Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

segmenting sled?

Posts

segmenting sled?

#1

segmenting sled?

Bob Fawcett

>I am building a sled for my table saw so I can attempt some segmented turning. I am not following anyones design, which may be a mistake.

How wide are your segments usually? If I leave space for 2" wide is that enough?

What angle range do I need? Seems like 45degrees is maximum.

How long a segment might I need to cut? Seems like 3 or 4 inches is about max.

Anything else I should watch out for?

Thanks

Re: segmenting sled?

#2

Re: segmenting sled? *LINK*

Bill Youngblood

>Hi Bob, Go to the link below. That is Kevin Neeleys site and he has some pretty good instructions on sled building. Bill


http://www.turnedwood.com

Re: segmenting sled?

#3

Re: segmenting sled?

John Bussom

>Bob,

That is a good link that Bill gave you to follow.

Yes there are many things to watch out for, I will suggest visiting a couple other sites also,

http://www.verifiedsoftware.com/goodturns/acumiter.htm

http://www.woodturner.org/products/aw/more_info/2005_winter_sled.pdf

The most important thing to me is to get the sled built correctly for consistant cutting of the segments!

John

Re: segmenting sled?

#4

Re: segmenting sled? *LINK*

Bill Youngblood

>This is another good site for designing. You can play with it and get a feel for designing before buying it. The three main things about sleds are accuracy, accuracy, and accuracy. Good luck and have fun with it.


http://www.woodturnerpro.com

Re: segmenting sled?

#5

Re: segmenting sled?

Bob Fawcett

>Thanks Bill and John.

I had some scraps of HDPE and I found one that fit my saw table groove exactly. I have a base now that slides nicely with no play.

Now for a fence and a way to clamp the segments.

Re: segmenting sled?

#6

Re: segmenting sled?

John Bussom

>Bill, about half way down the page I posted a response to "Help on Tool" that has a poor picture of my sled with a segment hold down!

wouldn't cut without it!

John

Re: segmenting sled?

#7

Re: segmenting sled?

Bob Fawcett

>Thanks John,

Just what I was thinking.

Re: segmenting sled?

#8

Re: segmenting sled?

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>I currently have 4 sleds, one for each of my most common segments per ring 12, 24, 36, 72.

At first my sleds were the simple sort that Kevin shows on Turnedwood.com. Then I started making them, or improving the ones I already had, by bracing both the front and back to keep them from flexing - this became more important, when I added a toggle clamp to hold the wood down. All of this gave more accurate cuts.

The biggest improvement was when I stopped using a stop block clamped on the sled fence to set the segment size, and changed to a stop black attached to my table saw fence. See the picture (this was my most simple sled). With the stop block on the sled, when the segment was cut, it was trapped between the stop block, and the blade. Though there is some danger of the segment flying at you, the biggest issue for me, was the fact that as I drew the sled back, many times, the blade damaged the edge of the segment I just cut. With the stop block on the TS fence, when the sled moves forward, the segment is free to move out of the way after cut - with small pieces, the wind from the rotating blade move it out of the way.

Mark


img

Re: segmenting sled?

#9

Re: segmenting sled?

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>John,

The only problem I see with your setup, is that with a clamp on the segment, you are limiting how small a segment you can cut, especially if you are cutting segments of more that 12 segments a ring.

By clamping the board side vs cut segment side, you have eliminated that problem.

Let me see if I can take a couple of pictures of my current sleds to show everyone, and post them in a couple of hours.

Mark

Re: segmenting sled?

#10

Re: segmenting sled?

eaglesc

>Wouldn't a sled along the lines of a Dubby be the type you are looking for?

(adjustable)

Re: segmenting sled?

