Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Why Weyerhaeuser doesn't soak lumber in alcohol

Posts

Why Weyerhaeuser doesn't soak lumber in alcohol

#1

Why Weyerhaeuser doesn't soak lumber in alcohol

Russ Fairfield

>Someone related a comment the Weyerhaeuser Company doesn't soak lumber in alcohol and that rang a bell in my memory.

I was associated with a lumber drying research team at the Weyerhaeuser Research faciility in the mid-60's when it was still in Longview, WA. Being a bunch of research folks, we did everything possible to increase the drying rate and reduce the degrade (cracking, warping and over-dry) of the lumber in the process. Yes, it was even soaked it in surfactants (Liquid Detergent) and alcohol, along with many other things. We even tried freeze drying and drying with Microwaves.

All of these things appeared to work on individual pieces of wood, but our biggest problem was monitoring and measuring the process of drying the lumber in a big enough sample to remove the effects of the variability in wood. So we built a kiln with a capacity of about 2000 bf of dimension lumber per load. It was insulated and instrumented to measure and control humidity throughout the encosure and within the lumber load. Another instrumentation that had to be developed was a moisture meter probe that would measure the moisture inside of a piece of wood without having to penetrate the wood with pins. This instrumentation was developed, and placed at various places around and throughout the stack of lumber.

We made an amazing discovery. With all of this instrumentation and control, we were able to accomplish the same increase in drying rate and the same reduction in drying defects without soaking the wood in anything.

We then went on to full-sized lumber kilns and the results were essentially the same with the installation of new instrumentation and control.

And, that is why Weyerhaeuser doesn't soak the lumber in anything.

I will leave it to all of you to determine whether any of this can be related to drying a rough turned bowl and whether you think soaking them in either alcohol or dishwater is an improvement over carefully monitoring and controlling your air drying.

Re: Why Weyerhaeuser doesn't soak lumber in alcohol

#2

Re: Why Weyerhaeuser doesn't soak lumber in alcoho

Ron in Drums PA

>Good info Russ, I see the sense in drying the way you suggest.

I still have a few hundred board foot of furniture grade lumber, 80% is kiln dried. The other 20% is walnut, which in my opinion looks better when it is air dried.

If I had 2000 board feet of Instrument Grade Tiger Maple, you bet I would use a kiln in a heart beat, I would want as little degradation as possible.

I my small experience, a bowl takes on slightly different properties because of all the exposed end grain. Plus, when I am drying a bowl, I'm only drying 2-3 board foot at a time, not 2000 board feet.

Lets assume I just finish turning a nicely curled maple bowl.

If I was in a rush, and sometimes I am, I'd soak it in DNA because from my little experience, it seems to dry faster with little if any chance of cracking.

If I was not in a rush, and sometimes I'm not, I'd seal the endgrain with anchorsel and place it on a shelf. From my little experience it seems to dry well with little if any chance of cracking.

JMO

Re: Why Weyerhaeuser doesn't soak lumber in alcohol

#3

Bob Moffett

Re: Why Weyerhaeuser doesn't soak lumber in alcoho

Bob Moffett

>Ron,

When you seal the endgrain with Anchorsol and put on a shelf to dry, do you put it in a paper bag or do you just leave it out? How long do you let it sit before it is dry? Would other endgrain sealers probably yield the same result?

Re: Why Weyerhaeuser doesn't soak lumber in alcohol

#4

Re: Why Weyerhaeuser doesn't soak lumber in alcoho

Ron in Drums PA

>Bob, I just set it on the shelf without a bag. I also place it so the inside is face down.

As to the amount of time, however long it takes. Some wood dries in three months, others take a year. For the most part, when I pick a blank that was anchorsealed, I usually look for the oldest one I have on the shelf.

Something I learned from Bill Grumbine is to place the bowl next to your cheek, if it feels cold it's not dry enough.

Re: Why Weyerhaeuser doesn't soak lumber in alcohol

#5

Re: Why Weyerhaeuser doesn't soak lumber in alcoho

Barry Irby

>What we don't know is really stunning. Kiln drying has been about as much art as science. I have read studies done by NC State on drying wood. They developed remote reading scales suitable for use inside kilns. With those place at a few strategic locations they were able to computerize the process and improve the results. Oddly, somewhere in the process it occurred to them that the kilns were not well built and basically rusted and rotted themselves to pieces in a few years. They came up with suggestions for improving the kilns. They sold their ideas to industry who in many cases have jumped right on the instrumentation, but they have been reluctant to improve the kilns.

The wood drying industry and turners are confronted with many variables. A zillion species of wood. Even in industry, they take many kinds of Oak and sort it into Red and White. In most cases the loads in the kilns are sawed �tree run� and not sorted by flat sawn or quarter sawn. So industry is most interested in simplifying this and grouping wood into easily sorted and managed groups. A small percentage of loss is �the norm�. Turners tend to grieve over an individual loss.

