Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Bonehead Award for the Week .........

Posts

Bonehead Award for the Week .........

#1

Bonehead Award for the Week .........

Pete LaBelle

>Well, it happened to me last night. Had a 10" bowl fly apart and about 1/3 of it wack me just above the eye. Eyeball itself was untouched. Perscription glasses absorbed most of the blow. Had a small tear in the eyelid and a small cut under the eyebrow. Doctor at the med center cleaned it up, advised an anceptic cream, and sent me home. Vison is fine. Pride is hurt.

It's been said here before and it will be said again: Turning is a dangerous hobby. Some might be lucky, but most turners will have to spend a hundred dollars or so now or later on either hospital deductables or safety equipment. I, thinking I didn't want to pay for either, like others have learned on this site, will now be paying for both.

That said; has anyone had any experiences with the new $49 shield from Woodcraft ?

Pete

Re: Bonehead Award for the Week .........

#2

Re: Bonehead Award for the Week .........

Rick Allen

>Would that be the Bionic Face Shield

I find face shields have three major issues:

1. The shield attracts dust which ruins your view

2. The shield fogs up from you breathing

3. The shield is less comfortable than not wearing it

The Bionic Face Shield seams like it would fail badly at issue #2. If the shield fogs up, because you have to breath, then you are not going to wear it.

You need something that will protect your face AND actually wear. That is why the powered face shields are popular. They protect your face and blow air across your face so the shield doesn't get fogged up. You still have issues 1 and 3. Many folks have a procedure for cleaning the face shield to work around issue 1. Issue 3 is the price you pay for safety.

I have seen issue 2 addressed in different ways. Some face shields are much more open on the sides. I knew one guy who cut the lower half of the face shield off. Not sure if cutting the lower half off made his face shield any better than a pair of safety goggles.

If I was going cheap this $20 shield would be a good choice.

Good luck with your choice.

Re: Bonehead Award for the Week .........

#3

Re: Bonehead Award for the Week .........

Curly Smith

>I use a hard hat equipped with a face shield. I find it much more comfortable than the "regular" face shield because the hard hat supports the weight and it won't fall off if I bend over. I don't know about you but if it's uncomfortable then I'm less inclined to use it. You can find the parts needed here:

Hardhat Adapter



Polycarbonate Clear Faceshield


You can also add ear muffs to your hard hat, if you have one with the necessary slots, for noise protection. No affiliation, etc.

Re: Bonehead Award for the Week .........

#4

URLs

Curly Smith

>Well, it appears that my first attempt at hyperlinks didn't work. It's back to cut and paste...

Hardhat Adapter - http://www.abcsafetyglasses.com/mly-hhab.html

Polycarbonate Clear Faceshield - http://www.abcsafetyglasses.com/mly-s1020.html

Re: Bonehead Award for the Week .........

#5

Re: Bonehead Award for the Week .........

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>Another option is a catcher's mask coupled with safety glasses. Face shields give me terrible eye strain in addition to all of the previously mentioned issues.

Catcher/umpire baseball masks are quite rugged (a baseball traveling at 100 mph packs a bit of a wallop). And they aren't very expensive.

The mask won't stop the small stuff, which is why safety glasses are a very, very good idea. But the mask should keep you from needing reconstructive surgery.

Re: Bonehead Award for the Week .........

#6

Hyperlinks

Ron in Drums PA

>Here is the code for a hyperlink

<a href="http://www.abcsafetyglasses.com/mly-hhab.html">

Here is the code for a hyperlink with a name

<a href="http://www.abcsafetyglasses.com/mly-hhab.html">Hardhat Adapter </a>

Re: Bonehead Award for the Week .........

#8

Re: Bonehead Award for the Week .........

Rick Davenport

>Face shields may be uncomfortable, dusty, foggy and inconvenient.

They are also absolutely necessary.

R

Re: Bonehead Award for the Week .........

#9

Re: Hyperlinks

Ron McKinley

>Thanks for posting that code Ron. I used to know that stuff then didn't use it for a while and had a memory dump! Thanks again....Ron

Re: Bonehead Award for the Week .........

#10

Steve Kubien

Re: Bonehead Award for the Week .........

Steve Kubien

>I've a cheapo that I like. No different than any other cheap model. Cost $20 and even though I've been turning for less than a year, it has already saved me twice. No problems with fogging if I angle it down so the edge is close to my throat. The dust and dirt on the lens is a pain and will obscure your vision. I often use regular safety glasses when I'm doing finer work (a relative term in my case).

Take care,

Steve Kubien

P.S. I know of one woodworker who is totally blind. Fully equipped shop and some nice work coming out of it. Anyone ever heard of a blind turner? Gotta think that would be tougher.

Re: Bonehead Award for the Week .........

#11

Re: Bonehead Award for the Week .........

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I'll admit...I have a face shield and seldom use it. I hate it. However..I ALWAYS ALWAYS wear safety glasses.

Wally

Re: Bonehead Award for the Week .........

#12

Re: Bonehead Award for the Week .........

Pete LaBelle

>Just ordered the Lee Valley mask that ET suggested. Looks very much like the mask Woodcraft offers. Like computer printers, not much money is made with the mask. It's the replacment lenses where they get their money made.

Keep you posted on how I like it.

Thanks for the suggestions and concerns.

Pete

Re: Bonehead Award for the Week .........

#13

Re: Bonehead Award for the Week .........

John Lucas

>Ditto Wally. I've tried face masks and just can't stand to wear them. Never work without safety glasses. I try not to get in the line of fire especially with any suspect wood. I've pulled a few pieces out of the chuck but have only had 2 explode. Both times I was out of the line of fire. Both times I either heard a noise or funny vibration and didn't stop the lathe. If you have any unusual sounds or vibration, stop the lathe and check everything out.

