Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Spraysystem for finishes

Posts

Spraysystem for finishes

#1

Spraysystem for finishes

Bob Fawcett

>I would like to get a spray system for finishes. HVLP seems to be the way to go. WoodCrafts new catalog shows a new product, a system with spraygun and turbine for $299. The price is lower than most no idea about the quality. Currently, the only compressor I have is the little pancake that came with my PC brad/finish nailers.

Are there any good systems that don't break the bank?

Re: Spraysystem for finishes

#2

Re: Spraysystem for finishes

Dave Belser

>Try a Critter siphon gun - I needed to add the ability to spray and was looking for a system. The HVLP systems look great and seem to be the latest must have tool. But I just couldn't spring for one. I asked here and some suggested the Critter gun that costs about $30.

So I figured that for that amount I couldn't go wrong. Well it works good enough for me that I don't see adding any more spray equipment for a while.

Down side: over spray / waste, not good for big stuff like cabinets

Up side: cheap, easy to clean, works with existing compressor.

Wood craft was also selling a cheap HVLP system for around $100 but I have no idea how good it is. I do believe that any HVLP system will require a significant amount of time for cleaning when you are done. Hence for me the Critter is great, I don't dread breaking it out for small jobs, and most of what I do is small. I also do my spraying outside.

Hope this helps

- Dave

Re: Spraysystem for finishes

#3

Re: Spraysystem for finishes

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>What kind of finishes are you using / thinking of using? Turbine HVLPs are more for water based and waterborne finishes. If you're thinking of solvent finishes, a conversion gun running off your compressor might be better. Need more info.

mm

Re: Spraysystem for finishes

#4

Re: Spraysystem for finishes

Bob Fawcett

>I use mostly solvent finishes. I want to be able to spray laquer and others. I am not the fond of water base finishes. I have an airless, but I don't think thats the right thing for this. The one I have is more suited to a 5 gallon bucket of latex and spraying my porches. Besides it would take a quart just to fill the hose and pump.

What exactly is a "conversion" gun.

Re: Spraysystem for finishes

#5

Re: Spraysystem for finishes

Bob Fawcett

>I considered the Critter, but one of the things I would like to spray is a bed I am making.

Re: Spraysystem for finishes

#6

Re: Spraysystem for finishes

Jerry Whitaker

>Dave.....where do you get the Critter for $30.00? The last price I saw was about a nickle less than a $50 bill. For $30, I will spring for one in a heartbeat.

Re: Spraysystem for finishes

#7

Re: Spraysystem for finishes

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>A conversion gun is an HVLP that runs off a compressor and "converts" the air supply to HVLP mode inside the gun.

If solvents are your goal, a turbine-driven gun is NOT the way to go. Reason being that the turbine, essentially a vacuum cleaner motor moving lots of air at low pressure, pull the air through its motor and thus warmes the flow. The warm air, inturn warms the finish and flashes off solvents thus giving heave orange peel in solvent applications.

The suggestion of the little $30 critter is not a bad one for small objects and lighter body finishes like solvent lacquer and shellac. Since it's a venturi feed gun, you don't have to worry about cleaning the interior ports, and it will do a credible job on small stuff. You do have to remember to keep the gun more or less level as it's not a pressure feed cup.

You will find top-feed HVLP conversion guns that run from $25 at Harbor Freight to several thousand at some of the pro sites. The difference with be the gun's ability to lay down an even, controlled coating of droplets of equal size, influencing the price.

mm

Re: Spraysystem for finishes

#8

Re: Spraysystem for finishes

Bob Fawcett

>Thanks Mark,

Could I run such a gun off my little compressor?

The compressor is a Porter Cable pancake that comes with the nailer kit. Rating is 2.6 SCFM at 90 PSI and 3.7 SCFM at 40 PSI.

Long term I am sure I would want a larger compressor.

Re: Spraysystem for finishes

#9

I had one of the cheap Wagner turbine outfits

Don Henthorn

>and it worked great fpr spraying enamel on a steel circular staircase I installed to the attic. I thinned the enamel pretty much per the instructions and it worked like a charm. I experienced no orange peel. Also used it for a number of materials and projects and never had problems if I followed the instructions.

Re: Spraysystem for finishes

#10

in my dreams?

Dave Belser

>Got mine from Lee Valley, and you are right they now have them at $45. I don't know if the price has gone up since I bought it but I recall it was less than $40 - oh well....

Re: Spraysystem for finishes

#11

Keith Tompkins

Re: Spraysystem for finishes

Keith Tompkins

>Bob, if you're just spraying turnings, try an airbrush. Using commercial spray equipment to finish a turning is like hitting a fly with a sledge hammer. You will spend more time cleaning equipment than anything else. I've sprayed all kinds of finishes with my airbrush...from dyes, stains, lacquer, acrylics. I use a double action Badger. Plus, a fun toy!

