Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Are there real differences between turning tools?

Posts

Re: Are there real differences between turning tools?

#26

Re: Cryogenic?

Russ Fairfield

>My only experience with cryogenic is when I left some tools in the back of my truck box through several days of sub-Zero weather. They didn't cut any different from those that were in the heated shop. This comparison is probably as valid as some of the claims I read in the woodturning catalogs. {8>)

Re: Are there real differences between turning tools?

#27

Re: Are there real differences between turning too

John Kyler

>Glad to see your professional response to Benjamin's Best.

I purchased a 5/8" bowl gouge and it just wont keep an edge. I had been very disappointed, vowing to not buy more.

Maybe it is just a problem with the temper on this one? I was figuring it was just they used a second grade of HSS.

John

Re: Are there real differences between turning tools?

#28

Re: Are there real differences between turning too

Gordon Seto

>John,

Try it with a hand file. As reported in other sites, some of the Ben Best tools were shipped without even heat treated. It seems the QC is not doing the job.

Gordon

Re: Are there real differences between turning tools?

#29

Re: Are there real differences between turning too

John Kyler

>Good idea.

Thanks.

Re: Are there real differences between turning tools?

#30

Re: M2 not necessarily M2

Bill Neddow

>Bill, I think you will find the industry is very particular about specifications. M2 has to be M2 and V15 has to be V15. Otherwise, you could not trust the parts in aircraft engines, or the wings on the planes to stay attached. Now what the companies do to this steel as they forge it into shape and temper it is something different. Even the best steel can be ruined by faulty heat treating and tempering. I think that is where you will find the bulk of the differences between tools. Cryo treatment helps overcome faulty heat treating and tempering, but I do not feel I should be paying extra for something used to rectify someones shoddy workmanship.

Re: Are there real differences between turning tools?

#31

Re: M2 not necessarily M2

John Kyler

>Dumb question... But M2 is M2 on paper, but is it certified as M2 by someone before it is marked that?

I know for some time and likely still to this day people would buy a .999 fine stamp for their sterling silver jewelry and stamp it, but the buyer has no idea that it is that quality. Are the tools either made in England or those from Asia truly M2 or just marked/stamped.

I would guess England has some standards and checks for same... But does any other country? Sorry I just don't know. I have had great luck with Sorby and Crown... But some of the less expensive imports from other parts of the world have had a few issues.

Re: Are there real differences between turning tools?

#32

Russ

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>I'm sure you know why the edge doesn't hold up the last two inches. Manufactures use a induction heater to harden the steel so the shank never reaches a high temperature. Remember you need to hold on to the steel so the entire piece doesn't go inside of the coils. The steel is heated in seconds then quenched hardened.

What turners have been using for years is CASE hardened steel. Only the outside is hard and the inside is soft. M2 can be manufactured at a low cost and cuts wood just fine.

Re: Are there real differences between turning tools?

#33

ReThat is also a good safety....

Jamie Donaldson

>..feature- the shaft is less likely to snap under load at the area of the handle.

Re: Are there real differences between turning tools?

#34

Don't know... the stress is at the toolrest

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Every tool on the market has broken at one time or another. I'm sure the P&N spindle roughing gouge is the exception. A question about broken tools might answer this.