Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Trend Airshield Vs Triton Resporator?

Posts

Re: Trend Airshield Vs Triton Resporator?

#26

Re: Trend Airshield Vs Triton Resporator?

Bill Clark

>I have had both. I owned the Trend first. It worked OK for me but it always felt heavy on my forehead. This is because the batteries, motor and filter set up is all in front. It always felt like it would slide down and hit my glasses which it did frequently. To stop that movement I made it fit tighter but then it gave me a headache. When it died I got a Triton. I love it. It fit my head better and the neck collar covers my beard. The flip up face shield is a real nice feature that I use quite a bit. Because the shield is a solid piece of lexan and well mounted there is extra protection for you face and head in case a work piece comes loose. The battery lasts about twice as long as the Trend, 6 to 8 hours. The batteries are not replaceable (I have to check on the new units as they may be) but a second motor/battery unit costs about the same as a second Trend battery alone. The motor belt pack works best if it is worn on your hip, not in the back. The directions recommend this. Because the motor and its weight are on your hip, not your head it is quieter and makes the helmet a lot lighter. I was worried about the hose restricting my movement but I have the newer flexible one and have not had any problems with the hose restricting movement or catching on anything. The filter set up is two stage which is excellent. Because the Triton has a neck collar and fits around your neck, not your chin, it seals and filters better. The flip-up face shield does distort your vision a little but not enough to cause any problems making accurate cuts or inhibiting general vision. There is one feature that I have found cumbersome however. The ear pieces are not well designed. They can be removed, which I did, and I installed some hard foam to fill the space. Overall, for me the Triton is a superior set up in comfort, weight on the head and battery life.

Re: Trend Airshield Vs Triton Resporator?

#27

Re: Thanks Tom

Tom Minehan

>I'm not sure what I expected but my first impression was "All they did was add a motor, some filters, padding and $200 to a regular face shield". Perhaps it's my personal bias against shop things plastic especially snap together. I bought it anyway and it does meet my expectations. I would buy another one if the need should arise.

Re: Trend Airshield Vs Triton Resporator?

#28

Trend

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Dom,

I've had the Trend for about two years now. First of all let me say that I love the design and the comfort and the ease of use of this unit, but after about 10 months I noticed several things that were failing on it that concerned me. The face shield had small fissure cracks all around the edges, (I had never been hit by flying anything in the face) the material that seals around your face was cracked like crazy and uncomfortably scratchy on my face and I assume allowing dust to get in, and the plastic spacers between the tightening knobs and the flip up mechanism were cracking and breaking. I really love the Trend for its compact design and ease of use, but like Tom, I think it could be made a lot more ROBUST for the $$ you pay for one. The housing plastic is just plastic. I unfortunately dropped mine a month or so ago on the shop floor and cracked the front of the unit. It doesn't hamper the device, but it ticked me off that it just cracked! If it's to protect my face and head, I would have thought that it wouldn't crack from a drop at 3ft. Getting back to the 10 month problems... I contacted TREND in Kentucky and they were very concerned and helpful. I even sent them pictures via email of the problems with the thing falling apart. They determined that they wanted me to ship it back and they ended up sending me a new one. This one seems to be holding up a bit better....no fissure cracks in the face shield and the spacers are not cracking up. The seal is again cracked all over and now this one is the one I dropped so it's got a nice big crack in the front plastic the covers the pre filter. I'd have to say that when this one bites the dust, I'll do some shopping. For nearly $300 I think they can do a lot better in making a unit that will hold together better. For that kind of money I think the thing should last at least 5 years...and I'll be surprised if this one makes it to 3 or 4. I do love the comfort and ease of use. It's too bad the the accessories are so pricey too. $25 for a pack of 10 plastic overlays? Puleeze! I've heard that motorcycle shops have

the same for cheeper but I haven't checked. I'll need to make one of the batteries that I've read about when these go bad. $40 something for one is ridiculous.

Good luck with your search.

Jen

Re: Trend Airshield Vs Triton Resporator?

#29

Yes, you are correct

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Thanks for pointing that out.

Re: Trend Airshield Vs Triton Resporator?

#30

Oh boy!

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Jennifer,

Wow, I was all set to go for the Trend. But your comments really hit a nerve with me. I'm not the most "graceful" of people and I tend to drop, bump, and generally make life hard for all my more delicate tools (that's one reason while most of my shop floor is covered in rubber mats!).

After reading your comments (as well as the others in this thread) that question the durability of the Trend's design, I have to question why I would want to purchase it!

As I stated in response to similar comment in this thread, I have a hard time paying top dollar for something that looks like it came out of a gum ball machine.

Thanks,

Dominic

Re: Trend Airshield Vs Triton Resporator?

#31

Re: Oh boy!

Bill Clark

>Dominic, my Trend was the old model but it was just cheap plastic and the head band broke in two places and I was not rough on it. I agree that Trend's prices are out of sight for the apparent quality of materials. When my old Trend died I checked out the Triton for that very reason. I paid about $200.00 and got what I believe is a better quality unit. I would advise you to look at a Triton and try it on before you decide. I found the Triton fit me better and the weight of the helmet was better balanced than the Trend. I've been happy with mine and two members of my turning club just bought the Triton.

Re: Trend Airshield Vs Triton Resporator?

#32

Re: Oh boy!

Bill Howatt

>I was going to ignore this thread because of the numerous responses. I have a Lee Valley plain face shield which is made by American Optical. On the clear shield it is labelled W96 Propionate. I have dropped it a few times and the shield has cracked about half its length from the drop. I was surprised since it seems fairly flexible.

I have a Triton and I like it but I also don't have much to compare it to. Mine had the stiff hose but it was replaced with the newer, more flexible model. It is a little bit of work to get on since I have to take my glasses off but once it is on I don't mind it at all but I do tend to get oblivious to things like that.

I also consider the hard-hat an important safety feature. I know of 2 turners who have been literally knocked unconcious by flying wood hitting their forheads. Like they say, other tools will maim you, your lathe can kill you.

Bill

Re: Trend Airshield Vs Triton Resporator?

#33

Re: Trend Airshield Vs Triton Resporator?

Fog Tanner

>Like you I was concerned about my breathing, that and I have some allergies to some of the wood I turn. My allergist told me you can become sensitized to any wood given enough exposure, so I didn't want to add to the list.

Originally I bought a Powervisior, much the same as the Trend. I have never been reall happy with the filtration, knowing that it doesn't trap the real harmful dust. The Trend fall pretty much into the same filtration. I looked at the Triton when it came out, looked up the specs and found it was higher than the Trend or Powervisor. But, the helmet bothered me. This was now a have to item for a new respirator, but the Trition was just too bulky.

I settled on an Airstream and have not looked back. When I turn, I am wearning it. Along with all these I have a Oendia cyclone and a dust hood that really works. I was turning some Cedar not too long ago (I am allergic to it) and could not even tell it was cedar other than it was red. After reading the Book of Raffin and his mention about receiveing a head wound that required thirteen stitches, I was pretty much convinced that it was only a matter of time - hence the requirement for some sort of head protection. This is the secondary reason I always wera it while turning.

My only regret was not buying it sooner, when I bought mine the price had gone up and I had the price of the Powervisor to add in on top of that. I did spend and additional $130 on their Smartcharger. I can use it for 1 hour or 10-12 hours and put on charge and not worry about overcharging. So if you price it without the Smart Charger against the Trend it is not a whole lot more for a lot better unit...

Good luck in your quest, I know I spend some agonizing time with mine. My wife kept telling me to just buy it and not worry about it any more (epecially after one of my 3 day sinus headaches after turning), really need to learn to listen to her more...

Fog