Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

I give up on Keltons

Posts

I give up on Keltons

#1

I give up on Keltons

dwfII

>I have spent the last six months...an hour or two at a time...trying to hollow out a Siberian Elm vessel. The wood is totally dry and it's coarse. But I wanted to try a one inch hole and I've been working carefully. Even bought a Oneway bowl steady.

Well, I just can't get friendly with these Keltons. I get a screeching sound (and have from the day the tool was new) the minute the blade touches wood. A high, screechy vibration is really what it is. I've tried everything from raising and lowering the rest to tilting the blade but while I have moments I just can't get a smooth or comfortable cut with this tool. And it beats me to death.

This morning I got a "catch"...surprisingly the only bad one Ive had since beginning. But the mouth of the HF was chewed up....maybe even cracked.

Not wanting to dump my work and the hollow form, I cut the hole from one inch to about two inches.

At that point I could comfortably get my Sorby Hollowmaster in there and...it was like I knew what I was doing, all of a sudden!

My cutting was smooth and fast and I was dern near relaxed--despite that ever dangerous square edge on the bottom of the shaft. I have used the Sorby to make a very sweet apple vase and a big leaf maple hollow form that had an ebonized persimmon collar. I think I posted photos of both on this forum.

I can do this...with the Sorby, but I can't find the edge with the Keltons.

If anyone can suggest a tool that will run as smooth as the Sorby in a one inch hole, I would appreciate the recommend and the advice.

In the meantime, my Keltons are up for sale--driven only on Sundays by a little old grey haired bootmaker. Perfect condition, no rust, low miles.

DW

In the High Desert of Central Oregon

Re: I give up on Keltons

#2

Re: I give up on Keltons

Carole Valentine

>DW, how deep is the vessel, which size Kelton's are you using and in what type of handle? How far into the handle do you have the shaft of the tool? They are my "go to" tools for hollowing. Sometimes I will start getting a little screeching on some woods in deep shoulder areas, but a little honing and a lighter cut or a change in cutting direction (bottom to top or top to bottom) generally solves the problem.

Re: I give up on Keltons

#3

Re: I give up on Keltons

Greg Jensen

>How are you sharpening the tools. Sound like they are dull.

Greg Jensen

Re: I give up on Keltons

#4

Re: I give up on Keltons

john lucas

>I think Carol covered the questions I was going to ask. Shaft size and length extended over the tool rest are major factors that cause screetching or vibration. A dull tool and the how big a bite the tool takes are also factors as well as the angle you approach the work.

With my Homemade Jordan style tools I start to get the screetch at 6" with my 1/2" tools and 10 to 12" with 3/4". That's using 3/16" HSS cutters.

Re: I give up on Keltons

#5

Re: I give up on Keltons

Jeff Myroup

>I have a set of the 5/8" keltons. I have had the same problems as you. I have only used them a half dozen times and seem to be getting better. I find if I am to aggresive they will take me on a wild ride. There have been times I've had to hold on for my life. I also have a hard time sharpening them. I never seem to get a raised burr. I use the recommended diamond files but they are to smooth/ fine. I need to get a more course stone. I am looking into ways of adding a 90 degree handle to help with the torque. Maybe with this post we can both get some good help

Re: I give up on Keltons

#6

Re: I give up on Keltons

Jeff Myroup

>I have seen hollowing gates and pins added to the tool rest that aid with leverage. Do you use these in your hollowing? I have been thinking about adding a pin to my rest to see if that helps.

Re: I give up on Keltons

#7

Re: I give up on Keltons

dwfII

>Carol,

The bowl was about five inches deep and about seven inches in diameter. I have a Jet mini lathe and can't get too big. The Keltons are the 1/2" shafts with a Kelton weighted handle.

I had this same problem when I tried to use them on my apple vase. And again on my big leaf maple.

I have tried to use a light touch, although at that rate it might take me a year or two to finish the vase. But the screeching does get worse when I try to firm up a little. Using a light touch doesn't really help, though. I think I know what a light touch is...I can barely scratch with the Sorby and it rides smooth and easy. Using the Keltons even with a light touch it seems like it will vibrate if I even get within a whisper of the wood.

I have the shafts embedded such that both set screws are biting. But that's another thing I did try---setting the shafts in the handle more deeply..no joy. And I have tried running my rest really close to the opening and a bit further away...no difference.

