Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Survey

Posts

Re: Survey

#26

Ric Taylor

Re: Survey

Ric Taylor

>A gathering works for me. The lack of formality encourages casual discussions, then the golden nuggets of great information begin to fly around. That leads to spontaneous demos and try-its on the nearest lathe to illustrate points in the discussion. The $150 will be eaten up by gas, food and lodging.

Ric

Re: Survey

#27

Re: I agree

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>It really depends on the person and where they are in their turning skills. Each has its place.

Ed, you weren't by any chance a teacher or something? ;-)

Re: Survey

#28

Re: How about option #4

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>Another option is books, magazines and DVDs.

I learned to turn before the AAW and turning clubs. Demos, hands-on, etc. weren't an option. Books and magazines worked fine for me, and they still provide me with the most bang for my buck. They also suit my personality better.

Re: Survey

#29

Re: Survey

Robert Henderson

>If you have a specific learning goal - one-on-one.

If you just wish to pick up a lot of different information - symposium

Re: Survey

#30

Re: Survey

keith zimmerman, Normal, IL

>Can't comment on the one-on-one teaching as I have not enjoyed this level of training. However, I agree with the statement someone made about symposia, a great place to see lots of demos and get the creative juices flowing. A gathering type of environment is currently my favorite because the relaxed atmosphere allows so much interaction between the participants that no one feels uneasy about asking anyone a question about an aspect. There is so much informal hands-on going on that it is really hard to go away from a gathering without learning something.

keithz

Re: Survey

#31

All of the above

Ron in Drums PA

>I've been to one symposium, two gatherings, 2 instructors and no clubs ( none around)

I benefited from all of them.

If I was worried about $150, I won't be turning.

One call to a woodturning catalog company would cost more!

Re: Survey

#32

Re: Survey

Wilford Bickel

>Based on my own experience when I decided to get back into turning - a day of one on one training turned out to be invaluable. Since then I would have difficulty justifying that type of training unless it was to learn something specific that I was interested in - otherwise the symposium and gatherings are more value for my money as I get more varied ideas and can pick specific topics to attend during the weekend. Part of the learning at Symposiums is just getting to talk and bounce ideas off of other turners - this can solve problems and you can learn as much from these "bull" sessions as you do the demos.

Re: Survey

#33

A Club Near You?

Rick Allen

>Mid Penn Turners

Area Served: Mid PA

Meeting State: PA

Meeting Date: Various Saturdays

Contact:

Robert Rosand

198 Dug Rd

Bloomsburg, PA 17815

570-784-6158

rrosand@ptdprolog.net

Lehigh Valley Woodturners

Area Served: Greater Lehigh Valley Area

Meeting City: Allentown

Meeting State: PA

Meeting Place: Woodcraft, Lehigh St.

Meeting Date: 4th Tuesday

Number of Members: 59

Chapter Web Site: www.lehighvalleywoodturners.com

Contact:

George Geissler

5522 Heather Ln

Orefield, PA 18069

610-398-7858

gng_jfg@verizon.net

Re: Survey

#34

Thanks

Ron in Drums PA

>Bob is close to me and he hasn't had a meeting in years. I spoke to him about this. Meetings need to be on a set schedule. Bob doesn't want that because of his schedule. That is why that club has fizzled.

Allentown is a two hour drive, at night, each way, on a week night no less, and Orefield is right next door to Allentown. I think the two are combined.

But I appreciate you looking this up for me, thanks again.

Re: Survey

#35

Brian, I plead ...

Ed Moore

>GUILTY. My first job was at St Andrews School in Middletown, Delaware, where they filmed "Dead Poets Society". Then 36 years as a professor at the Naval Academy in Annapolis. And I was the first Director of Tutoring Programs there - until I went back to the Mathematics Department because I was too linear and was a misfit among the psychologists.

I always told my students in mathematics why "Sequence Matters" and related a true story about a fraternity guy who zipped up one step too soon at a party. Obviously, the order of the steps in a computation will affect the answer. In turning, and especially when making boxes, the order in which one does things is extremely important, so the lesson carries over to woodturning.

So, for today's lesson: SEQUENCE MATTERS!!

Ed

Re: Survey

#36

It's also possible that the club ...

Ed Moore

>fizzled because no one besides Bob wanted to do anything. One guy can carry a lot, but a club needs multiple Sherpas if it is going to succeed and flourish.

The Smith Mountain Lake Woodturners was formed in the spring of 2004 and it now has 68 members. At first, a few people did a LOT. Some of the "Old Guard" have stepped aside (willingly) and now we are growing because a lot more people have gotten involved. Some good people have assumed "ownership" and the future looks good at the moment.

Ed

Re: Survey

#37

I sent you a email

Ron in Drums PA

>

Re: Survey

#38

Brad Vietje

Hmmmm...

Brad Vietje

>I'd say for learning techniques, one-on-one would be best (assuming a good instructor).

For ideas and inspiration, the gathering can result in a great number of creative ideas being flung around. This can benefit even an old salt who is sorta stuck in a rut and needs to blend their skills with some new, sometimes crazy, possibly impossible ideas! Neat things can happen in this environment.

For a beginner who has some basic skills, but needs some help, inspiration and encouragement to go to the next level, a symposium can be a fantastic experience.

So there you have it -- all of the above !

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT