Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Stopping my lathe

Posts

Stopping my lathe

#1

Stopping my lathe

eliot d

>I have a variable speed lathe. So I can stop it from turning by rotating the variable speed all the way down; and that's what I always do while I'm turning. But the lathe also has a red push/pull knob that turns the power on and off. A friend came over once to try my lathe, and I noticed that he always turned it off and on with the knob. I don't like it because the lathe speed will be what it was before turning it off.( I do push the knob in to turn off the power when I'm done turning for a while, but even then I turn the speed all the way down first.) But is there something to be said for using the on/off switch while turning? Or, put the other way around, is there a PROBLEM with using the variable speed control to frequently stop the lathe?

Re: Stopping my lathe

#2

Leo Van Der Loo

If either one wears out, which one would you like

Leo Van Der Loo

>to replace ??, other than that, I do see no negative to use one or the other, just my way of looking at it.

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Stopping my lathe

#3

Re: Stopping my lathe

Fog Tanner

>I guess part of it would depend on how often you stop and start. I have two lathes with variable drives. On one there is a red stop button that kills the power to the controller, along with a button on the controller that just stops the motor (also has electronic brake). The other has a "power on button" which supplies power to the controller, but it has a red stop button to stop the motor - no electronic brake enabled on it.

On both I use the "controller" stop button and leave the power to the controller on until I am through for the day. I generally leave the power to the controller on even if I am not going to be using it for a while. Years working around large computers, I found that they like to stay at a constant temp and that heating up and cooling down can shorten the life. As far as using the controller speed to slow the lathe down, that will just wear the "pot" (i.e variable resisitor) out a little sooner - so you may ao may not see it go out in your lifetime. You are the one running it, so whatever you are comfortable with is the best for you. On my big lathe, the brake is disabled and I use the handwheel to stop the spindle in a few seconds when doing boxes and smaller bowls. On larger bowls(19"-20"), it can freewheel and give me a break from the pounding.

Re: Stopping my lathe

#4

Re: Stopping my lathe

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I would not use the pot [the VS control knob] to stop the lathe for 2 reasons. First is the potential to not get it turned all the way "off" so that even though the spindle has stopped, there's still a small amount of juice being delivered to the motor windings. That will creat heat and eventually damage your motor. Second, many (but not all) controller-driven lathes have an electronic brake that's actuated by the off-switch. Dialing it down may negate this feature.

My VS lathe has both an emergency kill switch (mushroom-type) and a 2-button on/off on a satellite. For someone like me who turns the machine on and off frequently, the on/off is the best choice. I've set the speed that I want to use for the operation that I'm doing, and I don't have to keep fussing with the controller every time I turn on the lathe. I do dial the pot down to about the 300 rpm setting when I'm done turning, and always check that setting before turning the lathe on to start a new turning session.

mm

Re: Stopping my lathe

#5

Re: Stopping my lathe

john lucas

>I do like Mark does. Also the electronic brake works to stop the turning when you turn off the stop button on my Powermatic. I don't like turning the speed button down because everything is still on. It would be easy to just walk away at the end of the day and leave it that way. I prefer the lathe to be completely off when I leave it for whatever reason.

Re: Stopping my lathe

#6

Re: Stopping my lathe

Steven Smith

>I have a PowerMatic 3520 and I use the speed control to start and stop the lathe until the end of the session when I turn the power off and unplug it - inverters are expensive should you get a power surge. I use the speed control because thats what the instruction manual said to do.

Re: Stopping my lathe

#7

Re: Stopping my lathe

eliot d

>You response is different from most of the others; but I'm impressed that you (unlike myself) read the manual, which backs you up, and for that matter backs me up, since that's the way I do it on my Powermatic 3520A. I think I may just call them to understand better just why they recommend this method.

Re: Stopping my lathe

#8

Re: Stopping my lathe

Bill Howatt

>Interesting! Please post what they tell you. A guess is that if you don't have a braking resistor the lathe will stop faster than just letting it free-wheel with no power on the motor.

It does provide a degree of safety since the lathe won't inadvertently start at the last setting which may be too high. When I remoted my On/Off buttons on my General I deliberately made sure the On button was only (I have two Off buttons) beside the speed control so I could easily see it when I started the lathe.

Bill

Re: Stopping my lathe

#9

Re: Stopping my lathe

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Eliot, it depends on how the box was designed to work. I have a Minarik DC variable speed controller on my Vicmark mini, and the manual says in big letters, DO NOT USE THE SWITCH to turn the lathe on and off. To do so shortens motor life and voids the warranty. They want the operator to use the dial to dial the speed down to zero. I've been using it that way since I bought in in 1996 and no failures yet.

