>the messageboard. After reading Russ's comments on the two I think the messageboard is the best place to post this because of the ability for everyone to think out their answers.
Question is: "What are the things that destroy a turning club"? I have listed one already (below) but I can see some problems developing as we speak in our club and I have heard others mention problems in their clubs. We are gaining beginners and losing advanced turners. In my opinion our problem is lack of balance. We are ignoring the needs of advanced turners and gearing all of our demos to beginner subjects.
>Without a doubt Ego's can kill a club. If one person dominates or there are battles between 2 members it can kill a club. Everyone is there to enjoy themselves and if it becomes work, or you have to listen to power struggles they will not come back.
What saves a club is comraderie. People attend events where they feel comfortable. If you can go out of your way to welcome each other and make it a fun sharing place, your club will grow.
TD is very correct in that you have to cater to all members. The really advanced people do get bored with all the lower end demos but they usually hang in there if you do something that interests them once in a while. On the other hand if all you do is high end demos that require expensive tools or extreme skill you can lose the beginners.
>The opposite situation is a bad thing too. When no one wants to take on any responsibility those few who will soon become tired. Membership in a club should imply a willingness to help out with various aspects of the club.
>Some clubs seem to have success teaming up the veterans with the newbies and getting them personally involved in demos and leading discussions, but in the end, that's all give, and not much take in return (besides feeling good about helping a beginner get started).
Since many turning veterans sell their work, or would like to, maybe a separate sub-group of turning pros and semi-pro's could gather before or after the usual meeting -- and work on marketing & sales, advanced techniques, planning group shows, or more advanced discussions and critiques of form, or inspiration... some clubs have tried this, but I'm not aware of the results, so I'm still wondering how well this would work.
Some veterans are so wrapped up in turning to meet the needs of customers or galleries or their production schedule that they are missing a lot of the fun in search of an income stream. Another option would be to get the old salts to gather maybe a few times a year in a shop for a hands-on session, trading ideas on how to cut up a burl, or whatever. They could trade ideas, techniques, and even make collaborative pieces (...DING ! ... time's up, time to pass it on to Larry here...) to help them find new inspiration or get out of their current turning rut. I've seen this work, and it can be like a small-scale Emma Lake sorta deal with turners and carvers and potters and metal workers messing outside their usual boxes, and hopefully going home with some new ideas.
>I have always advocated balance. I think a balance has to be sought for both the local clubs and the AAW; ignoring those at either end will cause a loss of members. I like the "thirds rule", a third of the meetings aimed toward beginners, a third toward the intermediate, and a third toward the advanced turners. Ditto for the AAW mag.
>Every club seems to be 20% active members, and 80% who just occupy a seat on meeting night. There are always 2 or 3 from that active 20% who carry most of the load for leadership and instruction. They need that 80% for their dues, and they need tha 20% for their skills, knowledge, and willingness to work.
Achieving the "balance" is a difficult thing to do, and I don't think there is a formula for doing it. It depends on the people in the club and their personalities; and sometimes it depends on the economics of the larger society they come from and their place in it.
The problems begin when we ignore the 20% for the 80% because those who occupy the seats are always the loudest and most frequent with their complaints.
I have been a member of several clubs, and I have visited about 40 as a demonstrator. Disfunctional clubs don't invite demonstrators, so I haven't had much experience with them. Clubs fall into several categories.
There are clubs where most of the members are employed by the same Company, and their same work and social structure is carried over into their woodturning club. The same people are supervisors, the same people are the workers, and the same people just show up and occupy a seat. It works very well for them because they are comfortable with it. Their "balance" is the same as the one they live with every day. Can you imagine an outsider trying to fit into such a club??
I have seen clubs with membership by application only. A resume is required. Their membership is limited by the size of someone's shop space, meeting space available, the desire to keep a balance in the demographics, because they have always done it this way, and sometimes to keep some one person from joining. Someone has to die or move away before there is an opening. They have a long wainting list and a 5 year wait was not uncommon. Their "balance" is achieved through regulation and a plan.
