Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

I am moving this subject from the chatroom to

Posts

Re: I am moving this subject from the chatroom to

#26

Steven Antonucci

Not meant to a slight your group, Mike...

steve antonucci

>I had a specific experience at one club meeting (remain nameless) where I would generically describe it as a "waste of time". Admittedly, it was my first and only true club meeting, but I have spent a fair amount of time at the wood shows with the local turning clubs (making tops or whatever) and I've gotten the exact same vibe.

At the specific meeting I attended, I was told that something I had been doing for years was "impossible", and even after showing it to the "club expert" (who hollowed with a sharpened screw driver...), I was dismissed because of my age (35-ish at the time) and because I had shown him up.

When a club has a caste system for it's members, only bad things can happen. Good turners can teach tool skills to a new turner, but many new turners have great eyes for form and color and can quickly come up to speed on how to hold a gouge. Someone who's been turning for a long time and producing very average work can quickly be passed by a new turner with creative skills. As many people may be threatened by this, I think a lot of clubs suffer.

If I was going to start a club, I would require ALL of the members attending the meetings to bring in a turning for Show and Tell so that everyone got to know their work. I would also have several sessions where through a lottery, several turners would be forced to collaborate on a piece and discuss the process with the club. I've watched David Ellsworth cut a simple bowl, and even though I've probably turned 500 bowls or more in my life- I still have room to improve.

It's too bad that your club is at the exact "longest distance" from where I am in NJ. There are no clubs in the Northwestern corner...

Steve

Re: I am moving this subject from the chatroom to

#27

Re: Sometimes, the club doesn't even know it's ...

Walt Drummond - Middlesex, NJ

>Steven, I'm the secretary of the NJ Woodturners and I also don't see the situations that you are describing. I've visited with most of the NJ clubs at wood shows and a few meetings. For the most part, all the NJ clubs are open and very friendly.

We always ask at every meeting if we have any first timers or visitors. We ask them to stand and introduce themselves. We have a varied demo program thru out the year, and have extremely good attendance at all of them. Many of the "out of town" demonstrators have remarked how nice it is to have a very attentive audience.

We have grown for about 46 members a few years ago to 100 as of the last meeting. We try to include things for all levels of turning skills. One of the biggest and best received is the sharing of skills from the skilled to the beginner.

I've met you at the 5 Barns affairs and hope to see you there again this year. We need to talk.

Walt Drummond Secretary, New Jersey Woodturners Association.

Re: I am moving this subject from the chatroom to

#28

Here's what I'd do

Mike Cunningham (Cape May NJ)

>Thanks Steve, I didn't take it personally. Our chapter has it's problems but there not of the clique, "better than you" variety.

Speaking of David, I saw him 2 weeks back at Bucks Woodturners. He executed a natural edge bowl start to finish, turned quite thin and requiring next to know sanding in 10 - 12 minutes. I can execute a bowl in that amount of time as well, unfortunately it would in fact be executed.

I agree with some of your comments, as well as those of others regarding meetings and members, there's a great deal of room for improvement at most clubs. There needs to be greater member participation. I've found that the majority simply want to sit and be entertained by others, don't seem to seek skill improvement and aren't interested in pitching in and carrying the work load. Those few that do, often times tire of it, and the crowd loses the worker. He or she moves on to another chapter or simply keeps to him/herself.

If I were to start a new chapter, active participation would be a requirement. At each meeting, all members must bring at least one item for show and tell. At least one item must be submitted for critique and members need to learn good design and form and offer their critique. All members must participate in a rotating demo/presentation. If there are ten members, then once every ten months a member must demo or do some sort of presentation, even if it's oral....do something. Dues, payable monthly at the meeting would be such as to enable the club to afford to bring in a worthwhile demonstrator annually. These demos and other presentations would be geared, probably by virtue of who was doing them, to each level of ability. All members would be strongly encouraged to participate, if not as officers, then at the very least on various committees, all carry the work load. Through fund raisers we'd attempt to fund annual grants to a member desiring to attend a woodturning school or individual training, with the understanding that he or she would then give a presentation about the knowledge/skills gained white attending. A mentoring program would be available, if you have a skill share it, if you need help, seek it out.

There's lots of things that can be done, the way to achieve it is by having the right members, not 10% but closer to 100%. If you don't want to play, see you later.

However, ain't gonna happen.

Mike

Re: I am moving this subject from the chatroom to

#29

Re: Allow me to clarify

Mike Cunningham (Cape May NJ)

>Hi Curly,

Does your club have enough workers, that you'd have people to run each sub-club? People to organize, run the meeting, demo, etc? OR, would the same workers, usually 10% - 15% of a club, have to perform these tasks for each group?