On the other hand, some boxes have a power on/off switch as well as a run/stop switch. My Poolewood works that way. The Vega has switches that I am not even supposed to touch, much less operate. It uses a run/stop switch as well as the dial for controlling speed.

Bill

Re: Stopping my lathe

#10

What's a manual... LoL

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>On my 3520 I use the red button or the remote on/off switch to stop the spindle. On each turning the lathe is stopped and started 25-30 times. We'll see how long it lasts.

When all else fails read the manual is the norm. Does anyone read the entire manual before using the tool?

Re: Stopping my lathe

#11

Re: Stopping my lathe

Leppikallio

>Frequence converters (inverters) doesn't hate anything more than power on / off. Or most of them. I doesn't know PWM (for DC) current that well but I'm sure those also have some contactors in their power supply which doesn't love that power on/off.

All inverters and probably most PWM controllers have drive enable / run switch which is efectively on/off switch but it is the friendly way to do that. This is usually the switch what causes that braking function to take place. One way to stop lathe is turn direction switch to off so no direction (forward/reverse is selected) but then there is not braking (usually). Same thing with main power off function, no braking when power off. Also some / all drives take some time to shut down so that is not the good way to stop lathe. However all systems should have that safety switch because their most of the time has that power off -> switch off function (so that after blackout lathe won't start to run on its own).

I wouldn't / don't stop lathe with turning speed off (which means your are turning drive current frequence to 0 or close to 0). Because indeed you are not turning current off (well basically you may be turning it off because drives control both current and frequence but...). As a safety measurement I understand that at the end of a day you may wish to turn speed low enough so that nothing will explode off the lathe next day. However I think that it should be one of the most important things to always and everytime to check lathe speed before hitting on button.

Because we are talking about motor controllers and inverters one more thing. Most of these drives have those ramp functions so that when you power them on or hit run button they will speed up slowly. However I wouldn't recommend using these functions with lathe because you don't want to experience that surprise that you turn speed knob more and more because lathe doesn't run fast enough. You start to turn but lathe is speeding more and more.... after a moment it is good to have "off" switch close... Slow down should have ramp so that when you hit stop button controller won't try to stop lathe too quickly. Nasty things will happen sooner than later if it does.

Re: Stopping my lathe

#12

Now I'm scared...My General lathe

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>okay, now I'm worried that I'm doing harm to my lathe. On the General 26020 VS there is a dial for adjusting speed, which you can turn all the way down to 0 to stop it. Or there is a toggle switch below the dial that you turn right to go in reverse, left to forward or center to stop. Then there is a Green on button/ Red off button. I normally use the toggle switch to turn the lathe off...and then the Red off button when I'm done for the day. If I'm frying something could somebody let me know. I'm be seriously bummed if I am. I'm at work or I'd go check the "manual".

Thanks!

Jen

Re: Stopping my lathe

#13

Re: Now I'm scared...My General lathe

Bruce Forrest

>You got a manual?? I'd have to go check, but I'm pretty sure mine came with about one sheet which said next to nothing.

Anyway, most of the time I use the red/green buttons. Probably a habit picked up using the table saw.

Re: Stopping my lathe

#14

Re: Now I'm scared...My General lathe

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Jen, I don't what the system is on the General. We have seven Woodfast lathes in our local community woodshop. There are dozens of turners who use the lathes. Some of them got in the habit of turning the lathes off by just turning the speed control dial down to zero. As a result a couple of the systems fried and had to be replaced. The off button is meant to be used to turn the lathe off. The speed dial doesn't actually turn it off.

Wally

Re: Stopping my lathe

#15

Re: Now I'm scared...My General lathe

Bill Howatt

>Hi Jennifer,

I have an Altivar 28 VFD on my General 26020. If yours is the same and you look on P58 in the book it shows what is called "2-wire control"; this is what the General uses (I remoted my on/off and speed pot so I was snooping in the book previously to see how it worked). The switch you mention applies the 24V to one or the other of the LI1 or LIx terminals depending on the desired direction.

It also says that the "open or closed state of the input controls running or stopping". I would take that to mean that what you are doing is just fine. It is leaving the power on inside the VFD box but when the switch is in the center position there is no power sent to the motor.

