Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Trend Airshield Vs Triton Resporator?

Posts

Trend Airshield Vs Triton Resporator?

#1

Trend Airshield Vs Triton Resporator?

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Hello Everyone,

Like everyone, I'm concerned about prolonged exposure to wood dust. I have a dust collector pick up at my lathe and an air filter going in at all time when I'm working in the shop. But I realize that additional protection is sometimes required. I tend to turn more in the winter, when it's not easy to have an opened window or door to allow for ventilation. Plus I've been turning more and more tropical hardwoods recently. I'm not sure if thats doing my sinuses any good! I wear a disposable dust mask but feel that they really don't do that great of a job by themselves.

I always wear a face mask. So the next logical step would be to combine the two and purchase one of those air filter masks. I'm not ready to buy one just yet. Rather, I'm at the point now where I'm investigating these items to determine which direction to go.

At this moment the two products in the lead are the Trend Airshield ($279.99 at Woodcraft) and the Triton Respirator ($189.95 at Amazon.com)

Despite the apparent cost difference, I prefer the compact design of the Trend Airshield over the Triton. The Triton with it's "membrane-like" dust hood just looks like a royal PITA to wear! And that umbilical looks like an invitation to catch on something. But that's not to say that the Triton is totally out of the picture! I just need to hear from those of you that use these airshields. So here are my questions:





  1. Which one did you get and why?


  2. How do you rate their performance in regards to getting the dust before it gets in your lungs?


  3. How comfortable are they to wear? Do you wear them all the time when you turn?


  4. How's the battery life?


  5. What limitations do they impose on your work (field of vision, hearing impalement), and how did you adjust to them?


  6. Is there another brand of "air shield" besides these two?


  7. What about the "comsumables" (filters, batteries, spare parts, etc)? How are these priced? What extras (replacement faceshield, spare battery pack, extra charger...) would you recommend getting?


  8. Lastly, has any wood working magazine or website done a comprehensive review of these two airshields?





Thanks in advance.

See ya around,

My ugly mug


Dominic

Re: Trend Airshield Vs Triton Resporator?

#2

Re: Trend Airshield Vs Triton Resporator?

Russ Babbitt

>I can't speak for these particular products, I have older versions of both. A self contained unit like the Trend and a belt pack hose unit like the Triton. I like the all self contained unit best because there is no hose or belt pack to deal with. In my case both head units weight the same. It seems I always reach for the Trend like unit.

Re: Trend Airshield Vs Triton Resporator?

#3

I had both...

Peter Teubel

>1st I bought the Triton. Never liked it from the beginning. The hood is an integral part of the whole system to seal your face. Too hot in the warm weather. Batteries are not replaceable, so you are down for the count while it's recharging. The other thing I found annoying was the plenum inside the top of the helmet which channels fresh air onto your face. When I adjusted the helmet for a good snug fit, I( found that I was crushing the plenum (i.e. restricting the air flow) due to its thin design. Also the hose is not flexible enough (although I heard they changed to a more flexible one not too long ago).

Needless to say, I sold it very soon thereafter.

I bought the Trend Airshield and I find it quite comfortable. Replaceable battery pack. In fact, you can run TWO batteries packs at the same time to double the run time. Using the shield overlays really help keep the shield clean. Judging by the filter, it's seems to be collecting ALOT of dust.

Re: Trend Airshield Vs Triton Resporator?

#4

Triton...

Joe Pack

>Hi Dominic,

I just bought the Triton a month or so ago. The Trend seemed awfully top/front heavy when I bent my head down as though I was working at the lathe. The Triton is no feather, but it feels more balanced to me.

The biggest reason for the Triton purchase, though, was that the Trend did not fit my fat head. I wear a 7 3/4-7 7/8 hat. The best I could get out of the Trend was about a 7 1/2. It just plain hurt, even when I adjusted it all the way loose.

I haven't used the Triton for any long time yet, so I can't give you an intelligent comment about it yet.

Re: Trend Airshield Vs Triton Resporator?

#5

Re: Trend Airshield Vs Triton Resporator?

