Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Chucks: Vicmarc VM100 vs. Oneway Talon vs. Nova G3

Posts

Chucks: Vicmarc VM100 vs. Oneway Talon vs. Nova G3

#1

Chucks: Vicmarc VM100 vs. Oneway Talon vs. Nova G3

wilbur

>I'm looking to get a chuck for an old Walker Turner lathe that I have been fixing up. This will be the first chuck I'll buy. I'm looking to do primarily bowl turning.

The reason I'm interested in these chucks in particular is that my lathe has a 12" swing, and from what I've read I won't need something the size of a Oneway Stronghold. I am leaning toward the Oneway, but only for the reason that neither Vicmarc or Nova seem to make an insert that is 1 x 12" LH, which would fit the outboard side of my lathe, whereas Oneway could at least custom make one for me, allowing me to use this chuck on the outboard side.

Any thoughts?

Re: Chucks: Vicmarc VM100 vs. Oneway Talon vs. Nova G3

#2

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Chucks: Vicmarc VM100 vs. Oneway Talon vs. Nov *LINK*

Leo Van Der Loo

>Hi Wilbur, all three are good chucks, the real difference is the jaw shape, and only the Oneway has the patented jaws that will hold better on a greater size variety, the also have all the other jaw shapes if you want to use those for some reason, I have both the Stronghold and a couple of Talon chucks, non better IMO, they'll last a life time and service is top notch if ever required.

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo


http://homepage.mac.com/l.vanderloo/PhotoAlbum26.html

Re: Chucks: Vicmarc VM100 vs. Oneway Talon vs. Nova G3

#3

Brad Vietje

Re: Chucks: Vicmarc VM100 vs. Oneway Talon vs. Nov

Brad Vietje

>Hey Wilbur,

All are great chucks, and I'll bet all would custom-size an insert if that's needed. The Talon is a very versatile chuck you can use for a lifetime.

Each platform has a wide variety of jaw shapes and sizes. As Leo states, Oneway profile jaws are excellent at gripping a wide variety of stock, and thus more forgiving when it comes to shaping a tenon to fit. However, jaws with teeth are a real PITA to re-align later if you want to take work off the lathe and re-mount later. Dovetail, or smooth jaws work better for that in my experience. The Oneway lineup won't allow you to use those jaws if you get a second chuck of a different size -- say the Stronghold, which has its own jaw sets. Of the chucks mentioned, I believe the Talon also has the greatest jaw travel, meaning you could grip a wider variety of sizes.

Which exact chuck and jaw style you will come to prefer in 5 years will be determined by just what kind of turning you do. Some people really love their Axminster with the O'Donnell jaws, and others love the Supernova-2 with their spigot jaws. You will only know that from experience.

For all-round basic bowl explorations, I suppose I'd get the Talon with their #2 jaws and a set of #2 smooth jaws, too: best of both worlds.

Have fun, and safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Chucks: Vicmarc VM100 vs. Oneway Talon vs. Nova G3

#4

Oneway Talon+

Rick Allen

>You should likely get a spindle adapter for that 1x12 LH side of the spindle so that it matches the inboard side of the lathe. Doing that will eliminate a lot of grief down the road.

While that change of thread will open up all the chucks and faceplates... for use on the outboard side the Oneway has an advantage. The Oneway chucks have two set screws on the chuck spindle adapter which let you lock the chuck to the spindle. Use of these set screws will prevent the chuck from spontaneous dismounting, a very exciting woodturning event.

Good Luck

Re: Chucks: Vicmarc VM100 vs. Oneway Talon vs. Nova G3

#5

Chucks: Vicmarc VM100

Ed Moore

>I have two Talons and a Vicmarc 100. And whenever possible I use the Vicmarc. I like the dovetail jaws, the shark jaws, and the long-nose jaws. I make ornament icicles from 1" red oak dowels and find the Vicmarc with the longnose jaws to be solid and accurate.

When I got a Robust lathe I got the large Vicmarc chuck. Actually, I got two since a friend was downsizing and sold off his Powermatic and accessories.

The Talon is not a bad chuck, I just think that the Vicmarc is slightly more accurate. And having the key be a hex shape is MUCH better than the serrated gear of the Talon.

JMHO,

Ed

Re: Chucks: Vicmarc VM100 vs. Oneway Talon vs. Nova G3

#6

Re: Oneway Talon+

wilbur

>I thought the reason that the outboard side had LH threads was to prevent spontaneous dismounting of whatever you had mounted on that side of the lathe. I could easily be mistaken.

