Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Are there real differences between turning tools?

Posts

Are there real differences between turning tools?

#1

Are there real differences between turning tools?

wilbur

>There's going to be a woodworking show coming to town next weekend, and I thought it might be a good chance to pick up some "real" turning tools. This will be my first time buying something off the shelf. The used lathe that I bought came with some old 1950's era Buck Bros. and Craftsman turning tools, which are all spindle oriented. I'm going to be looking for some tools more oriented towards bowl turning.

However, having perused the Packard Woodworks catalog, and the Craft Supplies USA website (they won't send me a catalog, despite 4 attempts to request one), I've become real confused as to which brand I should go with. As far as I can tell, the only real differences between brands is the type of steel used to make the gouge. I'm assuming that any differences in profile I can alter with grinding to a new profile, and any differences in tool handles can be addressed by making new handles. After all, that's why I got a lathe, right?

I've figured out the difference between M2 high speed steel, ASP 2030 and 2060, and cryo treated steels. What I'd like to know is if there are any real differences between brands, assuming that you keep the type of steel the same (e.g., a Hamlet M2 HSS gouge and a Sorby M2 HSS gouge).

Re: Are there real differences between turning tools?

#2

Re: Are there real differences between turning too

Jeff Myroup

>I thought I was the only one CSA would not send a catalog too. I have requested 3-4 time as well. As for your questions I will let the pros answer those

Jeff

Re: Are there real differences between turning tools?

#3

Re: Are there real differences between turning too

Ed Moore

>Wilbur,

It is my opinion that there are differences between tools you get from different companies. These differences may be subtle, such as in the cross-section of the tools. One bowl gouge may be U-shaped while the other may be more vee-shaped. Since you said that you are going to a woodWORKing show I assume that Packard and Craft USA will not be there. But maybe a Woodcraft will be.

Before you get caught in the turning tool buying vortex, give some thought to what kind(s) of turning you would like to do. Then buy tools that reflect the projects you will be doing. Suppose you decide to buy a few tools. Everyone needs a GOOD 3/8" spindle gouge, a GOOD parting tool, and a GOOD bowl gouge (try 3/8" unless you are into bowls). Given that Craft Supply USA won't send you a catalog, get these from Packard. I THINK Hamlet makes the Packard line and the two lines are comparable and probably interchangeable except for the wood in the handles.

If you are going to do any spindle work, buy a P&N roughing gouge. These have a stout tang, which can be very important. I think Lee Valley has these.

I'll stop here lest I get a war going over which tools are best or exactly which tools are the absolute minimum.

Ed

Re: Are there real differences between turning tools?

#4

Re: Are there real differences between turning too

RevDoug

>Flute design, length of flute, even differences in HSS between the different makers can be huge or minimal. You'll just have to experiment and see what you like best.

Turn 'em round,

Re: Are there real differences between turning tools?

#5

JL

Re: Are there real differences between turning too

JL

>Beefier is better, IMO. Meaning that a longer, "weightier" tool is to be prefered to one that is shorter. I want enough steel so that a tool can be sharpened many times. I forget the brand, but one tool I was looking at had about 20% less steel than the competition (which cost only 10% more). The cross-sections were similar.

Re: Are there real differences between turning tools?

#6

Re: Are there real differences between turning too

Bill Youngblood

>I prefer the OneWay brand for gouges. The tools are double ended so you can have 2 different grinds. The handles come in two sizes and are quite hefty which removes a lot of vibration on an uneven piece of wood.

Re: Are there real differences between turning tools?

#7

Re: Are there real differences between turning too

Greg Haugen

>Someone who is turning for a hobby a luxury steels are a bit overkill. They're nice for production but if money is a slight issue don't feel you have to spend 180 dollars on a bowl gouge. I would stay with any version of the M2 HSS, this includes the basic series of Hamlet/Packard tool (same tools), Sorby, Henry Taylor, P&N, Crown, and there are some overseas versions of HSS tools that could be good or bad I don't know. They are "steel X" and the HSS line for Delta, Delta has two lines a new HSS version and an old carbon steel version. As far as what to buy it depends on what you turn. I'm not going to tell someone to buy two skews if they hate spindles and want to turn only bowls or vessels.