Gil Jones on Lake Seminole GA

>Dominic,

I have been using the Trend AirShield for a bit over 2 years, and I like it a lot! Cost was not a factor as it was a birthday gift from my Wife and Kids. I would have bought it myself anyway. The Trend unit and associated filters do cost more than the Triton. My decision was based on not wanting to wear a fanny-pack with an air hose. I have two batteries, and when using one at a time, they last me all day (plus, the first one is recharged by the end of the day, and the second battery gets to recharge overnight. I am working on a plug-in power supply to eliminate the batteries (which may or may not be a good idea). I vacuum the two filters a few times during the day, and wash them several times a year. I have not replaced the main filter yet, but have replaced the first-stage filter once, and I have replaced the clear face-shield overlay once so far. The face-shield has been whacked several times (and save my eyes/face) but is still in good condition. The "woodturners accessory" pack contains enough goodies to last several years unless you are wasteful. You may want to keep in mind that the Trend is for "dust" only (don't know about the filters for the Triton). CA and lacquer fumes will go right on through the Trend filters, but they are NOT made to stop them anyway. I would choose the Trend again if the need arose. It takes a day or so to get used to wearing it, but it is not a problem at all. Glasses are no trouble; I cannot speak for a beard though I suspect one would be no problem. Whichever way you choose, I reckon you will be glad you did.

Gil

Re: Trend Airshield Vs Triton Resporator?

#6

Re: Trend Airshield Vs Triton Resporator?

Wayne Leach-NW Ontario

>Hi Dom,

I have been woodworking for almost 50 years and recently was diagnosed by an allergist with allergies to all things in the forest (trees). This was good news as I live in the forest of NW Ontario and winter in the forest in Georgia and I am a woodworker!!!

I have the Triton and it is the only one I have experience with. Here are some of my observations/comments since getting it for Christmas from my wife.

. It can be usaed for many purposes because it has ear protection-such as chainsawing,shop sawing,planing (my 20 inch planer rips the ear drums) etc.

. I saw a lot of Melamine and there is nothing worse for toxic dust-the Triton is great for this!

. I used it for turning all winter in Americus,GA and at first I was not happy with it but came to regard it as a valuable asset. It seemed a little bulky but I got used to it, the hose does not get in the way as it routes down the back and the battery supply can be placed there as well. Air flow is adequate and you can feel the fresh air and the visor never fogs.

. The filter does a great job of stopping the dust and is very easy to clean. The battery lasts longer than the 4 hour claim. I dont use the ear muffs when turning and the outfit is not that uncomfortable so I use it all the time. It takes only a minute to get ready to turn-I am retired so I have all kinds of time anyway???

. I got a spare face shield just in case? The optics thru the face shield are not the greatest but I wear stronger glasses and so far have adapted very well.

Thats about all I can tell you but I am thinking of getting the Trend for woodturning only and using it for portability and travel. I used the Triton today for the first time cutting wood with the chainsaw and it is terrific at keeping the choking sawdust out of the lungs. I know that both will get much use over the years.

Hope this gives you some insights and feel free to contact me if I can be of any further use.

Best regards,

Wayne

Re: Trend Airshield Vs Triton Resporator?

#7

Re: Trend Airshield Vs Triton Resporator?

Tom Minehan

>Dominic - Here are my answers to your questions. I can only comment on the Trend as I have not used others.

1) I needed some sort of dust filtration as the dust from turning and sanding was killing my sinus. Three years ago I bought the Trend becasuse I wanted a one piece unit that provided face and lung protection.

2) Based on the amount of dust trapped in the filters I would have to say it is working fine.

3) Very comfortable to wear. It took a very short time of wearing it until I forgot that I had it on. Now I pull the usual dumb things like trying to blow the dust off of something or stick a pencil in my mouth with it on.

4) Battery life is around 6 hrs between charges. The early units had battery problems. Trend replaced the problem batteries without charge. The early batteries were NICAD and lasted around 4 hrs. The replacement batteries are NIMH and are problem free. The down side of the batteries and charging system is the length of time to charge (14 hrs) and the batteriey must be removed from the unit to charge. There are several posts on various forums showing how to build a replacement quick charge battery pack using Radio Shack parts for around $20.

5) None The fan does emit some noise but you soon get used to it. Hearing is somewhat reduced but I can still hear with it on. As mentioned above I had no problem adjusting to it. Just tonight I tried to stick a pencil in my mouth with it on.

6) Yes - Others will respond about them

7) Trend has an "Accessory Pack that they sell that contains the most needed replacement parts. Individual parts are also available. My opinion is these parts are very overpriced; in fact, I don't see why the whole unit costs so much. You won't need a spare charger but a spare battery is a must if you turn for long periods.

