Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Spindle Turning Challenge

Posts

Spindle Turning Challenge

#1

Spindle Turning Challenge

Stuart Johnson

>After Keith posted his finial diagram I thought about a spindle diagram I downloaded from one of the club site. I don't remember which one so please excuse me for not giving credit.

I have tried to duplicate it without success several times and still give it a shot now and then for practice.

Let's have a contest to see who can turn a spindle duplicating the diagram. If we can get at least 10 contestants along with a couple judges I'll donate an 8mm P&N unhandled detail gouge for first place and an 8mm spindle gouge for second.

Post your interest. If there is enough I'll come up with some simple rules and deadline.


img

Re: Spindle Turning Challenge

#2

Larger Photo Available

Stuart Johnson

>I have a larger photo if anyone wants it. Send me an email and I'll forward it to you.

Re: Spindle Turning Challenge

#3

Re: Spindle Turning Challenge

John Lucas

>Boy that would be fun. I don't know if I'll have time to try it or not. I've got a lot going on. It would be a good display piece at club meetings.

Re: Spindle Turning Challenge

#4

Re: Spindle Turning Challenge

John Bussom

>Well if this is open to amature turners I would be interested in taking a shot at it!

For sure I could use practice on anything, not being very inventive with ideas to do things on my own I pretty much am a more duplicative (if you get the idea) and since I don't do HF's or bowls other than segmented it may help keep my turning interests going!

Send me a big pic even if you don't get the contest going!

Thanks,

John

Re: Spindle Turning Challenge

#5

Re: Spindle Turning Challenge

jeff myroup

>I am in! Might take a month or two to finish but I think it would be a fun challenge.

Re: Spindle Turning Challenge

#6

Me thinks

Jorge Castaneda

>I can do that, if it not in short notice, too much going on right now.

Please give dimensions, total lenght, each section, diameter etc

Thanks

Jorge

Re: Spindle Turning Challenge

#7

Re: Spindle Turning Challenge

RK in Milwaukee

>Hi Stuart,

What you have presented here is an excellant spindle turning exercise. I may appropriate this for any future classes I teach.

I think the contest is a good idea and I would be interested in participating if you go ahead with this. Either way, I would appreciate it if you could send me a full size drawing.

Thanks for your post.

Ron Nelson

Re: Spindle Turning Challenge

#8

Re: Larger Photo Available

John Morovich

>I would appreciate a larger drawing or pic of the spindle any dimensions would be helpful.

Re: Spindle Turning Challenge

#9

Re: Spindle Turning Challenge

MikefromTn.

>I'll give it a shot. Get up some rules and time lines measurments etc.

Re: Spindle Turning Challenge

#10

Re: Larger Photo Available

Sam Nelson

>Hi Stuart

This looks like a great spindle turning,fun project.

Post some rules, guide lines, times etc.

Count me in.

Sam

Re: Spindle Turning Challenge

#11

Re: Spindle Turning Challenge

HarryB

>I'd like to take a shot at this too. Will you send me the larger drawing and some idea of size and dimensions.

Re: Spindle Turning Challenge

#12

Re: Spindle Turning Challenge

Lee Dale

>I would like to try also. A larger photo and a line drawing would help........Lee

Re: Spindle Turning Challenge

#13

Re: Good to see you posting again, Lee.

Allen Neighbors

>

Re: Spindle Turning Challenge

#14

Re: Spindle Turning Challenge

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>I'm very interested! Hopefully not over about 3" max diameter, as I don't have much in the way of spindle stock over that size. Unless I turn it from log wood--I've got plenty of Box Elder! ;)

Re: Spindle Turning Challenge

#15

Re: Spindle Turning Challenge

JanManuel

>Turning one of these spindles would be interesting, but the real challenge is...can we turn 4 of them that exactly match each other.......

Re: Spindle Turning Challenge

#16

Re: Spindle Turning Challenge

Bruce

>Count me in. Sounds like fun!!

Re: Spindle Turning Challenge

#17

Re: Spindle Turning Challenge *LINK*

charlie b

>Too easy. How about if you add "and it has to be done with just one gouge or chisel - perhaps a skew - straight or curved cutting edged - or a bedan? And maybe add a loose ring on the ogee and rather than a flat cylinder at the top - an "onion"?

For the next spindle project - a Snottite?

(back up a page from the web page provided)


formal spindle form

Re: Spindle Turning Challenge

#18

Re: Spindle Turning Challenge

Bob Fawcett

>I'm in.

Send me the larer picture as well.

If we make this a contest, we should have dimensions.

Re: Spindle Turning Challenge

#19

Re: Spindle Turning Challenge

Carol from AZ

>Am I missing something here?

It sounds like everyone want a a larger drawing - for the purpose of turning what's in the drawing?

Where is the contest?

I may be completely off base here, but I thought the challenge of finials was design? Along with execution.

And if that is the case, would not that finial have to top off a closed form, or in Cindy's case, also provide a perch for said form to rest?

Just wondering...been doddling with a pencil...might have to try...hmmm...

Re: Spindle Turning Challenge

#20

Re: Spindle Turning Challenge

Stuart Johnson

>Carol, No you are not missing anything. The challenge is to turn an exact copy of the spindle. It is not a finial but in my opinion if one can turn a copy of each of the elements in order and the right dimension they can then design just about any type of spindle they want. After all a finial is just a fancy spindle turning. I am not very good at either spindle or finial turning and as my original post says I have tried to copy it and can't.

The large photo will just make it easier to see the detail and layout.

Re: Spindle Turning Challenge

#21

Spindle Turning Challenge - Details to follow

Stuart Johnson

>We have enough interest in copying the spindle to make for a fun challenge. I'll try to get the rules set up early next week plus come up with a deadline. Right now I'm thinking April 15 might give us something to look forward to rather than dread. Will this give everyone sufficient time?

Rules will certainly be simple. I do know the main thing will be to turn an exact copy. Ron Sardo will host the photos the judges will use to determine a winner.

Re: Spindle Turning Challenge

#22

Re: Spindle Turning Challenge

john lucas

>I have that image somewhere in one of my books and I can't find it. What we all need is a full size image we can download. I'm not sure how someone would jugde this since each printer might be off a hair. Personally I want to turn one just to see how close I can get.

Re: Spindle Turning Challenge

#23

Spindle Turning Challenge - Large Photo

Stuart Johnson

>Ron Sardo is going to put the large photo on his web site. Please download it from there when he sends the link. It will be much faster than my poor dial-up.

Re: Spindle Turning Challenge

#24

Jan, You're exactly right !

Ruth Niles

>