Best thing you can do is to find another turner or a few turners and try their tools. Feel how the handle length works for you, etc.

Depending on your grinder, if you're buying "real" tools they should be sharpened on "real" wheels. Again, they don't have to be expensive. I like the pink wheels from Woodcraft for 30 each. Pink, white, or blue are good starting points in a J or K hardness. Grits can be 36-60 for roughing or 60 to 100 for sharpening.

If the show is "The woodworking shows" that travels to different cities, Craft Supplies will be there. They have a booth and mini seminars each day. Kirk Deheer runs the booth. A very knowledgeable turner. Ask him any questions. Like, "where the heck is my catalog?" :-))))

Holler if I can help in any way,

Greg

Re: Are there real differences between turning tools?

#8

Brad Vietje

Re: Are there real differences between turning too

Brad Vietje

>Good comments already.

One other thought: one difference is that extra little bit if polishing of the ground surfaces. Some manufacturers take extra time (which costs $$) to polish the inside surface of the flutes so there are no ridges -- which can become little teeth when you sharpen through them. Its a very simple matter to wrap some 320 around a dowel and clean up the inside of the flute by hand, and save yourself some money.

Some less expensive tools are pretty darned good, but don't mess with non name-brand tools -- some are real crap. These sort of tools are often sold as cheap-o boxed sets, or come free with some new lathes. They have crappy handles, ultra-cheap ferrules (both of these can be easily made at home), and when you look closely at a tool like a parting tool, the sides of the tool aren't square and/or parallel, so it will sit on the rest at an angle. These are not worth your time or money.

Safe spinning (and shopping),

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Are there real differences between turning tools?

#9

Re: Are there real differences between turning too

John Kyler

>I have tools made by many of the companies (Sorby, Hamlet, Crown, BB, etc.).

I think it is like buying a vehicle, it seem most any of them make one in an area that is better then the others. My bowl gouges are Crown Pro-PM, and Sorby, skews both Sorby and Lacer Signature, scrapers what ever I can afford or need for a specific use. I do like the hollowing tools from Sorby. I find some of the less expensive tools I got early on I have re-ground to more special purpose tools.

John

Re: Are there real differences between turning tools?

#10

Brad Vietje

OOPS -- One Other Thing...

Brad Vietje

>I have been told by wise sages of all things tools and turning that it does not make sense to buy scraping tools in these super-hard, abrasion-resistant alloys, powder metals, etc... The reason given involved more metallurgy than I understand, but had to do with the fine grain structure of the steel itself. Basic M-2 HSS is more maleable,or ductile than exotic alloys, having a more "flaky" grain structure, and produces a better burr edge, and can be given a curled burr edge by lightly burnishing. Super wear-resistant tools are harder, but more brittle, too, (with a more granular structure), and appear to be better for cutting tools than scraping tools.

There are people on this list who know much more about metals than I -- maybe they'll have better, or more accurate information.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Are there real differences between turning tools?

#11

Re: Are there real differences between turning too

Bill Hale / The Wood Spinner

>I agree with Bill on the Oneway. Remember that I do no spindle work. I do 99% of my work with the 5/8 and 1/2 Oneway gouges. I also use a 3/8 Oneway for smaller or detail work. Buy these in quality and then buy cheaper, not cheap, other tools to see what others you use and then buy those in quality. I don' even know how many tools I have but as I said 99 % of my work is done with 3 tools.

Good turning and be safe

Bill in Casa Grande, AZ.

Re: Are there real differences between turning tools?

#12

Re: Are there real differences between turning too

Bill Hale / The Wood Spinner

>Wilbur

I forgot to mention that if the show you mentioned is of any size Craft supply and or Packard may be there. Complaign about the Catalog situation ! They may also have tools there to look at and to buy.