Greg,

This happened right out of the "box"--they should have been sharp then, if anytime. I have taken a diamond file to them once or twice and I have also very carefully given them a light sharpening on a grindstone being particular about maintaining the angle. It does not help, not even initially.

It's probably just me...but again, I find the Sorby almost easy. Carol do you use the Sorby at all? The Sorby actually has a narrower cutter yet I get almost no ridges and a relatively smooth interior. Using the Keltons I get almost all ridges and cannot come anywhere near to the smoothness of the interior.

[sigh]

Anyone have a Sorby R2000 set up for sale?

DW

In the High Desert of Central Oregon

Re: I give up on Keltons

#8

Re: I give up on Keltons

dwfII

>Jeff,

I can raise a burr. I use cabinet scrapers in my real job. I do raise a burr on the Keltons although it is not a turned burr like what would be on a cabinet scraper. It doesn't seem to make a difference.

What kills me is that the Sorby Multi-tip or Hollowmaster tool doesn't seem to have much of a following but I find it very easy and I don't get all tight and stressed trying to control it like I do with the Keltons.

I'm thinking that the tips and the holder for the cutting tip on the Sorby Multi-tip tool might fit on a Sorby R2000. If so, I think I'd like to try one of those.

In another post a couple of weeks ago, I asked about ridges on this same vessel (left by the Keltons) and several people indicated that they used the Sorby R2000 with a scraper blade.

DW

In the High Desert of Central Oregon

Re: I give up on Keltons

#9

Re: I give up on Keltons

Jeff Myroup

>I get the same ridges. I use my hollow master shear scraper to smooth it out when I can get it in the hole. I am thinking about picking up a munro articulated hollower in the next couple of weeks, once I get the money. I have heard alot of good things about them.

Re: I give up on Keltons

#10

Re: I give up on Keltons

Carole Valentine

>LOL! I have a Sorby Hollow Master and am not at all fond of the thing. Each to his or her own, I guess. I also have a Multi-tip and I do use it, but usually only with the teardrop scraper on open vessels. I'm interested in the Munro mini hollower, but I won't buy one of those until I have tried it though.

Just a thought about your problem - what speed are you running your Jet mini when this happens? Does speed matter? Just wondering if you could be setting up some sort of harmonics.

Re: I give up on Keltons

#11

Re: I give up on Keltons

dwfII

>Actually, I have tried running at the lowest speed on the standard (non-variable) Jet midi (500? rpm) and one step up which is, I believe, about 850rpm. No real difference in incidence but the screeching and vibration does seem worse at the lower speed. On the other hand, I got the catch atthe higher speed and the consequences are, I suppose, always going to the worse.

DW

In the High Desert of Central Oregon

Re: I give up on Keltons

#12

From my experience with them...

Peter Teubel

>I have 4 sets of Kelton hollowers from micro to 3/4". While I usually use them in a captured system, I still use them freehand occasionally.

The 1/2" ones will vibrate when extended over 4" over the tool rest. The mini ones, 3". The micro ones, 1 1/2". Even the big 3/4" ones start to vibrate when extended over 8". I think the reason you are having good luck with the Sorby is because of the smaller cutter. The Kelton's edge is MUCH larger than the Sorby.

Re: I give up on Keltons

#13

Re: I give up on Keltons *LINK*

joaz

>I used a hollowing gate for a while and found it did not help much and generally got in the way.

I like the Kelton system but instead of using Kelton cutters I had a machinist friend bore out the carrier and used the bar and cutters from my old Jamieson rig. This works well with the larger diameter

bar and adjustable cutters.


http://www.maine-web.com/woodturning

Re: I give up on Keltons

#14

Re: I give up on Keltons *LINK*

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>I have the mini and 1/2" sized kelton hollowers and don't have problems you describe when using them. I use the mini handle for the mini's and the armbrace from the Scorpion for the 1/2". The only time I get "screeching" or excessive vibration is if I try to take too much of a bite.

Here is a link to Kelton's site. Check it out for more information about these tools.

keithz


kelton hollowers

Re: I give up on Keltons

#15

Re: I give up on Keltons

john lucas

>I don't own keltons so I can't seak with authority but are you cutting with the tip on the centerline of the vessel. I also tilt the cutters to the left so the tip of the cutter(left side) is lower than the right side.