And, I have seen clubs that were just 5 old guys getting together on a Saturday morning to discuss the news and politics. Heaven forbid that they should talk about woodturning. They each had their secrets that they were unwilling to share. Their "balance" is achieved by keeping this an exclusive group. Sometimes this was out of necessity because they were the only woodturners in town.
And, I have seen clubs where one dynamo-woodturner led a group of beginners into the promised land of woodturning and AAW membership. When they were ready, he would leave the club to fend for itself and either start a new club or lose interest. Here the "balance" is the same as that of a minister and his congregation.
And I have seen clubs where there were 2 meetings going on at the same time. After the business meeting there were the 80% who were occupying the seats and watching the presentation for the night. The 20% who had seen it all before, were gathered in another room in a bull session, and sometimes the discussion was even about woodturning. Here the "balance" is achieved through a defacto separation of the 2 groups.
I have also seen clubs that had 2 meetings on separate days. One was a business meeting and a brief demonstration or presentation on a Thursday. That was followed by the Saturday meeting that was a full day working session with the featured demonstrator in someones large shop with several lathes available. "Balance" was achieved by recognizing the differences between those of the 80% who were members because it gave them a night out of the house, and those who wanted to learn something, and provided for both. My observation is that these were the most successful clubs.
Finally there were the clubs who had an all day Saturday or Sunday meeting with lunch being served at noon. Some of them split the day into 2 different sessions, and some didn't. Either way they had the entire day to cover all bases, and many of the membership only came for the part they were interested in. The lunch crowd was always twice as large as either the morning or afternoon turning sessions. Everyone was comfortable with people coming and going at various times during the day.
All of these clubs share two things. They served the social and learning needs of ALL of the membership, and they worked. I think these 2 things are what makes and keeps a club active and going. How they are achieved depends on the people, their skills, their personalities, their economics, and the location and the social structure and economics of the larger community they live in.
And, sometimes it takes 2 different clubs with 2 different personalities to achieve that "balance" that.
And, it would be expected that any club would change as the people and/or their experience changed.
Its a lot like woodturning itself. We all do different things because we do what works for us. It's the results that count.
>I''ve belonged to several clubs over the years. All have been successful, some more than others. One thing that must be present for any club to succeed is to have a few members that are "doers". People who will spend the time and put in the effort to make it work. And it takes more than one or two.
As others have mentioned, the activities and programs must have a balance. Something for members of all skill levels. That's a difficult thing to do. Of course club memberships will vary. Some will be mostly beginners and others will be mostly intermediate and better. The club that I'm involved with now was started a little over two years ago. Most of our members are beginners and intermediate, with only 4 or 5 advanced turners. Our membership is around 70 with perhaps 40 attending on a regular basis. A few of our members are snowbirds, so we only see them in the Winter months.
One of the important things that a club should have is a well stocked library. A variety of videos, books, magazines etc. One of the first club priorities was a camera and monitor for demos. We make a DVD of all demos and it goes into the library. This year we applied for a grant from the AAW. We received $1000. Much of that will go into stocking the library.
We are trying to have enough money on hand to get at least two of the better known demostrators each year. The rest has been done by club members.
The show and tell is important and the members like to have someone do a critique. In our club that happens to be done by me. I've found that I have to be careful to not step on sensitive toes. Some want me to tell it as I see it and a few get upset if I do. I'm learning who the sensitive ones are and just say nice things about their work. Gotta keep 'em happy.
>Same stuff here Wally. Many of our members are retired and like to take trips so they do not want to be officers of the club. Several have been turning for 4 years now and they are getting pretty good. We have picked up a lot of new members and most of these are new turners so we have to cater to the beginners and that is causing a problem because we are losing the more experienced turners. It really is a hard thing to balance. The first 2 years was easy because most of us were at the same level. Add to this the egos that have formed as some have gotten better and then we have those who are using the club for their own purpose (resume building) and such and there she goes.....
>How often are these meetings and how long do meetings last? If the meeting is once a month and lasts 2 or 3 hours, you have very little time to get to know any one else in the club.
