Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

stumped by tear- out

Posts

stumped by tear- out

#1

stumped by tear- out

eliot d

>It's happened again, and I had to stop turning to post for help. I'm turning the outside of a fairly large piece of Norway maple. The grain is oriented for faceplate turning (sideways),and the end grain portions ( the parts that come around twice per revolution) have horrible tear- out. I am turning with an extremely sharp Glaser gauge sharpened on a Tormek. I have tried very light shear cutting at a high angle with the gauge and careful shear scraping with another Glaser tool specifically designed for such scraping using the burr. Nothing works. Please help.

Re: stumped by tear- out

#2

Re: If the gouge is sharp and bevel rubbing,....

Jamie Donaldson

>... try coating the area with lacquer thinned with a bit of acetone to stabilize the fibers before making a new cut. I use this technique on almost every piece I turn- the lacquer server as a sanding sealer and undercoat for the final finish.

Re: stumped by tear- out

#3

Re: stumped by tear- out

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi Eliot,

Tear out is a feaurure of the wood, so turning technique is everything. It's been awhile since I turned a bowl, but a high angle shearing cut with a gouge seemed to work for me.

One cut I tried also is to turn the flute over so it is facing the work, bring the gouge up to the work at a near vertical postion and allow the lower edge of the gouge to present itself to the work at a high shearing angle....the shavings as Bill Grumbine calls them should resemble "Angel Hair"...super fine.

Another option is to stabilze the end grain with a treat ment of a wood stablizer or glue mixture, let it dry out and then cut it, this is a way of "holding" the end grain firm.

End grain is a teacher, it lets you know when your tool technique is working and it screams at you when it is not working, so it is good to pay attention to it's appearnce.

Hope that helped, it is what I do, others will offer their own experiences I hope.

Take care,

Jim

Re: stumped by tear- out

#4

Re: stumped by tear- out

Russ Fairfield

>You didn't say, but I am assuming that you are turning a piece of dry wood.

I think you have answered your own question. You have tried everything, and nothing works. Some species are just prone to tear-out. Fortunately, they are usually the same ones that sand easily. I would place Norway Maple into that category.

There is no guarantee that you can make a perfect cut on every piece of wood with a bowl gouge or a scraper. Do the best you can and get out the 60-grit sanding discs.

Re: stumped by tear- out

#5

Re: stumped by tear- out *LINK*

joaz

>I agree with all of the solution mentioned above. You could also try making the shear scraper featured on my web site.

I works for me and lots of other turners on pesky endgrain tear out.

This is not a commercial post. Information for making your own is free.


http://www.maine-web.com/woodturning

Re: stumped by tear- out

#6

Re: If the gouge is sharp and bevel rubbing,....

georgetroy

>Jamie has the right of it. The lacquer makes the fiber stiffer and easier to cut. You may need several licks at it to get the end grain. The end grain and or rough areas will turn dark and show up later if you don't take care of it. Wipe the lacquer down enough to keep any spray off your helmut. You are using it aren't you? GT

Re: stumped by tear- out

#7

Thanks Joaz

Mike Nelson

>I have an old roughing gouge with the same curve that will work great. Thanks for the idea, it sounds like the solution many scraper problems. Mike

Re: stumped by tear- out

#8

Cut WITH Not Against The Grain....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>

Re: stumped by tear- out

#9

Re: Cut WITH Not Against The Grain....

john lucas

>all great suggestions. I'll add one more. Slow down your cut or speed up the lathe. You may be forcing the cut which will cause tearout. Sometimes 60 grit is the only way.

Re: stumped by tear- out

#10

Re: Cut WITH Not Against The Grain....

eliot d

>I appreciate the various responses. The only one that doesn't make sense to me is the one from Walley Dickerman. The problem is the end grain that runs more or less perpendicular to the axis of the lathe bed. It's the grain in a side grain piece that comes around twice per revolution. There's no way to cut with that grain.

Re: stumped by tear- out

#11

Re: Cut WITH Not Against The Grain....