Mike

Re: I am moving this subject from the chatroom to

#30

Yo, Walt

Mike Cunningham (Cape May NJ)

>Hi Walt.

Say hello to Dennis when you see him and let him know that we enjoyed his visit during our two day annual spring workshop. He ran day one and Bob Rosand did day two. It was a great success.

I'm having back surgery June 6 and will miss Bill's 5 Barns.

Also, we have Lyle Jamieson here for 5 days the end of Sept and early Oct so I'll miss Totally Turning this year.

Mike

Re: I am moving this subject from the chatroom to

#31

Re: I am moving this subject from the chatroom to

Mike Cunningham (Cape May NJ)

>Lots of good info. I don't have the time right now to comment on everything that you said but will offer two things.

This thread should be shared with club members, not just the AAW presidents forum, maybe it would open some eyes.

The other thing. You are probably spot on about why the demonstrator seemed to lose the audience. We had the exact same type of demo about 18 months ago and the same thing happened. Mini turnings and the crowd couldn't see and they faded.

Solution: Look into a decent size television, get a small demo camera and project the action onto the screen, zoomed it for all to see. We often do it and it works.

I'm now in the position of your predecessor. Before that I was in your shoes.

Mike

Mike

Re: I am moving this subject from the chatroom to

#32

Steven Antonucci

I am planning on being at Five Barns

steve antonucci

>I also wasn't at one of your meetings - :-) we're narrowing it down, aren't we?

I do remember you, and I'd love to talk again. See you in July.

Steve

Re: I am moving this subject from the chatroom to

#33

nailer.....

TDaniel

>Your last paragraph says it all. Like Truman said, "The Buck stops here". Leadership is key. The club leader must read the pulse of the club and provide for all. Politics must not get in the way of doing what is best for a club. This crap of "you scratch my back and I'll scratch yours" leads to ruin. All must be done for the betterment of the club, not to build someone's resume'. And cliques have no place in a club. Good leadership will break up the cliques. It is ok to have friends at meetings and it is fine for these friends to get together and converse but what is not ok is for a group to be treated better or worse than the others.

Re: I am moving this subject from the chatroom to

#34

Re:Having a formal structure and....

Jamie Donaldson

>.. effective officers really helps democratize a club- remember Robert's Rules of Order? It takes a fair and strong leader to allow for all elements within a club to interact in a manner beneficial to the whole membership.

Re: I am moving this subject from the chatroom to

#35

Re: Groucho Marx?

Russ Fairfield

>Some of these comments remind me of Groucho Marx, who said, "I would never belong to any organization that would have me as a member".

Re: I am moving this subject from the chatroom to

#36

Re: Here's what I'd do

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Mike I've been an active member in 5 different clubs, all in different places. Your ideas seem to be good ones, but unfortunately they just wouldn't work. You just can't force or require that members participate other than just sitting and listening and watching if that's what they want to do. Actually you need these members to pay their dues just to keep the club running. In every club that I've belonged to there are always the doers that keep the club going. In one of my clubs we had a member who did wonderful work. He was very shy and didn't actively participate. I was in charge of programs so I asked him to do a demo. I must have scared h**l out of him. We never saw him again. All you can really do is try to encourage people to actively get involved. Some will and some won't and if you try to push it they'll just drop out.

I'm off to teach an all day class in hollow forms...I'll be beat tonight.

Wally

Re: I am moving this subject from the chatroom to

#37

Re: Allow me to clarify

Curly Smith

>You have to spread the workload, the same people can't do it all.

You're quite right that 10-15% generally do all of the work but it's been my experience that those 10-15% do it because they've always done it. There a bunch more that are willing but they have to be asked, they will not volunteer because there's no obvious need - you've got the 10-15% running the show.

There are people who would like to contribute more but either they don't know how, maybe they asked "what can I do to help" sometime in the past and were rebuffed (probably just told "nothing, we've got it under control") or they're not confident enough in their abilities to volunteer. Either way, they now have to be recruited and encouraged. Most people will be flattered that you though enough of them to ask...

Re: I am moving this subject from the chatroom to

#38

I agree

Mike Cunningham (Cape May NJ)

>Yes Wally, which is why I said "Ain't gonna happen". Just a dream of mine is all. I'd love to be part of a group where the reverse of the real world would prevail, 80+% participation. Being one of the 2 or 3 doers gets real old, particularly when many of the observers not only sit back, but when they do participate, they almost need to be dragged along, not all of them, but many. Doers tire of the feeling of banging their head against a brick wall and asking the age old question "Why do you belong to this club?" Which inevitably leads to the next question, "Why do I?" Which leads to.............just doing things on your own, at least you know the work will be appreciated.

Mike

Re: I am moving this subject from the chatroom to

#39

Re: Groucho Marx?

john lucas

>He also said I was married by a judge, I should have had a Jury.