Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

pricing question

Posts

pricing question

#1

pricing question

John Lucas

>I know pricing is all over the place and also depends on where you sell and what venue but for the sake of seeing how things sell around the country I thought I would post this little bowl and see what kind of prices you guys and gals would sell this for. Around here I might get $35on a good day. More than likely I'll have to ask $20. Burls sell better than most woods as far as price but If I turned a 12" burl bowl I would be hard pressed to get $70 for it and you know the price of burl stock. This little bowl was a limb knot that was given to me and I don't even know what kind of wood it is. It was an ugly little thing with a rotten limb imbedded in it. I looked at it for 6 months before deciding I could do something to salvage it. It's 4" by 2".


img

Re: pricing question

#2

better sizing photo 

John Lucas

>


img

Re: pricing question

#3

Re: pricing question

Steve Russell

>Hello John,

Pricing is a very difficult issue as you mentioned. I usually prefer not to comment as it's such a volatile issue with many turners and without actually seeing the piece it's difficult to say for sure. However, assuming it's a very high quality piece, I would sell it for $125.00 - $175.00. Perhaps more depending on the quality, the species, selling location and any marketable provenance of the piece.

As for a 12" burl bowl, I would charge $500.00 - $750.00 for typical examples with grade one artistic details. For a really fine example with grade five details, the price would range up to $2,500.00 give or take, depending on the complexity of the piece, the selling location and any marketable provenance, if any.

Twelve inch highly carved and or embellished/inlaid pieces (up to grade 10) would be priced according to species, complexity, amount and type of embellishments, detail level, marketable provenance if any and selling location and would be $5,000.00+ depending on the above factors. I hope this helps you a wee bit. Take care and all the best to you and yours!

Steve Russell

The Woodlands, Texas

Re: pricing question

#4

Re: pricing question

David Breth

>John -

I'm the guy who posted recently about completing his first craft show last weekend, so I'm definitely not the end all authority, but I'll share with you what I noticed. The pieces that had the most fingerprints, going away, were three pieces of willow burl that were similar to what you are showing, except maybe a third larger, and with bark still attached. The idea is the same though - missing edges, small burly pieces with inclusions, etc. I actually had four. One sold to a friend prior to the show for the #1 fan-of-my-work rate of $15. I would have gone lower for her except she would have fought me about the favoritism. Two at the show sold for $22 and I think $18, maybe $15. The best one of the bunch, and it was the best one by a longshot, was priced at $30. That one didn't sell (and now has a permanent spot on my shelf). For this market, I think I came up with appropriate prices for those pieces. They sold during the course of the show, and I was able to see slighly above the market ceiling with the one really good piece.

In this area (Buffalo, NY) I think you would own even a phenomenal piece of burl for a very long time before you found someone ready to go $500+ for it. Maybe I'm wrong, but that concern is the reason that I would only turn burl if I found it, traded for it, or was given it. The cost of the bare wood could put you behind the market-price curve before you ever touched it with a tool. I know other areas of the country are way different, and maybe I underestimate what the art-savvy population will spend for such a piece, but I just don't see liquidating something like that very quickly around here.

David B.

Re: pricing question

#5

Brad Vietje

Re: pricing question

Brad Vietje

>HI Folks,

The problems with pricing seem magnified when burls are involved, since they are highly variable in look, feel and quality, and each burl is unique.

Burl bowls probably sell better in a higher-end craft of art gallery that has established a reputation for finely handcrafted work, and somewhat higher price points. It would HAVE to be a place with a good jury process to insure high-level work which will attract a crowd that will pay for fine work. I often think in terms of $'s per inch, with some accommodations for natural edges, burls, and spectacular work or wood.

For example, let's say well made Cherry bowls sell for a nice round number like $10/inch, which you can adjust as you gain experience or reputation, and might be a different price for different size ranges, say, $12/inch for 13" - 20" bowls, or $15/inch for over 20"... Then a 10" bowl would be $100. You could add 50% for natural edge bowls, another 25% for intact bark, 20% for really thin or delicate, and so on. I typically add 50% - 100% for burl bowls, and for really spectacular or really large burls, I add some factor that attempts to address the rarity of the stock, or a gut feeling about just how great a job the turning was. Sometimes this is experience, and sometimes dumb luck -- like a void included or avoided (some of which IS experience).