Re: Chucks: Vicmarc VM100 vs. Oneway Talon vs. Nova G3

#7

Re: Chucks: Vicmarc VM100 vs. Oneway Talon vs. Nov

Peter Teubel

>The Oneway inserts are LH/RH, so they could be used either outboard or inboard without changing adapters (assuming your inboard thread is the same).

Re: Chucks: Vicmarc VM100 vs. Oneway Talon vs. Nova G3

#8

Re: Oneway Talon+

Rick Allen

>You are correct that LH threads on the outboard side tend to prevent "spontaneous dismount".

But the down side of the LH thread is finding attachments for it. The cost of custom inserts for chucks and faceplates become an issue. Back in the day when that lathe was new the number of attachments a woodturner would have for mounting on a lathe headstock spindle consisted of one or two faceplates. Instead of one or two faceplates we now add chucks to the list. So the ability to use the same chuck or faceplate on both sides of the headstock becomes an economy issue as well as eliminating duplicates.

Oneway recommends that their chuck spindle adaptors be swapped out sparingly.

The old Delta lathes has LH threads on the outboard side. The made a faceplate which had both LH and RH threads so you could use the same faceplate on either side of the headstock.

Re: Chucks: Vicmarc VM100 vs. Oneway Talon vs. Nova G3

#9

Re: Chucks: Vicmarc VM100 vs. Oneway Talon vs. Nov

Bob Fawcett

>I just looked at the inserts in my 2 oneway chucks. Both of mine are RH only (1 1/4 x 8 for PM). You may need to specify if you want inserts that are RH/LH. I bet the inserts in Oneway's thread size are RH/LH by default, since most if not all of their lathes allow outboard turning on a LH thread spindle.

Re: Chucks: Vicmarc VM100 vs. Oneway Talon vs. Nova G3

#10

Re: Chucks: Vicmarc VM100 vs. Oneway Talon vs. Nov

Peter Teubel

>Sorry, let me clarify that. The most popular inserts are available in LH/RH. Oneway will make one in any configuration, provided its mechanically possible.

BTW, the outboard threads of Oneway lathes are RH (at least since I got mine 2 years ago).

Re: Chucks: Vicmarc VM100 vs. Oneway Talon vs. Nova G3

#11

Re: Chucks: Vicmarc VM100

john lucas

>I love my Vicmarc. The long jaws for small work are exceptional holding anything from 1/4" up to about 1 1/4 or maybe larger. They have a huge number of jaws available, more than are imported. You can get the other sizes from them directly.

The main reason I bought the Vicmarc is the allen wrench. I find this very secure and quick to engage. You never have a problem with brocken teeth on the drive wrench which I've seen on other brands. If you lose it you can just use a standard allen wrench until you get another. I needed a long wrench for my cole jaws so I just took an old allen and cut and welded it to a shaft to make a new one. You couldn't do that with the keyed wrenches.

the only downside I've found is changing the inserts. Sometimes it can be difficult to remove the old one. I have to change inserts for demos fairly often and then can be a a challenge sometimes.

Re: Chucks: Vicmarc VM100 vs. Oneway Talon vs. Nova G3

#12

Re: Chucks: Vicmarc VM100 vs. Oneway Talon vs. Nov

Bill Neddow

>The Oneway has a far better grip on the spigot than any other brand because of the shape of the jaws. We have Nova chucks at the club, and they (like the Vicmarc) do not have this patented feature. I have seen too many blocks of wood come off the non-Oneway chucks. I like the serrated jaws. They make sure the wood stays on the lathe. I do not take the chunk of wood out of the chuck and then try to realign it, so realigning the bowl is not an issue with me. It is just the way i work. Also, if anyone has broken a gear on the back of one of the chucks, they have been tightening it with a sledge hammer. I do not like the Allen keys because they fall out too easily and get lost in the shavings. So you see, every turner has a different perspective. One thing is key, though. Make sure all your chucks tighten the same direction (the Nova tightens backwards to the Oneway.) This can lead to some very interesting flight training. That may not seem important now, but eventually you will probably buy a second chuck.

Re: Chucks: Vicmarc VM100 vs. Oneway Talon vs. Nova G3

#13

Talon & Stronghold

MIke from St. Clair Shores

>Heh Leo,

I see that you own some oneway chucks. i also have 3 of them.

