Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

Posts

Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

#1

Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

Ruth Niles

>Recently I've heard a few opinions/comments that have me wondering and would like some feedback from everyone here. A few emails, talking at the FL Symposium and at a gallery recently these questions or comments were expressed.

OK, trying to be diplomatic now but not embellishing the expressed thoughts:

If a person merely lurks, never contributes to the forum, are they members like all of us verbal turners? Now that's paraphrased a LOT. Should they be in the exchange? Was the exchange started so we who know each other could have a piece of each other's work? Last year was my first, I knew both my doner and donee, this year my donee does post here and on WoW.

Second concern; (which I can't relate to because I got a perfect Jennifer piece) the exchange should be of your better work, nothing with cracks, holes through the bottoms, unfinished, etc. ***PLEASE READ CAREFULLY "I am not talking about a beginner's work, we all have our first pieces and can relate and enjoy the effort. I am talking about someone who we all know does good work" (this may tie into the lurker question, you think?) Now, I would not expect someone like Wally, Molly, Jamie, etc. (there are about 4 others) to donate one of their "gallery" pieces, that really would be totally unfair. If they just turn a nice bowl or vase, that's all that should be expected.

Seems a few agreeded upon guidelines might help?

My opinion, IF I had any of these problems: I'd like to get a piece from someone who I've read their opinion or have enjoyed a picture they posted. This would/should eliminate the unfinished item being sent?? Am I being diplomatic? When I suggested the people who said these things to me, that they post but do it diplomatically, they said it couldn't be done, are they right? Hey, things have to be said to be fixed, right? ok I'm babbling

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

#2

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

Carole Valentine

>Was it last year that I ranted about lurkers? Probably. I am not known for my diplomacy but I will again express my opinion. I see the forum as a place to share info and get to know each other. I also see the Exchange as a sharing - a means for those who have put forth at least some effort to make this forum what it is to exchange their work. They don't have to be professionals. They can be beginners, intermediates, experts or anything in between as long as they make some effort to be a part of the community. But someone who lurks and NEVER contributes to the forum, who never asks a question, never shares their thoughts and opinions in response to other's questions, never posts ANY of their work and never comments on other's work, but then jumps right into the Exchange, I would have to view purely as an opportunist.

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

#3

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ont.

>Hi Ruth,

I support your post and have some feelings about it as well.

I do think that in all good consciousness that most people who participate in exchanges do give their best work.

I do not have a problem participating in an exchange if I know the people in it, I look forward to it. I do have a problem though when the exchange involves people who do not contribute to the forum.

I consider this a community of wood turners and I appreciate that we all have a wide variety of talents and skills, I can accept and enjoy that�I do have a problem though when it comes to invisible people stepping out and then back into the shadows with work created by participants who make WC the sharing place that it is. I have respect for people who lurk, they do share in silence what we do publicly, but I feel there is an investment the community makes in being a part of WC that lurkers have not committed to yet, and in that light I do not feel like participating this time.

This is my opinion and my own feelings, I love participating and sending something in an exchange, I enjoy knowing the recipient enjoys what I make. I feel that if I sent something I made to a lurker that the interaction I would enjoy with a known person on WC has the potential to be a new beginning but also the potential for a less satisfying experience with that of a lurker.

What binds the exchange is simply the honour system between our selves on line. It is the credibility we have with each other and knowing we will do our best send a quality turned object. While I am sure that people will do that as a rule I also believe that the risk is greater with a lurker that they will not. I feel they have a choice as well, they are not committed to the honour of their name on lie as we are, they do not have to do so and will have no exposure for the lack of their commitment to the intention of the exchange should they decide to forfeit on the exchange.

Just how I feel..

Take care,

Jim

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

#4

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Jim and Carole have said very well the way I feel about lurkers and not only the Turning Exchange but also any other similar event. I have no problem with lurkers; if they do not want to contribute or participate in the forum information exchange that is fine with me. It is dismaying and surprising however when they selectively lurk so they can participate in an exchange among established friends.

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

#5

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

john lucas

>Ruth I look at it like donating a piece to an organization that will auction it off for the betterment of that organization. If I get something cool in return that's great but it really matters more that I contribute to keep the machine moving.

I totally agree that each of us would like to have something from someone we've talked to personally. I don't know how we would regulate that. Some who don't talk a lot on WC are still people I've met at symposiums or clubs and I would be proud to own thier work. That further confuses things.

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

#6

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

Russ Babbitt

>I sometimes contribute with what little I feel I know. I do not exchange. When our club did a Christmas gift exchange I was not in favor of it. I did not want someones "lesser work" in exchange for mine. I was reminded I did not have to spend days on a piece of work then add it to the exchange. Something I found easy and quick would be good. I participated and in exchange received a wonderful piece. I now participate every year. I would say the morale to the story is participate if you wish and make the piece you are willing to part with.

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

#7

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

Bill Stehman

>Interesting dilemma and I have to agree. I was hoping to draw someone that participates and had a recognizable name but what the hey. Like John and Russ just said, maybe their recipient will receive a marvelous piece. One never knows what lurks.... chuckle.