The fudge factor for a spectacular bowl really comes down to subjective, gut feelings you have for your little wooden baby: what would I have to pay you to take this one home ? Maybe you don't really want to part with this one here, maybe its your all-time favorite. We should feel free to take a piece home and display or use it for our own pleasure once in a while, too. Once you sell it, you can't show it to people who want to see and touch your work -- and that has value, too.

As for John's bowl: I'd guess that around here that would sell for $65 - $85 with my name on it, since I'm no big deal, big-name turner, though others with a greater following could probably charge more. In the end, it really depends on where its offered for sale, who sees it, and how they react emotionally to it. I sold my favorite hollow form in a gallery a few years ago, and after they took their 40%, I felt like I didn't get all that much for a once-so-far-in-my-lifetime sorta piece. Even if I had gotten 80% or 100% of the selling price, I wish I still had that piece to show to people as an example of my work.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: pricing question

#6

Re: pricing question

TDaniel

>John, the market here is changing so rapidly that I cannot even guess the value of the piece, I don't know whether it is the high energy prices, the plant closings (Ford, GM, plus 2 military bases), or what but things are just not selling well now. Generally, small pieces sell better just before Christmas although that did not happen this past season. The way I price my work at shows is this:

I try to price 80% of my work at the amount that I think it is worth, then I price a couple of pieces about 25 or 30% less than I think they are worth, and I price a couple of pieces about 25-30% more than I think they are worth. Sometimes I get surprised. I have had shows where the overpriced pieces sold, I have also had shows that pieces priced way too cheap did not sell. Selling burl pieces in a gallery can be difficult because the cost of the burl can be such a large portion of the price, example: I buy a nice burl for $150. I spend a lot of time working with it to get the best form and grain orientation, then I spend a lot of time trying to pop the grain, then I spend a lot of time getting a perfect finish. This piece in a gallery might sell for $600. The gallery gets $240 to $300 and I get $300 to $360 minus my $150 that I paid for the burl so I end up with $150 to $200 profit for an awful lot of time and work. Because of this I try to sell all my burl pieces myself. I occasionally put a burl piece in a gallery but it ain't often.

Re: pricing question

#7

Re: pricing question

John Lucas

>Excellent responses. This is what I hoped to bring up. I know pricing is all over the place and we all have different formulas so it's quite interesting to see how other break it down. Steven is obviously in a different market than most of us which is cool. We all hope to get there some day. I'm going to put Brad's name on my piece so it will sell.:) Thanks TD. wonderful breakdown of the profit thing works, or doesn't work in some cases.

Re: pricing question

#8

Re: pricing question

Russ Fairfield

>My firt reaction was $600 in a gallery, but then I realized that it isn't 14" diameter. It is less than 4" diameter and that makes a difference. Of course it depends on your market, but I would price it at $60, but take $45 for it as it is. The price would go up to $150 if it was paper thin.

Something that is only 4" diameter is a tough one to sell, regardless of the figuring. Paper thin would be the attraction that would sell it at a higher price.

I never turn anything like this less than 12" diamater because I already have a shop full of small stuff that nobody wants. hey make nice gifts, but they are not something that is worth the time to make and sell.

Re: pricing question

#9

Re:In the middle market juried shows....

Jamie Donaldson

>.. that I do the price would be $60~$90 depending on several factors like burl, color, rarity, thinness, phase of the moon, etc!

Re: pricing question

#10

Re: Steve- please define your comments...

Jamie Donaldson

>.. regarding the grade 1~10 evaluations you mentioned. I've not heard this evaluation scale used before?

Re: pricing question

#11

Re: pricing question

Russ Fairfield

>Steve,

I don't know what you are selling and to whom, but your prices are so far off the chart of my experience that I cannot even imagine prices like that. I am not questioning that you are getting those prices, but man, I just gotta see it to believe it.

