Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Maple Hollow Form - Please Critique

Posts

Maple Hollow Form - Please Critique

#1

Bob Moffett

Maple Hollow Form - Please Critique

Bob Moffett

>This is a spalted Maple Hollow form 8 1/2" tall X 6 1/2" wide and 1/4" thick. The top is 2 1/4" at the top and 1" at the neck. The base is 2". Please let me know what you think. Thanks in advance. I know the photography isn't great and the picture may be a little large.


img

Re: Maple Hollow Form - Please Critique

#2

Re: Maple Hollow Form - Please Critique

david

>Bob: Since you asked, I think that the top is a bit unfortunate. This is what I did--scroll your photo down until the cut-off is at the top of the three lines. This, in my opinion, is the best result of the form you currently have.

Re: Maple Hollow Form - Please Critique

#3

Re: Maple Hollow Form - Please Critique

Jorge Castaneda

>Hi Bob

I like the body, but not the trombon mouth piece, look at it leaving out the very top, just to the narrowest spot of that neck or slightly above, I think that looks better. Also maybe what we see now will not be the same if the picture does not have that heavy shadow, try using daylight rather than the flash.

Nice piece of wood.

$0.02

Jorge

Re: Maple Hollow Form - Please Critique

#4

Bob Moffett

Re: Maple Hollow Form - Please Critique

Bob Moffett

>Good Idea, I'll try that on the next one.

Re: Maple Hollow Form - Please Critique

#5

Bob Moffett

Re: Maple Hollow Form - Please Critique

Bob Moffett

>Thanks Jorge, I'll give that a try on the next one. I like your idea. That's what I like about this forum, it is a good place to get new ideas and perspectives.

Re: Maple Hollow Form - Please Critique

#6

Re: Maple Hollow Form - Please Critique

David

>Bob,

I agree with the others re the top, but I think you nailed the rest of the form! Great lines and a delicate foot. BTW great choice of wood as well.

Re: Maple Hollow Form - Please Critique

#7

Bob Moffett

Re: Maple Hollow Form - Please Critique

Bob Moffett

>Thanks David, I guess I have some work to do on learning how to do the tops. That's what I like about this forum. I can get many different ideas to help improve upon my turnings.

Re: Maple Hollow Form - Please Critique

#8

Bob Moffett

Re: Maple Hollow Form - Please Critique

Bob Moffett

>How would you suggest changing the top?