I was mentoring a guy just yesterday, and he brought a new talon to my shop. He knew I had a talon so he didn't bring the Tightening tool, thought we would just use mine. When we went to do it, it didn't fit. So I tried the stronghold one and it did. I wish they did that a long time ago because I'm always grabbing the wrong one. Did you know that they make the tightening/loosening tool the same size for both chucks? Also referred to as the chuck key.

Mike

Re: Chucks: Vicmarc VM100 vs. Oneway Talon vs. Nova G3

#14

Re: Oneway Talon+

Ed in Leaside (Toronto, Ontario)

>My Oneway Basic chuck, which I use mostly on a 12" swing lathe, came with a 1-8 insert threaded LH & RH for both inboard & outboard use. I don't know if the 1.25-8 insert I have for this chuck is threaded for both. I'd have to look and it's in the shop.

My Oneway Stronghold chuck, which I use only on the 16" swing lathe, came with a 1.25-8 insert threaded LH & RH for both inboard & outboard use.

I'm sure that Oneway could supply a Talon insert threaded 1-12 LH & RH. Some care is required when mounting chucks with crossthreaded inserts. ;)

Re: Chucks: Vicmarc VM100 vs. Oneway Talon vs. Nova G3

#15

Keith Tompkins

Re: Chucks: Vicmarc VM100 vs. Oneway Talon vs. Nov

keith tompkins

>HI Peter, my 1 1/8" oneway adapter is both L and R as well.

Re: Chucks: Vicmarc VM100 vs. Oneway Talon vs. Nova G3

#16

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Talon & Stronghold

Jesper, Denmark

>Dont't feel too bad. I have two "identical" Strongholds. Bought about a year apart. They use two different keys.

Ut was supposed to be an improvement, but it is impossible to see which is which, so in use a pain.....

Re: Chucks: Vicmarc VM100 vs. Oneway Talon vs. Nova G3

#17

Re: Oneway Talon+

wilbur

>I contacted Oneway about the possibility of making a 1" x 12TPI RH/LH insert. They said they could do it.

Then I sent an email to the Vicmarc people with the same question. And then I realized it's the middle of the night over in Australia.

Re: Chucks: Vicmarc VM100 vs. Oneway Talon vs. Nova G3

#18

Leo Van Der Loo

The Oneway chuck key is 8" long, not a small

Leo Van Der Loo

>allen key you can easily loose in the shavings, the gears that are on the Oneway chuck are also in the chucks that get alan key tightened, only they stay in the chuck and crud can get inside and get trapped in there, then there was a problem with the Nova Chuck key if I recall that right, they used a separate cast light metal gear part on the chuck key for a while and some broke, the Oneway chuck key is precision machined out of a high quality steel, and hardened, I'm sure if you broke one, Oneway would replace that right away, no questions asked, and you also do not have to weld an extension on your chuck key as the key is made to be used also with even the mega jumbo cole jaws.

The chuck and all its parts and accessories are made with the customary Oneway well thought out and high quality, that is just the way they do things, and if things do go wrong they will stand behind their products, and make things right, been shown time and again. Off of my soap box, and I'm sorry to report I'm not getting any rewards for this ;-)).

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Chucks: Vicmarc VM100 vs. Oneway Talon vs. Nova G3

#19

Re: Chucks: Vicmarc VM100 vs. Oneway Talon vs. Nov

Brodie Brickey

>If you are able to outboard turn and will do so over 16", go with the Oneway Stronghold. It will give you the largest range of options from small to large turning. The Vicmarc and all the Oneways are quality products.

I think that if you turn a lot of green wood, Oneway's serrated jaws are better than a dovetail jaw for holding wet wood. If you turn a lot of boxes and the occaisonal larger turning but its segmented or from dry stock, the smooth dovetail jaws will serve you better. That being said, Oneway has both types. I'm sure Vicmarc does also, but I haven't used their chucks.

Regards,

Brodie

Re: Chucks: Vicmarc VM100 vs. Oneway Talon vs. Nova G3

#20

Re: Talon & Stronghold

Rick Allen

>One Stronghold uses and 11 spline key and the other uses a 12 spline key. You can purchase a new gear for the old chuck so that both Strongholds use the same key. You can not purchase a key which will work on the older chuck.

I wrote to Kevin, of Oneway, about the Talon using the same key as the Stronghold.

