Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

bowl saver - yet again!

Posts

bowl saver - yet again!

#1

bowl saver - yet again!

John Pickett

>I've heard some very good arguements for both the McNaughton and One Way Systems. Seems like everybody has an opinion, but it seems to come down to personal preference.

I saw a demonstration of the McNaughton system several years ago at Texas Turn or Two, but would like to see it again and one of the one way system as well. Does anybody know when & where I might be able to see one?

Re: bowl saver - yet again!

#2

Re: bowl saver - yet again!

Russ Fairfield

>Bill Grumbine can help you with the McNaughton demonstration, and you can go to the Oneway website for a vifeo on their Bowl Saver.

Re: bowl saver - yet again!

#3

Re: bowl saver - yet again!

Gordon Seto

>Greg Jensen who is the McNaughton rep, demoed at the Louisville Symposium last year.

Happy New Year

Gordon

Re: bowl saver - yet again!

#4

Re: bowl saver - yet again!

MIke from St. Clair Shores

>John,

The biggest difference is that the McNaughton system allows you to core the bowl how you want to. If you want a deep bowl or a shallow one it's your choice. I have this one and like it alot. The oneway is probably a great system ( i own 3 of their chucks, 2 complete sharpening systems, the termite tool and 3 double ended bowl gouges and 2 of their handles) I think that they make awesome stuff. That being said, I don't like the bowl saver, because it swings a dedicated arc and the bowls you core will will always be the same size and shape. If that is not an issue then the choice will be simple.

Mike

Re: bowl saver - yet again!

#5

Oneway not always the same profile

Mike Brazeau

>With the Oneway, by offsetting from center and varying the depth setting, you do change the ultimate shape of the bowl from a hemisphere to a gentle arc. This is perhaps not as flexible as the McNaughton, but is really repeatable, effortless and almost foolproof to use. So far has not impaired the finished product for me. You get to know what will work and what won't.

Re: bowl saver - yet again!

#6

Re: Oneway not always the same profile

John Pickett

>Thanks Mike AND Mike B. That is why I really would like to see an up close and personal demonstration of each.

Of course, its not like I can afford one right now anyway right on the heels of Christmas, getting my wife ready for her trip to London, fixing my daughter's car, ad nauseam. LOL

Maybe by the time I figure out which one I want I can actually afford it!

Re: bowl saver - yet again!

#7

Re: Oneway not always the same profile

Bill Neddow

>I agree with Mike B. The Oneway is a lot more flexible than some people believe. Just remember that both the Oneway and Kelton-McNaughton are tools bent to form a portion of a circle. The curves may differr in radius but both systems cut arcs. If you are cutting an egg shape with a Kelton, you are cutting several curves -- deep down in the wood where you cannot see what is going on. I would rather pop the core out with the Oneway and shape it where I can see what curves I am getting.

Re: bowl saver - yet again!

#8

Re: bowl saver - yet again!

robo hippy

>I have all 3 of the systems. I use the McNaughton the most, primarily because it is the most versatile. The only thing that you can't core with it is a hollow form. It is cheaper and a lot easier to sharpen than the Oneway (you have to remove the tip, and hold it to the grinder, then put it back on). From a production turner standpoint, the McNaughton is also faster to set up and core with. The down side to it is that there is a learning curve. Since you can't see where the blade and it isn't on a pivoting center, is you have to guess exactly where the tip is. McNaughton does make a laser pointer that goes with the system. It hasn't improved my aim yet, but it does let me know when I need to change course. For removing cores much over 14 inches in diameter, I do prefer the Oneway. That support finger does make for a lot less chatter. Having to turn the lathe off and move the support finger does take extra time in the coring process. I do wish the McNaughton blades had a bit more curve to some of them.

robo hippy

Re: bowl saver - yet again!

#9

Re: bowl saver - yet again!

David Walser

>Robo,

Since you said you have all three systems, and you mentioned circumstances in which you prefer the McNaughton to the Oneway, and vice versa; are we to assume that the Woodcut is never your preferred option?