Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

The Case Against the Vessel

Posts

The Case Against the Vessel

#1

The Case Against the Vessel

Greg Haugen

>I was a part of the chat last night and this article came up. It's not a "how to" but more of a "food for thought" article. I'd really like to hear from responses to it. Maybe even get a discussion started.

http://www.woodturningcenter.org/TurningPoints/002/TP002_Exton.pdf

Greg

Re: The Case Against the Vessel

#2

Re: The Case Against the Vessel

Russ Fairfield

>This is the same old argument about "What is woodturning"?

I see it as another and more extreme iteration of the "craft" versus "art" argument.

How we view this argument depends on whether we are a traditionalist or a modernist in out view of woodturning and what we do with it.

The "traditionalist" says that if it ain't 100% turned on a lathe, it isn't turned wood. This means bowls and vessels that hold things inside, and spindle type turnings that hold things up or together. Some "traditionalists" take the more extreme position that spindle turning doesn't belong in modern woodturning.

The "modernist" position is that it shouldn't look like it was turned on a lathe, and we have done something wrong if it does. Peter Exton is definitely one of these.

The problem is that these people see this as a black or white issue with nothing in between. The problem is that most of us are somewhere in that vast gray area.

Personally, I have no time for fools or extremeists, whether it be in life, politics, or woodturning.

Re: The Case Against the Vessel

#3

Personally

Ron in Drums PA

>If I choose to paint it, carve it, burn it, spit on it, call it art or call it craft, it doesn't matter to me, I like to turn wood.

I've seen some really beautiful work that I can't tell if it was ever on a lathe.

I've seen some really ugly work and asked myself "Why would a person do that to a wonderful piece of wood"

And then there where times I've said to myself. "Man I wish I thought of that!"

Bottom line still is - I like to turn wood.

Re: The Case Against the Vessel

#4

Re: The Case Against the Vessel

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I also posted this on WOW. I need to re-read and digest the article but I will throw out this thought. One of the definitions of sculpture is "any three-dimentional form created as an artistic expression". Personally I feel as if this is a good basic definition.

Does this put a new twist on the argument that carved turnings have no place in woodturning publications? :-)

Re: The Case Against the Vessel

#5

reverse it

TDaniel

>If I subscribed to a carving magazine or joined a carving club and found that everything in the mag or done at a meeting was "carved" while spinning on a lathe I might be somewhat disappointed, not because it would not be technically a carving but it would not be what I expected and possibly would be something that I had no desire to learn. Words must have limits or they become non definitive. Art does not have to have limits but words do. We expect a certain word to have certain meaning. Some words are more encompasing than others. Wood art covers everything artistic that is made of wood. A turning to me indicates something that is carved while it is spinning. A carving to me is something that is carved while it is not spinning. Anything in between would be a carved turning. There is nothing wrong with carved turnings. We have members in our club that also belong to a carving club and they are doing some really pretty work which they bring to our show and tell at the turning meeting. There is no problem with this. However, if half our turning meetings were carving classes I think we would lose members and I think the same thing would happen to the carving club if they started teaching wood-turning instead of carving. Again, no slap to either, just my thoughts on the importance of words.

Re: The Case Against the Vessel

#6

Re: The Case Against the Vessel

John Lucas

>Greg First off you have to realize that the article was written by a guy who makes his living turning "art spindles", not vessels. Nothing against Peter Exton I love his work. The article is written to try and present a larger view of the turning artist. This being someone who's main reason for turning is to create a name or style that will change the art world. For this reason we as mostly amateurs or crafts artists are more concerned with what sells and/or what we simply like to make. To me this means if your market sells vessels then you make vessels, if you sell Treen ware then you make treen. It's difficult in my mind to try and put his argument in the same text as what most of us are doing. We make what makes us happy and try to find others with like minds.

Re: The Case Against the Vessel

#7

Re: The Case Against the Vessel

Troy German

>My thoughts:

1) He needs an editor. I stopped reading on page 4. Every paragraph seemed like a restatement of the same idea.

2) His main idea, try new things ON the lathe, is good. It�s good to encourage creativity.