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

#8

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

chris rolke

>I post on here some what infrequently

having said that i do interject when i feel it is necessary.

i am on a few other forums and lists and see alot of the same questions asked and it can sometimes annoy other members.

i personally like to read alot of the posts and just learn how to do things

i try to sit back and watch i can say that i have tried alot of new things just because of seeing something posted on this site

so thats my thoughts on it

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

#9

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

David Breth

>Just a thought that occurred to me as I read the thread. Lurkers have their reasons for lurking. It is an open forum, and that affords the opportunity to peruse and "lurn" from the site. I don't so much view those folks as "takers" as I do people who want to learn but for whatever reason would rather watch from a virtual distance.

So, having prefaced in that way, I don't really have a problem with lurkers participating in the exchanges, as it may be one of the only ways in which they feel comfortable participating in the woodcentral community.

People of high or low skill have the capacity to give somebody an item of poor effort, however. All depends on the individual. Not sure how you safeguard that type of problem. As has been noted earlier, allowances need to be made for skill level, but that's different than sending something you know just screams out "I sent junk to check the box!" Unfortunately, people are people, and the planet is just chock full of them. Last year at work, I made a little ornament for an ornament exchange at a work Christmas party. Somebody walked out with a piece of cherry that I liked a lot. I walked out with a crappy plain glass ornament filled with crinkly red and blue tissue paper and a Buffalo Bills logo. It didn't exactly smack of effort.

I'm sure I could state things better, but every two seconds my daughter is asking me to let her out of her play area. So if I said something really contentious oops.

David B.

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

#10

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

Russ Fairfield

>I have no problem at all with lurkers. There are a lot of them. In fact, they are in the majority. The average thread runs to something like 100or more readers, and the average responses are less than 10. That means the lurkers outnumber us by at least 10 to 1. I have no problem with that. This is a public forum, and they are free to chose whether to participate or only read the messages. In that respect, this forum is no different than the AAW Journal. Everybody reads it, but a very few write articles for publication.

However, they should not expect equal treatment in a gift exchange. Personally, I will make my own distinction between the lurkers and people I know by sending something nice to someone I know, and something that is of far lesser value to someone I don't know. As an example, Ruth Niles would get one of my best salad bowls, but the Joe Bloke who I have never heard of will get a weedpot; and I will have met my obligation in the exchange.

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

#11

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

stacey s

>I definitely agree that the person should make an effort to give something in the exchange that is to the best of their ability. If the person is a professional they should be expected to give one of their most valuable pieces but everyone should give to their ability. I agree with some other comments I don't always post on a daily basis because I don't feel I have something to contribute to the conversation(I will try to do better this year) But we also have to realize like was mentioned this is done on the honor system. I think most people intentions are good so there should be little to worry about.Like others I would hope to get something from a person that I know who they are but if it is from a person that I hardly know who they are I will be just as happy. I think that I am more excited right now about sending the piece to the person and find out their reaction(It's all about the giving not receiving.(That's what my mom always told me a christmas anyway :). Anyway I hope that everyone enjoys the gift that they recieve. I know I will no matter who it is from. It will be given a place on the shelf with the other works in my collection.

Stacey

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

#12

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

>I do not participate in the Exchange because I do not do much turning even though I enjoy it very much. I have done turning professionally in my modelmaking and patternmaking days but that was creating something from others creative abilities. I am constantly amazed at some of the pieces I see here on WC. I am a NON LURKER expressing my opinions and limited knowledge and most times inane chatter but if I want to give someone something I do not expect something in return. I have reached the point in my life where I am beginning to dispose of things rather than aquire.

It maybe unacceptible in todays Politically Correct world but why not have an exchange limited to Non Lurkers only?

The Lurkers are here to learn for the most part and may feel their opinions are not worthy of posting on this forum. They could become Non Lurkers someday.

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

#13

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

Bob Fawcett

>I think I fit in a second category that no one has mentioned yet. I don't lurk as much as I should. I am one of those people who can't help but open their mouth. In the turning world, I am by no means an expert, but I offer advice or comments if I think I know the answer. Maybe I should still be more lurker!

I hope my recipient will appreciate my turning. I am an intermediate at best, and that may be streching it. I started turning January 2006, so I have a whole year of experience.

Since I can't keep my mouth (or keyboard) shut, everyone please feel free to correct my errors.

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

#14

Re: It is an unfortunate reality that.........

Jamie Donaldson

>.. there are lurkers who remain in the internet shadows, but I also strongly believe anyone who posts on friendly theme sites like WC should be willing to use a real name to identify themselves as a real human being.A poster should be willing to accept responsibility for their words- anything less is dishonest at least.

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

#15

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

stacey s

>I think Chris said exactly what I was trying to say. I dont think that I said it to well in my post above. Maybe that is why I don't post as oftern I am not a very good speaker.

