Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Survey

Posts

Survey

#1

Survey

TDaniel

>I just had a friend over and we discussed the various ways to learn and the costs of each. One on one, symposiums, gatherings, club meetings, etc. Question is for $150 where can you learn the most? Choose between these:

One on one with an instructor

a Gathering type event

A symposium

Re: Survey

#2

Bob Moffett

Re: Survey

Bob Moffett

>I vote for a symposium because you get to see more demos of different techniques and the Instant Gallery. If you just want to learn one thing, one on one instruction may be the best.

Re: Survey

#3

Re: Survey

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi TD,

I suppose it depends on what you want to learn. Perhaps you want to learn a detail from a turning teacher and you have a chance to meet with some one who can help you one on one, perhaps you want to share what you know with a larger group and informal setting is what will work best like a gathering, perhaps you want to see several top of the line turners teach a few seminars in a setting that is more like a symposium ($150 is under current admisssions).....so with out those qualifiers I can't see the survey you posted actually giving meaningful responses

I think you need to add some detail to your survey to get some answers that have some information that is useful regarding the completed and supported results.

Every one is different so being able to capture what you want within these three classificatiosn also means that we need to know what each one will provide.

Take care,

Jim

Re: Survey

#4

Steven Antonucci

Gatherings Event's don't usually cost $150...

steve antonucci

>The answer has to be "it depends".

Could you pay an instructor and get excellent help for $150? Sure, but you are limited to a couple hour drive in your immediate neighborhood, or you'll incur the costs of gas, meals, and hoteling.

Same at the symposiums, but now the pool of instructors goes way up, and you can target your particular style of turning and interests.

I've been to a couple of Five Barns' events, and last year, Ron Sardo and I spent a few minutes with Dustmaker Mike- a relative newbie turner. Neither Ron nor I are "experts", but after a few minutes of time, we had Mike making curls. Free help for anyone that wanted it.

So, in summary, I think a new turner should save their money and go to a "gathering" to meet other turners who will be happy to help. Once you've got the basics down, taking a class or attending a symposium makes a bunch of sense. If you are an "advanced turner", $150 probably isn't going to go very far...

Steve

Re: Survey

#5

Re: Survey

Lan Brady

>No question in my mind.

You will learn the most at a Gathering!

Lan

Re: Survey

#6

Jim

TDaniel

>I am one who needs "hands-on" time. unless I can get time with the tool and the "coach" I don't seem to learn much. I think I have it but when I try to do it I find that I have missed about 20% of what was taught and that 20% prevents me from accomplishing what i want to do. Now if that person who taught the class can spend a few minutes with me correcting what I do wrong then I learn a lot. I attended a class with Ray key a few years ago and although I thought I had absorbed it all I really didn't know what to do until Ray spent a few minutes explaining a couple of things that i had missed, one on one.

Re: Survey

#7

Re: Survey

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Depends a lot on the individual. I've attended a lot of symposiums and I suppose that I've learned a few things. Spending 2 or 3 days watching a number of different experts gave me more ideas than actual working knowledge. I've attended a couple of gatherings and found that I spent most of my time socializing and helping newbies.

In my opinion there is no subsitute for hands on learning if the instructor knows how to teach. I've had many of my students tell me that they learned more from one day of instruction than they'd learned in a year or two of struggling on their own.

Wally

Re: Survey

#8

Re: Survey

IAN

>definatly has to be a gathering.

one on one although excellent to learn a technique, it is limited to one persons technique or approach.

symposium is good to get exposure to many different techniques or turners styles, but doesn't allow for hands on, and being shown if you are doing it incorrectly.

gathering not only allows you to learn from multiple turners, but also allows you to get hands in most cases. which can cut the learning curve down to a minimal.

IAN

Re: Survey

#9

JL

Re: Survey

JL

>Gathering type event or a one on one with the instructor.

I think the camaraderie and the non-competitive atmosphere of a Gathering type event helps a lot. You can ask a seemingly ridiculous question and it'll be considered. I've been to a couple of symposia - mostly too crowded and too far from the action.

Re: Survey

#10

same here Wally

TDaniel

>class followed by "hands-on" give the best results

Re: Survey

#11

Ian, my thoughts exactly!

TDaniel

>

Re: Survey

#12

JL, that is how I see it too.

TDaniel

>I remember my first class with a nationally known turner; it was totally above my head. I wasted my precious money because I did not get the "coaching" that I needed. I think we need to make certain that the "Gatherings" don't fade out. Sure they are a lot of trouble but i think they are worth it. We need to get more of these Gatherings organized around the country because i think that is the best way to teach a lot of people the techniques of turning. Symposiums are great for teaching ideas but they fall short for teaching skills.

Re: Survey

#13

Re: Survey

john lucas

>TD I'm with Wally. I really enjoy the gatherings but spend a lot of time helping others and just BS,ing. I think hands on is the best way to learn. I really enjoy the symposiums. I don't necessarily learn all that much but get all excited about the turning possibilities and can't wait to get back to the shop.

I look at all 3 as an excuse to help me out of a rut and get my motor reved to try some new things or expand on what I've been doing. Anytime you get more than 2 turners together you learn something. We all do things differently and therefore it's always worth discussing techniques and tips with other turners.