We can find methods that work pretty well most of the time, such as waxing them, bagging them and letting them dry for months or a year or two. Its when we start pushing the envelop we get into trouble. We want to take some exotic wood we have almost no experience with and dry it perfectly, TODAY, preferably before lunch, so we can finish the bowl this afternoon.

None of us has the money, time, patience or what ever to do a truly controlled study like turning a thousand perfectly matched bowl blanks in a hundred difference species and in every size and shape conceivable and then dry them every way you can think of. (That�s a thousand each, not total.) And then do it again in each climate and for each set of shop conditions around the country, and lets not ignore our friends around the world.

It seems to me that a bowl blank drying system would want to keep the air around the bowl saturated evenly with moisture and somehow cause the bowl to dry uniformly. The bowl shape itself introduces a set of variables the lumber industry barely deals with. They fight the tendency of the lumber to dry quickly at the ends. ENDS represent a very small percentage of a stick of lumber. OTOH, Bowls might be thought of as being about half Ends.

Thanks Russ.

Re: Why Weyerhaeuser doesn't soak lumber in alcohol

#6

Keith Tompkins

Re: Why Weyerhaeuser doesn't soak lumber in alcoho

keith tompkins

>Russ, My methods and testing procedures are Neanderthal in comparison with yours, but were promising nevertheless until I totalled my dry-kiln. Let me explain: I would turn several rough bowls, bag 'em, then place them in the rear of my old Dodge Caravan. With the seats removed,I could load quite a few blanks. By lowering and raising the windows, I could regulate the drying rate. On hot, sunny days I would have to park in the shade, of course. I could tell when my blanks were done when my windows weren't all steamed up at the end of the day. Sadly, my portable kiln was demolished when I struck TWO deer with it. Total loss. My new vehicle is much too nice to convert into a portable kiln. (although I'm trying to be funny, I really did that. yes, it worked pretty well)

Re: Why Weyerhaeuser doesn't soak lumber in alcohol

#7

Re: Why Weyerhaeuser doesn't soak lumber in alcoho

Ron in Drums PA

>I hope you played some music on the stereo to keep the bowls happy while they where drying

Re: Why Weyerhaeuser doesn't soak lumber in alcohol

#8

Re: Why Weyerhaeuser doesn't soak lumber in alcoho

john lucas

>Bob I put my bowls on the floor for the first period which is usually somewhere around 2 or 3 weeks. I forget about them so I move them up when I remember. They sit on the shelf until I return them which is usually way longer than needed to dry. I go through rough out spells when I get the time and wood. That way when I do need a bowl I just go through the rough outs until something excites me.

If I want something that day I just turn it thin and go ahead and finish it.

I understand thoroughly the excitement of turning a new piece of wood and wanting to finish it as soon as possible. It's inherent in all of us, which is why all Alcohol, soap, boiling and microwave methods exist. There's nothing wrong with those methods if you choose to go that route. I simply don't want the mess although I do experiment a little and have use the microwave and will probably try the alcohol on some boxes.

Re: Why Weyerhaeuser doesn't soak lumber in alcohol

#9

You might be a redneck if???

john lucas

>You store your rough turn bowls in your van. Wow I could put 2 old refrigerators on the front porch and convert them to kiln's. Then I would look just like the neighbors and could submit it to Jeff Foxworthy for the redneck of the week photo.

Re: Why Weyerhaeuser doesn't soak lumber in alcohol

#10

It doesn't matter that Weyerhaeuser doesn't soak

Dinyar Chavda

>Russ:

You are suffering from a delusion, that I, unfortunately, share.

You believe that scientific research can overcome the power of anecdotal "evidence". You present the results of large-scale research, conducted by a company that has the profit-motive driving it to find a better way, and they concluded that there wasn't a faster way. Fred Holder has done the only other documented study that has been reported, where, also, he said that there was no reduction in drying time.

None of these can overcome the power of personal observation, despite all its inherent bias.

In my past life, I did a lot of quantitative research on consumer behavior. I would have doubled my income if I had a dollar for every argument I lost where the results of the quantitative study contradicted what my client had seen with his/her own eyes in a focus group!!! This, despite the fact that the first page of every focus group report says something to the effect that the information in the report is to be used for generating hypotheses only, and not for drawing conclusions.

You are fighting human nature, if you think that you can overcome personal observation with statistics and, heaven-forbid, scientific research.

Re: Why Weyerhaeuser doesn't soak lumber in alcohol

#11

99 percent of all statistics are made up :)

john lucas

>

Re: Why Weyerhaeuser doesn't soak lumber in alcohol

#12

Re: It doesn't matter that Weyerhaeuser doesn't so

MIke from St. Clair Shores

>Dinyar,

I actually love reading your responses. They are so focused and complete. But after I read one, being the smart alec that I am, I always want to kid around and send my favorite picture that tells it all.