Re: pricing question

#12

Re: better sizing photo

Sean Troy

>I'd keep it. Not because it's not worthy of selling but because of the size. I love to keep the smaller turnings I make and place them in a glass cabinet I have in our family room.

Re: pricing question

#13

Steven Antonucci

Why is one bowl worth $40 and another worth $400?

steve antonucci

>It's not the name on the bottom, but rather something completely different.

It's the attitude of the turner.

If you think your work is worth $40, you're probably right. If you think it's worth $400, you're probably also right. Either way, someone somewhere will be willing to pay whatever you charge if they want it bad enough.

I bought 4 metal bowls at Ikea today for $7 or so each, and if I wanted plastic, they were $2. People buy these things because they want them, not because they need them. Disposable income needs to be marketed to - to get the buyer interested. Why does a big name turner get big $$$? Because they won't sell for small $$$.

Rather than spending time in the shop producing finer and finer work, why not spend time in marketing your work to a "better" audience? Just because I don't live by you doesn't make me a potential customer...

steven

Re: pricing question

#14

Keith Tompkins

Re: Why is one bowl worth $40 and another worth $4

keith tompkins

>Steve, I think you're partially right. You do need a bit of a cocky attitude...however, when showing your work to a gallery, you're liable to get one of two responses....After handling a piece or two, the gallery owner will smile and hand the piece back to you. Or, after a moment or two of reflection, may reply "OH MY GOD!"

With a response similar to the latter, your prices will go up very quickly. The first response has just the opposite effect.

Quality sells.

Re: pricing question

#15

Dick Hines

Re:In the middle market juried shows....

Dick Hines

>I agree with you jamie. $60 -$90 would be a fair price---if the turning was nice, and this piece is and the finish was good. It also depends on where you are trying to sell the piece.

Great work John.

Re: pricing question

#16

Keith Tompkins

Re: Why is one bowl worth $40 and another worth $4

keith tompkins

>Steve, I re-read your post....I may have misunderstood it....Are you saying "think Bigger"? Instead of thinking local galleries and shows, broaden the horizons? I agree.

Re: pricing question

#17

I bid 30 John

C.W.Stivison

>

Re: pricing question

#18

think big

john lucas

>That's the way I took it keith. You have to think big and go after the marketing aspect. One problem I chasatise myself about often is thinking based on the money I can spend. I can't even imagine someone being able to pay $1000 for a bowl, much less 8 to 10 K like Jacque Vessery and Binh Pho get. I have to get out of that pattern and market myself for the bigger picture. If you only think small you will only be small. If you read about the extremely wealthy they almost always have 2 things in common. they think big and they take chances.

Re: pricing question

#19

Re: I bid 30 John

john lucas

>Thanks CW. When I get more finish on it and get it buffed to perfection I may come calling.

Re: pricing question

#20

Taking chances

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>It takes time, money and risk to develop a market.

Time: First it takes time to develop the product. That means focusing on the item and "perfecting" it. Second it takes time for the market to develop. Success doesn't happen overnight.

Money: This takes two forms. First there are the direct expenses to develop the product (R&D expenses in business). The second is lost income while you spend your time and effort on the new product.

Risk: There is the chance that the market might not develop to an extent that will let you re-coup your time and expenses. You need to be able to risk a couple of years on something that may never pay off. An excellent product is no guarantee that you will be able to break into a market that is saturated with established names.

That's a brief synopsis from someone who never took a business course.

Personally, in my non-work time, I like to explore new things and ideas. I don�t want to spend all of my spare time for a year or two developing and perfecting something. This is a strong contrast to my career where the average project required 2 years of focused effort.

Re: pricing question

#21

Re: pricing question

Carole Valentine

>Hi John. If you have to sell that little gem for $20, it's time for you to move to a new venue. Of course I am partial to burl and voids, but there are buyers out there who feel the same and they look for "Natural Conversation Pieces" - pieces that you can't resist picking up and examining. I sell a fair number of small pieces that are well under 4". The ones that always sell seem to be the ones that I don't WANT to sell and have put what "I" consider to be a ridiculous price on thinking no one will pay that and I can keep it. Examples: a 1.75" Holly and Blackwood hollow form for $150 - gone. A 3.5" x 2.25" NE Slippery Elm Burl HF for $125 - gone. I guess what I am saying is that if you don't see your work as having value, buyers won't either. Does that make sense?