Re: Spraysystem for finishes

#12

Specs

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>That will depend on the gun. Full size guns call for 5 CFM or better, however there are compact guns that take less, I think. You'll have to check their requirements. When I get a chance. I'll see if I can find you a few links.

mm

Re: Spraysystem for finishes

#13

Re: Spraysystem for finishes

Stuart Johnson

>I have a Critter and it works very well with easy clean up. I have only used it on flat work but I think it would work very well for small turning jobs. At around $40 it might be worth trying.

Re: Spraysystem for finishes

#14

Critter or read all the posts..

Stuart Johnson

>I saw after my post about the Critter it had already been discussed. I have used mine for spraying cabinets It is a little slow but it should work with a bed. You will have more over spray than with other units. I have bought two of them for around $40 but that was several years ago so it doesn't surprise me that the price has gone up.

Re: Spraysystem for finishes

#15

Re: Spraysystem for finishes *LINK*

nailshooter

>I have to say, I am a little more than dumbfounded at reading not to use HVLP with solvent finishes. What about the thousands of us that do? I have used the Apollo, Graco and Turbinaire systems before, ALL with solvent based finishes - no latex.

But I have found that my Fuji pro (highest volume turbine out there) is the best system I have ever used, and it was recommended to me by some of the best finishers locally as well as on the net. I have used it for over a year, and it has paid for itself many times in the work I have done in restoration at a local historical building where overspray cannot be tolerated. The money is saved on material savings as well as the lack of cleanup and prep due to less overspray. I finish/refinish doors, tables, wood paneling, etc. all the time and no other system goes to the job with me.

BTW, if you are interested, I shoot >super high< VOC conversion lacquers as well as low solid high flash industrial enamels. And I do that in humid South Texas heat; I don't shut down because it is summer. You do have to learn to proper thinning, pressure requirements, etc. for your gun and your material, but once you have that down you are good to go and can spray with wild abandon. My only limitation is in the summer, when I have found that I cannot spray outside with my conversion materials when it is over 100 degrees. But I can still spray commercial grade polyurethanes - even in the heat.

Go by any professional (not HD) finisher's supply house and ask them about shooting solvent based through HVLP compared to latex.

You will be surprised... none of us in my area use latex in our machines. None of us want any kind of water or residue in the guns, packings, seals or workings. We all keep cheap conversion guns around for latex. For me, I have a small airless that has a finish tip and a broad tip, and it is for latex only.

My system cost about $1600 and could be had for a LOT less by someone that doesn't need all the different tips, hose extensions, filters, etc. that I use.

I am thinking that your experience might be with one of those $100 machines. Although, some have reported good luck with those.

If OP is still following this, I would look at this gun at the link below. I have it and use it a lot, and it shoots as well (sadly) as a $250 SATA gun. I use mine a lot when I have a small job as I can just pull air off a job compressor or one in my shop. Out of this gun I have shot water based, and mineral solvent based as well as high VOC. If the link doesn't work, try the harborfreight site, item #90977. It even comes with its own regulator on the handle. It is really easy to clean, too. It is not true HVLP, but a conversion gun which is almost as good.

I will never go back to high pressure guns (and in many states like CA professionals cannot use them) even though I like them. I learned on them, and I can set the gun up while asleep, but that was yesterday's technology. The is a learning curve when starting with HVLP, but the rewards are plenty.

Robert


http://tinyurl.com/y24n6g

Re: Spraysystem for finishes

#16

Re: Spraysystem for finishes

David Galloway

>Highland Hardware is carrying the Critter. I can't remember the pricing.

Re: Spraysystem for finishes

#17

Re: Spraysystem for finishes

Russ Fairfield

>Personally, I think that an HVLP system is overkill for turned wood. Spraying of any finish on turned wood is overkill.

There isn't a finish that we would use on a piece of turned wood that can't be done faster and a lot cheaper with thinning and wiping; and the results will be equal or better than spraying.

I could make a case for spraying lacquer; but don't believe for a minute that the next coat of a lacquer will burn into the previous coat and make the flaws disappear. Dust pimples, sags, and runs are accented by subsequent coats. They will not disappear. They will only be magnified.

Having said all of that, I sometimes use a cheap detail gun to apply lacquer when I want to use a lot of coats (sometimes 27 the way I count them). Less coats than that and I wipe lacquer same as everything else.

The only difference between a cheap gun and an expensive system is measured by how much sanding is required between coats to remove the orange peel, sags, runs, and overspray. Dust pimples are a function of how clean the air in our spraying area. The critter is totally adequate for spraying lacquer on turned work; but I have better control and prefer the results I get from the gun that I bought for $5 out of the back of a truck in a Holiday Inn parking lot.

Re: Spraysystem for finishes

#18

Re: Spraysystem for finishes

eaglesc

>Harbor Freight air brush for thinned lacquers.

$5.00 on sale

Re: Spraysystem for finishes

#19

Mitigating Dumbfoundedness

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I too used a turbine gun (Fuji 3-stage) for solvent finishing, and was able to get "acceptable" results with lacquer and shellac, but only with a lot of fussing over retarders, wetting agents, and extenders. The waterbornes, on the other hand, went on beautifully and were near good "off-the-gun" without being rubbed out on flatwork, except for table tops.