Bill

Re: Stopping my lathe

#16

Re: Now I'm scared...My General lathe

eliot d

>I guess I'm glad that I asked the question since so many different answers are coming in, and none of us wants to fry anything. I said I will check with the Powermatic people, and I will. But I'm surprised that someone from that company --or someone closely related to them --- hasn't gotten into this by now.

Perhaps I could simplify the discussion by asking, "On a variable speed lathe controlled by frequency, is there harm done by repeatedly turning the variable speed knob to zero during the normal course of turning ?"

Re: Stopping my lathe

#17

Re: Now I'm scared...My General lathe

eliot d

>I suppose I'm glad that I asked the question since so many different answers are coming in, and none of us wants to fry anything. I said I will check with the Powermatic people, and I will. But I'm surprised that someone from that company --or someone closely related to them --- hasn't gotten into this by now.

Perhaps I could simplify the discussion by asking, "On a variable speed lathe controlled by frequency, is there harm done by repeatedly turning the variable speed knob to zero during the normal course of turning ?"

Re: Stopping my lathe

#18

Re: Now I'm scared...My General lathe

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Thanks Bill, I'm still at work so haven't looked at the manual, but I'm thinking that I probably did when I bought the thing. I'm sure I read it fron to back...or as much as I could stand :) I can't imagine that I would not have read carefully the part about which way to shut it off.

The manual for the VS part was like a text book and horribly boring.

Thanks again. You've eased my mind.

Jen

Re: Stopping my lathe

#19

Re: Now I'm scared...My General lathe

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Thanks Wally,

That's what I'm thinking too. I don't ever use the speed dial to turn it off. That would seem to be a hassle trying to remember where I had the speed set every time? I think I'll keep doing what I'm doing.

I sure hope where ever I retire to has a community center with 7 lathes! Man that sounds like heaven to me!

Jen

Re: Stopping my lathe

#20

Re: Now I'm scared...My General lathe

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>I know what you mean Bruce. The part that General wrote is pretty lame, not much to it, but the manual that came with the controller was like a small paperback. Even though it was written in English, it might as well have been Japanese. I couldn't make heads or tails out of it :)

Jen

Re: Stopping my lathe

#21

I'm glad too Eliot!

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>

Re: Stopping my lathe

#22

Re: Now I'm scared...My General lathe

Juergen

>After reading all these comment I decided to check my 280. I've had my General for almost 8 years. It has a Square D VFD. The only time I've unplugged my unit is when I go away for extended periods, there's a lightning storm or when the unit overloads an I have to recycle it. My lathe has the standard magnetic on/off switch and a secondary switch consisting of a paddle switch marked Forward - Off - Reverse and a potentiometer with 1-10 calibration marks.

The magnetic switch off (red) button DOES NOT cut off power to the VFD but it disables the secondary switch. As a matter fact the VFD is always on showing RDY (ready) on the display. The only way to turn it off is to pull the plug. Essentially it's a series connection VFD->Magnetic Switch->Secondary switch/Pot

I only use the secondary switch to control the lathe and typically use only the paddle switch to turn the lathe on and off. The only potential problem is turning the lathe on with the pot at max RPM. But that's why I moved the secondary switch to an 8ft embelical, which is mounted out of the line of file. I understand this is standard on the new 280s.

To show how robust the system is I've accidentally gone from forward to reverse while at 2500 RPM with no negative effects. Button line, I wouldn't worry about burning up the 280 it's a GREAT Lathe.

Re: Stopping my lathe

#23

Re: Now I'm scared...My General lathe

john lucas

>Elliot I just checked my Powermatic 2035A manual and there isn't mention at all about leaving the power on or off.

Re: Stopping my lathe

#24

Looked at my diagram

Bill Howatt

>I went and looked at the circuit diagram that I made of my 260 (do you mean 260 or is there a 280?). The pushbutton switches are configured like a standard magnetic switch and control a relay with a 240V coil. The relay only connects the 24V DC provided by the controller to the paddle switch and in effect using this switch like Jennifer and others do is electrically the same as pushing the on/off pushbutton switch. The relay also has a contact that provides the "seal" function for the on pushbutton.

I can't get at the back of my lathe easily but your observation supports the above.

Bill

Re: Stopping my lathe

#25

Re: Now I'm scared...My General lathe

Bill Howatt

>Hi Again,

See my response to Juergen below. To summarize it, what you are doing is electrically exactly the same as pushing the on/off buttons.

The manual that describes the VFD is the technical manual for the VFD and unless you understand motor controllers and some electronics it is useless to a lathe operator. I doubt if it tells you how to shut it off the best way because the controller can be used in many configurations. If you do see something, let us know.

Bill