Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Giant English Elm Tree Question

Posts

Giant English Elm Tree Question

#1

Giant English Elm Tree Question

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Greetings all

A tree trimmer friend of mine just called to ask me a question which I am passing on to the group. He has been asked to bid on the removal of a very large English elm tree. His size comment was that he would need a 6' bar on his saw to get through the bottom of the stump. Apparently this tree is on some sort of register and dates back to the War Between the States. He called to ask me if there was some way to research the tree for economic viability. He does not want to just cut this thing up and heat the house with it. He would much rather see the wood go to some good use, preferably lumber, although I suspect there will be turning blanks aplenty for those who desire them.

If anyone here has any ideas on how to research this thing, I would be interested to hear them.

Thanks.

Bill

Re: Giant English Elm Tree Question

#2

Re: Sounds like it might have ......

Jamie Donaldson

>...a collection of musket balls and other chronologically arranged projectiles embedded.

Re: Giant English Elm Tree Question

#3

Re: Giant English Elm Tree Question *LINK*

Thad in middle GA

>I'd post it on WoodWeb's Sawing & Drying forum. Ask Gene Wengert.

~ Thad


WoodWeb's sawing & drying forum

Re: Giant English Elm Tree Question

#4

Re: Sounds like it might have ......

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Once the tree is cut down, most likely the presence of old iron will present itself as a dark spot. Of course all that tells is that it is in there and approx. how far from the center of the tree. The same is true of a metal detector. I once had someone bring a huge very old walnut to saw into boards. My blades discovered many hand cut nails before the job was finished

I have always been intrigued with the fund raising possibilities of historic wood. If there is a club or organization which might be interested in a fund raiser a deal might be worked out between the agency, woodworkers and the cutter.

I would possibly be interested in buying a piece or two if the price is not too high. Historic documentation could come with the wood. The turner or flat woodworker could pass the documentation along with the finished piece.

Re: Giant English Elm Tree Question

#5

Re: Sounds like it might have ......

Ron in Drums PA

>Or even cement!!

Re: Giant English Elm Tree Question

#6

Re: Giant English Elm Tree Question

MIke from St. Clair Shores

>Bill,

If I am understanding you correctly, I think what you are looking for could be found by starting at the Registers office for the county or town it is located in. Then by finding out who owned the property, the Mormons have some very detailed family ancestry infomation. I don't know if this is what you were looking for, but locating the families can often bring out some very detailed historical details.

IMO,

Mike

Re: Giant English Elm Tree Question

#7

Brad Vietje

Related Question

Brad Vietje

>Bill,

Once the tree is researched, could part of this tree be used as a group project at the next 5 Barns Gathering ? If a big chunk of the log (up where its maybe 2'-3') is Anchorsealed, with a few sealed crotches thrown in, maybe a bandsaw mill could be brought in to cut it up, (or a trusty chainsaw or two) and turners from all over could collaborate on turned items to raise funds for a good cause ...? Just a passing idea...

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Giant English Elm Tree Question

#8

Re: Giant English Elm Tree Question *LINK*

Stokes

>If he lives near you, I would suggest that he call Sam Talarico. I have purchased some wood from him, and many of the pieces he saws and sells are from similar types of one off trees.

Stokes


Talarico Hardwoods

Re: Giant English Elm Tree Question

#9

Re: Giant English Elm Tree Question *LINK*

Bob Fawcett

>Does your area have a historical society or group of some kind? Does he know the early owner of the land? If it is on a Register of some kind start there.

The link is about an Oak in SC that is on land once belonging to one of my ancestors. This tree predates the US and so does may ancestor, Abraham Waight.


Angel Oak

Re: Giant English Elm Tree Question

#10

May be a "Witness Tree"?

Ron Bauman

>

Re: Giant English Elm Tree Question

#11

Re: Giant English Elm Tree Question

David Breth

>Mike -

I think you are on the right track here. A local library, historical society, town hall, should have some old maps of the area. Using these, it isn't too difficult to figure out on whose property it was at a particular point in time. Once the tree is down, and its' age assessed, location and chronology can be tied together. If there is a historical society in the area, they might be able to help tie interesting events to the tree or locale.

Might get some hints from nearby roads. If the tree is at the corner of "Smith's Battalion Surrendered Next To The Giant Elm Tree Road" and "That Big Elm, Right There Drive", then you're on to something!!!

David B.

Re: Giant English Elm Tree Question

#12

Re: Giant English Elm Tree Question

Glenn Hodges, Nashville, GA

>If you don't have any luck, I know a guy around here that can really shoot the bull, and if the price is right he will lay it on for your buddy.

Re: Giant English Elm Tree Question

#13

Re: Giant English Elm Tree Question

Barry Irby

>George Nakashima used to collect trees like this had have them sawn at the Martin Guitar works. (I think). Aren't they in Penn. somewhere? Aren't you and this log in the neighborhood? They could be right next door and you could just roll the log to them.

Re: Giant English Elm Tree Question

#14

Re: Giant English Elm Tree Question

Chuck Engstrom

>Hearne Hardwoods (I think; maybe it was Groff) has a huge bandsaw they brought up from the Philadelphia Naval Yard and restored to operation. Current generation of Nakamishi's were the first to use it for some huge item still in their inventory. Woodshop News did an article on it some months back.

Chuck Engstrom

Re: Giant English Elm Tree Question

#15

Re: Giant English Elm Tree Question

Terry Quiram, Roanoke Illinois

>Bill

Google "Champion Tree" for your state. If it is registered it would show up there.

Terry

Re: Giant English Elm Tree Question

#16

Re: Giant English Elm Tree Question

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Thanks for the responses everyone! I will be sure to pass them on to my tree trimmer friend, who of course, will remain anonymous.

Bill