Not meant to a slight your group, Mike...
steve antonucci
>I had a specific experience at one club meeting (remain nameless) where I would generically describe it as a "waste of time". Admittedly, it was my first and only true club meeting, but I have spent a fair amount of time at the wood shows with the local turning clubs (making tops or whatever) and I've gotten the exact same vibe.
At the specific meeting I attended, I was told that something I had been doing for years was "impossible", and even after showing it to the "club expert" (who hollowed with a sharpened screw driver...), I was dismissed because of my age (35-ish at the time) and because I had shown him up.
When a club has a caste system for it's members, only bad things can happen. Good turners can teach tool skills to a new turner, but many new turners have great eyes for form and color and can quickly come up to speed on how to hold a gouge. Someone who's been turning for a long time and producing very average work can quickly be passed by a new turner with creative skills. As many people may be threatened by this, I think a lot of clubs suffer.
If I was going to start a club, I would require ALL of the members attending the meetings to bring in a turning for Show and Tell so that everyone got to know their work. I would also have several sessions where through a lottery, several turners would be forced to collaborate on a piece and discuss the process with the club. I've watched David Ellsworth cut a simple bowl, and even though I've probably turned 500 bowls or more in my life- I still have room to improve.
It's too bad that your club is at the exact "longest distance" from where I am in NJ. There are no clubs in the Northwestern corner...
Steve



