Re: It's OFF!!!!!! Congradualtions!!!!
Barry Irby
>I knew you would get it.
Wonder if we (All of us) learned anything?
1: Don't that. Parting off something big and heavy and getting a terrible catch really locks them on. Don't do that.
2: Preventative measures. Might be good to have a plastic washer and or some lubricant on the shaft and faceplate.
3: Impact beats simple force.
4: Brains over brawn.
I was thinking about this a lot. The reason the wooden leaver did not work was the connection failed because he wood was "soft" and broke before it transferred all the force to the Faceplate and shaft. The reason the wrench did not work was it was soft and bent and failed before it put the force on the shaft.
From the dim recesses of ancient memory of Physics it seems to me that Impact has a doubling or "squaring" effect in the force calculations. That's why striking the wrench worked better than just adding leverage. (It was also important that the wrench was made well enough to withstand the impact without bending or breaking.) This is why I was suggesting things like filing a notch in the edge of the faceplate and striking it with a hammer and chisel. Trying to apply the impact force to rotate the FP without the cushion of a soft or weak connection in between.
Check the end of the shaft on the General for galling. Also check the inside of the FP. May need to do a little polishing.



