Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Sharpening Tools

Posts

Sharpening Tools

#1

Sharpening Tools

C.W.Stivison

>First I want to thank everyone for thier response to my last question about what tools to buy. Now I need to know what kind of stones or files I need to sharpen these tools. Remember I am just getting started. When I look in the woodworking catalogs there seems to be alot of options. I plan to get some training at some point, but I am sure that the best thing to do is to work at it on my own frist. Thanks

Re: Sharpening Tools

#2

Steven Antonucci

Wow... here comes the holy war again...

Steve Antonucci

>I own a Tormek, and I love it. I don't think you can do better. Faster, sure. Better, nope.

That being said, it's a pricey system. You could sharpen on a belt sander carefully with 220 paper if you've got a steady hand. Some will recommend a grinder and a Wolverine.

In the end, the wood doesn't know what you did to sharpen the steel, only if it's sharp or not. If I wasn't sure if turning was for me or not, I'd probably try the belt sander first, since you probably own one already. A little diamond hone will clean up the flute nicely, and you haven't spent a penny.

Steve

Re: Sharpening Tools

#3

Re: Sharpening Tools *LINK*

john lucas

>CW first tell us what grinding,sanding, honing etc tools you have. You can sharpen turning tools with a lot of different tools. The most used is a grinder, second most popular seems to be a belt sander. When I'm at my dad's house we use a disc sander. I have even used a 3x21 belt sander mounted so it sits up. Let me know what you have and I'll try to council you on how to use it.

I would also recommend the AAW video on sharpening. It shows 3 different turners sharpening in different ways. It's the best thing I've seen to describe sharpening.


http://www.woodturner.org/products/videos/

Re: Sharpening Tools

#4

Re: Sharpening Tools

C.W.Stivison

>AT the present time I have nothing. A clean slate

Re: Sharpening Tools

#5

Brad Vietje

Re: Sharpening Tools

Brad Vietje

>CW,

Like Steve implies, there are many opinions about which way one should sharpen turning tools -- and quite a few times this subject has come up and exposed those opinions and sometimes the passionate disagreement about the topic.

If you search the archives using terms like "sharpening", or "honing", you can read all the passionate comments.

One answer I can offer that takes no position is that the very best single thing a new turner can do is find other turners in your area to learn from -- you can save a LOT of time and frustration that way. Probably the best way to do that is to find a "local" turning club, which might mean within a 2 - 3 hour's drive. AAW-affiliated chapters are listed at www.woodturner.org. Finding a club in your area is probably the best single investment of time and effort you can make -- you'll find answers to questions about all aspects of turning, and in most cases, you'll get to try out different methods and different equipment before you spend money or learn the hard way. Most people find a more experienced mentor that lives nearby, which is the best way to learn more complex facets of turning. Try it -- you'll like it.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Sharpening Tools

#6

Re: Sharpening Tools

George Van

>CW, if you have an AAW group near you I would suggest going to one of their meetings or looking them up in the AAW directory and see who the contact people are. If you call them they can point you toward a mentor or members that would be more than happpy to show you their sharpening systems, after which you could make your choice based on trying the systems. Before we started our own group I used to travel 125 miles to the meeting but it was worth it for what I learned and the great people I met.

Re: Sharpening Tools

#7

Steven Antonucci

Brad makes a great point...

Steve Antonucci

>I'm sure that there's a cub close to you, but if you let on to where you are located, I'd bet someone here is not far away. The folks at WoodCentral are always willing to help our, and maybe you could meet someone who'd be willing to show you what they know?

I'm in Northern NJ.

Steve

Re: Sharpening Tools

#8

Re: Sharpening Tools

Russ Fairfield

>Keep in mind that it doesn't matter whether it is round or flat, large or small, fast or slow, attached to a belt, made by man, or a rock you found in the yard. If it leaves a scratch in the steel when they are rubbed together, it can be used to make and sharpen a cutting edge. Evwerything else is opinion and personal preferrence.

