We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
I also took some time today to rough out a really wet maple bowl. Right now I have little interest in DNA, or magic deterrgent potions and I want to know if I am going about drying it the right way...
I packed it in a large plastic ziploc back with the wet shavings and sealed it up. No air holes for it to breathe but I am thinking that I should have made some. I suppose moisture is going to have a tough time escaping but I thought I would hold off until I hear from you folks. I am quite prepared to let it sit for many months. Should I remove it from the bag and shavings and just let it sit on a shelf in a cool place? Other ideas/procedures? Again, I am going to hold off on the alcohol drying for now. No good reason but it is what I am going to do.
>Without air circulation you will likely grow mold or fungus, on the positive side it could generate spalting. You have several options, make a lot of hols in the bag, or open the bag every day to exchange the air, or use to a paper bag with the shavings. The paper bag inhibits the air circulation, but still allows the moisture to escape.
>The plastic is going to contain the moisture and result in a high humidity environment that will not let the piece dry but will promote mold. Put the bowl in a brown paper bag with or without shavings as you desire. They wet shavings do slow drying but are more likely to cause mold growth. I often put several bowls in the large double-layer brown bags they sell for garden waste.
You can also wrap the bowl in newspaper and when the paper is damp change the newspaper. You will be changing it every day to start.
Some people put them in cardboard boxes and just fold the flaps shut.
If I have some piece I really like and want to reduce the risk of cracking, I'll paint anchorseal on the end-grain part to slow the drying a bit more. This can be a big help on crack-prone wood like apple.
>shavings, get your self a nice thick brown paper bag, Colonel Sanders bags are great for this, (they do come with your Kentucky fried chicken) ;-))
If you have a basement, just place the closed bag with the bowl somewhere down on a low shelf, and go have look every couple of days for the next week or so, if there is anyplace that is starting to check put a little CA on it, that will give it some extra strength, and prevent the split from getting larger.
That's all you have to do, in a few weeks when the bowl has settled a bit and the wood is drier take it out of the bag and let it dry at the same spot, till dry.
>Leo, sometimes if I put CA in a crack in green wood, it turns white the whole depth of the crack and is impossible to to turn away. Any idea as to why this happens on some wet woods and not others? Is it a function of moisture or a function of how much air can get in the crack, or neither of the above?
>CA start curing real fast, with soft spongy wood, also with getting some on a cloth, and it maybe that fine wood dust does trigger that or the cellulose thats left as the wood decays, but No I'm not sure.
But the White, I don't recall getting that in such a manner, I have gotten it after applying accelerator, seems it start boiling and you get the white right down in there, one reason I seldom use the accelerator, it also makes the CA more brittle.
Putting it in a sealed plastic bag will buy you a few days to decide. There's no one correct procedure, but many ways to get to a finished bowl. Which course you select will (well, ought to) depend on your local climate. You can get rid of the shavings anytime -- they aren't all that helpful.
If you keep it in plastic, I'd recommend turning the bag inside-out every day. The inside will be wet, and inverting it will allow that moisture to evaporate. Next day, wet again. you can do this until it doesn't seem damp, then put it in a paper bag until it stops losing weight. Ziplock's don't invert very well, so I'd go to a plain plastic bag and a twist-tie. BTW: I have done this, but usually do not.
For fragile woods in dry climates, and a turner wanting the tried & true way, follow Ron's advice, and coat it w/Anchorseal. For really crack-prone woods and rare woods, I'd seal the whole shebang, inside and out. For plain woods, just the end grain areas.
What I actually do (in VT, where its dry and cold in winter, but very humid at other times:
1. Single Bowls: I put single bowls in a paper bag and pile them in a cool place -- in my case, the barn floor. When I trip over them, I move them and take a look. If they get moldy or start to look crappy, I wipe them off & get them a new bag, and place them on a higher shelf, away from the humidity of the floor.
2. Multiple Bowls: (more common) I toss them in a cardboard box, maybe 2-10/box depending on the size, and close the box up w/masking tape and stack it in a cool place. The cardboard is like a really thick paper bag, and works very well. Every month or so I look in there and move 'em about, then re-stack 'em. After 6-12 months I take them out and place them, upside down, on a shelf where they stare at me and remind me how much I like to rough turn, and how much I don't like sanding. Once they get too numerous to walk around anymore, I decide to finish turn a few, which reminds me how much I don't like sanding. So usually I get a fresh piece of green wood and rough out some more -- no sanding !
I rarely lose more than 1/2" or so near the pith (if I've gotten too close), and almost always have an air-dried piece I can finish turn later (if only I felt like sanding...)
>Thanks for the advice. I'll lose the plastic bag when I get into the shop tonight.
I've read that you should aim for wall thickness to be about 15% when roughing out bowls to be dried this way. Fair enough but does that apply to the bottom as well?
Thanks for putting up with my odd sense of humor...
Most people shoot for ~10%, but that depends on the wood species (some move more, like Apple or Beech, and for these I go more toward 15%). I've also made so many really thin bowls that I'm starting to prefer bowls with a little more mass.