8) Don't know

My only complaint is the cost. To me the construction seems more fitting to a $100 unit as opposed to $250-$300. It has been knocked because it is not listed as meeting NOISH standards for such units. My understanding is that it meets the equiviliant UK standards. I have heard that they are coming out with a new model this Spring. Trend has a US office in Kentucky. They were very helpful to me over the battery problem.

Tom

Re: Trend Airshield Vs Triton Resporator?

#8

Re: Trend Airshield Vs Triton Resporator?

Colin Spencer

>Dominic

I have the Trend, I chose it because it was one self contained unit and the spares were easily available form any Trend supplier in the UK and there are not as many Triton stockists. I liked the all in one design and want something I can take off easily and the Trend fitted the bill. The performance of the Trend is excellent since I stated using it I don't get any crud up my nose and the filters are always full. The Trend took a couple of hours to get used to I now put it on before I go into the workshop for any work either turning or flat and take it off after I have left, I sometimes forget that I have it on annoying when you pick up the phone. Battery life is OK on mine with the original NiCad battery but I have made my own packs with NiMH batteries and these are superb usually lasting at least two full workshop sessions and only costing a fraction of what Trend batteries cost. I wear glasses and have a beard and find that the Trend seals well and don't find any problems with filed of vision or noise the only problem is If you wear ear protectors when using a saw or planer it can be a bit awkward. Trend do a filter pack and if I remember rightly that has three primary filters and one secondary filter, with my amount of turning I find that with regular vacuuming this set lasts me about 12 months. I also replace the face seal about once a year too as in the hot humid climate in Spain where I now live I find the rubber goes off but it is inexpensive. Spare batteries are a must but make your own as you will save a serious amount of money. I have never used a Triton but am a very happy Trend owner IMHO treat it carefully like you would any piece of safety equipment and it should give years of service.

I hope this helps

Colin

Re: Trend Airshield Vs Triton Resporator?

#9

Re: Trend Airshield Vs Triton Resporator? *LINK*

joaz

>I have been using the Trend for years and have been very happy with it. Never a problem. If you get it, be sure and get the plastic overlays for the the shield as it does scratch easily.


http://www.maine-web.com/woodturning

Re: Trend Airshield Vs Triton Resporator?

#10

Re: Trend Airshield Vs Triton Resporator?

Danny Wells

>Dominic,

I have had the Triton for about 18 months now. I really like it.

1) the batteries are now replaceable and the charge does last longer than the claim. Mine goes over 4 hours considerably.

2) It is comfortable and not top heavy. I have not found the belt pack to be bothersome at all. I use it for everything. I recently was doing a lot of router work, and ear muffs worked well as well as the dust filter.

3) It has a two-stage filter, a pre-filter that can be easily blown off and is relatively inexpensive to replace as well as the cartidge filters to get the really fine dust.

4) It seems to me that the replacement parts are relatively inexpensive compared to other brands.

5) I bought it at the SWAT symposium from Craft Supplies. The guy manning the booth said that it was all he used. I figured if a pro was using it full time, it must do a good job.

6) For me price was the one of the factors. Since I purchased it, it obviously was the best deal in my opinion.

Re: Trend Airshield Vs Triton Resporator?

#11

Re: Trend Airshield Vs Triton Resporator?

Russ Fairfield

>You should add "Comfort" to your list of things to compare.

I think comfort should be at the top of the list, and it seems to be the one thing that the manufacturers forgot about. These things are heavy, and you will be wearing it for long periods of time. If you are not used to wearing a hardhat or something similar, it can get uncomfortable real quick. I see a lot of units hanging on shop walls gathering dust because the owner found it too uncomfortable to wear.

I got the old AirMate because it was the only one available 10 years ago. I have managed to keep it in batteries and face gaskets from alternative sources. I make my own faceshields or modify what is available by drilling new holes. The filters can be blown out with an airhose.

But, it is one of those that hangs on the shop wall gathering dust. By the time they got all of the duct work stuffed inside of the hardhat, there is no room left for my head. For anyone who wears a hat larger than a Size 7-1/8, this thing is difficult to wear, and impossible for larger than a 7-1/2. Unfortunately, I haven't found the new ones on the market to be any better.

Re: Trend Airshield Vs Triton Resporator?