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>eliot, I think Wally meant to cut downhill on the wood fibers, which on a side-grain turning means from center out.

Funny how downhill and uphill have opposite meanings--on side-grain turning (bowls, platters, etc) downhill is from center out while with end-grain turning, it's from outside inwards. And that's only on the turning's exterior! On the interior, it's opposite!!

Without special equipment, we have no choice but to go uphill in a radial direction, on a side-grain turning, twice in each revolution. But in the other plane of direction(axial), we do.

Radial = in any direction across center of a circle

axial = parallel to axis of rotation

Re: stumped by tear- out

#12

Re: stumped by tear- out

RevDoug

>Elliot, you have gotten a lot of great advice. I've had to do all the above. Wally's "cut with the grain" is basic, turning 101 information that for some reason turners want to ignore. Very important though. With your cross grain bowl orientation that means that on the outside you cut from bottom to top, on the inside, from rim to center. However, I have run across a piece of wood once in a while where I have had to cut from the top to the bottom in order to get the end grain to cut cleanly. Yes, it does go against the conventional wisdom. It doesn't even sound logical. But, when you are desperate you'll try anything. Give it a go, if it doesn't work, get the lacquer out and stiffen those fibres up.

Turn 'em round,

Re: stumped by tear- out

#13

Re: Cut WITH Not Against The Grain....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Eliot, the answer is really quite simple. Imagine that you are going to round the end off of a 2x4 with a pocket knife or a block plane. Would you slice from the end against the grain or would you slice toward the end with the grain? Now cut that 2x4 round as in a bowl blank...you'd still cut the same way, with the grain.....

Wally

Re: stumped by tear- out

#14

Keith Tompkins

Re: stumped by tear- out

keith tompkins

>Eliot, I'm assuming you're using a swept-back grind, pulling the cut from the base to the rim. This doesn't always produce a clean cut, as the bevel isn't rubbing.

A couple of things to try...a push-cut, with the nose of the gouge doing all the cutting, flute rolled away from the cut. This keeps the bevel rubbing, and the cutting edge is presented to the end grain at a skewing angle.(similar to flat work, where a plane cuts across the end grain at a 45 degree angle.

As a last resort, cut from the rim to the foot...using the same tool technique..sometimes it works. A continental spindle gouge works well here as well, with the flute facing away from the cut.

Re: stumped by tear- out

#15

Re: Cut WITH Not Against The Grain....

eliot d

>Wally, You're talking about the well-know principle of supporting the fibers as you cut. If you want to stick to the 2 x4 example, imagine the end of the 2 x 4 mounted on the lathe with the fibers running perpendicular to the lathe bed axis, and imagine cutting a cylinder; so there's no up hill /down hill issue. Then the end grain comes around twice per revolution, and you will be cutting end grain -- against the grain -- no matter whether you are moving the cutting edge from left to right or from right to left. It's true that for my piece there is some slant to it. But I was careful to cut up hill. (I tried down hill, too, just to try it out.) Nothing worked. I think Russ got it right; this piece of Norway maple just won't cooperate.I will probably have to resort to 60 grit sanding. ( I will first try painting on some stiffener solution as some have suggested.) I appreciate your help, and I haven't forgotten that I'm the one who asked for help.

Re: stumped by tear- out

#16

Re: Joaz, what is a firmer's gouge?

Allen Neighbors

>I saw the one on your website... and I've seen it before now, once. I'm curious what they were originally used for, and where a person might locate one. Thanks,

Allen

Re: stumped by tear- out

#17

Re: Cut WITH Not Against The Grain....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Eliot, you're correct in that if you cut a cylinder there's no with or against the grain. But if you cut a bowl shape you must cut from the small dia. to large in order to cut with the grain. If you're turning a hollowform using a face grain blank you'll cut from the rim to the widest point of the piece, and from the foot to the widest point in order to cut with the grain. When I'm teaching a class I draw pictures which makes it easier to make my point.