Re: Sharpening Tools

#9

Re: Sharpening Tools

eliot d

>If you ever go to any serious turning demonstrations, you will see that EVERYBODY has standing by a pair of grinding wheels on a stand --one course, one fine -- and usually something like a Wolverine jig system, When you get deeper into the craft, you may want to spring for a Tormek, which is much slower ( and much more expensive) but produces a sharper edge. Then there's the JoolTool. but that's a story for another day.

Re: Sharpening Tools

#10

Re: Sharpening Tools

Greg Haugen

>Ok, I would suggest NOT to learn sharpening on your own trial and error. Been there, done that, and have some short tools to prove it. I would strongly recommend finding someone to show you their technique. And get the AAW DVD. For a Beginner I don't believe a Tormek is a good starting point. I have one and love it but not for learning and not for all types of turning. Don't ask turners what wheels to get. You'll be able to film a "Snicker's" commercial because you will be "not going anywhere for awhile." As a general rule white wheels are preferred and aren't expensive, pink or blue are also fine. Usually 8" grinders are preferred, slow speed. Woodcraft sells an affordable one for 90ish, if its on sale 70. You can usually throw out the wheels that come with a grinder because one or both of them are way to hard for HSS. Roughing can be 36 to 60 grit and sharpening 60 grit to 120 grit. For learning a Wolverine system is priceless, I feel. The base system and a vari grind. Get a diamond dresser other than the wolverine for learning, range 20-40 dollars usually shaped like a T.

One tool has to be honed, the rest is preference. That tool is the Skew. Other than the Tormek it cannot be used off of a grinder effectively. Two options to do this honing, a diamond hone ranges 20-50 dollars or a Medium grit India Oil Stone (norton) under 20, Nick Cook's method.

HSS tools are the way to go for sharpening. No worries of overheating like Carbon Steel tools.

Other than that. ASK. This is a great site for stuff like this. Find help and watch a DVD or two.

Hope it helps,

Greg

Re: Sharpening Tools

#11

Re: Sharpening Tools *LINK*

Russ Babbitt

>DO NOT learn on your own. Like has been suggested already. If you can find a chapter of the AAW, American Association of Woodturners, in your area, do so. The information they can provide is priceless. The link below shows the popularity of a slow speed (1735rpm) grinder. I have the Tormek and it's a great machine, but I use an 8" heavy duty Delta with the Wolverine jig from Oneway. As do most members in my club. It's fast and it works.....for me.


Sharpening Poll

Re: Sharpening Tools

#12

What Great Responses ......

Barry Irby

>Follow all the advice you have gotten here. Find a club or eflellow turner in your area (priceless).

I think you are going to find that you will ahve to have some sort of "power tool" for sharpening. You will most probably start with a belt sander or a grinder. I have both. Did not consider the belt sander as a sharpenign tool, but might have if I had known the possibilities. Look hard at the Woodcraft 8" grinder. For under a $100 its hard to beat and I am still using the original wheels. Whish appeals to you more, a belt sander which might have many applications or a grinder that is more or less dieicated to this task?

And you will need a few slip stone or hones.

I have not been draw to the Tormek yet. I have never used a tool sharpened on a Tormek and maybe if I did I would be Sucked into that maelstrome. Clearly I am ignorant of the system, but I think that you will start with a grinder or a sander and will always need one for heavier stock remaoval and then advance to a Tormek for refinement. Not sure, but I believe that almost everyone who ownes a Tormek also owns a Grinder of some description and still uses it to some extent. Most of them did not start with a Tormek.

I also am a big advocate of jigs like the Wolverine. Mine is home made, but I stoll the idea form others who went before me. I know part fo the Holy War on sharpening is Jig VS Hand. My experince is that a good jig is fast and produces a reproducible edge or profile. I have been sharpeing my Ellsworth gouge for years and have lost less metal than a fellow who came to a club meeting and refused to buy the jig lost in the month between meetings. Essentially, the jigs are an investment and the tools are consumables. The investment in jigs will make your (expensive) consumables last a lot longer and be a joy to use.

