:

"Living is hazardous to your health and leads to death."

Re: Woodturning techniques and the PC Police

#25

Re:Point up...Point down

ET

>My toolrack holds my tools point down, But it is open at the bottom. I often slice some part of my anatomy open on one of the sharp ends. But I simply bite down hard on a bullit, tape it up with a bandage and soldier on.

"The inner artist must be released"

ET