Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Thompson spindle gouges

Posts

Thompson spindle gouges

#1

Thompson spindle gouges

john lucas

>I spent the day turning some projects and just turning wood into scrap using my new Thompson spindle gouges. I think I'm going to really like these. The big one is 1/2" thick and the other is 3/8". Since I have both a 3/8" and a 1/2" spindle gouges in other brands this was a good comparison.

First off the hollow ground portion is shallower than my gouges. This makes them very thick. To test this I hollowed out a 3" deep ash box. The lack of vibration in the 1/2" tool was really nice. To test the difference I made several cuts with both of the 3/8" gouges. As expected the Thompson gouge had much less vibration even though both were struggling with 3" of tool hanging over the tool rest.

I'm still having trouble determining if the edge stays sharp longer. It seems like it does but like I said before I tend to sharpen often and haven't really done a fair test to determine how long an edge lasts.

I did find something a bit unusual. I sharpened all the gouges on a 100 grit white wheel. The Thompson gouge just didn't seem to cut as well even though they were sharpened at the exact same angle. Then I decided to hone the edge using a fine diamond hone. Now it cut just as good. I turned several items with the gouge without sharpening or honing any more and it seemed to cut fine. I'm assuming the difference is in the toughness of the edge and what happens at the microscopic level while grinding.

I've heard before that powdered metal doesn't get as sharp. I think this is because we tend to sharpen them the same as other tools. This metal is different and apparently requires a different sharpening technique. Once honed this tool cuts exactly like my other tools when I honed them. The other tools seem to be sharper straight off the grinder but once honed all of them cut the same. I'm going to try the same thing with the bowl gouge when I work with it on sunday. More experimentation is needed to prove this one way or the other. I'll be intersted if anyone else who has a powdered metal gouge has noticed this.

Re: Thompson spindle gouges

#2

Re: Thompson spindle gouges

Fog Tanner

>John,

I sharpened my Thompson 5/8" bowl gouge on my Tormek at the finer grit. It cuts extremly well, a little too good for what I was doing at the time. It held the edge longer than the M2, I did go back and sharpen it on my dry grinder using a 100 grit wheel to get it a little less agressive. I have sharpened my Henry Taylor on my Tormek before and it stays sharper longer, but it did not appear to be as sharp as my Thompson doing the same thing. I have also bought a 150 grit wheel for my dry grinder to see if that makes any differnce in the edge.

I would like to know the theory of why the particulate metals can't get as sharp as the M2. From all that I have been able to read, it is all in the wheel hardness. In college, I worked in a shop that made carbide cutting tools. We made the carbide, shaped it, fired it, and ground it. I ran the surface grinder part of the time and could get a razor edge - although the angle was fairly short. But, I was using a diamond wheel, the only thing harder than what I was grinding. It may probably take a different wheel for the Thompsons.

Re: Thompson spindle gouges

#3

Re: Thompson spindle gouges

john lucas

>I'm not sure they won't get as sharp. I think we just have to sharpen them differently. It seems to me that if we sharpened these tools ( and other carbon or HSS tools) to the same level that I sharpen a hand plane blade, we might not see any difference.

I think the problem is sharpening on a grinder (even a fine wheel grinder). The grinder removes metal at a high rate of speed and from the micro photos I've seen it moves the metal also causing a build up on the edge. I suspect this build up is different on different metals. Honing would remove this metal and create a finer edge.

I'm speculating of course because I don't have a microscope to check my theory.

Re: Thompson spindle gouges

#4

It's time to devise a test

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Let's figure this out, can someone come up with a test to compare the sharpness off the grinder between M2 and CPM 10V. Does someone have a old Glaser detail gouge that they have been using a while, how sharp does it get off the grinder compared to M2? It's the same steel.

I did buy a (Gulp) whole sheet of CPM 10V to make scrapers and a skew. Scrapers work great but the skew is another tool with a sharp angle, if it's not as sharp off the grinder as M2 it's not worth making.

OK guys/gals HELP me out

Re: Thompson spindle gouges

#5

Re: Thompson spindle gouges

Bob Fawcett

>Could it also be the wheel?

I have a Norton SG wheel (the real SG that costs nearly $100) and I think my Thompson gouge is just as sharp off the wheel as my others.

I do like to run the diamond hone across the edges of all of them, but sometimes I don't. When I do use the hone, I lay it flat across the hollow from the wheel and move it parallel to the edge.

Re: Thompson spindle gouges

#6

Dick Hines

Re: Thompson spindle gouges

Dick Hines

>I don't hone anything except my Kelton hollowing tools. I use everything just as it comes off the white wheel. I don't seen taking the time to hone if I can get a gouge to cut well.

I figure I can grind my 4 bowl gouges and use one at a time and regrind faster than I can hone one tool.

Re: Thompson spindle gouges

#7

Keith Tompkins

Re: It's time to devise a test

keith tompkins

>Doug, the skew shouldn't be a problem...the skew should always be honed anyway, no matter what material it's made of. I don't know any accomplished skew users who DON'T hone the skew.

