Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

A questoin about standards

Posts

A questoin about standards

#1

A questoin about standards

Troy German

>What criteria do you guys use to determine if a piece is of high enough quality to be sold? Or put another way, what imperfections are acceptable and not acceptable on a turning you�re willing to sell?

I think that�s an interesting discussion question by itself, but I also have a reason for asking.

A friend of mine is a florist and would like to sell some the things I turn. I�m a hobbyist and am not too concerned about my reputation as I don�t plan to make a living at this, but her store is her livelihood. As a florist a reputation for quality matters, and I don�t want to put something in her store that is sub par. The problem is I can always find something wrong with everything I turn. So, I�m trying to figure out where to draw the line.

Thanks for the help,

Troy

Re: A questoin about standards

#2

Troy: The line is where you choose to draw it.

david

>The florist has already passed judgement on your work by asking you to sell your pieces in his/her shop. You alone will determine if the pieces you produce meets your standards. Remember the saying: One man's junk is another man's treasure? What you consider flawed may be the most appealing feature to a buyer because then it looks like it was produced by a human and not a machine. Then your most perfect piece will sit on the store shelf unsold. It may be the price, form, color, texture, whatever. You can never predict the market for some of this stuff.

Re: A questoin about standards

#3

Re: A questoin about standards

Carole Valentine

>Troy, I have never, and I repeat NEVER, made a piece that I thought was perfect and I am quite sure I never will. Let your friend decide if they are good enough for her shop. She is the one who knows her customers and she must have seen your work or she wouldn't have asked. And don't get huffy if she decides it's not quite what she wants. Just find out why learn from it.

Standards? Gosh...I dunno. Each piece is different - but in a nutshell, I would say pleasing form, uniform thickness, no tool marks, no tearout, no sanding marks, good finish, attention to details.

Just my two cents worth.

Re: A questoin about standards

#4

Nobody's perfect.....

Ron Bauman

>I believe it is the Persian rug weavers who always weave an error into their work. Their reason was that no one but God is perfect, but I suspect it applies to all of us in that none of us is perfect. You set your own standards and then work to that line. You certainly can raise or lower them as you become more proficient. It'll gnaw at you if you let it.

Re: A questoin about standards

#5

Bob Moffett

Re: Nobody's perfect.....

Bob Moffett

>The Amish did the same thing with their quilts.

Re: A questoin about standards

#6

There is only one Decider.

Rick Davenport

>When selling your turnings, there is only one opinion that counts.

And that is the person willing to pay money for your work.

A hundred people may look at your favorite piece with total indifference.

Then someone walks up and it's love at first sight.

It's a wonderful feeling when someone connects with your work.

And it's seldom for the reason that you think.

Go for it.

I have no doubt that there is someone out there who will absolutely love your work.

R

Re: A questoin about standards

#7

Re: Is is a matter of individual taste

Steve in NC

>Troy

Last year I did my first show. It was a display in the gallery at my church with some items for sale. After I set up the display I realized that it needed a few more items so I added a couple of items that I had initially judged "not worthy". I received many compliments on the show but I was amazed at the amount of positive feedback I received over two Items that I was not even going to include at the start. Turns out these two items sold first and there were many requests to make additional similar items.

Who can say what is good enough. Maybe we are too hard on ourselves.

Steve

Re: A questoin about standards

#8

Good Chat room discussion?

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Troy this is a great discussion. I think it is something that many of us struggle with.

Jen

Re: A questoin about standards

#9

Re: A questoin about standards

Troy German

>Thanks for the encouragement everyone. I hope it doesn't sound as if I'm super hard on myself. I'm not. I just think it's a practical question that everyone will have different answers to, but some things might be generally agreed upon (e.g. a poor finish should be reworked, a foot that�s smaller than planned is OK, �etc.)

Thanks for the input,

Troy

Re: A questoin about standards

#10

Your market determines the standards

Jim Swank

>

Re: A questoin about standards

#11

Keith Tompkins

Re: A questoin about standards

keith tompkins

>Hi Troy, Interesting question, and one that I've run into many, many times. If you are a hobbyist, I think the answer is this....in examining your work, ask yourself this question honestly: "Is this the best I am capable of at this point in time?"

If there are noticeable flaws that could have been corrected with a bit more effort, for example torn grain or sanding marks, then only you can determine the answer.

Am I happy with my own work? Occasionally. Most of the time, be glad you're not me...I'm rough on myself. I strive for perfection, but will never reach it...it's the journey that makes it all worthwhile.

Re: A questoin about standards

#12

Re: A questoin about standards

Terence Rice

>Like most of the others who have replied I have never had a perfect piece. I do, however, try to make each as nearly perfect as I am able. I think that usually we are much harder on ourselves than anyone else is. Often that imperfection that glares out at you every time you look at the piece is completely imperceptable to anyone else.

I have a burn box that I throw my scraps in and occasionally I toss in a reject that is unsalvagable. Because I don't have a woodburner I give the wood to an elderly couple that live nearby.

The last time I took a boxful over she gave me four pieces that she had saved because she knew that I had thrown them out by accident. When I explained that they were unusable she told me they were beautiful and if I didn't want them she was going to put them on display in her house. Beauty is indeed in the eye of the beholder.

If your friend thinks your pieces are good enough for her shop by all means sell them and make no apologies. Just do as good a job as you can.

Re: A questoin about standards

#13

So did the Navajo with their rugs, I am told,

Don Henthorn

>but not by a Navajo.

Re: A questoin about standards

#14

Re: A questoin about standards

Sam Dean

>Standards are a very personal thing. Like most of the others have said, you are the only one that can choose what is good, and what is not. Your market will let you know if your thought process was right or not. Like most of us, I see imperfections in everything I do. However, my customers usually have a completely different view of what they percieve as an imperfection, and most will never be able to see what I think made the piece imperfect.

For me, I won't sell a bowl that is warped or has more than just the slightest crack (unless I wanted it to be that way), or has sanding scratches, tool marks, torn grain or just doesn't "look" right. Actually, whenever I make something, I usually let it set around for a month or so before I will sign it, just to make sure I think it is good enough to sell. Those are just some of my personal "standards", and they seem to work well for me. If I had to do this for a living, they probably would not.

Funny story about the elderly woman keeping the bowls: A few years ago, I was doing some house cleaning, and had accumulated about 50 or 60 bowls that I didn't like for all kinds of reasons. I looked at them like practice wood, and put them in a trash bag for the garbage man to pick up the next morning. Somehow my neighbor, who is my brother-in-law (but we won't go into that right now...), saw this bag full of bowls and decided he didn't want them to go to waste. Now it seems like everyone on my wife's side seems to have a few of my "junk" bowls on display, and I still cringe every time I see them. Now I burn everything I don't like....

Thanks,

Sam

Re: A questoin about standards

#15

Re: A questoin about standards

Troy German

>Thanks. There is some good info in here on a hard question to answer. I, too, am finding that setting a piece aside for a couple of weeks is an important part of the process. When I'm working a piece, I'm very intimate with its littlest flaws (By the way, in my opinion that's where most of the fun of craftmanship lies, learning the skills to work the wood in increasingly finer detail. I have a lot to learn, but it's fun.). Given a little time the small imperfections that occupied most of my time and therefore seem so glaring become small again.

Thanks again,

Troy

Re: A questoin about standards

#16

Re: A questoin about standards

Fly Capt

>Just thought my lesson learned from my apprentice days with a German Cabinetmaker. Some people believe there are levels of quality. But his thought that I have tried to live to are there is "Quality or there isn't". You know if its the best you could do, if not don't sell.

Best of luck