Are clubs better to limit size and meet in members' shops or grow big and meet in a hall. If a club is say 50+ members they have a hard time remembering each others name never mind the other persons skill level. I have seen clubs that have limited their size to 12 or 14 members, meet in each others' shops/home and get together for social luncheons. ET
>Several of us do meet in each other's shops aside from our normal monthly evening meetings. We have had a few Saturday demos in addition to our regular meetings. Club size.....ummmmm....toss up. When the club is small it is easier to manage and to get to know everyone but difficult to raise enough money to pay to get a good demo. I think it takes about 50 for a club to be able to support good demos 2 or 3 times a year. I would guess on average it takes 25 members per demo, that is for every 25 members you can afford a demo each year, thus 50 members equals 2 demos (more or less); the rest of the demos have to be done by members or by swapping with other clubs (which works well if you have another club close enough).
I know, you're saying "that's just more work for me" but it's not if you also split the leadership. Let the advanced club meet Mondays and the other club can meet on Tuesdays. The newbies can attend the advanced sessions by registering (and sitting in the back with their mouths shut). The advanced turners can attend the newbie meetings under the same conditions.
Let the people attend the club that best matches their needs/talents/desires. If you don't have enough people to form an advanced group then that tells you that you need to focus on the newbies and vice versa.
Sometimes, the club doesn't even know it's sick...
steve antonucci
>Personal opinion (you may not agree...):
I've spoken to a bunch of the NJ clubs at the woodworking shows, and without casting stones, I don't really see a lot of value to joining any one of them. All of the clubs I've approached seemed very "clique-y" and not very well organized.
What would someone like me need (Type A all the way) to see to join a club?
1.) A direction (any direction). Seems to me that a bunch of people standing around a shop may be "fun" for some folks, but I'd want more. Whether leading a demo or attending, everyone must have the courtesy and respect for the "event" of the night. If you can turn bowls with one hand behind your back and your eyes closed, you still need to pay attention to presenter or stay home. Too often, the meetings seem to be a smattering of this and that, with some woodturning thrown in for good measure.
2.) Diversity. Skills, viewpoints, experience... and desire. I no sooner want to be in a room full of beginners than a room full of experts. I do want to be in a room full of creative people willing to give and take their ideas and techniques.
3.) Open minds. Sad to say, but I've noticed that as a "new guy" at one club, there were a bunch of people who didn't know me and unwilling to accept anything I had to say- even though I was a considerably more skilled turner than they were at the time. Goes back to my original idea of the cliques I've seen within the clubs I've spoken to... not my thing.
If there was a club with VB lathes, frequented by creative people, all willing to give or take depending upon the opportunity, and they were covering a bunch of very well thought out topics in there meetings, I might be a member of that club.
>What's being forgotten by some of us is that over time most newbies become more skilled and some of them become very good turners in a very short time. The older more established clubs always have a lot of good turners. Only the new members might be beginners.
If we pay to have a name turner in to do a demo nobody wants to see him/her just cater to the beginner. Everybody wants to see the turner do what they are known for. That includes the beginner. If I watch Binh Pho I want to see him turn thin then pierce and air brush.
>I know of several expert woodturners who either don't belong to a club or never attend their meetings because they have been taken advantage of too many times. We too often overwork them for demonstrations because they are there and they are free, while other clubs have to pay for them. More than 1 or 2 times a year, and they will just disappear rather than have to say "No"; and that is not good for the club. When the experts leave, so does everyone else.
>I'm the president of one NJ club, the Cape Atlantic Woodturners, I'm also a member of DelVal Woodturners. I've attended meetings or am otherwise familiar with Atlantic Shore Woodturners, and New Jersey woodturners and none sound like what you're describing. They're the only 4 AAW chapters that I'm aware of in NJ, all four are welcoming, have a mix of experienced and new turners and offer demos from in house turners and out of town as well.
I do agree with others comments that much of the work usually falls on the shoulders of just 2 or 3 members and most just want to sit and be entertained.
