Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Vacuum Pump-less Vacuum Chucking Report pt 1

Posts

Vacuum Pump-less Vacuum Chucking Report pt 1

#1

Vacuum Pump-less Vacuum Chucking Report pt 1

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>There was a thread a week ago, or so, about using one of the new vacuum chucking systems that used your compressor and a venturi system to create the vacuum.

I bought the Hold Fast from Crafts Supply. I have had some time over the last couple of days to play with it, and here are my initial thoughts.

1) Very Light and compact system. It does not come with anything but the generator. So if you do not already have things like air pressure regulators or hose connectors, you are going to have to get some.

2) I attached a cheap regulator ($8 at HD) and a quick air cuppler nipple to it and hooked it into a AC line. I turned on the "Switch"....Very little noise, sounds more like a air hose leak than anything else.

3) I covered the suction inlet, and right away it produced 18 inches of vacuum. By adjusting the incoming pressure, I was able to get 23 inches. Oddly enough, I needed to turn the pressure down. I have the air pressure out of the hose in my shop set to 90 psi, you have to have the pressure down in the 70 psi range to get maximum vacuum. Great so far.

4) Now, I hooked it up to my homemade (Al Crandal design) vacuum adapter. Turn it on, and it pulls 2 inches. This is a problem. You need somewhere around 12 inches for vacuum chucking. Here is the problem. The Hold Fast system creates a great vacuum, but pull very little volume of air. The slightest leaks are a huge problem. I have a very noisy old rotary vane vacuum pump, that has worked for me for years. It pulls a pretty good volume of air (one of the reasons it is noisy - even with a muffler). Small leaks like those in my homemade adapter are no problem.

5) I have ordered the Hold fast Vacuum adapter, and will let you know how it goes when that gets here the middle of this next week.

If I can get it to work, I will keep it. I want a quieter system. But the the old vacuum pump is staying where it is right now.

Mark

Re: Vacuum Pump-less Vacuum Chucking Report pt 1

#2

Re: Vacuum Pump-less Vacuum Chucking Report pt 1

john lucas

>Thanks Mark. I'm always interested in new systems. What size compressor does it take. I'm in the market for a new compressor. Mine is too small and way to loud.

My vacuum pump is also noisy and gets quite hot. One of these days I may just buy a new pump. Mine came from the Flea Mkt for $35. It's a Gast and looks just like the Oneway but who knows how old the thing is.

Re: Vacuum Pump-less Vacuum Chucking Report pt 1

#3

Re: Vacuum Pump-less Vacuum Chucking Report pt 1 *LINK*

John Stegall

>Just curious if this looks like it would work as a vacuum chuck. There sure are a lot of this guy's design used for vacuum presses, just not sure about using it as a chuck.

john in very wet Kerrville.


http://www.joewoodworker.com/veneering/vacuumchucking.htm

Re: Vacuum Pump-less Vacuum Chucking Report pt 1

#4

Re: Vacuum Pump-less Vacuum Chucking Report pt 1

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>John,

The specs call for 2.5 cfm at 55-65 psi. Pretty low really.

Mark

Re: Vacuum Pump-less Vacuum Chucking Report pt 1

#5

Re: Vacuum Pump-less Vacuum Chucking Report pt 1

Pete LaBelle

>We use air powered vacuum generators her at work to operate suction cups in fixtures to hold parts in place. They work well in confined areas, do create a pretty good pressure, but like has been learned, do not have much CFM, thus tolerance for leaks is poor.

Pete

Re: Vacuum Pump-less Vacuum Chucking Report pt 1

#6

Re: Vacuum Pump-less Vacuum Chucking Report pt 1

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Yeah, I can imagine that if you have something like a 6" suction cup and it is holding a smooth surface, it would provide all the suction you would need.

I am concerned that even if I get all the way to a 21 inch vacuum at the chuck, that the wood itself will leak too much.

Mark

Re: Vacuum Pump-less Vacuum Chucking Report pt 1

#7

No Free Lunch, Mark

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Units can't create more vacuum than the flow of the compressor, and must, given efficiency rules, create less. Thus 2 CFM or less of potential flow-tolerance is not, in my view, good for turning. Mind you it'll work just fine for a veneer press rig that also uses 3-5 gal. reservoir tanks and a sealed bag where the whole rig is static during use. But spinning a piece of porous wood to finish off the bottom of a nice thin turning where you're depending on so many moving and flexing seal surfaces? I'll pass, thanks.

BTW. If your vacuum pump is noisy, there's no reason you can't put it in another room, the attic, outside, or in a sound box. After all, you don't have a parade of turners stopping by to check out your vacuum pump such that you need to keep it in plain sight, right? |;-}}

Re: Vacuum Pump-less Vacuum Chucking Report pt 1

#8

Re: No Free Lunch, Mark

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Oh, I hear you, Mark. I saw this thing first back at TD's gathering last April. I don't use vacuum chucking hardly ever, and I already had a setup, so did not think of it.