Call Craft Supply and ask again for a Catalog 1-800-551-8876

Bill

Re: Are there real differences between turning tools?

#13

Re: OOPS -- One Other Thing...

John Kyler

>Thanks for mentioning the polishing.

That is one of the major cost that I failed to mention. I have a Cratex wheel and polish my tools and it is very effective, and take little time.

And the scrapers comment is what I have also been told by far smarter people than I on tools. And I have experienced this by some tools that I have bought over the years.

M2 or less expensive tools have been my better scrapers.

John

Re: Are there real differences between turning tools?

#14

Re: Are there real differences between turning too

Mike Brazeau

>My thoughts which I had posted at another forum just a couple of days ago - I have gouges made from all of the alloys and powder metallurgy commonly avilable and am in the midst of putting together a talk on tools and tool making for presentation at our guild in April. I worked in the scientific instruments industry where we made the optical spectrometers to measure metal constituents, so have some knowledge of alloys. I ran the 2060 by one of our experienced people a few years ago and he had never run across anything like it. It has a decent percentage of every hard element known in it (Molybdenum, Tungsten, Manganese and Vanadium). I have had my 2060 bowl gouge for 5 years and love it. There is no doubt in my mind that it holds an edge the longest. I have a M4 spindle gouge from Oneway and find that it does not hold an edge nearly as long as the 2060. I find the 2060 takes a very fine edge, almost like Carbon Steel, while the M4 seems to be coarser. Could be related to the powder metallurgy technology which they both are. Jacques Coulombe, who convinced me to buy the 2060 years ago, no longer carries Hamlett 2030 as the 2060 is not that much more expensive and outperforms it. I have purchased a couple of P&N gouges in the last year which are M2 and for value I am very pleased. I do not like the black treatment on them, but it doesn't affect their performance. I also like to make my own handles. For the casual turner, I don't really think it matters, but if you have the $ go with the best you can afford. I have a six piece HSS set made in China which I paid $90 Cdn for and the tools have been excellent, both for design and holding an edge, so you never know. I bought to practise grinds on and have got much more than that from them. The new Cryo tools from various manufacturers seem to be creating some stir, but I have no feedback on their performance. In Canada, Woodchuckers has some Cryo tools from Craft Supplies UK that are very reasonably priced.

Re: Are there real differences between turning tools?

#15

Re: Are there real differences between turning too

Bill Neddow

>Funny. I am doing a presentation on this very subject at our turning club tonight. I got interested because I felt I got burned by the advertising for some of the tools- but it has taken several years of bulldog-like perserverence to get by the advertising and to get at the facts.

Basically, M2 steel is M2 steel -- no matter who markets the tool. Same thing with M4 and all the other brands. Buy the cheapest one that meets your needs. But avoid the generaic crap coming from China and India. One exception is Benjamin's Best. The steel in these is good, but there have been a few reports of problems with tempering. There is a 900 per cent difference between the cost of a Benjamin's Best and a 2060 tool. You do not get a 900 per cent improvement in quality or life of the tool. And if there is a tempering problem, the supplier has been quick to replace the tool.

Look at design. P&N make some really well designed tools. Their spindle roughing gouge is so well designed that others should copy it. It actually has a tine on it that will not break. The others should be banned as being dangerous. P&N also has some wonderful detail gouges with lots of mass under the flute -- great design. Remember that most catches start with a tool vibrating. One of the best designed bowl gouges comes from Oneway, and the M4 steel is worth buying. If you get the double ended tools (flute on both ends) they are very cost-effect and you are close to getting two tools for the price of one.

I am a production bowl turner and for production use, I have a stable of 5 Benjamin's Best 5/8 inch bowl gouges for woods like maple (low silica woods). I sharpen them all, then go at it until they are all dull. Saves walking to grinder. For high silica woods like Walnut, I use an M4 Oneway. My roughing gouge is a P&N as well as my detail gouges. I have a couple of large drawers full of other tools that never get used.

Other tools to consider if you are in the States:

1. The John Jordan tools. there is no indication of the type of steel on my bowl gouge but it stands up very well. If the price is right, go for it.