Re: Sometimes, the club doesn't even know it's sic
Mark Paulley
>Steven,
I have been slammed by a few for my views but I relate to what you have stated!!! Thank YOU! To afraid to say to much due to the experts! In the end if we are ALL progessing we are ALL beginners
untill we accept our abilities or the experts say so! Again just a beginner turner having FUN!!!!!!!!!!
>Wally, I think he meant that if you attended the advanced night and you were a beginner that you should keep quiet that night only; you would also be able to go to the other night's beginner's meeting where you could participate. This is done at some hand's-on sessions where you can pay maybe $100 for a day's lessons with a lathe in front of you or you can pay $25 as an observer only with no lathe or tools in your hands. I think I see his point.
>I don't know what the make-up of the club in question is but, for the sake of argument, let's assume that it's currently 30% expert, 30% intermediate, and 40% novice. In theory, one could devote 1/3rd of each meeting to each skill group wherein we would get the following dynamic:
the expert is bored 70% of the time
the intermediate turner is confused 30% and bored 40% of the time
the novice is confused 30% of the time and completely lost 30% of the time.
In my book that's not a design for lasting success. By dividing into "sub-clubs" the turners can identify the group that best fits their needs and, by doing so, they will be more likely to participate. That doesn't mean one couldn't attend the other meetings but it's not helpful if "novice" observers continually interrupt and ask questions during an "expert" meeting. By the same token, it's not helpful to novice turners when the experts offer 307 better ways to do what the demonstrator is demonstrating. If you're attending the meeting as an observer then you should observe, if you're a participant then you should participate.
At some point the novice "sub-club" may dissolve as the majority of the members gravitate to the intermediate and expert levels. At some other point it may reform as new members join. A club that is flexible and responsive to its members needs will have a higher level of participation than a "one size fits all" club. People have a lot more options on how to spend their free time than they did 20 years ago and organizations that don't recognize the competition won't be around for long.
What you guys are saying should be posted to the AAW Presidents Forum on the AAW website. This is all great info for current/future presidents.
I hear a lot of what you all are saying.
I am president of a local AAW chapter club. When I took over in January I didn't feel qualified to be President. I was one of those 20%'ers. I volunteered for way too many things and often sacrificed my time and effort for the betterment of the club. The long standing President expressed his intentions to leave the post for 2 years before he finally left the post. Before he left he appointed myself and "another guy" to the nominating comitee. Well, after an extensive search of the membership.....I became president and the "other guy" became vice president.
Our biggest problem to date has been finding a new meeting location. Our membership is scattered over a 75 mile area and finding a place to meet near the middle was tough. But we managed. So far the new location seems to be working out well.
We try to have a nationally known turner in for a 2 day demo about once a year. We have hosted David Ellsworth, Melvin Firmager, Beth Ireland, and others, we are planning for Bill Grumbine this summer. The cost for the demo is split between the club and the attendees. This seems to work out well. The demonstrators we choose are selected for their ability to mix beginner and advanced techqniques while keeping everyone happy.
At our monthly meetings my program committee and I try to reach that club balance. We let everyone know about a month ahead of time what the demo will be. That way if someone isn't comfortable with the subject they can skip that meeting. This seems to work out well.
Last month one of our senior members demonstrated turning micro-goblets. The subject was well recieved but the demonstrator felt like he lost the crowd about 1/2 way through. He is an experienced demonstrator and didn't have an explanation why. I was watching from the sidelines and the only guess I have is that the subject matter was too small for the crowd to see. When everyone was invited up to see the finished item the crowd was huge. I don't think people were dis-interested, I think they couldn't see what was going on and got frustrated.
We meet once a month for about 3 hours. But, we also have member supported private sessions 2-3 times a month. This is an oppurtunity for an experienced member to host several junior members to his or her shop for a demo. The subject and rules of the session are up the host. This has worked out real well.
Another big plus we have is that we hold a wood raffel at every meeting. I know when I was new that was a big draw to the club for me.
I think getting 100% involvement in a larger club is impossible. But as officers and committee members of a club we believe in, it is up to us to keep the "faith". We need to exercise the members for what ever they are willing to offer. Some people like to follow a lead. It is up to the leader to see that they get fufillment.