I also assume your intention is to turn wood, not sharpen tools. I wonder sometimes if some of us don't get that backwards. We get so enthralled with sharpening that we almost forget about turning. So, Look at those DVD's, find a club, figure out what will work for you, get it set up and turn.

Re: Sharpening Tools

#13

Steven Antonucci

Hijack: Great point- I enjoy sharpening as much..

Steve Antonucci

>as I enjoy turning! Nothing quite so satisfying as seeing that brand new edge in anticipation of the "hiss" of the first cut.

Am I the only one who gets that little happy smile when a tool is freshly sharpened?

Didn't think so :-)

Steve

Re: Sharpening Tools

#14

Re: Hijack:Ahhhmmmm

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>No, Steve, just you.

|;-}}}}}}}}}

Re: Sharpening Tools

#15

Steven Antonucci

I know there's someone here who cut themself

Steve Antonucci

>and not felt it, only to find blood everywhere and have to look for the cut. When they find it, even though they're bleeding like a stuck pig, their first though is "Wow. I did a good job on that edge..."

Steve

Re: Sharpening Tools

#16

Those who enjoy sharpening as much as

Reality Check

>turning, should get a Tormek, it�s almost a hobby all in itself. Having said that, I do enjoy �turning� with a very sharp edge. Sharpening is a must, so you should make it as easy as possible, why?...so you will sharpen often. Those who mentioned 8� woodcraft grinder probably gave you the best practical advice, put it as close to the lathe as practical. Mine is two steps away, this encourages me to grind often and I do not mind going back often. Whatever system you get, and after someone from your local club (important or your going to struggle) shows you the basic grinds for your tools, keep in mind what I�m about to tell you. I�m going to tell you one of the best kept secrets to sharpening, that even some �experienced� turners either don�t know or have forgot, �ready, ok here it is�.when your making a nice cut on your wood, and your gouge is cutting like a hot knife through butter, STOP & sharpen your tool again BEFORE it needs sharpening. That�s why you need to get a system that�s fast and efficient and encourages you to KEEP a fine edge by sharpening often; and thankfully in this case, it does not have to be the most expensive system out there. Just because one system cost more doesn�t mean it will help you, and you could end up paying more money for something that will actually hinder your turning. Many of those �T system� users will deny this, but most won�t go back to sharpen their tools as often as they should because the T system is painful to use, they may say they don�t have to sharpen as often because they get a a bette edge on their tools�hmmm. However, you should see the Tormek system in action at least once (maybe at a tool show or a wood workers retailer). It is truly a well built, fine machine, and you will marvel at the mirror edge it can put on a tool with after fiddeling with the stone graders, wheel dressors and honing compounds and... whew, I'll stop there; then walk away and be happy you bought a bench grinder. I can sharpen, take a bunch of cuts, resharpen and be practically finished with my form by the time most are finished fooling around with the T machine. I should mention that some Pros agree there is no better edge to turn bowls and side grain than the MICRO serrated edge you get off a grinder(not talking shear scraping, where honing your tool, on your last cuts will give your wood a great surface) Don�t believe me, I�m not quite a professional turner, but ask the real pro�s like Ellsworth & Jordan or any other pro out there (I have heard their answers about Tormek). The truth is, NONE of them use the Tormek for there general turning tools. If turning is going to be a hobby for you get the Woodcraft grinder- it�s the best practical choice. If Sharpening is going to be your hobby� get that green T machine, and savor the edge you can make while I turn some wood.

Reality Check

PS after you learn to sharpen by hand, a sharpening jig (like the Wolverine)can get you from wood to grinder to wood in about 20-30 seconds

Re: Sharpening Tools

#17

Re: A real reality check

Russ Fairfield

>Why does "Reality Check" choose to remain anonymous with a ficticious e-mail address. The messages show a knowledge of the topic that people would take seriously if they were a real person.