#11

Re: segmenting sled?

georgetroy

>The sled is helpful, but a jig on the disc sander issues accuracy down to .0001, believe it or not. I use a Smart Miter Sled, the holdown is a safe way to go. A Zero clearance insert is good. I also use a 8" thin kerf blade to keep the air down. You can cut miters with almost anything, as long as safety is keep in mind. A bandsaw for the little guys will do the trick along with the sanding sled jig. A funnel from Curt Theobald will help keeps those lines straight. Gt www.georgetroygraphics.com


img

Re: segmenting sled?

#12

Re: segmenting sled?

Bill Youngblood

>the Dubby is good for a lot of things, but not segmenting. I make my sleds similar to Mark's. I have a seperate one for each of the degree cuts that I use. If anyone would like a Dubby, I have one that I will sell ... cheap.

Bill

Re: segmenting sled?

#13

Re: segmenting sled?

Bob Fawcett

>Thanks Mark.

I will incorporate that in my sled.

Re: segmenting sled?

#14

Re: segmenting sled?

John Bussom

>Mark, I apologize for my p poor photos, where the big red clamp is holds my size stop put on after the dowel is put into the size hole and goes through the block being held, I have holes there that align for 1" through 2" in 1/8th increments. The holddown clamp holds the segmented piece in place while being cut.

John

Re: segmenting sled?

#15

Re: segmenting sled?

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Good segmenting requires really, really accurate sleds. Remember if you do 24 segments to a ring, and you are off 1/10th of a degree, you will be off 2.4 degrees in the ring - that is a big gap.

If someone is going to do one segmented bowl, then by fine tuning a regular mitre gauge or an adjustable sled like a Dubby, you are fine. However, if you are going to do more than a few, then fixed sleds are the way to go.

In the pictures, the top sled is my 72 segment sled, and it is setup so that the wood sets above the sled, so that when the segment is cut, it falls down and away from the blade. This is nice because I can cut piece after piece w/o having to move them out of the way. The other sled is my 24 segment sled - probably the most used of all my sleds.

Mark


img

Re: segmenting sled?

#16

Re: segmenting sled?

Malcolm Tibbetts

>For those interested, here�s a shot of another sled. As with Mark�s, there is an elevated platform for the board so that the cut-offs shake away from the blade. The �stop� is attached to the saw fence. In the lower photo, you can see the red exit ramp. I also recommend making individual sleds for each needed angle. Personally, I don�t use my table saw for segment cutting. I use a 12� chop saw and then use a sanding jig on a disc sander.


img

Re: segmenting sled?

#17

SmartMiter *LINK*

Stuart Johnson

>I also use a SmartMiter and get very accurate cuts needing just a bit of touch up. I have not found a problem with the segments being brushed by the blade when pulled back but that might be why they need to be tweaked.

I use a two step approach to gluing. Two half of the rings are glued up with two nails separating the halves. When that drys it takes just a touch on the disc (okay when is it disk vs. disc?) sander clean it up.

This photo shows how I use the SmartMiter. There are a couple more at the link.


img

SmartMiter

Re: segmenting sled?

#18

Re: segmenting sled?

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Malcolm,

This is a nice looking sled. Very high tech looking with all the different colors.

You of course raise the "How to Cut" and "Do I Sand Segments" questions. But it demonstrates that in Segmenting there a multiplicty of was to get to the finished product.

I think most of us most of us start off the way were first learned, and then tweak it as we go. In my demos that everytime I attend another segmented turner's demo, I end up seeing/something that makes me ponder my methods at least a little. Sometimes it means a change, sometimes a refinement, and sometimes just knowing another way when I see it.

Mark

Re: segmenting sled?

#19

Hi Mark,

Bill Youngblood

>I tried a sled very similar to yours. The problem I had was when the cut piece was very small, 1/4" in thick x 1/4 or 3/8 wide, they would come back at me like bullets. I tried a sloped board next to the blade like Malcolm's with no change. I now clamp the board and hold the cut off piece with a short piece of dowel with a small nail in the end of it. So far, so good. I cut pieces as small as 1/4 x 1/4 x 1/2. Any suggestions about the bullets?