From a personal observation only, the powdered metals are brittle. When ground, the particles that remain on the edge break off easily, leaving a rough, jagged edge that doesn't cut well. Honing refines the edge.

Re: Thompson spindle gouges

#8

CPM 10V and M2

Nick Stagg

>Doug,

Perhaps I misread the post. I thought that CPM 10V was 10% vanadium and M2 was 2% vanadium. That wouldn't make them the same , would it? Please correct me if I'm wrong.

Nick

Re: Thompson spindle gouges

#9

I think Doug was saying...

DWR

>... that the Glaser steel is the same as his, so a comparison should be equal.

Re: Thompson spindle gouges

#10

Re: It's time to devise a test

Fog Tanner

>Doug,

From what I have seen in shapening my Thompson bowl gouge on my Tormek, I can get it as sharp as any of the M2 or M4 that I have. I only use the Tormek for all my spindle tools, and the way I check sharpness on my skews is to use a piece of paper (have a stack of HD crdit card apps). If it slices the paper without any effort or any tearing, it is sharp enough. Out of curiosity, I did the same with my Thompson gouge....same results. The stone was around 1000grit and there were no scratch marks at all, a mirror reflection. So I would say that a skew out of the CPM 10V would work. I know I am up for a couple of them, so put me down...

Re: Thompson spindle gouges

#11

Re: Thompson spindle gouges

Fog Tanner

>John,

What you are saying makes sense. I use a Tormek for most of my sharpening and do hone a lot of the tools, sometimes alternating between honing and sharpening. I don' have a microscope anymore, but I know my 100grit dry grinder does throw up metal on the edge. The Tormek will raise a slight amount and I have the two leather wheels and useually knock that off. So probably when I sharpened my Thompson on my Tormek and honed it, I was doing the same as you and not even thinking about it.

Re: Thompson spindle gouges

#12

Re: CPM 10V and M2

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>I don't own anything made from M2 so I can't compare. Some own the old Glaser detail gouge and they could tell us about the edge off the grinder.

The detail gouges are ground at a 40 degree angle on a 80 grit SG wheel.

It's the weekend, time to grind some tools. Let's figure out why.

Re: Thompson spindle gouges

#13

Bill Blasic

Re: Thompson spindle gouges

Bill Blasic

>I received my 5/8" V bowl gouge from Doug yesterday. Bill Noce and I were supposed to go to Pittsburgh this morning for an all day demo with David Ellsworth, but alas I awoke to a foot of new snow over night and it's still snowing with next to zero visibility. So it's into the shop to try out Doug's gouge.

Re: Thompson spindle gouges

#14

What about your stereo microscope?

MIke from St. Clair Shores

>

Re: Thompson spindle gouges

#15

Re: It's time to devise a test

john lucas

>Fog I will try a test this weekend. I'm going to polish the edges of my M2 and V10 spindle gouges just like I would sharpen a carving tool. Then I'll try the old cutting across grain trick by pushing them by hand. That should tell pretty quickly if they sharpen the same. They will be a much more blunt angle than my carving tools but the test is to compare these two steels at the same angle.

should be able to try the paper cut test as well.

Re: Thompson spindle gouges

#16

Re: Thompson spindle gouges

Chuck Engstrom

>Does Doug Thompson have a website for his tools? Could someone post a link?

Thanks--

Chuck Engstrom

Re: Thompson spindle gouges

#17

Re: Thompson spindle gouges

George Van

>Chuck, you have to contact him at dougswoodworking@aol.com, he replies quite promptly.

Re: Thompson spindle gouges

#18

That's a good one John

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>I'm going to try different wheels and look at them on a 10X comparator.

I am glad you noticed this John, I don't think this information is out there. not to the public anyhow.

Re: Thompson spindle gouges

#19

not powerful enough.

john lucas

>

Re: Thompson spindle gouges

#20

Re: It's time to devise a test

dwr

>If they both start out cutting the same, maybe one will last longer than the other, which would be of greater importance to me. But then, I have been using the same carbon steel tools for 20 years, with the exception of one of the first HSS Super Flutes and a 3/8" BG... so almost anything will be sharper and last longer!!

I especially like the design and the price is really on my radar screen... once I get done building my bowl lathe... in about a month or so.

Re: Thompson spindle gouges

#21

Re: That's a good one John

Jorge Castaneda

>Doug,

I spent this afternoon turning, and alternated using your 5/8" and 1/2"gouges and my M2 versions of same, I did not hone this time because it was rough work, but initially they both cut well, and after a while the M2 wants to go to the grinding wheel and the A11 is still going strong, all this while removing lots of wood in a hurry, I was turning bone dry white oak. When I got to the point of refining the shape of the piece, the M2's were able to get finer shavings. This is not a scientific test, I am not Lynn Mangiamelli with his system and patience. just a turner trying to make the most of his time at the lathe. I am happy I got your gauges.

Next time I have a chance to turn I will be finishing that platter and this time I will hone right after sharpening and tell you how it went.

Jorge

Re: Thompson spindle gouges

#22

Jorge, This would help... Thanks

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>