3) I think he could communicate this without disparaging the work that many people are currently doing, but it's his opinion and he is welcome to express it.

Troy

Re: The Case Against the Vessel

#8

Re: The Case Against the Vessel

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>In Peter Exton's article, he tells of the advent in the late 70's and early 80's to turning vessels. He states that in the 90's turning became precictable, so it became boring. Turners no longer saw frontiers, they saw limits. So turners either went off into other fields or they turned to working on turned pieces off the lathe. Is this Bad? I don't think so.

If you attend one of the larger symposiums you'll find a wide variety of demonstrations of doing work on and off the lathe. They all seem to be well attended, so surely the interest in all phases of turning and embellishing those turning is there. A visit to the instant gallery is an eye-popping experience. Some of what I would term as far out are still interesting to me. The skill, imagination and use of various techniques in creating the piece can be almost mind boggling.

Who knows where turning is heading. It sure isn't going to stay the same, whether we like it or not.

Wally

Re: The Case Against the Vessel

#9

Re: The Case Against the Vessel

Barry Elder

>I agree with every one of you out there. I am in awe of turners, carvers, artists, and anyone more talented than I am. When I finish my turning love affair with bowls, then perhaps it will be time to turn my urn or expand!

Re: The Case Against the Vessel

#10

Art vs. Craft

Troy German

>Tongue-in-cheek stereotype based on my limited exposure (from Calif.) to art vs. craft.

If you�re cynical and brooding, with bonus points given for being darkly anti-religious, then what you do is art.

If you�re optimistic, enthusiastic, and generally happy, then what you do is crafts.

Troy

Re: The Case Against the Vessel

#11

Re: The Case Against the Vessel

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Many of us copy the wonderful pottery forms that have been used by SW Indians for centuries. While those forms can be beautiful, If they weren't embellished they would be very commonplace and would sell for very little. It's the wonderful designs and what they do to the finished pot that makes them unique. I've seen Mata Ortiz pots that sold for over $5000.

Wally

Re: The Case Against the Vessel

#12

Wally, are they spun or carved? :)

TDaniel

>

Re: The Case Against the Vessel

#13

neither- their thrown or slab built :) :)

John Lucas

>

Re: The Case Against the Vessel

#14

When I throw them they break :):):)

TDaniel

>

Re: The Case Against the Vessel

#15

Re: When I throw them they break :):):)

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>They are neither spun or carved (well sometimes carved a little, and the wheel wasn't invented in the new world). Indian pots are made with the fingers molding a long ropelike piece of clay. They start with a mold, usually made of clay, to form the round bottom by making a sort of clay tortilla.

The clay pots found in museums that are hundreds of years old were all functional, but they all have beautiful painted designs. They must have found the plain pots to be commonplace too.

Wally

Re: The Case Against the Vessel

#16

a good chat topic??

e

>i posted this article on last night's chat thinking it might be a good topic for a future chat session.

anyone interested?

if so, let steve know.

Re: The Case Against the Vessel

#17

just joking Wally:)

TDaniel

>Their simple lines were timeless. I like their shapes, with or without the extra decorations. They were true pieces of art, no matter how they were made. Your use of them as an example is perfect if compared to working with a piece of wood with no character; in such case the piece would be bland without some enhancement. On the other hand, if the wood has enough character on its own, then it would be a shame to not just show that and leave it be. Perhaps the key word is "enhance", not "destroy"?

Re: The Case Against the Vessel

#18

Wood Art

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>I think Terry hit the nail on the head when he used the term "Wood Artists". That term seems perfect in it describes everyone that works with wood. It doesn't matter if you turn, carve, glue, saw, or scrape the wood.

Ask yourself, Am I happy with my final result? If that answer is "yes", then whatever techniques you used to achieve it were appropriate for you.

I believe there is room for all Wood Artists.

keithz

Re: The Case Against the Vessel

#19

Some of mine should be brocken :)

John Lucas

>

Re: The Case Against the Vessel

#20

I'm a leg man.

Paul Kierstead

>I just want some nice legs. Maybe a knob or two. The odd foot. What is wrong with that? Why are there a zillion "art" pieces but rarely a beautifully formed set of legs?

