Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

Posts

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

#51

Steven Antonucci

I think Russ said it best

Steve Antonucci

>If I was to receive a name I knew from the forum, I'd be more inclined to send them better item than an unknown person. That being said, it won't leave my shop without being my best work- no matter who it's going to!

Part of any "social website" is that leap of faith we all have to take that the nature of man is generally good. From time to time, someone will eventually screw you, but I don't believe that most of the WoodCentral folks have that in their DNA.

Steve

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

#52

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

Bill Noce

>From the keyboard of a lurker...it sounds like we need to list what we have accomplished to be in the turning exchange....I have been turning since 1995, have taken classes from several professional turners and the peolpe who buy my turnings at the shows that I do have no problem with them and they don't know me from Adam. I just don't post anything because I just enjoy reading all the nice things and interesting topics that are talked about on WC isn't that what this group is all about.....those that talk and those that listen....thats all I have to say.....

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

#53

I Second That!!

Jorge Castaneda

>Doug,

You said " Maybe two rules, (1) they posted before (2) they use their real name"

You beat me to it, that is exactly what I was to say, It bothers me to no end to see a post signed by a person that does not use their real name. I would also like to see that everybody has a valid email address, maybe as a pre-requisit to be able to post, in other words, we all should register, I think this would make this wanderful place even better.

Thanks Ruth for starting this thread, it is healthy to vent when things are bothering us.

Jorge

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

#54

Relax, breathe deeply and slowly...

Ed Moore

>... and don't worry. There's no problem.

Ed

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

#55

Perhaps true,

Don Henthorn

>but let's face it realistically, if there weren't the posters and regulars there wouldn't be any WC, period. No one objects to lurkers and learners, in fact I am very happy they are there. But they are "there," not "here." There is a difference. It isn't a club mentality as some would have it. It is a family type relationship that was built up on purpose to foster openness and trust. At least that is my understanding. Maybe some one can correct me.

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

#56

Re: Heck, Stacey,

stacey s

>Point taken I will try to do a better job participating

Stacey

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

#57

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

Lan Brady

>I participated last year. I sent a piece that was to the best of my abilty. But in dollar value it did not compare to what I received. But you know, the genetlemen that recieved my gift was very kind with his thank you. And as an introduction, we have since become friends on this website. Finally we met at a symposium in Virginia. It was great to meet a friend that I had never seen before.

Again this year, I will send the best that I can. and I assume that the gift I recieve, will be their best . If it is a beginner, that is fine as well. It will go on the display shelf just the same!

Lan

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

#58

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

John Bussom

>After having read all of the posts in this thread I feel like a Lurker with the exception that I did not attempt to participate in the recent Exchange. Being fairly new to turning I didn't consider my work to be good enough even though I put my best into it!

Having said that I feel like a "Lurker" it's because I visit this wealth of knowledge frequently seeking information! Rather than bother asking the same old question of you well experienced turners I use the search feature with about 99% success.

I really do enjoy reading most of the posts and seeing the fine quality work produced by the experienced here but usually I spend most of my free time practicing on my lathe either turning pens, tops or birdhouse ornaments and not much time on this puter.

Just another!

John

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

#59

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

>Like John, I feel as if I am a "lurker" mainly because there are very few discussions in which I can actively participate because I do not understand either the content or the theme!

It would be a pleasure to take part in an exchange but the distances and the costs preclude that involvement.

I enjoy popping in every day just to read about the activities of others, mainly over the pond, and feel as if I am a part of the whole even though full involvement is impossible.

Warm regards, Peter

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

#60

We all started the same way

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>This is like the new guy in the shop, the first day or two not much is said after that he's part of the group. I sure after this post people will know your name and respond more. A post will get lost once in a while below a thread of this size but if it does ask again.

Do the best work you can and don't worry. This past summer I was really proud of my work and thought I had this turning thing figured out until I bought a new pair of glasses. People still thank me for the gifts given back then and probably never saw the defect. What I'm trying to say is just because you know it might not be perfect others won't see it.

It's late, take care and post,

Doug

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

#61

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

Mac

>I have always felt that all were welcome here...and in the exchange also.....still feel that way.....off to the shop......

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

#62

Bob Moffett

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

Bob Moffett

>I participate moderately in the forum. I have mainly asked questions or voiced my opinion as to pieces others have posted. I don't consider my evaluations to be on the level of most of the regular posters, but they are my opinion, for what that is worth. I have not posted pictues of my work because I am not very good with a comera and the last time I tried my file was to large to post.