Re: Sharpening Tools

#18

Brad Vietje

Ditto That, Brother Russ !

Brad Vietje

>I have always been uncomfortable with cool-sounding user names, but generally don't mind if "SoVeryCool" actually signs off as "Jim in Milwaukee" or something similar that lets us know who we are dealing with.

Maybe I'm just a luddite from the dark ages, or maybe I'm just not hip enough to mix with the tech-savvy X-Box, I-Pod, eBay crowd, and further, maybe I'm being foolish, and exposing myself to identity theft by using my real name and location (though I sure don't have much anyone would want to take !). But I'm a real person with a real name. My name is Brad Vietje and I live in Newbury, VT. I'm the only person by that name in the USA, and one of only 8 with my surname. I turn wood, and sometimes I write too much about it. People can either respect what I write or reject it -- either way is fine with me.

Let's get real.

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Sharpening Tools

#19

I respect what you write!

Clem Wixted, Jonesboro, AR

>

Re: Sharpening Tools

#20

Re: Reality isn't an issue, attitude can be.

Brad Armstrong

>The reason these people don't go by their names is because they have an attitude or theory that they think is right because they "dream" they are Ellsworth. Reality made sense until he got an attitude about the Tormek. A true "professional" doesn't cut down one technique to build theirs. They give their view, "that's how I do it." And leave it at that. Because the minute you cut down something you can effect people you didn't know. Example Nick Cook and Richard Raffan use the Tormek quite a bit. And those two don't know anyting about turning, right. I am kidding. Is it wrong not to use it, no. Is it wrong to use it, no. But do you have to say stuff like he did about some enjoying sharpening or whatever and how he turns. That just shows maturity. Yes, Jordan and Ellsworth like a grind, so does Richard Raffan and Nick Cook. Bottom line, keep your dang tools sharp.

There are professionals, and there are "professionally minded" people.

This issue is old, and will never be solved because no one is right or wrong. Instead of cutting down people or techniques because you don't know how to do it or prefer another method go and cut some wood.

B. Armstrong

Re: Sharpening Tools

#21

Re: Those who enjoy sharpening as much as

TDRice

>I will try to respond to "Reality Check's" legitimate points while ignoring the attitude.

Yes, keeping the tool sharp is critical. Contrary to what R. C. says, I believe every really good turner knows this. I've watched Stuart Batty return to the grinder time after time, much sooner than I would have. It was a learning experience.

I have two grinders, a belt sander, numerous stones, and a Tormek. The grinders are used for shaping, especially a new tool. The Tormek is used for sharpening. Yes, it is slower but it has three advantages. One, the tool is sharper. Two I can repeat the same profile over and over with no trouble. Three, it extends the life of the tools. With a grinder even an really good, experienced person will remove hundredths or even tenths of an inch of length with every sharpening. With the Tormek I can do the same job while removing only thousandths. I can see why a production turner uses a grinder. It is much faster and when you are making a living turning speed is crucial. I don't have to support myself with my turnings and I'm not an a race.

Use what suits you best.

Re: Sharpening Tools

#22

Re: I know there's someone here who cut themself

Don O.

>I did that the other night while regrinding a cheap HSS skew into a different profile. While honing with a diamond plate I touched my thumb on the long point. No pain but knew I had touched it. All of a sudden blood starts showing up on the skew. I looked at my thumb, saw the blood, and thought "must be sharp". Went to the lathe to try the skew and THEN went in the house to get a bandage. Gotts love sharp tools!

Re: Sharpening Tools

#23

why it's Reality

Reality Check

>I believe any information given on a website or anyplace for that matter should be taken with a grain of salt. A person�s final determination of an answer should be based on all the research he has done and yes on who has given whatever advice, and then use ones common sense to collate the data and make a final determination for ones self until more data is in view.