I'm always surprised at how many experienced turners don't get the concept of cutting with the grain to get the best results. With some wood it doesn't make much difference but with a wood like fir for example, it makes a lot of difference.

Wally

Re: stumped by tear- out

#18

Brad Vietje

Re: Cut WITH Not Against The Grain....

Brad Vietje

>I think Eliot gets the uphill/downhill analogy... but maybe the shape of the bowl is the problem. If the bowl is a cylinder, as he suggests earlier, there may be no better or worse direction to cut. However -- what I think Wally's also saying is that the bowl would cut better if it wasn't a cylinder, but a gentle curve instead, which does have a favored direction. I, for one, don't like the look of cylindrical bowls. If there's enough wood left, maybe a shape that's narrower at the foot, and wider at the rim would be more satisfying to cut AND look at (?)

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: stumped by tear- out

#19

Brad Vietje

One more idea...

Brad Vietje

>Eliot,

Sometimes, especially on Ash and Red Oak or other open-grained woods, I have the best luck cutting the outer profile with a sharp spindle gouge with a long bevel and fingernail grind. I lower the rest a little, and cut with the tool as vertical as I can, trying to cut down one wing in a slicing cut instead of cutting across the nose of the tool. At that steep angle, the cutting happens at or slightly above center. I can't usually control, or steer, the profile shape quite as well as with a bowl gouge, but cleanly-cut ridges sand or shear scrape away easily, while tear-out is just no fun.

There's nothing unusual in the orientation of your blank. This is the usual side-grain or "bowl" orientation that Wally's been using since about 1940 or so. Russ is another wealth of information here: sometimes a blank just won't cut cleanly while another blank of the same species will. Softwoods are usually more difficult than hardwoods, due to the larger difference in hardness and porosity of early/late growth rings.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: stumped by tear- out

#20

Re: I let the wood decide which direction is best

Russ Fairfield

>I used to worry about the "dowhill rule", but either the direction of the hill changed twice with every revolution, or the wood had a mind of its own and wanted to be cut in the opposite direction from what I saw as "downhill". Now I don't worry about it. I rough out the bowl in whatever direction is the easiest for me; and then make a trail cut in either direction and let the wood tell me which way will be best for making the finish cuts.

Re: stumped by tear- out

#21

Re: Joaz, what is a firmer's gouge?

Jorge Castaneda

>Hi Allen,

Firmer gouges are carpenter tools, you can still find them in catalogs or in you favorite rust outlet. They come in two flavors, in cannel or out cannel depending if the bevel is in the inside or outside of the gouge.

Jorge

Re: stumped by tear- out

#22

Exactly what I've discovered Russ

john lucas

>Especially with curly or highly figured woods. Sometimes uphill just cuts cleaner. As I approach the final shape I'll start playing with different tool approaches, both angle and direction of cut and see if that works. You can usually tell early on that there is a problem area and start trying some of the methods mentioned above.

Quite often what I'll find is that cutting in the opposite direction will help the problem area and create a problem somewhere else but usually not as bad. I use the cut that leaves it so I can sand the problem with the smallest grit.

Re: stumped by tear- out

#23

Re: Joaz, what is a firmer's gouge?

joaz

>Jorge has given the best discription, better then i could give.

I am now using a Rude Olsolnic(sp) 1 1/2" spindle roughing gouge that works even better. I posted better info. on turning archive a few months ago with pictures. However, the archive seems to have disappeared from view.

Anyone know what's going on with that??

Re: stumped by tear- out

#24

Re: One more idea...

sam nelson

>another little trick I learned from this site, is to rub pariffin wax over the tear out area, and take a light cut with a sharp gouge. Final sanding will remove any wax left.

Take Care

Sam

Re: stumped by tear- out

#25

Good explanation!

Ron McKinley

>Thanks for expressing it that way! I've never understood "cutting with the grain" when woodturning since you're only cutting "with" the grain for 1/4 of the rotation.........Ron