Re: segmenting sled?

#20

Consistent Speed and Pressure

Stuart Johnson

>Consistent speed and pressure on the sled which one you use is also very important. I think there are so many factors involved there might always be room for improvement. You start of squaring up your stock and then by the time you start actually cutting the segments there has been a bit of wood movement or you apply on the sled toward or away from the blade. The results aren't perfect. My HF disc sander is so out of whack a setup like Malcolm's doesn't work well.

I can't speak to how it works with the miter saw. I tried it one time and after a couple cuts I was a nervous wreak. I use my miter saw but I am never comfortable using it. I think the whirring noise translate into "give me fingers".

Re: segmenting sled?

#21

Re: Consistent Speed and Pressure

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>You are so right, Stuart. Another factor - the Blade. You could certainly make a segmented bowl using a 24 tooth rip blade, but the joints would not be very good. Even the much praised Forrest WWII is not great for high quality segmented turning.

I have found that blades with 80-100 teeth give the best finish. You would not want to rip with them, and you really would not want to cut much wood over 4" wide and 2" thick, as the blades heat up. My absolute favorite is the full 1/8" thick, Forrest Dura-Line AT. Costs about $150, but the finish it leaves on even soft wood is absolutely glass-like (I have two). There are others that I have that are satisfactory, like the Rigid 90 tooth Ultra Crosscut that you can get at Home Depot for about $70. I have tested a great many from Delta to Forrest to Oldham. I probably have $700 in sawblades for my $125 Craftsman TS.

I also suggest that you do not rush the cutting process. If you push too fast, you can watch the blade wobble from the overload, and that makes for a crummy joint. Slower means more cuts per inch which equals a smoother finish.

Pressure - Alway push with the same pressure in the same direction. If you do not, and you have a problem with the angle, you will not know where to start solving it. My 24 segment sled requires that I push too the left on the toggle handle for 12 segmants, and to the right for 12 segments. The difference in the segments from each direction are almost un-measureable, but doing it this way provides a perfect ring.

Mark

Re: segmenting sled?

#22

Re: Hi Mark,

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Bill,

No, you are doing it right for the very small pieces. Especially with the 72 segment sled, I control the cutoff segment with something like you have, or a pencil - using the eraser end.

The other thing I have stoppped doing, is cutting pieces that small. If I were to need a ring that would require a segment only 1/4" wide, 1/4" high, and wall thickness of 1/2" inch, I would use a board that is 1/2" high, and 1.5' wide, and make a bigger ring that I could then turn down to the required diameter, and thickness. It is just too hard to cut and clamp that small. I waste more wood trying to make rings that small, than I do making a bigger ring and turning it down. I made a bunch of little 1.5" diameter segmented bowls for a gallery - but they started out about 3" in diamter, but with a 3.8" hole in the middle. Much easier and faster to do it that way.

Mark

Re: segmenting sled?

#23

Re: segmenting sled?

Malcolm Tibbetts

>Mark, I had the photos from my book project. I made the sled specifically for the book; it's hardly been used.

Regarding the sanding of segment ends, I think that discussion will go on forever.

Re: segmenting sled?

#24

Re: segmenting sled?

Bob Fawcett

>Thanks to everyone for the great discussion and photos. Lots to consider here.

I was planning to make something adjustable, but I think now building a dedicated sled for whatever angle I decide to try first is the way to go. I think I will start with 12 segments unless someone has a reason not to.

Thanks again.

Re: segmenting sled?

#25

Re: segmenting sled?

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Yeah, ain't it great we can all use our own methods - what we feel comfortable.

I know a segmented turner that occasionally lurks here that makes plastic outlines of the segments, traces them on to the wood, cuts them out (curve and all) with a bandsaw, and then sands to final length and angle.

We all have fun. That is the point.

Now that I have a drum sander, I may even try some of the interesting things that you do with tapered rings.

Mark