Re: I give up on Keltons

#16

Re: I give up on Keltons

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>DW, set the speed on your Mini at 1200. You'll get smoother cutting at the higher speed. In my classes at Woodcraft I always set the speed at 1200 for the beginners on what might even be their first bowl. We use 7 inch blanks. If I was turning a 5-incher on the mini I'd set it at 1800. Can't help you on the Kelton...I've never used it.

Wally

Re: I give up on Keltons

#17

Re: I give up on Keltons

Barry Turner

>I have a set of the 5/8" shaft Keltons. When you read the literature, it says you are not supposed to grind the tips, only touch up with a credit-card sized diamond hone. The hone usually is all you need, but if the tips are still not sharp, you're gonna have to grind the tips. Grind very carefully while maintaining the factory bevel and shape. Grind very lightly and only as much as is necessary. After grinding, you should be able to just hone the edge with the diamond hone a number of times before it is necessary to regrind again. It made all the difference with mine. Kelton has a website that is very helpful with sharpening the hollowing tools.

http://www.kelton.co.nz/holuse.html

Re: I give up on Keltons

#18

Re: I give up on Keltons

Barry Turner

>Roll the Kelton over counter-clockwise about 45-degrees so you get a shearing cut instead of a scraping cut.

Re: I give up on Keltons

#19

Re: I give up on Keltons

Carole Valentine

>Wally, do you turn at high speed even when hollowing out vessels through a small opening? I have often thought I may be turning at too slow a speed, but was leery of jacking it up, especially when doing a hollow form through a small opening. I don't think I have ever had my lathe at 1800 except when doing a spindle or finial. I have had some bad catches inside a vessel at 850...I don't know what would have happened at 1800. Maybe the cutter would have blown on through the potential catch? Am I being a wuss?

Re: I give up on Keltons

#20

Re: I give up on Keltons

dwfII

>Thanks Wally, I'll give that a try.

BTW, what do you use for hollowing through a small opening?

DW

In the High Desert of Central Oregon

Re: I give up on Keltons

#21

Re: I give up on Keltons

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>Carole, I turn my hollow forms as well as bowls at 1200. I start off-balanced work at 500, then dial up to 1200 after I get it spinning true. I have found the kelton's cut quite well at this speed.

keithz

Re: I give up on Keltons

#22

Re: I give up on Keltons

robo hippy

>DW,

I haven't had the problems you are talking about with the Keltons. The first few forms were done hand held, but that is too much work. I had a Jaimeson type handle made for them. It is a lot less work. As I got used to them I did turn up the speed, and found that I could be quite agressive with them. They don't seem to make a very good finish cut for me. Come on over to Eugene some time.

robo hippy

Re: I give up on Keltons

#23

Re: I give up on Keltons

John Scheideman

>Have you tried calling Kelton and talking to them about it? They must have someone who could help you.

John

Re: I give up on Keltons

#24

Re: I give up on Keltons

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Carol, I find that many turners turn at speeds that are, in my opinion, too slow. I have a unique opportunity here in my town to observe other turners. Out community woodshop has 7 Woodfast lathes. I teach classes there, so most of the turners are students of mine. I often suggest that they ramp up the speed. They will just about always agree that it helps to make better, smoother cuts, and possibly fewer mistakes.

Wally

Re: I give up on Keltons

#25

Re: I give up on Keltons

Greg Jensen

>I would be glad to help.

Do not use a diamond on the Kelton Tools with the hard faceing. This includes hollowers center saver blades and shear scrapers. A diamond is very fine and will not work well. A course diamond is 220 grit. Use a medium slip stone or hard arkansas. They will raise a burr much better then the diamond. DO NOT BURNISH THE TIPS TO RAISE A BURR on the hollowers. This will make the tool very agressive and you will not be able to control them. You can grind the tips to get a good shape to the tip but grinding takes away alot of metal so be careful. You will be required to grind the tip if you round over the edge while honing.

You can send the tool to me and I will check it out and grind it to shape for you.

Contact me on my cell at 440-570-7596. I live in Cleveland Ohio.

Greg Jensen

North American Rep for Kelton Tools.