Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

big spindle commission

Posts

big spindle commission

#1

big spindle commission

john lucas

>I'm asking for advice here. This will be the biggest (not the longest) spindle I've been asked to do. I want your opinions on how you would turn it and how you think I should figure the cost. The overall height is 36" and the width is 22" I may be off a little because I was estimating size from a really bad photo. I'll get a better photo from her if this goes through.

The bottom 10" will probably be segmented turning. I'm thinking I should probably do the top portion that way as well. If I do stave construction of the upper portion I'll have a lot of waste, not to mention that I've never done stave that would be 8" deep.

I figure it would take 2 days to cut and glue up all the segments. I hope I'm figuring that time right.

It will also mean that I'll need to add some wood spacers below the headstock and tailstock to give me a swing of more than 22". I have some MDF so that will be pretty easy. I've done it before on a smaller lathe and it works surprisingly well.

I figure about 1/2 a day for turning. I would want to take it slow to reduce the chances for error.

I hope to do more work like this around here because I think the money is better than selling art pieces or craft. I don't want to undersell myself but also don't want to lose the job. Give me your best guess. Your help is really appreciated.


img

Re: big spindle commission

#2

Re: big spindle commission

Peter Hyde

>John, I recently turned these capitals and bases at work. They are about 18" in diameter. Tulip wood (Black poplar?)segmented construction done in layers for each of the varying diameters. Milling and glue up for each piece was around 8 hours. I used LePage carpenters glue because there is nothing else at work and so far there are no glue lines showing. If this was for a customer I would definitely use the marine plastic resin powder glue.

Turning time was around 3 hours. Does your spindle have to be solid? Could you use stave construction with a plug in the top? Even on the base hollow would be preferable IMO as it would save a lot of weight and also cut down on material. If this is for exterior use I would definitely use a good oil base primer on the inside surfaces before plugging and also allow some breathing holes for air passage through the piece. Good luck!


img

Re: big spindle commission

#3

Re: big spindle commission

john lucas

>Thanks Peter This can be hollow although it's a table column and I think the base should be pretty heavy. I've never used a 2 part resin glue but thought I might try it on this project. It will be painted and I don't want any glue lines to show. I thought about epoxy because I'm much more familiar with how it works.

Re: big spindle commission

#4

Re: big spindle commission

Mac

>Hi John, I do a bit of turning for a boat yard that builds custom yachts,they do the blanks,and I do the turning. They use stave construction, epoxy, and the staves are all splined. I believe that the splines are necessary in stave construction.I've done quite a few for them and I can tell you that they never go as fast as you think they will.I work by the hour for them and have found that to be the best way for us.They always seem to take twice as long as the estimates.I've done them up to 18X38,good luck with it.....dont work too cheap,we're worth whatever the market will bear.....

Re: big spindle commission

#5

Re: big spindle commission *LINK*

Peter Hyde

>John the plastic resin glue is not a 2 part one. It's simply a powder you mix with water and is water proof when set. It has no creep characteristics and it sets like glass. I have used various manufacturers and all I can say is beware of shelf life. The nice thing is it cleans off with water and sets in about 3 hours @ 70 deg so there is a good open work time. Sands very nicely and dries to a pale brown colour.


http://www.constantines.com/index.asp?PageAction=VIEWPROD&ProdID=17

Re: big spindle commission

#6

Re: big spindle commission

john lucas

>Thanks Peter I had forgotten that it is one part.

Re: big spindle commission

#7

Re: big spindle commission

john lucas

>Mac After I finish all the drawings and determine the wood I need I'm going to double the time I think it will take. Like you everything I do takes twice as long as I think.

Re: big spindle commission

#8

John, Good luck with the piece, but

Keith Newton

>I would work on the design a bit more. I can't say that I am very fond of the shape. If I were doing it, I would at least put a bit more curve in those two bottom quarter-rounds. Maybe even put some tumble-home, in boat terms on the bottom one. But then again, that is just my taste and 2�. K

Re: big spindle commission

#9

Re: John, Good luck with the piece, but

john lucas

>Keith I'm going to ask her if I can refine the design. This is copied as close as I could get from a poor photo she gave me. I think the first bead is too large and don't like the curve on the bottom section. I would probably change the height of several of the elements as well. Not dramatically mind you but just little subtle changes.

Re: big spindle commission

#10

Re: big spindle commission

Barry Irby

>John, You sure about the 36" height? Kitchen cabinets are 36" but tables are usually closer to 30". I just made a table and the legs were 29 inches tall. Looked way too short until I put the top on.