My apologies, if anyone feels that my statements or anyone else�s are worthless because I didn�t call myself �Jim in Milwaukee� or Bozo of Boston, and they are entitled to feel that, however, by taking that general attitude they are potentially restricting themselves of valuable information to make decisions by shutting out ideas completely, only because there is no name (real or not) attached. After all, I have seen many beautiful inspirational quotes that are timeless and yet remain nameless, and being nameless did not make them any less beautiful.

I have seen too many new turners get sucked into buying more tools than they need, or wrong tools because they see it work great by a show demonstrator, they get it home, find out its flaws and then the piece of crap gets thrown in a drawer taking up space. Yes, I have been there, I have made some of those mistakes, If I can give out a bit of information to help one make a better choice than I have, or what I have learned over the years, great, they can decide themselves if the points are valid enough whether there�s a name attached to it or not.

Woodturning is a great craft, but like in many things there is a lot BS to confuse a new turner. Last year it�s LD, this year alcohol, next year it will spaghetti sauce. Too many get caught up in the BS they lose site of what they really need to know to get in the right path to simply turn some wood. I�m not here to give or receive flames. I made statements of what I do, I give the REASONS why I don�t like something, one can then decide for themselves if it make�s sense of not.

The very reason I don�t use my birth name is because of the Brad Armstrongs out there. I only pointed out facts on what I do, I pointed out facts about the Tormek including it was a well built machine, however indicating words to the effect that it is not best suited for woodturning, yet Brad decided to want to attack me personally with the speculative hypothesis of a backyard psychologist . I guess he�s entitled to his assumptions.

The truth is, I truly do like to see ones getting into the craft off on the right foot, or give them other ideas to consider, to help them make better decisions, of the many and confusing paths to follow. The truth is; that many people can�t handle the truth. Many get offended by hearing an opinion that completely contradicts them especially, pointing out opinions or even negative facts about a particular tool that they spent a week�s salary on. In the craft circles, one can almost be shunned by being too vocal. Vendors are also less likely to donate tools to examine, if they feel one may give a strong negative opinion. My God, it�s sad that in this current state of a politically correct society we now live in, we often have to walk on eggshells, and not be so honest; except ones that are brave, and willing to take the consequences of that bravery, I greatly respect that bravery, but you won�t get elected to office or anything else in life by being too vocally honest�and that is sad. So out of respect for friend�s & associates feelings being hurt, and not being brave enough to personally stand the flames when I may have touch on a sensitive issue, I will remain, Reality Check. Now when you see me at that symposium I will tell you my birth name where I'm from and we can have a nice friendly discussion about that interesting hollow form on the instant gallery table; instead of you thinking I�m a jerk because I feel there are better & safer ways of drying a piece of wood, than showing a beginner to slosh it around in a ten gallon vat of flammable alcohol in his new woodshop.

Bozo from Boston...Naw, just kiddn

Reality Check

Re: Sharpening Tools

#24

Re: why it's Reality

Ron in Drums PA

>Why the bogus email?

Re: Sharpening Tools

#25

Why? The Last Laugh Principal

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Here's how it works:

You get PO'd at RC's post and determine to frost his butt with the quintessential nastygram of composed invective far beyond anything possible for posting here on WC. You put Real Time into your proffered proof that his parents were not, in fact, married, and then fire this thing-of-beauty it off to that listed address. "THAT'LL SHOW THAT ***!!!" you think as you sign off and go to bed, happy that you've now struck a telling blow for the forces of Light & Right.

You arise rested and refresheed and check your e-mail the next morning, fully expecting to have received a contrite apology, acknowledgement of your superior high moral ground, and a pledge to mend his ways, but only to find the Failed Mail Delivery Notice in your inbox.

Meanwhile, the dude's sitting back, sipping his morning coffee, and gently chuckling over the thought of how many people just you there are sitting out there in Internetland having gotten that very same e-mail message.

|;-}}}