#12

Triton Resporator

Ron in Drums PA

>Since I never tried on a Trend I can't really say which one is better. I've had my Triton now for about 2-1/2 years and I am happy with it.

I'm still using the primary filter (comes with two) that came with the helmet. I blow them out regularly and every so often I throw them into the dishwasher when the wife isn't looking. The secondary filter I change once a year, whether I need to or not.

The original set of batteries lasted only about 2 hours after 6 months. I called Triton and they sent me a free replacement. The charge on this set last 4-5 hours. I know someone who replaced the batteries with cells they purchased online and they last 6-7 hours on a charge. I plan on doing the same eventually.

The helmet is warm during the summer months but not uncomfortable. If you turn in the sun it would be unbearable. I like the belt on the battery pack because when it starts getting tight I know I need to go on a diet. I don't find the weight of the pack bothersome. The hose is really non issue for me.

I'm still using the original shield, it has gunked up a few times and I was able to clean it with mineral spirits. It is surprisingly clear of scratches.

I think if I was buying my first respirator I would would look into the cost AND the availability of the filters, then the cost of the helmet and base my purchase in that order.

Re: Trend Airshield Vs Triton Resporator?

#13

Thanks Colin

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Colin,

You wrote:

"The performance of the Trend is excellent since I started using it, I don't get any crud up my nose and the filters are always full.

Thank you! That's what I was looking to hear. I didn't need a scientific study. Just an observation from someone that uses it.

"The Trend took a couple of hours to get used...I sometimes forget that I have it on annoying when you pick up the phone."

There's an endorsement for the comfort level right there! If you can forget that you're wearing it, that is a plus in my book.

Dominic

Re: Trend Airshield Vs Triton Resporator?

#14

Thanks Ron

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>

Re: Trend Airshield Vs Triton Resporator?

#15

"Comfort" been bumped up to the top

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Russ,

You make a very good point. If a type of safety gear is uncomfortable to wear, 9 times out of 10 it'll end up not getting used.

Thanks for the advice.

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: Trend Airshield Vs Triton Resporator?

#16

Thanks Danny

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Another endorsement for the Trend Airshield! Looks like the majority favors this one.

Thanks for your input

Dominic

Re: Trend Airshield Vs Triton Resporator?

#17

Thanks, another vote for the Trend!

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>

Re: Trend Airshield Vs Triton Resporator?

#18

Thanks Joe

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>You and Ron make a good argument for the Triton. I believe Bill Grumbine also uses the Triton. Maybe I should try one on to see how they fit....

Thanks for your input

Dominic

Re: Trend Airshield Vs Triton Resporator?

#19

Insightful comments Peter!

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Peter,

Your comments make convincing argument to sway toward the Trend Airshield. I mean, you had the Triton and bagged it in favor of the Trend. You comments about the bag-like "plenum" and the fit are the type I needed to hear.

Thanks for your input

Dominic

Re: Trend Airshield Vs Triton Resporator?

#20

Thanks for your input

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>

Re: Trend Airshield Vs Triton Resporator?

#21

Thanks Tom

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Another argument in favor of the Trend. However, your comment about the Trend's grade of construction has me thinking. I need to see one up close so I can look at it. Nothing tweaks me more than paying top dollar for something and having it looks like it came in a box of cereal.

Thanks for your input

Dominic

Re: Trend Airshield Vs Triton Resporator?

#22

Thansk Wayne

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Wayne,

You comment about the Triton being useful for all types of work is pretty significant. However, I have a full face mask and shield when cutting up logs. I see myself using whatever face shield I buy mostly for wood turning and sanding.

Dominic

Re: Trend Airshield Vs Triton Resporator?

#23

Thanks Gil

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Another satisfied Trend Airshield user!

Thanks for your input.

Dominic

Re: Trend Airshield Vs Triton Resporator?

#24

Re: Thanks Danny

Wayne Leach-NW Ontario

>Dom,

Look again, I think he has and favors the Triton???

Wayne

Re: Trend Airshield Vs Triton Resporator?

#25

Re: Triton Resporator

Ken

>WOW Talk about timing.The misses has been on me for a while to get one,so this morn.I thought I would post a topic and get an opinion on which one's is most recomended.Well needless to say I was beaten to the punch.So it look's like the trend is on the way.(I like the one piece unit)I was gonna respond to the note about the beard question and tell all to look at Bill Grumbine and that would answer that debate.

Ken