Kevin wrote:

"No, this is not true. If it does work it shouldn't the key will wear excessively, won't run very smooth and the teeth might break."

Re: Chucks: Vicmarc VM100 vs. Oneway Talon vs. Nova G3

#21

Re: Chucks: Vicmarc VM100 vs. Oneway Talon vs. Nov

Donna Banfield

>I'm going to stick my neck out on this one, because I know there are many who disagree, but I vote for the Vicmarc chucks.

Here's why: All Oneway chucks are great; but it doesn't take much opening of the jaws for the SLIDES to come away from the body of the chuck. By that I mean, measure the size of the tenon that you make for the jaws when they are almost closed. Then start cranking the jaws open; it's not many cranks before the slides on the chuck to protrude away from the body. If you've ever wrapped a knuckle on a protruding slide, you'll know what I'm talking about when I tell you it REALLY hurts!

Don't get me wrong, I love Oneway, and own many of their products, I just am not a fan of their chucks. I have three Vicmarc's and a number of the jaws that go with them. If you pay attention to the tenon that you make, and be sure that you get solid contact on the sides and the flat portion of the bowl, i.e., the top part of the jaws, you will lose very few blanks. The serrated jaws tend to crush the wood fibers. This is important to me when I am doing a second/final turning of the dry blank. Depending on the wood, I may need to make that foot much smaller than I wanted to turn away the crushed/bruised wood fibers.

I have only one complaint about Vicmarc chucks, and that is no set screw to secure the chuck on the spindle. If you turn outboard, or try to slow a very large blank down quickly, the weight will spin the chuck off the spindle. Granted, this only happened once, and I learned my lesson, but it would be nice if Vicmarc addressed that issue.

Just my opinion, for what it's worth.

Re: Chucks: Vicmarc VM100 vs. Oneway Talon vs. Nova G3

#22

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Chucks: Vicmarc VM100 vs. Oneway Talon vs. Nov *LINK*

Leo Van Der Loo

>Hi Donna

Donna, Oneway chucks have two grooves in the face of the chuck body, if you instal the jaw with the safety pin in the short groove, the jaws will not go beyond the chucks surface, but most turners do like the extra jaw movement and install that jaw in the longer groove, your choice.

Also Oneway does have smooth dovetail jaws for those that like to use them, but the serrated jaws do hold much better, especially in green or soft wood, and the wood crushing is greatly exaggerated, I have made a photo album, where I turn a 24" bowl from a green blank, that is quite unbalanced, and with no tailstock support, to show that the chuck does not crush all this wood, as is claimed by some, I made sure to make a close-up picture of the bowl after the outside is rough turned, so if you want to see for yourself, have a look for yourself, thank you.

One added thought, a tenon could be turned away, I never leave a tenon sticking out of my turnings, but that's your choice also of course.

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo


http://homepage.mac.com/l.vanderloo/PhotoAlbum26.html

Re: Chucks: Vicmarc VM100 vs. Oneway Talon vs. Nova G3

#23

Re: Chucks: Vicmarc VM100 vs. Oneway Talon vs. Nov

Fog Tanner

>Donna, I have two Vicmarc chucks and two Oneway Strongholds. I don't have a problem with the Vic's wanting to unscrew, I have a Vicmarc lathe and that groove on the adapter is for the retaining ring. There is a corresponding grove on the spindle and the retaining ring locks them together. But, I have not needed it yet.

I bought the Stronghold because I was told it was the best, along with most of the jaws. Then bought a second one so I didn't have to change jaws all the time. One day when making a box and using the backhollowing technique of Raffan's, I pulled the blank from those serated jaws. It hit the wall, bounced off and then nailed my wrist. Pretty much ended the day. The next day, I went out and bout the doevatil jaws and have not had the problem since. Shortly after that I bought a Vic 5 1/2" for my primary chuck. This was not the fist time that had happened (first for the wrist), so now the serated jaws stay in a box. For real serated jaws I bought the Shark jaws to go with it, for boxes. I use the doevtail jaws for bowls. I liked the Vic enough to but a second one, the VM90, and would buy another when the "need" (i.e. extra cash) arises.

Re: Chucks: Vicmarc VM100 vs. Oneway Talon vs. Nova G3

#24

Both Vicmarc and Oneway have custom inserts

wilbur

>I got word that Vicmarc can also supply a custom made insert. It would cost me $39 total.

Oneway's custom insert would be $42 total.

Thanks for all the input!