Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

alcohol drying question

Posts

alcohol drying question

#1

Steve Kubien

alcohol drying question

Steve Kubien

>I've seen Dave Smith's site and I've got a question... Is methyl hydrate the same thing as DNA? It is what I use to mix/thin shellac and it works great. The reason I ask is because I have never found a place which carries DNA here in southern Ontario. I would prefer somewhere relatively close by so I am not stuck paying shipping costs. Methyl hydrate can be got at our (Canadian) Home Depots.

What say you?

Thanks,

Steve Kubien

P.S. Buying products such as 'shellac thinner' gets way too expensive way too quickly for the volume I need.

Re: alcohol drying question

#2

Re: alcohol drying question

Charlie Anderson

>There's quite a bit of discussion on that topic in the archives. Try a search there and here as well.

Re: alcohol drying question

#3

Yes, it's the same stuff.

RevDoug

>

Re: alcohol drying question

#4

JL

Re: No, it's not the same thing (long)...

JL

>Methyl Hydrate is methanol or methyl alcohol - CH3-OH. One carbon, one oxygen and four hydrogens.

DNA is denatured alcohol - typically 90+ % ethanol (CH3-CH2-OH). Two carbons, one oxygen, six hydrogens. DNA contains varying percentages of denaturing agents that can include ethyl acetate, methyl isobutyl ketone and methanol.

Methanol - density at 25 C - 0.7915, boiling point - 64.7 C, flash point - 12 C (54 F), Dipole moment - 1.69 - quite toxic (usual fatal dose 100-250 ml).

Ethanol - density at 20 C - 0.789, boiling point - 78.5 C, flash point - 13 C, Dipole moment - 1.684 - some what less toxic (you can drink it :)).

Will methyl hydrate (aka methanol, methyl alcohol) work? Sure. I tried Dave Smith's method out using methanol, isopropanol (99%, not the 70% rubbing alcohol) and ethanol. All worked.

The Dipole moment is sort of the important thing. It measures the relative "polarity" of the solvent and how well it will "play" with water. You want a solvent that is miscible with water and will help draw the water out of the wood. You then want a solvent with a reasonable vapor pressure that will evaporate somewhat quickly from the wood.

The thing to realize about methyl hydrate (methanol) is that it is toxic. Your body has a tendency to turn it into formaldehyde (the tissue preservative and embalming fluid). You have to find some way to either get rid of the methanol vapors or block them (venting or air purifying respirator). Don't let the vapors accumulate where you breathe them in.

My $0.02.

Re: alcohol drying question

#5

Re: No, it's not the same thing (long)...

MIke from St. Clair Shores

>I think that your belief that DNA is made up mostly of ethanol is probably one that most people share. But in the Detroit Metropolitan area, most stores that sell DNA, sell the type that is 90%+ methanol. True Value hardware was the only place that sold a DNA with a larger concentration of Ethanol than Methanol. The Sunnyside brand in another good one. Check out Dave Smith's website and read about the studies he's done on percentages. Methanol is much worse for your health, so read the labels.

JMHO,

Mike

Re: alcohol drying question

#6

Re: alcohol drying question

Bill Neddow

>Check the companies listed in the Yellow Pages under "Chemicals" There will be at least one in every significant community that brings in DNA in 45 gallon drums and breaks it down into smaller quantities. Buying a liter can be exensive. Buying 20 liters is dirt cheap on a cost-per-liter basis. If that is too much, get another woodturner interested -- or maybe you know someone who make soap. They use it too. Not only is Methal Hydrate dangerous, you will never sell a bowl if the woman buying it finds out it has been soaked in a poison.

Re: alcohol drying question

#7

Methyl hydrate is methanol, bad stuff

Dave Smith, Longview, WA

>JL posted above some good info on the different alcohols. The bottom line is methanol and isopropanol are poisonous while ethanol is harmful. I lot of people are not aware of the presences of methanol in shellac thinner and apply shellac made with it with no gloves and inadequate ventilation. Methanol is readily absorbed through the skin. As in the case of shellac, a bowl soaked in alcohol will be safe once the alcohol has evaporated.

I highly recommend using denatured alcohol high in ethanol concentration when ever possible. You can find a list on the alcohol soaking blog of several brands of denatured alcohol high in ethanol. Ethanol can be make unfit to drink with the addition of less than 5% methanol.

The term denatured alcohol was coined to refer to ethanol that has been made unfit drink by the addition of one or more poisons. Methyl hydrate is 100% poison and should never be referred to as denatured alcohol IMHO.

Dave Smith

Enjoying my last sunny day in Mesa, AZ before heading home to Longview, WA.

Re: alcohol drying question

#8

Re: No, it's not the same thing (long)...

RevDoug

>JL, you are right. My mistake. But your explaination is what I meant by my very short answer. Thanks for the explainiation.

Turn 'em round,