Thanks for posting,

Be Safe and Keep Turning

Mike


img

Re: Why Weyerhaeuser doesn't soak lumber in alcohol

#13

Statistics Means Never Saying You Are ...

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ont.

>Certain...19 times out of 20...

:-)

take care,

Jim

Re: Why Weyerhaeuser doesn't soak lumber in alcohol

#14

On the other hand Russ, I do admire your knowledge

Don Henthorn

>and creativity in the woodworking field, but when it comes to research there are many people and universities who do research that don't know the first thing about research design and administration. Much of the research done today is not valid because although the researchers may be experts in their field, their research design is so faulty that its results are not valid. I have met few people today who have ever taken Methods of Reearch 101, let alone any advanced courses in proper research methods. To accept the results of Weyerhaeuser's study as authentic I would have to see the research design, see which variables they included and which ones they forgot. Just because a company is big and interested in profits doesn't mean they can do valid research. I'll still go by the method which is supported at least partly by good theory and I know that alcohol does evaporate faster than water. Just my humble experience. YMMN.

Re: Why Weyerhaeuser doesn't soak lumber in alcohol

#15

Re: On the other hand Russ, I do admire your knowl

Dinyar Chavda

>Don:

Russ says that he was "associated with a lumber drying research team at the Weyerhaeuser Research faciility". Based on my experiences working with R&D departments in other Fortune 500 companies, there were probably more than a couple of statisticians and experts in research design tucked away on that team. I would think that they had taken Research 101, as well as courses in proper research method.

The other team-members, being experts in their field of wood and drying. would have made sure that they took into account relevant variables and good theory (including the fact that alcohol evaporates faster than water....although I'm not sure I understand how that gets the water out of wood faster). Also, if they initially forgot to take into account some variables, given the large samples that Russ implies in his description, they could easily have gone back and done covariate analysis of the data, to see if these variables had any effect.

Mike from the Shores, you may want to start working on another batch of pancakes for that cute bunny! :-)

Re: Why Weyerhaeuser doesn't soak lumber in alcohol

#16

Re: Why Weyerhaeuser doesn't soak lumber in alcoho

Jim King

>Russ: With the base of experience you have what is your opinion of why boiled rough turned bowl blanks dry faster than non boiled with less degrade ? Would it be a similar reaction to heating and steaming the wood in a standard kiln ?

Boiling has been a savior for me but I dont technically know why.

Re: Why Weyerhaeuser doesn't soak lumber in alcohol

#17

Re: Why Weyerhaeuser doesn't soak lumber in alcoho

Russ Fairfield

>Boiling is an efficient way to get a piece of wood hot without drying it on the surface. It gets the wood hot enough to soften the lignin and allows internal stresses to relax. For that reason it is better to use a pressure cooker pot than atmospheric boiling because the pressure pot raises the boiling temperature to about 235F. Relieving the internal stresses prevents cracking.

I have never found that boiled wood dried any faster than any other wood. There may be some initial movement of free water when the wood is air cooled because hot water evaporates faster form the surface moves more freely through the wood than cold water. Once the wood has cooled to room temperature, there is no longer any driving force to make the moisture move through the wood any faster than unboiled wood.

Some folks have claimed that the boiling ruptures the cellular structure of the wood, and that allows the wood to dry faster. I have never found that to be true. The temperatures aren't high enough to flash any internal water into steam.

The microwave oven can be used to accomplish the same heating. In that case there can be sufficient heat generated to create flash steam and rupture the internal wood structure. It is also possible to dry the wood and ignite it.

An advantage of heating the wood is that a warped piece can be moved back to round and clamped, and them allowed to cool, and there is a reasonable chance that it will stay there.

Re: Why Weyerhaeuser doesn't soak lumber in alcohol

#18

Won't argue about it, Dinyar,

Don Henthorn

>but your arguments don't convince me that I am wrong. However as for the alcohol drying question, it is my understanding that alcohol is miscible in water and when the wood has been immersed in alcohol the water in the wood mixes with and is partially displaced by the alcohol and thus the wood drys faster. Perhaps that is wrong. All I know is that I can soak a rough turned bowl in alcohol, let it dry for a couple of weeks and then turn the bowl and it will be dry. If I bag it or cover it with wax I will have to wait six months or a year. Annecdotal? You bet, but the difference is real in my shop. Maybe not in others.

Re: Why Weyerhaeuser doesn't soak lumber in alcohol

#19

Re: Why Weyerhaeuser doesn't soak lumber in alcoho

Jim King

>Russ: Thankyou for the explanation..