2. Sweazey tools. These are made of M42 steel, which holds up almost as well as M4. M42 is supposed to be a little more brittle than M4 (which causes the tip break) but I have never had one instance of this happening with the Sweazy tool -- and I am an aggressive turner. Price is the reason I don't buy it -- the price is right for you, but after I pay shipping, customs brokerage fees, etc. It costs as much as a double ended Oneway. But the quality is there.

Stay away from the boutique steels and treatments. Titanium coating is not worth the cost. Cryo steel might be good, but not unless it is almost the price of a regular tool. OneCryo, a company in the US will cryo treat a 17 inch knife blade for $17 for the first and $2.50 for each subsequent blade. Take that as a reference for how much extra Cryo tools should cost.

Just as important as the tool -- and maybe more important -- is the way you sharpen it. Get a good grinding wheel (white, pink, blue) and a jig. And lean on a turner you respect to spend a couple of hours with you teaching you about sharpening. If you are not near other turners, get the sharpening DVD from the American Association of Woodturners.

Re: Are there real differences between turning tools?

#16

Catalog Request

Russ Babbitt

>Craft customer service is some of the best around in my opinion. If they haven't answered your email request, have you considered giving them a call?

Re: Are there real differences between turning tools?

#17

Excellent review, Bill

Ruth Niles

>You answered a lot of my unasked questions and quite clearly.

Re: Are there real differences between turning tools?

#18

Can I stay home now?

Bill Howatt

>Actually, looking forward to your words of wisdom as always! See you tonight, weather permitting.

Bill

Re: Are there real differences between turning tools?

#19

Re: Are there real differences between turning too

George Van

>Thanks Bill, I do not think you missed anything.

Re: Are there real differences between turning tools?

#20

Bill and Mike

Bob Fawcett

>Have either of you compared the 2060 to Crown's Pro PM or the A-11 in the original Glaser?

I have one of each and find the edge outlasts my M2 tools. I also think the A-11 seems to get sharper than some of the others. This is all subjective, I have no ability to do any scientific testing.

Re: Are there real differences between turning tools?

#21

M2 not necessarily M2

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

>Wife and I took a weekend bowl turning class at Arrowmont this October. We turned green cherry for over 22 hours. All four tools were M2. She had a 3/8" Benjamin's Best. I used a 3/8" Packards, 3/8" HFreight, and a 1/2" Pinnacle from Craft Supplies. All tools were ground identically to the same exact instructor's profile with a Wolverine and Varigrind jig. I sharpened all four tools. Wife turned twice as many bowls as I did. Order of needed sharpening. CS Pinnacle dulled very quickly! Then HF, BB, and the best was Packard by at least 50 %. The ingrediants of tool steel that really make the difference are in fractional percents. Variances as small as tenth of 1.0% can make DRASTIC changes in the results. That is only one part per thousand. Buy Crown or Packards if you can afford to. We own ten BB tools and they are 90% as good as more expensive ones. Stay away from the really cheap ones. We have some Sorby tools, but do not have anything similar for comparison.

Bill in WNC mountains

Re: Are there real differences between turning tools?

#24

Re: Even if the original M2's blanks were .....

Jamie Donaldson

>... all the same, the variations in heat treating/hardening can be substantial, and the resulting differences are called "quality control!"

Re: Are there real differences between turning tools?

#25

Re: Are there real differences between turning too

Russ Fairfield

>My complaint with all of the M2 tools is that the hardness starts to disappear while there is still 2" of useable flute left.

An advantage of the PM alloys (M4 and higher) is that they are the same hardness throughout the tool. I can use all of the flute and still make a round skew or a spindle tool from what is left after the flute has been used up.

The biggest difference I have found between the cheap M2 tools and the expensive ones is uniformity of hardhess. Most of the cheap tools have hard and soft spots in them. The only exception I have found is Benjamines Best from PSI. They seem to be a more uniform alloy and hardness than others in the same price range.