Yes, the thickness should be pretty uniform for best results. BUT, as it turns out, (at least for a side-grain bowl with the top toward the pith and the foot toward the bark), the wood is least likely to crack on the long grain near the foot, and most likely nearest the pith, unless the foot is a massive tenon that holds too much moisture.
Having a tenon on there adds some extra mass, so you can make the bottom a little thinner than the walls, as long as there is still enough mass for good strength later, when the bowl will be warped and a lot harder (so don't make it TOO thin). You can also hollow the tennon just a little as you make it, and make shorter tenons.
I usually end up reverse turning the tennon away between centers when completing the bowl, leaving a small foot, if any, turned from the wood that was between the jaws whn gripped by the chuck. In other words, I don't make a massive tenon to grip, and don't recommend it. When it comes to drying the bowl, a massive foot is very likely to crack because it retains more moisture, and acts like an un-even wall thickness.
>Depending on the final wall thickness I would like to end up with, and depending also a little on the wood, like a lot of sapwood and little heartwood, but the thicker the wood is left the harder it is for the wood to move as it dries, so more stress and also more likely to split/sheck.
As for the thickness, as the bowls size gets smaller going down from the top to the foot, the amount of change also goes down, still 10% let's say, but 10% of the rim is more than 10% of the foot, for that reason, and to try to keep the drying time and the stress forces down, I will make my walls thinner as I go down to the foot, it's not necessary, but it helps IMO.
This is also the reason I like to use a recess rather than a spigot, as I have had failures with the thicker spigot.
>Anchorseal it. When I rough turn bowls I seal the entire rough turned bowl inside and out then set it aside on the floor of my shop under a table for at least six months. I also have to mention that I live in southeast Georgia and my shop is a metal building(insulated) but it still gets pretty hot during the summer. It almost acts like a kiln at times. Most bowls probably could be turned sooner than the six months but I want to make sure.
>Pulled it out of it's bag, and made 2 pic's from the side to show what the glued splits look like.
The Apple log showed the splits when I sawed the log, and I rough turned the bowl, then let the CA soak into the splits, the idea is to prevent the wood from splitting or opening any farther, then when dry I will decide how much if any has to be turned away, but some will be turned away when I do return the bowl, doing that now, would have me turn more away again, when returning. This has worked just fine for me, and I will continue so until I find a better way.
>Did you turn that 11" bowl by expanding the chuck jaws into the recess in the bottom? Than nearly never works for me. Almost 100% break the foot and fly away. Wonder what I am doing wrong?
All this is for those who want twice-turned, round bowls, and they're starting with chunks of wet (green) wood. If you want OVAL bowls, just make 'em the thickness you want, wet sand them, and dry them slowly (paper bags, etc...). You'll just need to lightly sand by hand to remove raised grain when they're oval.
For ROUND bowls made from green wood, you'll have to turn them twice. A general rule of thumb is to rough-turn bowls from green wood to a wall thickness roughly equal to 10% of the diameter of the bowl. This is to make sure you have enough wood left after drying to re-mount the bowl and make it round again, beacuse these rough-turned bowls will warp well out-of-round as they dry, getting "narrower", if you will, across side grain, and hardly shrinking at all across endgrain. How much depends on the wood, and how wet it is when you start. Not leaving quite enough wood when green will force you to either make much thinner walls than you want later (leads to many a failed beginner bowl), or accept a lumpy, oval bowl that isn't thick enough to turn round again.
Of course, if you want a thick & chunky bowl at the end of the process, you may want a little more mass to deal with, but you'll have to dry it slower and for a longer time. For thinner bowls, you can do with a little less thickness, which will dry sooner and be less likely to crack.
BTW: How balanced the bowl looks, and how symmetrically it warps (can make ALL the difference in being able to make it round later!) depends on how you balanced the figure, sapwood, and other features when rough-turning. Great looking bowls are not an accident !
We also need to keep in mind that some woods shrink MUCH more than others, so they need thicker walls when green to leave enough thickness that they can be made round later. A bowl with part heartwood and part sapwood is another situation that calls for a little thicker, as the sapwood will shrink more than heartwood. More stable woods, like Mesquite, Black Walnut, or Butternut can be left little thinner when rough-turned, in my experience.
There are no exact answers to all this -- trial and error in your location with your climate is in order, but these general rules of thumb can help. See "Turning Bowls With Richard Raffan", or "Turning Green Wood" (Michael O'Donnell) for all the gorey details...
>I read an excellent article about a year ago by John Whiteside, af the NH Guild of Woodworkers, about the Zen of woodworking. Boiling it all down, he suggested that we try to see the grace and beauty of every step in what we do, even cleaning the shop (or in my case, sanding), because each step is necessary to the successful completion or practice of something we love to do. If we conciously and intentionally find pleasure in each step, the entire process is enhanced.
I guess I'm still struggling with the sanding part... ;o)