Later, I saw that Craft USA was carrying them, and thought that maybe they were worth looking at. Then I saw that Packard was carrying them, and decided to give it a try.

I will continue to report on my observations, but as I said before, I am not selling the big pump anytime soon.

Thanks for pointing out the glaringly obvious. I have already moved my air compressor, and DC to cut the noise to the storage room on the other side of the wall from the lathes. Thanks for the "I could have had a V-8" moment.

Mark

Re: Vacuum Pump-less Vacuum Chucking Report pt 1

#9

Eh? What?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>So many posts concern dust control, and lung and eye protection, yet so few seem to be concerned with noise polution in their shops. Yes, I know some who wear hearing protection, but, Norm notwithstanding, how many even consider how to REDUCE the noise in the shop. I wear hearing protection when doing many flatwood operations because the machines/toolings make noise (router, planer, jointer, chain saw, log splitter) that can't be abated. But I've never had the DC or compressor located in the shop, and I wouldn't hesitate to set up any vacuum pump outside my workspace as well. A few feet of 1/2" L copper is way cheaper than hearing aids!

Of course, if you LIKE walking around with things stuck in your ears and unable to hear SWMBO . . .

ps NO, I don't use a chain saw or log splitter in my shop |;-}}}

Re: Vacuum Pump-less Vacuum Chucking Report pt 1

#10

Re: Vacuum Pump-less Vacuum Chucking Report pt 1

TDaniel

>Mark, a much better alternative and much cheaper is the plate that uses the shop-vac for the vac source. It will not pull a high vacuum but the volume of air is much greater and little leaks don't affect it much. You have to have a shopvac with bypass cooling or follow their instructions and drill a small hole in the hose if your vac does not have bypass cooling. Mine works great with the Fein vac. The unit that you are testing was not in my shop at the Gathering and I do not recommend it.

Re: Vacuum Pump-less Vacuum Chucking Report pt 1

#11

Re: Vacuum Pump-less Vacuum Chucking Report pt 1

Allen Neighbors

>TD, I've asked you before, but I lost my notes. What is your rig called? I'll try to remember it this time. :o)

Thanks,

Allen

Re: Vacuum Pump-less Vacuum Chucking Report pt 1

#12

Re: Vacuum Pump-less Vacuum Chucking Report pt 1

TDaniel

>Hi Al

The plate and fitting is Vicmarc, the shop-vac is the mid size Fein. I am not a fan of vac chucks to start with since most everything I turn has voids but this one is adequate for my needs. I prefer the jumbo jaws (Vicmarc) over the vac systems....they are much quieter.

TD

Re: Vacuum Pump-less Vacuum Chucking Report pt 1

#13

Re: Eh? What?

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Oh, you got me going there (plumbing the vacuum), but I am still trying to figure our a remote power switch.

Mark

Re: Vacuum Pump-less Vacuum Chucking Report pt 1

#14

Re: Vacuum Pump-less Vacuum Chucking Report pt 1

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>TD,

Good to see that you are still lurking around.

Your are right, that vacuum system was not in your shop, but during the gathering someone had a display and some for sale down at the fire station.

You are right, high volume systems are better. I have a good high volume pump that works great. If I did this more, I would consider the system you have, but would have to have some quiet vacuum like a fine.

Mark

Re: Vacuum Pump-less Vacuum Chucking Report pt 1

#15

Whoa

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>You're telling me you built the shop but can't run a simple switch leg into the next room? Better find a friendly Sparky and get the rest of your shop wiring checked!

|;-}}

Re: Vacuum Pump-less Vacuum Chucking Report pt 1

#16

Re: Whoa

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Always with the joke, Mandell!!

Mostly, just a though process I have two 110v circuits in that room -both in the adjoining wall, but just figuring, just figuring. Were to I want the Vac outlet, and where do I want the switch.

Are you a tort lawyer, or alway a re-tort lawyer?

Mark

Re: Vacuum Pump-less Vacuum Chucking Report pt 1

#17

Re: Vacuum Pump-less Vacuum Chucking Report pt 2

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>I got the vacuum adapter today. Not bad, Not bad. It is ABS type plastic. Turns easily, and does not leak at all. It used standard threaded lamp rod to go though the headstock, so you can replace, or have sever different rods for different lathes.

Now, my problem is my leaky homemade cup chuck. I used to use it in my 4 jaw chuck, and threaded the adapter into the base of the cup chuck(s). But recently I moved it to a regular faceplate and then turned it true inside and out, but did not re-seal the wood. I did apply sealant around the faceplate and screw holes, and now I am spraying it with several heavy coats of lacquer.

I will report on the progress.

Mark

Re: Vacuum Pump-less Vacuum Chucking Report pt 1

#18

Re: Thanks, TD! :o)

Allen Neighbors

>

Re: Vacuum Pump-less Vacuum Chucking Report pt 1

#19

Either Or?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Neither Nor!