I'm not advocating that you don't wear a face shield. I know a lot of people have been hurt, in some cases seriously. It's like any other potentially dangerous activity. Study all you can and take all the safety precautions you are willing to tolerate.

Re: Bonehead Award for the Week .........

#14

Re: I'm seriously considering a chain saw helmet.

Al Crandall (N.E. of Indy)

>I turned at a buddy's house using his chainsaw helmet with the screen face protector, and I found most of my complaints regarding face shields didn't materialize while using the helmet. I could hear and be heard through the screen quite easily, it didn't gather dust particles or scratches, it was comfortable because the three crossing support staps inside the helmet distributed the weight evenly, chips can't come over the top of the face guard because it seals on the bill of the helmet, there was no glare from the screen which was essentially invisible while wearing, no fogging to contend with, and on and on.

Re: Bonehead Award for the Week .........

#15

Re: Bonehead Award for the Week .........---------

Barry Irby

Re: Bonehead Award for the Week .........

#16

Re: Bonehead Award for the Week .........

Barry Irby

>I have a cheap one I wear (Really, I do, I swear). I had an accident several years ago. Put an unbalanced piece on the lathe and hit the switch. Meant to reach with the other hand for the shield, but hit the switch first. A block of wood right between the eyes. Actually on the forehead just above the eyebrow, just left of center. A trip to the emergency room on Sunday night and $1300 later makes a face shield look real cheap and comfortable. Much better than that gleaming white bone staring back out of that third eye. You were very lucky you were not hurt worse. Take the warning.

My face shield is my third one and it has a knob on the back that lets you adjust it. (Good) One of them had the rows of snaps, PITA.

You can wipe them with a fabric softener sheet to cut down on static cling that attracts the dust. I blow mine off with the air compressor. Also, you can go to an office supply and get clear "presentation" folders which are thin clear plastic and tape a piece of one on the front of the shield. If you turn green or other juicy wood then you can throw the shield�s shield away and put on a new one. I wash mine occasionally with warm soapy water. I find the dirt on the shield not to be too distracting, but then I have worn glasses for the last fifty four of my fifty seven years. I cannot recall mine fogging.

I can tell you from experience that you are not fast enough to put it on during the event. Wear it.

As Captain Kirk used to say, �Shields up.�

Re: Bonehead Award for the Week .........

#17

Re: I'm seriously considering a chain saw helmet.

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>That is a heck of a good idea, Al. I hate wearing faceshield, and only do it when I am turning in some manner the throws the chips right in my face.

Mark

Re: Bonehead Award for the Week .........

#18

Re: Bonehead Award for the Week .........

Fog Tanner

>That is one of the reasons I spent the coins on an Airstream. Along with the dust filtration, I like the visor and "crash helemt". After reading in Raffin's book about turning without his and winding up needing 13 stitchs, I figured the price was not that great. When you stop to figure up the price of a new set of lungs and an eyeball or two, these items get real cheap...

Glad you had quick reflexes and the only thing that got seriously hit was your attention. I had been thinking about getting the Airstream and thinking about Raffin's experience, when I pulled a box blank off the chuck and it bounced off the wall and nailed my wrist. Had it been my skull, It could have been fairly serious as it alomost broke my wrist. That was my wake up call. Good luck with yours....

Re: Bonehead Award for the Week .........

#19

Re: I'm seriously considering a chain saw helmet.

Bill Crommett

>DUH ! I habve a chain saw helmet and face shield, but it is out in the barn with the chain saws. It never asked to come into the shop, so I never gave it another thought.

Double DUH ! But on the other hand all I have ever been hit with is sme small chunks of bark. Not enough incentive to learn.

Re: Bonehead Award for the Week .........

#20

Re: Bonehead Award for the Week .........

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>I rarely turn without one. Sort of like putting on a seat belt. Maybe it's a girl thing? Even when I'm turning pens. I just think about the split second it would take for a shard from a thin pen blank to fly up and penetrate my face or something! Yuk! Just the thought grosses me out. And besides, I just spent $22 on some magic fountain of youth face cream. Why would I take a chance on stalling the progress of the miracle potion! Ha!

Play it safe everyone!

:)

Re: Bonehead Award for the Week .........

#21

Re: Bonehead Award for the Week .........

Bob Fawcett

>I have this faceshield that Packard sells. Of all the less expensive ones I have seen, this is the best. Its even made in the USA.

I wonder if motorcycle helmet tearoffs would work on a face shield.

This one does not fog up as bad as some and is reasonably comfortable to wear.

Re: Bonehead Award for the Week .........

#22

That was good Jen. Best laugh all day.

Keith Newton

>

Re: Bonehead Award for the Week .........

#23

Re: Bonehead Award for the Week .........

Mikefrom TN.

>Ever since the first chunck of wood i put on a lath, I've worn glasses and a shield. I spray on Armor all on the front and a antifogging spray on the face side. No problem. It might be uncomfortable to wear but so is a glass eye or a partial.

Re: Bonehead Award for the Week .........

#24

Re: Bonehead Award for the Week .........

john lucas

>Jen I'm already ugly so any damage done would probably be an improvement. :)

Re: Bonehead Award for the Week .........

#25

Multifunctional Applications

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi Jennifer,

Well I don't have a true turning mask but this one works just fine for most other applications...and besides, it keeps the neighbours wondering...the mud treatments haven't worked either.

Photo Sharing and Video Hosting at Photobucket

Take care,

Jim