I would double the time. My projects always take at least twice as I think and then I still write off a lot of time to the "learning curve". I never get out of the steep part of the learning curve because I seldom do the same thing twice. I doubt I could turn that in half a day unless you mean half of 24 hours.

I would not choose this project to try a new glue. I would go with what I know and learn about new stuff on a smaller less important project. At least I would make some experimental practice glue ups first. (On a current project I made a practice leg. I made the initial cuts on it each time. Sort of seemed like a waste of time, but it worked out well and may have saved the other four legs)

On �enlarging your lathe� don�t forget the banjo and tool rest. Generally you can�t �block up� the banjo. The banjo will need to be long enough to reach out horizontally and the post on the tool rest will need to be long enough to center it vertically. Might be time to do two lathes back to back and a floor stand.

Re: big spindle commission

#11

Hi John,

Jorge Castaneda

>I have spent time in boatyards too and used the two part resin, (resorcinol), excellent adhesion and water proof, but it leaves an unsightly purple blue line, epoxie is more discreet.

Re: big spindle commission

#12

Re: big spindle commission

John Lucas

>Thanks Barry. She was adamant about the 36" I'm going to question her further on that if she accepts the commission.

After thinking it over I can turn the bulk of the spindle on my Powermatic as it is. I'll turn the foot off the end. I plan to lower my bed extension the way they have done it on the 3520B. It's easy enough to build a banjo extension. All you need is a shaft bored for the original 1" and then turn a 1" tenon on the end to go into the banjo. That's what Powermatic sells you. The difficult part might be locking the headstock and tailstock in place. I haven't looked at how they did that in enough detail to see if I can build what is necessary.

I agree 100 percent on the learning curve thing. I almost never do the same thing twice.

Re: big spindle commission

#13

Height?

Barry Irby

>Double and triple check the height. The client is never wrong, sometimes they just aren't right. I see 36" as too tall for chairs and too short for bar stools. The problem here is you build exactly what they want, having warned them it is wrong, and it�s still your fault. And you never hear from them or their friends again.

The problem I have with the Learning Curve thing is that I feel like I am thinking up hill or perhaps against the wind. I can't tell you how many times I have done something only to later realize there was a much easier way to do whatever. Sometimes stunningly simpler and easier. Maybe its an age induced ignancy. At least its not hops induced. OTOH, I could stop drinking, but there is no easy way out of aging.

Re: big spindle commission

#14

Table top height is 30" max.

david

>and that is to the finished top height. Many table heights you will find at 29-1/2". John, you need to determine the table top thickness to factor in the height of this column base. My suggestion for normal height dining chairs is 29-1/2" minus the table top thickness.

Re: big spindle commission

#15

Re: big spindle commission

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>John, when I was making staved djembe drums back in the mid- to late-90's I figured out the best way to cut the staves with the least amount of waste. The upper shape in your design is much like a conga which we did a little bit of, using the same technique.

We bandsawed the stave profiles from 2" slabs (A in the pic below), then mitered them on a 14" tablesaw since the profile's total height was almost 6" with the bigger drums. The two end pieces left over on a slab were glued together at the straight edges (shown in B), and a few more staves were cut from that glued piece. AFter that, individual stave blanks were clamped to a special tablesaw sled for mitering the edges. This was tricky with the ogee-shaped shape of the djembe staves, but a simple curve as for a conga or your turning would be less problematic.

C in the pic shows how you might get a single thick stave blank from a 2 x 4, or possibly even 2 or 3 thinner ones.

If you don't have a big enough tablesaw it may be possible to miter the staves on a good bandsaw with a sharp resawing blade.


img

Re: big spindle commission

#16

Re: big spindle commission

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>To clarify the image in my last post, B and C show a white line where the glue joint would be in the right-most piece of each section in the image.

Now, here's a djembe example glued and turned, from padauk and maple staves (at least I think that was maple)--showing the ogee shape of the profile. Each stave is a solid piece of wood, bandsawn from a slab:


img

Re: big spindle commission

#17

Re: Table top height is 30" max.

john lucas

>Thanks David and Barry. The photo I got shows chairs that look like bar stool height. The table top has a thick apron. You can bet I'll check out all the dimensions before finalizing anything. due to your suggestions I'll check the factory dimensions of these tables before I talk to her so I'll have something to base my opinions on.