Stacey

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

#16

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

Jim Swank

>Where do you draw the line between lurker and non-lurker? I'm not one of the more verbose in this crowd, but I post when I have something to say (that hasn't already been well said). I participate in chat at times (as arkie). I rarely post photos for a number of reasons, the main one being that I seldom can get an honest critique here. I can get all the "purty" comments I can stand from family and co-workers.

So once again, where do you draw the line? I think the best answer is not to draw one at all. If you know the recipient in advance and want too adjust within reason, fine. If it's a blind exchange like one that occurred at Louisville, figure you "pays yer money and takes yer chances" just like everyone else.

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

#17

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

Dawn Adams

>I guess I get to be the response from the lurkers. I was truly looking forward to this turning exchange so I could start to post on the board I have been watching now for a little over a year. This seemed to be a good opportunity to start to make friends on this board now that my confidence has grown as a turner and I am starting to feel comfortable sharing my work. Some of us are also just shy � compound that with being new to woodturning and it is often difficult to know what to post without feeling stupid or redundant.

I have posted a few questions on the board before (however, when I searched back 4 years I could not find my name as a participant) but with little to no response each time I posted. This also has dampened my enthusiasm at posting.

I promise to try to post more often, and I promise I will send my recipient a nice piece that I am proud of. It may not be at the same level that most of you are at, but it will be the best work I am capable of. I hope that is good enough.

I am still hopeful to make some friend on this board, although now I am a little more hesitant.

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

#18

Barb Siddiqui

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

Barb Siddiqui

>Ruth- I understand the concerns, but this whole thread worries me a little in sounding like making WC's turning forum a 'closed club.' Most lurkers are 'learners,' and if they're excited enough to want to join an exchange program (which, by the way, was offered up as "Not a contest as to quality," then it seems the recipient of such work might consider owning a first original turning piece from someone who may be going to get much better. Dave Smith accepted my honey dipper last summer as "an early original Barb Siddiqui." Then he told me I really needed a thinner parting tool. :-)

One solution to the problem might be this: on a public forum, no limitations as to entrants, but when the various barbeques and get-togethers are planned, do a turning exchange then, with goods brought and names exchanged as in a raffle. That way, you'd be exchanging turnings with people you know or are meeting, many of whom are WC regulars. Interested newcomers may come to those meet-and-greets. but lurkers rarely will.

What do you all think?

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

#19

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

David Breth

>Can I just tag on and say me too?? I'll keep an eye out for your posts now, Bob, as it sounds like you and I are in about the same weight class. Well, hopefully your weight isn't what mine is....

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

#20

Barb Siddiqui

Hang in there

Barb Siddiqui

>Dawn..this is really a very friendly group, and very helpful. The webmaster has changed servers a couple of times in four years, so backtracking to older posts may have been a problem that way. Ask your questions, perhaps in different ways, and someone will speakup and answer. I personally am not contributing right now because it's so darn cold where I live (plus we're still dealing with wind damage) that I cannot even finish sanding my troublesome mahogany bowl yet. Please don't be intimidated; offer your work up for comments and you'll get all the help you need to be a better turner. I'm glad you posted.

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

#21

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

bowlman

>He may not think he speaks well, but I can attest that his turnings and his skills speak volumes. I spent a remarkable and totlly enjoyable week with Stacy in '06 and would gladly do it again, just for the energy boost!

Dick Gerard

aka bowlman

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

#22

I am missing something here!!!

Jake Niedling

>Not sure what the real issue is regarding an open public invitation and participation in an exchange. You have to expect a variety of skill levels and quality. If you know the person, perhaps you make something nicer like Russ said, its your choice. This should be a fun and enjoyable thing that we like to do. If some of you want a private exchange, then that's ok as well. Someone just needs to organize it.

I just don't understand the issue with what are called "lurkers". I guess we are all lurkers, just some participate at a higher frequency and some with strong feelings. Many times by the time I get a chance to participate in the evenings or every other day, most of the items have already been replied to several times. Most of what I would have contributed has already been posted. So infrequent verbal participation I think is ok and normal.

I think the "lurkers" get alot from this forum and many thanks go out to those of you that have the time and post frequently.

I am participating in the gift exchange and feel my skill level is what I would call at the advanced level. I know John Lucas and he has seen my work, so if anyone is concerned about my work, send John an email. I think what I am planning to send to my exchange person, they will be pleased and happy.

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

#23

No comment...

Bob Fawcett

>At least on the weight thing.

I am sure I will comment on other things.

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

#24

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

Bob Fawcett

>Please don't take this personally.

I am a relatively new turner and in the exchange as well. Someone will get what I think is some of my best work. Since I only started in January 06 I hope they will appreciate it for what it is.

As long as your intent is to do your best, that is all anyone can ask, and all anyone has a right to expect.

Re: Exchange; Lurkers: Quality (with diplomacy)

#25

Re: Hang in there

john lucas

>Dawn I think Russ said it well one time. Sometimes when you post others are simply too busy to answer that day. I try to answer posts when I see one that hasn't had any activity but like many others, I work and can't always get to all the questions. Be patient or simply ask again. On days when there are a lot of responses your may get lost off the page and simply missed.