Re: Chucks: Vicmarc VM100 vs. Oneway Talon vs. Nov
Donna Banfield
>I'm going to stick my neck out on this one, because I know there are many who disagree, but I vote for the Vicmarc chucks.
Here's why: All Oneway chucks are great; but it doesn't take much opening of the jaws for the SLIDES to come away from the body of the chuck. By that I mean, measure the size of the tenon that you make for the jaws when they are almost closed. Then start cranking the jaws open; it's not many cranks before the slides on the chuck to protrude away from the body. If you've ever wrapped a knuckle on a protruding slide, you'll know what I'm talking about when I tell you it REALLY hurts!
Don't get me wrong, I love Oneway, and own many of their products, I just am not a fan of their chucks. I have three Vicmarc's and a number of the jaws that go with them. If you pay attention to the tenon that you make, and be sure that you get solid contact on the sides and the flat portion of the bowl, i.e., the top part of the jaws, you will lose very few blanks. The serrated jaws tend to crush the wood fibers. This is important to me when I am doing a second/final turning of the dry blank. Depending on the wood, I may need to make that foot much smaller than I wanted to turn away the crushed/bruised wood fibers.
I have only one complaint about Vicmarc chucks, and that is no set screw to secure the chuck on the spindle. If you turn outboard, or try to slow a very large blank down quickly, the weight will spin the chuck off the spindle. Granted, this only happened once, and I learned my lesson, but it would be nice if Vicmarc addressed that issue.
Just my opinion, for what it's worth.