Re: Art vs. Craft
Mkauder, Phenix City, AL Back From Europe
>I love that, Troy. I am going to make a sign of it and post it in my shop.
Mark
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Re: Art vs. Craft
Mkauder, Phenix City, AL Back From Europe
>I love that, Troy. I am going to make a sign of it and post it in my shop.
Mark
Re: I can say it simpler
Russ Fairfield
>Brad said it all, but I can say it simpler -
He pissed me off.
This guy is whining because he isn't getting the recognition HE thinks HE deserves. With an attitude like his, he never will.
Re: I like it too, Troy, but....
Allen Neighbors
>when I print it out, I'm going give you credit for it, but then I'm going to add my modification:
If you�re cynical and brooding, with bonus points given for being darkly anti-religious, then what you do is art. Hmmm, ART...PRODUCED BY A CRAFTY PERSON.
If you�re optimistic, enthusiastic, and generally happy, then what you do is crafts.
TO DO A CRAFT PIECE WELL, YOU HAVE TO BE AN ARTIST.
Re: My sentiments, exactly, Troy
Allen Neighbors
>
Re: Brad for President!!!
Allen Neighbors
>Now I not only envy your turnings, I also envy your ability to articulate.
Recent Article
Jennifer@Indy.USA
>TD, there was recently (last year) an article by Alan Lacer on architectural columns and balusters that was really well done. I learned a ton from it. Not necessarily technique, but historic information and such. It was very informative. Perhaps you should drop by a book store and pick up a copy every now and then and see what's inside?
Jen
Lets consider the reverse argument
Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin
>Spindle turning dominated for centuries and turning went nowhere. It took the vessel to break turning out of its doldrums. Maybe there should be a 10-year moratorium on spindle turning.
But not until I get my next batch of candle holders made. ;=)
Re: Lets consider the reverse argument
RevDoug
>I have to say that Russ summed things up well for me as well. As I read the article, I was reminded of others who have in recent years have attempted to force their points of view on the rest of the turning world. Some of those apparently are still alive and kicking.
Spindle turning has been around for nearly 2000 years. Bowl, or should I say "vessel", turning has been around for what 40 years or so? Between these two genre it is amazing how much has been and is being done. Now we are starting to see loads of escentric and multi-axis turning that is simply amazing. Does it mean that we all MUST start haveing 100% turned pieces that twist and turn or have three or more sides to them? Of course not. Does it mean that we can look at pieces and think that they are wonderfully imaginative even if we will never turn such a piece? Of course.
I read the article. I understood his point, over and over again. Understand what he's trying to say, I think. And don't like what I felt like he's calling me and the bulk of those I respect the work of. Yes, learning to turn is pretty easy and quick to learn. No, one is not good for a much longer time. And I don't respect folks that try to say what I do is too easy and simple. Most folks I show my work to, as amatuerish as it is, are purely amazed and dumbfounded at the work that it must take to create such an object of beauty. They like it. I like it. I don't appreciate criticizing my venue when I see their work and the only thing that comes to mind is, "Why?"
Turn 'em round,
Re: Lets consider the reverse argument
Wally Dickerman in Arizona
>First bowls turned 40 years ago?......Oh you kids..I turned my first bowl in 1936. Actually, bowl turning has been around for a long time. I have a turned bowl that belonged to my grandmother. Most likely turned in the late 1800's. It's quite oval so it was turned green. Wasn't sanded but tool marks are pretty smooth.
Wally
well said
Mike Nelson
>
Re: Lets consider the reverse argument
Fog Tanner
>I think you need to add a few more years to the 40. My daughter and I went to the Dead Sea Scrolls exhibit when it came through. We were walking through the various exhibits and we came across a case containing some pottery from the period and area that the scrolls were written. Also in the case from the same period were several wooden bowls, darkened from age but of the same basic shape that you will find in gallery at the various symposiums. These were turned on a lathe, not carved. The Egytians had lathes 4000 years ago.
In another case was a stone vessel, also from the same period of about 2000 years ago. It was an enclosed form with a narrow opening about three feet tall. The card by it said that it had been turned on a lathe. From the size of the foot and the weight of the object, it had to be a vertical lathe, but still a turned vessel.
I found it quite interesting that these people, along with the Egyptians, had been stealing all of our designs for the last several thousand years and now we need a moratorium to stop the proliferation of these objects....looks like somebody was a few thousand years shy...but, then again they didn't have excentric chucks back then for their spindle work either...
Re: Art vs. Craft
John Lucas
>That means that Monday thru about thursday I'm doing art and Friday thru sunday I'm doing Craft.
Re: Art vs. Craft
RevDoug
>Point taken. I was under the understanding that most bowl were carved or chisseled or even adzed into shape. Regardless, my point is still valid. We've been turning for a long time. There is always innovation taking place. Sometimes it is in technique. Sometimes design. Sometimes it is process or even in the tools we use. To say that nothing has changed, that the turning world is stagnant I feel is a slap and I don't appreciate it.
Can we all turn something different? We do even if we're trying to turn the same thing. Is the turning world in a rut? I don't think so. We're seeing too many innovations coming down the pike to make such a statement.
Turn 'em round,
Re: Personally
Mark Paulley
>Ron,
You have stated it perfectly!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
M
Re: reverse it
Wilford Bickel
>Terry,
I think you have hit the nail on the head in the defining of turning and carving. If you pull your resource guide and actually read the bylaws you will find that the stated purpose of the AAW is to "promote lathe-turning". I don't see where all the wood art fits into the stated purpose. It is a real shock to join the American Association of Woodturners as I did a few years back and find out when you receive the first issue of the journal that the majority of the articles are not centered on wood turning but on other wood art activities. I believe it is time for the AAW to get back to following it's stated purpose. I keep seeing postings on the AAW forum asking why so many local club members are not members of AAW - if you look at the journal that is a major part of you benefits from the point of view of a new beginning turner - why would you join? If we are not careful the lathe is soon going to be relegated to the position of the bandsaw and chain saw - blank preparation for carving and burning.
I don't have a problem with anyone doing wood art - just a problem with the AAW calling it turning and having it in the galleries and journal. I see beauty in a lot of it and know there is a lot of skill needed to do the carving so please don't anyone take what I have said here personally. I just feel that the AAW has lost it's direction and is not following the bylaws and it's stated purpose of promoting lathe-turnings!
Re: reverse it
TDaniel
>That is exactly how I see it too. The last time this subject came up there were several who thought I was against all enhancements. Actually I use some enhancements myself and I sometimes carve a bowl instead of turning it; again, no problem....but my carved bowl is called a "carving", not a turning. It could also be called a sculpter or wood art and I would not be upset. Some have mentioned that a lathe is just one of many tools used to produce their final product...again, I do not have a problem with that, but in the end to call the final product a woodturning is like calling a piece of fine furniture a "sawing". If we stick to the definitions in Webster we will all be ok.