Re: The Case Against the Vessel

#21

Good Suggestion e

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>It would be a lively chat. :-)

Re: The Case Against the Vessel

#22

Re: I'm a leg man.

Fog Tanner

>You obviously don't get out on the internet much... ;-)

Re: The Case Against the Vessel

#23

Good point but....

TDaniel

>the AAW does not think you are worthwhile. Sad, but true. I would really like to see a portion of the mag devoted to spindle work as in table legs and lampstands and such but there are very few articles on such unless it has started recently. I don't know about the last 2 years as I dropped out of it because it was not leading in a direction that I wanted to go. Maybe it is different now and I should take another look.....? The best way to learn to turn nice legs is to find a good instructor and get some one on one.

Re: The Case Against the Vessel

#24

Brad Vietje

Re: The Case Against the Vessel

Brad Vietje

>Hmmmmm,

I'd agree that better editing and focus would have resulted in a better article. Not only repetitive, but essentially insulting to everyone "else" -- those who turn things other than multi-axis spindles. I'm a little surprised at the whiny tone, too. I've only met the man once, in Albany a few years ago, and he seemed nice enough, and his work is truly fascinating. It reads like sour grapes and/or professional jealousy, essentially because his form of turned art hasn't gotten the same degree of acceptance or recognition as other forms.

First off, he doesn't define "vessel" in any reasonable way. Does this include open forms like bowls ? Is a vessel any object that can "contain" something ? I often take the term to describe closed forms or hollow forms like those of John Jordan, as well as those carved and textured or spiral cut a la Stewart Mortimer .... Is he including Michelle Holzaphel's stupendously amazing carvings as the unskilled and "easy" work he decries, or just those trivial 1/16" thick hollow forms of David Ellsworth and all the other turned vessel bums out there? And who, precisely, says that turning these is easy, quickly learned in a few hours, or in any way unskilled ? Oh, I get it -- they are simple because they don't contain any of the tedium of carefully executed glue joins or mathematical calculations of segmented work. Surely, then, Malcolm Tibbett's work would be elevated to a new level if he could only understand how to mount his creations on more than one axis...

In essence, then, I'm offended and annoyed at Mr. Exton's assertions about all turning that is "else" or "other" than his own corner of the turning world. Since his central point seems to be that turning innovation has not advanced much since the Ellsworth vessel era, I'd ask him to show me the evidence to back up his assertions. I am simply amazed at the creativity that abounds at any reasonably-sized symposium instant gallery -- even local and regional affairs, so I really don't see his point. I think he's trying to say that with the increased popularity of "artistic woodturning", especially the vessel form (whatever that is), have come economic forces that have created increased demand -- and thus, price -- for turned objects of a certain type; unfortunately for him, not the type he's turning. Can these forces stagnate the evolution of turning, or perhaps cause a temporary shift in widely-accepted norms of desirability and taste ? Sure -- just witness the female ideal popularized by Peter Paul Rubens so long ago, and contrast that with the skinny stick figures fainting on runways these days. Fortunately for Mr. Exton, these same forces that allow a famous "wood artist" to sell a turned and carved hollow vessel for seven figures have probably helped him raise the sale prices of his work a few points, too.

We could always go back to the days when nearly everything turned on a lathe was utilitarian and necessary for everyday life, but I suspect the cat's out of that creativity bag for good. Tastes change. Ideals change. And, given time, turning will change, too. There is no need to force this change -- it is an inevitable consequence of thousands of very talented and imaginative people doing what makes them happy, or exploring what makes them tick.

My two offended cents,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: The Case Against the Vessel

#25

Re: Good point but....

John Lucas

>The just posted an article on making stools by Nick Cook. I don't think anyone sends any photos of lamps, beds etc. to the Journal. I'll bet if they did and they were good quality Carl would run it. Look at the clubs. Most people turn bowls and vessels. How many of you have turned a spindle (other than a finial) in the last year.

I agree with TD. I'd love to see more spindle work and I think the AAW will publish it if you'll send it in.