Not being able to examine in person the piece you have shown makes it hard to say what sort of price I would put on it, but it certainly falls into the "NCP" category in my mind. Depending on wall thickness, final finish, etc. I would probably put it in the $75 - $100 range.

Re: pricing question

#22

$150

Ron in Drums PA

>If you don't ask for it you will never get it.

Art is in the eye of the beholder and the one who has the wallet.

Did you ever hear the story about the boy at his lemonade stand? He was selling lemonade at $1000.00 a cup.

A kindly older gentleman approached the boy's stand and said "How do you expect to make a profit at that price?"

The boy said "All I need to do is sell one cup."

Re: pricing question

#23

Re: Steve- please define your comments...

Steve Russell

>Hello Jamie,

Apologies for the confusion... The grading system I mentioned is a metric I came up with several years ago to help me determine a sales price for my turnings. It uses a sliding scale between one and ten, that helps to quantify the amount of time necessary to execute a piece based on the complexity of the design and the level of details incorporated into the piece. Everyone uses something different it seems and through the years I settled upon my grading system as a way to help arrive at the ultimate sales price. Take care and all the best to you and yours!

Steve Russell

The Woodlands, Texas

Re: pricing question

#24

Re: Why is one bowl worth $40 and another worth $4

Steve Russell

>Hello Steve,

Great comments Steve, you are one of the gems here on WC!

You have to look beyond the obvious many times to understand the nature of the sales process. Years ago, I was an insurance agent and much of our continuing education was on the psychology of sales and the buying process. That has helped me greatly over the years to refine my own sales metrics and to better understand what my customers, clients and collectors want and need in the pieces they are buying.

Many times the emotional side of the sales equation (passion, desire etc.) is lost when turners discuss pricing. Too many limit their thoughts to the sterile side of the equation (wood species, cost, labor etc.) and forget one of the most important aspects of sales, emotion. This is easily demonstrated at auctions, where the price is sometimes catapulted into the stratosphere by two bidders that both want the piece at any cost. In the end, the buyers viewpoint is the only one that really counts, because it's their money being spent.

Steve Russell

The Woodlands, Texas

Re: pricing question

#25

Re: think big

Steve Russell

>Hello John,

As always John, your comments hit the nail on the head! So many artists limit their perception of value to what they can afford, or what they would pay for something... This is a mistake and one that will cost you lots of money.

One of my insurance sales trainers years ago had a big sign in his office that said: "What you can afford is irrelevant, it's what your client can afford that matters!" Here is a great example of this...

When I started in the insurance business I was a wee lad of 19, not long out of high school and with a pocketbook to match. One of my first large cases was for $500,000 of life insurance on a man in his late fifties. The annual premium for the coverage was about $15,000 per year. That blew me away as a 19 year old, someone actually being able to afford a premium in excess of $1,000 per month and still have lots of money left for everything else.

I remember all the way to the appointment that I kept second guessing myself, wondering if this chap would throw me out for even suggesting a premium that was so large. The product was right on target for what the bloke needed and wanted, but I kept thinking that since I could not afford to pay $1,000 per month, nobody could. Luckily, I remembered something my grandfather told me when I was a wee lad that stuck with me. He told me to never project my own financial limitations on someone else and to always keep and open mind about life's possibilities...

I went into the appointment and presented my solutions to protect his estate upon his death and he immediately accepted my proposal. He even mentioned that he was glad it was so inexpensive, as he was hoping that it would be less than $25,000 per year, which was the most he could afford to spend to secure the coverage.

It's hard not to let your own financial limitations creep into the sales equation, but you have to ignore them as an artist. This is one of the hardest things for many turners to learn when they struggle with pricing. Luckily, I had the benefit of 20 years of prior sales experience to guide me as I opened my studio, not to mention the pearls of wisdom offered my grandfather when I was a wee lad growing up. Take care and all the best to you and yours!

Steve Russell

The Woodlands, Texas