I have been turning for several years and am participating in the exchange. I am sending one of my best ornaments because I think that what I give represents the quality of the work I am campable of and should be my best work. I think if we all approached the exchange with the same attitude, we would all enjoy it more. I think the exchange is about giving and not receiving and keeping score. No matter what a persons skill level is, if it is their best that should be what counts.

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

#63

Bill Blasic

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

Bill Blasic

>Wow! This was like finding that there is no Santa Clause! I visit this site for one reason, to learn. Now I find out that because I don't post every day I'm a Lurker and a Taker, I'm not part of the Family! Talk about disillusioned, as a matter of fact if you are one of these folks who have worries about Lurkers and have my name, please save your postage and don't send me anything. I will send my person a piece that will be the best of my ability and hope that he or she enjoys it in the spirit that it was given. How foolish am I, I thought that this was supposed to be fun!

Bill

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

#64

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

Rick Bane

>WOW!!! Everyone seems to have an opinion on this one including me. I cant beleive all the whining going on here. All of the so called professional turners and all those who think that they're stuff is at the top need to get a reality check. Not eveybody has something to say about everything. I post infrequently because of my skill level.I read and learn. It has nothing to do with being a lurker. I see the purpose of the exchange to put my take on turnings out there. Not because I think I'm going to receive a piece so valuable that I got over on somebody. Thats a really stupid statemenbt. And if thats the way you feel than I really dont want your piece anyway. I can tell all of you this-I will send the single best piece that I can make-PERIOD!!! I hope the rest of you do the same. I hope you all understand where I'm coming from.

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

#65

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

Kurt Rosenzweig

>I agree 100% with you Rick! Exactly how I feel spot on!

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

#66

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

Barry Scotton

>Bill

You are too correct. Until yesterday I did not realise lurker was a four letter word. Next on the hit list might be the Easter bunny. Had i known these sentiments exhisted before the exchange, I simply would not have entered my name. If I hade known after the exchange started i simply would have withdrawn my name. But after all has been said and done, I will carry on with my end of this bargain. I hope that my recipient will understand I am a Novice, and this is the best I am capable of. Having said all this, I would be simply delighted to recieve a weed pot from Russ, even though he does not know me. In fact I would be in novice turners heaven. And my thanks to all the organisers, they deserve better.

Best regards to all

Barry Scotton

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

#67

Hi my name is Stuart.... I'm a taker

Stuart Johnson

>I take every bit of information and help I can get from this group and over on the Chat session. I freely admit it. Maybe some day I'll be able to be a giver but I have rarely seen a thread that didn't have what I wanted to say already said much better.

When I received my name my first thought was Oh boy I'm going to send one of my pieces to xxxxx.

My second thought was Oh boy, I'm going to send one of my pieces to xxxxx?

I'm both glad and intimidated at the same time but I'm glad I joined the exchange and think the recipient will enjoy the piece.

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

#68

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

DD

>I have viewed this whole thread and the new one added by Bill Grumbine on "lurkers". It is a very unfortunate term, that, no matter how one views it, has a negative spin to it. This is a public forum that lets anyone with an internet connection view it, and should they chose, participate in it. There are no other expectations. Because an exchange is offered through the vehicle of the WC site, why are there any concerns at all, particularly that the "lurkers" are somehow going to adversely impact the exchange? To be honest, this sounds like a clique, and that is somewhat disappointing. I don't think that was the intent, but it is certainly an impression left.

This site has done wonders in providing me with a vehicle to talk to others who have gone down the path before me and can offer sage advice. Responses to queries happen within hours (even minutes) and beats any customer service hotline I have ever experienced. It is in some ways a mentoring tool for some, and to me, a library of turning knowledge. I post infrequently, and it will be a while before I ever post any pictures of my work. It simply isn't up to snuff, but I am working on it. The quality of my work (or lack thereof) doesn't permit me to participate in the exchange as a result. However, that will not stop me from using this library to gain a better understanding of what to do to improve. For some reason, however, the "lurker" moniker gets assigned to those who only participate infrequently. Does that make them less acceptable in the exchange or as a participant in the forum? If yes, why? Would anyone who uses a public library be called a "lurker" because he or she didn't engage in the running of the library, provide reviews of product used, or participate in any library public forums, but only took out library material? I seriously doubt it.

Too long winded, but the whole thread gives me cause for concern.

Doug Dubowski