Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Walnut Bowl - Please Critique

Posts

Walnut Bowl - Please Critique

#1

Bob Moffett

Walnut Bowl - Please Critique

Bob Moffett

>This is a Walnut bowl that I rough turned about a year ago and finished up a couple of weeks ago. It is 12" wide X 5 1/2" tall and about 3/8" thick. The top opening is 4" and the foot is 2 1/2". It has a textured ring in the top that I made with a homemade Sorby texturing tool. It is finished with 3 coats of Waterlox Satin sealer and 3 coats of Waterlox High Gloss.Please let me know how I could make the design better. I know the photo background isn't to good. It's the sofa in the den. This is the side view.


img

Re: Walnut Bowl - Please Critique

#2

Bob Moffett

Re: Walnut Bowl - Please Critique

Bob Moffett

>Bottom view. The foot is 2 1/2".


img

Re: Walnut Bowl - Please Critique

#3

Mike Stafford

Re: Walnut Bowl - Please Critique

Mike Stafford

>I like this view of your bowl Bob as it has a pleasing shape. The texturing is quite lovely. I like the accent it provides to the piece. It enriches an already rich wood with a fine form. Reminds of a fine lace collar around the neck of fine piece of ladies clothing. Good job!

Re: Walnut Bowl - Please Critique

#4

Steven Antonucci

That looks pretty nice-

steve antonucci

>Without putting my hands on it, I don't know that I could say anything negative about it. It looks like you may want to fill the grain on walnut (might just be the photo) and go for the high polish, but overall, a great work.

There was a short debate here a year or so ago about what a bowl vs. hollowform might be. The general consensus was that bowls had openings consistent with their major diameter, hollowforms smaller. For me, I see this as a hybrid- an enclosed bowl or something, since I think teeny tiny holes for hollowforms.

Good job overall.

Steve

Re: Walnut Bowl - Please Critique

#5

ebd

Re: Walnut Bowl - Please Critique

ebd

>I think the piece is wonderful as is. Really good form. The only thing I would change, and it's entirely due to MY OWN narrow-mindedness & bigotry, I would prefer the piece untextured. I'm sure that I'm in a minority and it's an arbitrary preference not a judgement anyway. The piece is beautiful.

Re: Walnut Bowl - Please Critique

#6

Top view tells me...

david

>that I would like the piece better as a flat ellipse. Find the widest point of the piece, strike a horizontal line at that point. Now, disregarding the collar, repeat the curve from the widest point to the collar under the horizontal line. You will end up with a piece approximately half the height. Just my 2 cents worth.

Re: Walnut Bowl - Please Critique

#7

JL

Re: Walnut Bowl - Please Critique

JL

>I like the bowl. I don't like the background :). I feel it detracts from the bowl. Too "busy". It seems like the color values are changing. Here is a panorama shot of your work. You can hopefully see a little of what I mean.

But it is a lovely bowl. The collar is fantastic.


img

Re: Walnut Bowl - Please Critique

#8

Bob Moffett

Re: Walnut Bowl - Please Critique

Bob Moffett

>Thanks Mike, I thought the texturing added a lot to the bowl. It looked sort of plain until I put the texturing on it.

Re: Walnut Bowl - Please Critique

#9

Bob Moffett

Re: That looks pretty nice-

Bob Moffett

>Thanks Steve,I didn't knwo whether to call it a bowl of hollow form. I think of hollow forms as being taller and with a small hole in the top. I think the grain is more due to the picture taker (me) than the bowl.

Re: Walnut Bowl - Please Critique

#10

Bob Moffett

Re: Walnut Bowl - Please Critique

Bob Moffett

>Thanks for your input. I posted one a couple of days earlier that was ambrosia maple that was not as tall and didn't have the texturing. Please look at it and let me know what you think.

Thanks

Re: Walnut Bowl - Please Critique

#11

Bob Moffett

Re: Top view tells me...

Bob Moffett

>David, that sounds like a great idea. That was what I was looking for. I'll try that. I posted an ambrosia maple bowl a day or so prior to posting the walnut one. Please look at it and tell me if that is what you mean. Thanks

Re: Walnut Bowl - Please Critique

#12

Bob Moffett

Re: Walnut Bowl - Please Critique

Bob Moffett

>You are exactly right about the background. It is a sofa in our den. I have since gotten a piece of gray vinyl and that makes a world of difference in the picture. I still have a lot to learn about photographing my work. Thanks.

Re: Walnut Bowl - Please Critique

#13

Re: ambrosia maple: sort of...

david

>I went back and looked at the pics of this piece. There is no profile shot, so I can't tell for sure. The maple piece has a definite edge, while the walnut piece has a convex curve that to me would look good in a squat form, sort of flying saucer like.

Re: Walnut Bowl - Please Critique

#14

Bob Moffett

Re: ambrosia maple: sort of...

Bob Moffett

>Thanks, I'll give that a try.

Re: Walnut Bowl - Please Critique

#15

Re: Walnut Bowl - Please Critique

Ed Siegel

>Can you tell us about your "homemade" Sorby Texturing tool?

Re: Walnut Bowl - Please Critique

#16

ebd

Re: Walnut Bowl - Please Critique

ebd

>Please understand - I am simply biased. But for what it's worth I like the Ambrosia much more because you can follow the grain through the changes in the form all the way from the bottom to the top. It seems to me that the texturing obscures the grain and provides a discontinuity in the grain. Not that that is a bad thing, I'm just not particularly partial to it.

One other thing I might be so bold as to suggest you try. Sometime when you're feeling exploratory, leave the bottom a little thick and when you reverse chuck the piece to finish the bottom turn the pedestal off and make it a recess. I've added a picture. I don't particularly like the piece but it shows what I'm talking about. I like both kinds of bottom. The pedestal lifts the piece off the surface and seems to make it float and the recess kind of joins it to whatever it is sitting on. It's just sometheing to play with for a little variety.


img

Re: Walnut Bowl - Please Critique

#17

Bob Moffett

Re: Walnut Bowl - Please Critique

Bob Moffett

>Sure, I took a 5/8" rod and welded 2 ears on it. Drilled a hole through both ears and went to Klingpore and bought a texturing wheel for a Sorby Texturing tool and put a bolt between the 2 ears and ana old wooden handle on it and I had a texturing tool for about $35. I think the wheel was about $25. Hope this makes sense. You could also use a small gear to make the wheel. I don't have any affiliation with Klingspore, I just shop there. I'll try and post a picture of it either tonight or this weekend.

Re: Walnut Bowl - Please Critique

#18

Bob Moffett

Re: Walnut Bowl - Please Critique

Bob Moffett

>I understand what you mean about the texturing breaking up the grain pattern. That makes a lot of sense. I didn't put any texturing on the maple piece for that very reason. The grain pattern was just to pretty on that piece.

Someone else also suggested taking the pedistal off and dishing out the bottom a little bit. I think that is a good suggestion.

That's why I asked people to to critique it, so I could learn from ya'll and get some more ideas.

Thanks for your comments.

Re: Walnut Bowl - Please Critique

#19

Bob Moffett

Re: Walnut Bowl - Please Critique

Bob Moffett

>Ed, I posted a message about my texturing tool on 5/10/07 about 10:45. Hope this helps.