We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
I am looking for some helpful critiques of this little guy. 4.5" wide and about 3" high, walls are not consistent but start at 1/4" and are just over 5/16" near the base. Finished with 3 coats of Deft semi-gloss and EEE Ultrashine. How did I do on the form and the proportions? Close? Right on? Trash and burn? I had some trouble with a crack forming and a high-pitched sound which made me think it was time to call it done. I CA'd it and sanded to 600. Should I have kept going to get it thinner or did I do right? I know the pictures are worth squat but that is something I will tackle another day.
>Okay Steve, I have a few suggestions....When working on form, the rule of thirds is a good one. Your bowl is 4.5 inches in dia., which means that the foot should be near 1.5 inches. This would allow a sweeping curve from the rim to the foot with no flat areas. In my classes I explain to the students that a plain flat rim is not as attractive as a rim that angles inward or outward or is rounded over, etc. The 1/4 inch wall thickness is okay. On a small bowl like this I would make it thinner but that's a matter of choice.
>Thanks Wally. So, if I understand correctly, the area close to the top should be more curved and with a smaller base would result in a more pleasing shape? I've got a few pieces in the shop which will yield similar sized bowls and I will try to apply what you say. Thinner was giving me the eebeejeebee's with the sounds coming from it. I'll try again with more sound wood.
Cheers,
Steve Kubien - Who will be putting up a large note near the lathe saying, "Remember the rule of 1/3's"
>Just keep it right side up. Realy you are doing pretty good. It looks like you have decent tool control and the finish looks good. The bottom is a little bigger than is popular, but good for a bowl that will actually be used. Your curve flows pretty well, and you have an idea of where yoiu want to go from here. It looks better than some of my early bowls that's for sure. My first bowl ended up about half the size it was supposed to be. Catches kept ruining the upper part. Hve fun.
>Don't worry about the form. It looks fine. Beginner bowls tend to have straight sides. That will change automatically as you make more bowls.
I agree with the comments about the foot. I don't like it either. Am I correct in assuming that the chuck jaws determined the size of the foot?? I would suggest using smaller jaws, or a thicker waste block.
Another alternative is no foot at all. There is no rule that a bowl has to have a foot, and my personal opinion is that these straight sided bowls look better without one. You can do that with the jaws you have by chucking on a spigot either from the wood or a waste-block, and turning it off when you reverse the bowl to turn the bottom.
>Great ideas about the foot Russ. I recently saw Mr. Grumbine's fine first video (along with a DVD of him teaching at the Woodturner's Guild of Ontario back in 2005) and these gave me similar ideas. Actually, Bill's teachings are going to change a few things about how I approach the next bowl(s).
I currently have a maple bowl in the freezer which has a small spigott-type foot. My plan is to finish turn outside and inside, mount it in my doughnut chuck and take off the spigott. That should accomplish some of what has been spoken of in this thread. Is my thinking correct on that?
I don't know how many bowls you've produced, but this is a pleasing shape with smooth, flowing lines that probably feels great in your hands -- a success ! My first 1/2 dozen or so bowls had fairly large feet, which was self-"correcting" as I admired other bowls with smaller feet. BTW: just because I like a smaller footprint doesn't mean you do -- or have to. I think Wally means that with a smaller foot, the entire bowl, but especially the lower 2/3 could curve in more sharply to arrive at the smaller diameter.
Are you using a scroll chuck ? A friction chuck ? A glue block ? When you reverse-turn the bowl to finish it off (either between centers or with some sort of jumbo jaws arrangement), you can make the foot any desired size, allowing you to make smaller feet within the tenon held by larger jaws, if that design suits you.
Spalted wood can be difficult to finish because there are usually hard and soft areas, so you did a great job in that department. I'd say its a very nice little bowl, and it makes me wonder how it will differ from the next 100 bowls you make ...?
>I agree with the critiques above. Something that may help you out a little, is mounting a bowl steady after you turn and sand the outside. I don't know about others, but I have to combat shaky hands. So I can't finish turn an inch, and then another inch, and then another, without going back over the entire inside, bottom to top, in order to make the final, light, smoothing cuts. The bowl steady helps me to do that. It also will keep down the squeal, most of the time. :o)
I made my own bowl steady using rollerblade wheels.
>Steve: To my mind, your work has no major flaws. To expand on Wally's comment about a flat rim, I believe he is talking about the very top, which on your piece is almost perfectly horizontal. This creates the impression that the piece was just cut off and left as is and/or it could continue up some more. Also, a rim with a sharp corner is not as comfortable to the touch as a rounded over corner.
This may be a very oblique characterization, but this kind of shape has already been claimed by people working in clay. My advice would be to stay away from a shape that looks like it could hold a liquid because then it would have a utility-like feeling and your work should aspire to look unique and one-of-a-kind.
>Thanks David. I actually took Wally's (and others) view of the "flatness" to mean both the top end of the sides AND the rim. You are right, the rim is almost horizontal and I can see what you mean by looking "cut-off".