I have enough trouble keeping my own mistakes under control. I'd be useless trying to correct those of others. Give me a nice little contract situation and I'm a happy camper.

With a 1/4 hp 110 pump, your switch leg can be 16 ga. stranded zip cord to a rated toggle switch on the wall next to your lathe.

Re: Vacuum Pump-less Vacuum Chucking Report pt 1

#20

Re: Vacuum Pump-less Vacuum Chucking Final Report

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Once I got my cup chuck sealed, and I threaded the lamp rod into my chuck rather than using the tip that fits in the #2 morris taper, this system pulled 19 in Hg. Pretty good.

I have one of my hollow forms in my shop that John Hill (AAW Auctioneer) bought 3 years ago from me. Someone cleaning in his house knocked it off a shelf and broke the rim. He shipped it to me to see if I could repair it. Sometime back, I had turned the old rim off of it, and glued a new rim to it. Tonight, I put the HF on the vacuum chuck and used this system to hold it. It worked very well, holding a fill 19 inches and secure as can be.

Conclusions:

1) The vacuum adapter works very well, and I would recommend it if you want a store bought adapter and a lower price.

2) The vacuum "pump" works as advertised. Pulls more than enough vacuum for safe turning. It is light, and with a couple of magnets, you can put it on the lathe where you can keep an eye on the vacuum gauge (always a good thing). Unless you build your own from scrap parts, this is probably the low price solution. This is also the quietest solution, virtually silent, at least you can't hear it over the normal lathe/turning/sanding sounds.

The downside: as first brought up in this thread by Mark Mandell, it pulls really low volume, so this is not forgiving of leaks in the system or in the wood. Remember, the homemade adapters that I used with my "Big" pump would allow me to pull 17-20 inches of vacuum, dispite leaks, yet the Hold Fast Vacuum Generator would not put over 4 inches with the same adapter. Also remember as TD said, if you regularly turn leaky wood, you might consider a system that uses a shop vacuum to pull a high volume of air.

Will I keep the Hold Fast - Probably, well maybe. Definately will keep the adapter.

Will I keep my old vacuum pump, yes. And I will take Mark's advice and put it out in my storage room a plumb a line into the shop.

Mark

Re: Vacuum Pump-less Vacuum Chucking Report pt 1

#21

Re: Vacuum Pump-less

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Mark,

Glad to hear of the improvement. Good example of how "fragile" any vacuum system actually is; lots of parts have to work well to keep it viable.

I will encourage you to constantly monitor the Hg. guage, especially during a cut, as flexing of the wood surface and the seal material will have the capacity to change your achieved vacuum very quickly. Also pay special attention to maintaining the contact/seal ring on the chuck to minimize abrasions or small cuts that will produce leaks.

I'd suggest that as a last part of your report, you compare power usage between your "regular" vacuum pump and the air compressor you're using to run the venturi. My shop air is supplied by a real 3hp. unit out in the garage which I know would use many times the juice that my vacuum pump does. A small compressor might improve that ratio.

BTW, you run the venturi at lower pressure from the compressor because the venturi works on the CFM passing over it, and your compressor puts out more CFM in the 40-50psi range than it does at 90. If you look at CFM ratings on air compressors, you'll usually see ratings for 40psi and 90psi with the 40psi rating higher by a factor of nearly 20%.

Re: Vacuum Pump-less Vacuum Chucking Report pt 1

#22

Re: Vacuum Pump-less Vacuum Chucking Final Report

John Lucas

>Great report Mark. Thanks for posting.

Re: Vacuum Pump-less Vacuum Chucking Report pt 1

#23

Re: Vacuum Pump-less Vacuum Chucking Final Report

Dave L

>Mark: What adapter are you referencing in number 1? I have one of these outifts and have been trying to improve the vacuum ever since I purchased it. Maybe this item will do it----the name, where you got it, etc..

Thanks.

Dave

Re: Vacuum Pump-less Vacuum Chucking Report pt 1

#24

Re: Vacuum Pump-less Vacuum Chucking Final Report

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>http://www.woodturnerscatalog.com/cgi-bin/shopper?preadd=action&key=280-2650

This the adapter.

Used it with the bigger vacuum pump this after noon, works great.

Mark

Re: Vacuum Pump-less Vacuum Chucking Report pt 1

#25

Improving the Seal

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Mark (& Dave),

You can improve your vacuum adapter's seal if you add an "O" ring to the intake end to seal against the morse taper. Most any hardware store sells the rubber rings for plumbing seals. Take your adpter with you and get a ring that is thicker than the shoulder lip on your adapter but with an inside dismater a bit smaller so that it has to stretch slightly to fit. Illustration shows how it should fit. You can also do the same thing on the other end with an flat rubber washer that fits tight onto the thread rod after you feed it through so that the rotating bearing adapter threads onto the rod and seals against the washer and the spindle face.


img