Re: Survey

#14

Re: Survey

Jim Terry

>TD, I did not get to attend last year but after talking to Lan about his experiences and reading the posts of others, the one-on-one experiences of the gathering are extremely valuable. This kind of experience allows you to gain that last 20% you miss at a demo.

Jim Terry

Re: Survey

#15

Thanks Jim

TDaniel

>I think that you have stated well the advantages of a Gathering type event. It is not to replace the symposiums but is a bridge to help those who are learning to gain the skills or techniques they need to move to the next level. Dollar for dollar I don't see how they can be beat. Turners helping turners is the most effective way to pass on the skills that i know of.

TD

Re: Survey

#16

TD

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>TD,

That is fine, I posted thoughts I felt you should consider to try to add clarity to your Survey questions....

Re: Survey

#17

Re: Survey

Allen Neighbors

>I'm partial to the Gathering event, TD.

It's the only place where you can pick and choose and learn at will, from several different people.

The Symposium environment would be second, but you are stuck with only one or two things.

Just my opinion... I really don't know about Symposium atmosphere, but I think from hearing comments on WC and WoW, I'm right in my assumptions.

One-on-one you can only learn what the one person teaches.

I choose the Gathering. :)

Re: Survey

#18

One On one with an Instructor........

Jake Niedling

>Hands on is the best way to learn. The others give you lots of ideas and techiques to try, if you can remember once you get back to the shop. And sometimes they just don't work as well as what was demostrated. Perhaps we just forget or didn't pick-up a small detail.

Re: Survey

#19

It depends on what you have been ...

Ed Moore

>exposed to. A total newbie needs one-on-one instruction. Someone with some experience, but who is bogged down a little, needs a Gathering type environment. But someone who has been exposed to a lot and needs some motivation to go to the next level can learn a lot from a good symposium.

The last person I referred to above will also benefit from a good video/DVD.

Some lessons are learned by repetition. Some lessons can only be learned when we have reached a certain plateau and are ready for them. This latter situation is vastly underestimated by those not familiar with the learning process. A certain level of turning maturity is needed before what is being said has a chance of generating the spark that we need to be receptive.

My reaction to the question is that anyone who thinks just one of the answers can be correct should rethink the process and expand their horizons.

Ed

Re: Survey

#20

Re: It depends on what you have been ...

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

>I think we need all three types of events. I have attended two smaller symposiums, Louisville, TD's gathering, and the meetings of probably the best club in the US. Our eleven yearly demonstrators equal a national symposium! A gathering allows a total newbie to teach others while they have limited turning skills. Most everyone of us can add to the varied knowledge exchange at an informal gathering. As said earlier you must have some knowledge/experience to get the most out of a class or demo. Our club, which has over 400 members, is planning a club picnic in September just to let everyone get to know each other a little better. A mini gathering.

We need to have fifteen, twenty or more gatherings a year. Hands on solidifies what you see in a demo. One of the best parts of last year's gathering had nothing to do with turning. It was the prayer meeting. The exchange of wood from different states was nice also.

Bill

Re: Survey

#21

Re: It depends on what you have been ...

adrien

>I agree. Unfortunately there aren't too many instructors at $150. Similarly for symposia which may entail travel and lodging.

Barring that limitation, I'd vote for individual instruction. Symposia start the juices flowing, and one returns with increased enthusiasm. Unhappily, I've never "gathered", but expect, as with symposia it would enhance one's sense of community, being a part of the enterprise.

Re: Survey

#22

Re: Survey

RevDoug

>I'm fortunate in that I'm a pretty quick study. When TD and I first met on a relief trip to the gulf after Katrina, we talked long into the night and I still use ideas I gathered from him. I took a couple of lessons at Woodcraft, that were only me and 3 other students. Instructor spent most of the time with the other students and kept asking where I had learned to turn. Last year's symposium was an opportunity to gather a few tools, some wood, and an idea or two. At the same time, I attended last year's "Gathering" where I collected a chunk of wood or two, met face to face with so many of the names I've come to respect, picked up loads of info concerning turning, gathering wood, and finishing, not to mention the opportunity to turn some and try techniques that folks were showing in various locations.

So, to answer the question at hand, I guess that as long as there is the opportunity to try my hand at what is being shown, the gathering is my choice. Second only because of the smaller scope would be the hands-on private lesson.

Sorry for the long and wordy answer.

Turn 'em round,

Re: Survey

#23

Re: Survey

Ron McKinley

>I pick up a lot of "tips" at symposiums but one-on-one is the best way to learn........Ron

Re: Survey

#24

Re: Survey

George Van

>I have been to one symposium, zero gatherings, and a few demos with one followed by a two day workshop. I learned the most from the demo followed by the workshop. It helped me practice what I saw during the demo and have the demonstrator show me what I was doing wrong and improve my techniques that were not even pertaining to the demo.

Re: Survey

#25

Re: Survey

Mike Cunningham (Cape May NJ)

>I'm with you guys and agree with all you say. At symposiums I pick up a lot of tips and ideas and love the atmosphere but learn best at a hands-on, particularly one on one.

Mike