Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Respirator questions

Posts

Re: Respirator questions

#26

Size

Jack Savona

>Ken, mine is a medium. I assumed that since I never get a swelled head over any of my turnings, I didn't need the large. :-)

Seriously, I would suggest calling 3M or North and finding out their sizing criteria. Then look at faces in a crowd to see where your face fits. As odd as that sounds, that's basically what I did. I saw people with smaller faces and people with larger faces. So I guessed in between.

If you do go with 3M, I suggest spending a few bucks more for the 7500 series. The softer nosepiece allows you to wear it for a long time without discomfort.

Re: Respirator questions

#27

Re: Respirator questions *LINK*

Chuck Engstrom

>Here's a link to an AOSafety item on sale for $9.20 at Lab Safety & Supply. Filters sold seperately. Interesting quick-release design to leave it hanging around your neck.

I've been using one of their 11291 half-masks for about six years and find it more comfortable than others I have used, full range of filters available. I wear a large size, I'm 5'11 180#.

Best to all--

Chuck Engstrom


http://www.labsafety.com/store/item/133264M/

Re: Respirator questions

#28

Re: Respirator questions

Brian McInturff in SC

>Hate to bust everyones bubble but none of those mask will actually "protect" you. Half face respirators have been proven not to maintain a seal. And if you have a beard, you may think you have a seal but it's virtually impossible to get a seal over a beard. Seems you guys are looking for the cheapest way to get protection. Protection isn't cheap. As for a company that sells an item that doesn't meet OSHA or NIOSH standards, they still have no liability issues. Check the regs to see what "you" must do to meet those standards. Now if you just want something to block out the bulk of the larger microns then just tie a handkerchief around your nose and mouth, you'll get about the same protection. Hope I don't sound too harsh as I know this arguement has gone on for years but unless you are fit tested and trained in the proper use, care, and operation of a respirator you are really wasting your time and money. I could go on and on about the hazards but won't. Please, be careful, and don't let the dollar determine your level of protection. Brian

Re: Respirator questions

#29

Re: Respirator questions

Allen Neighbors

>I agree with you about the beard and seal, except: You can, only one way that I know of, get a seal with a beard. I am a firefighter, and when I was a paid man, our department had enough face masks to go around, and we all had our own. I used to keep a tube of vaseline to smear on my beard before donning the Scott air pack. I sealed every time. Then had a heck of a cleanup problem after we got through.

That said, I'll add this: It would be a truly messy situation around sawdust... it was around ashes and smoke, too. :o)

But, anything you can wear, is better than going without. Even a flattened beard will stop some particles. If you close the intake openings and inhale, you will know if you have a seal. If you can inhale, you don't have a seal. If you can't inhale, you do. :o)

Re: Respirator questions

#30

Re: Respirator questions

Bruce Wiseman

>Well I know that the stats are higher for nasal cancer and other upper resp. problems in woodworkers, more so than lung problems. But I wonder if your "test" is logical. The stuff you can blow back into a tissue is already been filtered by your nose. (that's why its there) I think the stuff that is getting down to your lungs will not come out when you blow your nose. You may be getting half the problem with the nasal stuff but who knows about the rest. I asked the Dust-b-gone lady for filtering stats and all she said is that it wasn't rated.

Re: Respirator questions

#31

Re: Respirator questions

Brian McInturff in SC

>Allen,

The way most fit test are performed it would work with vaseline. But under normal use with all the movements and with sweat then the seal won't hold. That's one reason the Military doesn't allow hair growth for men in the Chemical field. I use to train a lot of guys and could always tell who would fail the fit test. Even in the private sector I've done a lot of fit testing with all kinds of PPE and only the PAPR's and of course an Airpack will allow a seal, and that's because of the positive pressure created. I agree also that some protection is better than none. You are one of the lucky ones who know some of the pitfalls of respirators and what to expect from them. A lot of people think putting on a respirator and they are automatically protected. Then there is the issue of the fatique factor the respirator puts on the lungs and the entire respiratory system, that's why you have to pass a spirometer test to wear a respirator(by OSHA standards). I just want people to know a respirator isn't just another tool that you pick up and use.

Brian

Re: Respirator questions

#32

Re: Respirator questions

James Duxbury

>I am the inventor of the Resp-O-Rator and would be glad to answer questions on it.

Saliva problems happen when you wear it wrong or hold your teeth apart. You can not completly swallow or control saliva with your mouth open. The small mouthpiece flange has to be held between the lips, in front of your teeth. This allows your mouth to close---all the way and saliva problem is gone. Some dry mouth is noticed but you just drop the mouthpiece out of your mouth, it hangs around your neck and take a drink.

I have two U.S. Patents on this and a third one pending. All scuba type mouthpieces drip salive you just do not notice it much when swimming in the ocean. www.duxterity.com

Read what manufacturers actually say about the filters. You have to know the efficiency and micron size. Fine dust filter, final filter sound good but??? HEPA is a minimum efficiency of 99.97% at 0.3 microns. They don't get any better.

I made the Resp-O-Rator for myself. HEPA Filters, No Straps, No Batteries, 7 Ounces, Nothing Hot On Your Face, Opens so that you can put it on easily. It looks different because it is.

Last---You even see this on TV. They put the respirator on, turn the sander on, make a cloud of dust and lots of noise, then turn off the sander and take the respirator off. This in many cases is at the highest consentration of dust. Keep the respirator on until the dust is cleared or you get out of the area.

Hope this helps.

Re: Respirator questions

#33

Re: Respirator questions

James Duxbury

>One more thing. I do not have a beard but the Resp-O-Rator with the mouthpiece seal, works very well for those with facial hair. It's also totally compatable with ear muffs & ear plugs, full face shields, and many welding helmets.

Re: Respirator questions

#34

Re: Respirator questions

Allen Neighbors

>Thanks for posting this. That's an interesting piece of safety equipment.

Re: Respirator questions

#35

Re: Respirator questions *LINK*

John Uteck

>...and the spirometer test is sooooooo much fun. I do these annually, as well as the quantitative fit tests for work.

For those interested, take a look at the OSHA link below for methods to check the seals on your respirators. If you're interested in more light reading, on that same page, enter 1910.134 in the search bar for the full Respiratory Protection Standard.


OSHA User Seal Check Procedures

Re: Respirator questions

#36

Re: Respirator questions

Brian McInturff in SC

>John,

Just had my annual with the Pulmonary Functions test. Seems the nurse was new. She forgot to tell me to stop, I dropped the holder you blow into, and about passed out. Good thing is I blew 98% and obviously only had to blow the one time. Glad we only have to do it once a year. Curious, who do you work for? Only a couple professions have to do this with the Quantitative test. Brian

Re: Respirator questions

#37

Re: Respirator questions

John Uteck

>Brian -- I work for an environmental consulting firm --- Conestoga-Rovers & Associates (CRA).

Re: Respirator questions

#38

Re: Respirator questions

Brian McInturff in SC

>John,

I figured it was an Environmental firm. I work for SHAW E&I formally IT Corp, OHM, Stone & Webster and several other firms. Brian

Re: Respirator questions

#39

Re: I understand, Brian. Thanks :o)

Allen Neighbors

>