But when I started spray finishing turnings it simply wasn't worth the fuss to have to sand and level out the orange peel that always arose because the retarders needed to allow flow and leveling of the film resulted in sags on the curved surfaces. I therefore sold my Fuji system and changed to a Walcom HVLP conversion gun. The difference in both solvent and waterborne finishes was outstanding without having to play chemist or cook.

Bob asked about getting into spray finishing without taking a second mortgage on the ranch. I therefore doubt he's fired up to lay out $7-800 for a good turbine set like Apollo or others. Moreover, buying some cheapo $100 knockoff HVLP unit is not ever going to do what he wants on a turning, and will just wind up in the Bin of Junk Tools under his bench. For solvent work, he's better off with a critter or some $150 gravity-fed conversion or even an airbrush.

You're entitled to your view, of course, hyperbole and all.

mm

Re: Spraysystem for finishes

#20

Anyone familiar with this one? *LINK*

Bob Fawcett

>This is the first one that popped up on a Google search.

I remember Gleam from my search for an airless when I painted all the porches on my house. (1600 spare feet).


HVLP conversion gun

Re: Spraysystem for finishes

#21

Re: Mitigating Dumbfoundedness

nailshooter

>"If solvents are your goal, a turbine-driven gun is NOT the way to go."

Sorry, I thought I understood what you were saying but I guess I misinterpreted your post. As mentioned farther down in this thread, I too have friends not me that use small turbine powered air brushes for effects and for finishing on the lathe using solvent based lacquers, paints and even polyurethane.

It seems to work fine for them.

Re: Spraysystem for finishes

#22

Re: Bob, the only thing I spray

Allen Neighbors

>is Pre-catalyzed Waterwhite Gloss Lacquer, thinned 20% with 1/2 oz of retarder per quart.. I use a cheap, 1 quart, "Buffalo" brand spray gun that I bought at a surplus store here in town. I use 30 to 32 PSI. And I used a porter cable pancake for two years.

I've cleaned this gun probably twice in the 8 or 10 years I've had it. I've only emptied the gun those times. (except when it runs out). The lacquer stays in it until I have to put more in it. If it sits for two days or two months, when I need it I get it down off the hook, connect the air hose, run my finger across the nozzle a time or two, and spray. Every couple of weeks I drop the nozzle into a small jar of lacquer thinner. That's it.

I have used it on kitchen cabinets that I've built, and on bandsaw boxes, but it's now just used on woodturnings. It takes a little time to get the adjustments right for your own spraying technique, but once it's adjusted, it's done; it works well, and I get quality finishes with it.

(One time I needed to spray some white paint, and I bought a second gun just like the old Buffalo. I've only used that gun once. But it was worth it, just to keep the paint out of my lacquer gun.)

If you only want to spray lacquer, it's a snap. If you want to use other solvent based finishes you'll have to clean the gun after each use.

I have an enclosed-motor 26" fan that exhausts the overspray outside, into the alley behind my shop, so I don't even have to wear a mask. I have a raised stand with a lazy susan on it, and I spray towards the fan.

No need to go to a lot of expense unless you want to.

Re: Spraysystem for finishes

#23

Re: Mitigating Dumbfoundedness *LINK*

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Mark,

I bought this conversion gun from Apollo back in August and after a little bit of getting the setting right for shooting Lacquer un-thinned, it has been a fantastic gun.

If some one already had an air compressor, with current conversion gun technology, I can't see spending $7-800 for a turbine.

As I said I bought this for about $375 (I think) and since paid another $50 or so for a full variety of nozzles and air caps.

Mark


http://www.hvlp.com/conversionguns/7500.htm

Re: Spraysystem for finishes

#24

Re: Bob, the only thing I spray

Brian McInturff in SC

>Boy Mark don't say that around the professional refinishers. I finished professionally and would only use an HVLP. I think Jeff Jewitt still uses an HVLP also. I spray a lot of catalyzed laquers and varnishes. Brian

Re: Spraysystem for finishes

#25

Re: Mitigating Dumbfoundedness

nailshooter

>Mark-

You know, they didn't have this when I went to a paint/finish mini vendor convention about a year and a half ago. The Apollo rep there told me about this magic gun and he was excited as he could be. I couldn't believe that they would have a gun that would use either turbine or air as a source without any performance loss. Then to top that off, the ability to use it as a pressure feed (can on bottom) or gravity feed (can on top) seemed an awful lot to put in one package.

It sounded like a pipe dream, especially when the Apollo rep was telling me it would sell for about the same as a regular turbine HVLP. The only thing I didn't like about the Apollo guns was the fact that they were all "bleeders". Now that I have a bleeder that I use for stains etc., it isn't as big a deal as I thought it would be.

So is this magic gun a bleeder or closed? This would certainly be worth bringing to the attention of my fellow finish slingers. Too late now for me, but this could have saved me some real dough when I was looking at full systems...

Robert