Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Sharpening Tools

Posts

Re: Sharpening Tools

#26

Re: Why? The Last Laugh Principal

Reality Check

>and that's a reality check

Reality Check

Re: Sharpening Tools

#27

JL

Re: Sharpening Tools

JL

>Speaking as someone who has a Tormek, an 8" grinder, some waterstones and somewhere in the back of one of the drawers, some oil stones.. There is a place for all methods of sharpening. I've tried scary sharp and sanding belts, but I don't like them.

I sharpen my skews with the waterstones. I sharpen my gouges with the 8". On the rare occasions I use and sharpen scrapers, I use the Tormek. I do use the Tormek for sharpening other things, not turning related.

Re: Sharpening Tools

#28

Brad Vietje

Thanks, Clem !

Brad Vietje

>Goly.. I guess maybe I touched off the Holy War this time... or maybe Russ ... Who'da thunk ?

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Yep, you guessed it -- Newbury, VT

Re: Sharpening Tools

#29

Keith Tompkins

Re: why it's Reality

keith tompkins

>I think there are a couple of problems here, Reality Check. First, your moniker "Reality Check" implies right from the start that you, in a condescending manner, are about to contradict something that has been posted, thereby invalidating what someone is attempting to say.

I think it's important to know that most of us on this site actually know one another....some of us are actually good friends. Many on this site have established a certain amount of credibility because the advice they've given over the years has been shown to actually work...to the benefit many others. I have personally seen and picked up the work turned by many "Bozo in Boston" posters here...and have a lot of respect for what they have done. I think you can add a great deal to your credibility by posting a few photos of your work...nothing gets people's attention or respect quicker that a stunning piece or two. Let us get to know you and your work.

You have, in the two posts I've seen, referred to professional turners such as Mr. Ellsworth and Mr. Jordan. That's fine, but many of us here have studied with these, and other, great turners and teachers. Most of us are acutely aware of their views, opinions, and prejudices. Perhaps it would be more relevant if you talked about insight you have gleaned from your own personal experience...not theirs.

HOW we choose to sharpen tools is a moot point. Most pros use bench grinders for a simple reason: they are cheap, plentiful, and simple fixtures can be fabricated for them. We all know what a bench grinder is, and are willing to invest in one. The Tormek is a specialty tool, and is not an absolute requirement....maybe overkill for turning , but an absolute godsend to a carver. Do I own one...no. Would I consider purchasing one....yes, if I could afford it. I will tell you from my own experience, the sharper the edge, the better the finish off the tool. This is a fact that you can discover for yourself, despite opinions to the contrary by the pros. During my demos and classes I show the difference a truly sharp tool can make.

The pros out there are not always right. Many of them exchew the use of grinding jigs of any kind, and insist that their pupils grind their tool freehand. This advice has caused more turners to become frustrated and quit than any other reason. One look at the business end of their tools tells the reason why.

One thing I will agree completey with you....that is many turners buy far, far too many tools. I probably own fewer turning tools than any other turner I've met.

Re: Sharpening Tools

#30

The single most important thing

Ron in Drums PA

>The single most important thing about sharpening is repeatability.

If you can repeat the same grind time after time, getting the same edge each time, you will not have to relearn how to use the tool every time you sharpen it.

Re: Sharpening Tools

#31

Re: why it's Reality

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>RC,

The word "I" in your writings means absolutely nothing because you have no identity here--therefore, no credibility. Harsh words, yes, but don't take it personally--how can you, if you are not a person? In this day and age, you could be a computer-generated 'bot for all we know!

;-)

Re: Sharpening Tools

#32

Ditto to what Ron just said.

john lucas

>

Re: Sharpening Tools

#33

Re: Sharpening Tools *LINK*

Darrell Feltmate

>For a beginner sharpener you need two things

(1) advice from other turners, do like the others say and go to a meeting. A lot of the fun of turning is the gathering of turners (a ton of turners?, a tangle of turners? ...)

(2) a sharpening jig. Free hand sharpening is a learned art and the art of turning is enough to learn at once.

I like a jig with a grinder for sharpening. My rather biased opinions are found on my web site along with instructions for making a jig. It will only cost a couple of dollars and make all the difference in the world.


Around the Woods - Sharpening

Re: Sharpening Tools

#34

Re: Sharpening Tools

eaglesc

>I don't believe the first guy who ever turned on a lathe had a jig and a grinder,

Probably a piece of broken glass.

There is a lot to be said in the satisfaction of learning on your own.