Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Disc Sander of choice

Posts

Disc Sander of choice

#1

Disc Sander of choice

Jim O in Davenport IA

>I'm thinking of trying some segmented turning. I have read several books, all seem to rely on a large disc sander for trueing the segments. Are their any recommededed sanders? I'm looking at the Delta 12" and the Jet 12". Also ginving some thought to the Rigid oscillating belt sander. All opinions welcome!

Thanks in advance!

Re: Disc Sander of choice

#2

Re: Disc Sander of choice *LINK*

Ralph

>I didn't like the feel of either the Jet or the Delta, nor the one from Harbor Freight. I ended up with the one from Woodworkers Supply


model

Re: Disc Sander of choice

#3

Re: Disc Sander of choice

Stuart Johnson

>Stay away from Harbor Freight. I bought one based on the price and found it is really worth only tenth of what I paid. The table will not line up square no matter what I do which makes the miter slot worthless.

Re: Disc Sander of choice

#4

Re: Disc Sander of choice

Russ Fairfield

>My choice was to make my own with an MDF disc mounted to the lathe.

Besides not costing more than the price of the sanding disc, the biggest benefit is that it has variable speed. All of the commercial sanders run at 1750 RPM or higher, some at 3600 RPM, and that removes too much wood too fast. To me, it is easier to make a whisper of a cut at 200 RPM than it is at 2000. The high speed also improves the chance of burning the wood surface, and that makes for poor glue joints.

Having a fixed table for 90-degrees and whatever other angles I use means that they are always accurate without having to do a lot of test cuts and tweaking every time an adjustable table is moved.


img

Re: Disc Sander of choice

#5

Re: Disc Sander of choice

Stuart Johnson

>Russ, How do you make sure the angle across the face is correct? I wanted to use mine to tweak the segmented angles. Your lathe mounted one especially using the vs sure beats what I have but I just don't see how you set the correct angle.

Re: Disc Sander of choice

#6

That's a darn good idea, Russ!

Nancy Jubb/ Eddie Pacheco, IChillin' in Denver

>It saves money, shop space, another cord to run, and any additional tool maintenanne worries. Now if I can just obtain the nicely built,white motor drive gizmo for it.

Re: Disc Sander of choice

#7

skip the small stuff and go for 15" or bigger

Robin Corell

>I think the best small disk sander ever made is the State MFG 15". I believe it is still being made but be prepared for serious sticker shock when shelling out for a new top quallity disc sander. Even used some of the quallity sanders purchased from a used machinery dealer can sell for upwards of $100 per inch, ie a 15" can go for $1,500.

I don't do segment turning but I do use my disk sander extensively. being trained as a patternmaker you get to the piont of not being able to sharpen a pencil without turning on the disk sander. I would never consider buying a disk sander smaller than 15" and would rather have a 20". The reason I recomend a larger disk is that working near the center of the disk tends to burn the wood, especially with disc grits finer than 40. with a larger disk you have a larger area to work withoug having to use the center. It sounds odd but it is easier and safer to use the whole width of the disk with a larger diameter disk. with a small disk it is not advisable to use the whole width. on a 20 or 24 it is not dificult to control a board across the full with, and an experianced user can easilly use the full with on a 15".

A good quallity disk sander of any size will have: cast and machined trunions rather than pressed sheet metal. A dynamically ballanced cast disc with steel being prefered over aluminium. A large 3/4 -1" shaft if the disk is mounted directly to the motor. double row bearings with high thrust capacity if the disk is mounted on a carrier shaft. A continuous duty 1 hp motor. and upwards of 300lbs. The top quallity machines and all 20" or larger machines should have gear driven table tilt mechanisims.

some vintage brands to look for would be in no particular order: Master, Apex-Rankin, Yates J-line, Max, State, Oliver. The most affordable is likely to be the Yates or the Max.

An occilating belt will not produce a perfectly straight edge. I was amused by the recent pick in the FWW article on OSS sanders of the ridged machine as the autors best choice. It seems like it was the choice because it was also a belt sander. I think it is actually a poor coice of a belt sander or a OSS. For the results that your investment of time warrents you should look for quallity equipment and that costs money. Think of the quallity of lathes that are popular by the experianced turners here and the cost compared to a Ridged machine that will turn round objects.

If you are in the central coast area of California feel free to drop me a line and come test drive my 15" Max to get a feel for what an industrial disk sander is like.

Robin Corell


img

Re: Disc Sander of choice

#8

Re: Disc Sander of choice

Jim O in Davenport IA

>I had not thought of that - I only have a midi lathe. Swing would limit me to about a 8" Disc. Any idea on sources for the disc?

Re: Disc Sander of choice

#9

Re: skip the small stuff and go for 15" or bigger

Jim O in Davenport IA

>Understand and appreciate the comments - However my shop is not the largest and I have very limited room for the sander. I'd love a 15 or 20" but cannot go that route right now.

THanks for the other info.

Re: Disc Sander of choice

#10

Re: Disc Sander of choice

Ralph

>All you need is some 8 inch discs, some MDF and a face-plate. Attach an MDF disc to the face-plate, turn it and stick the sandpaper disc to the MDF disc

Re: Disc Sander of choice

#11

Re: Disc Sander of choice

Ralph

>There are some designs in Tibbet's book that should be adaptable to this system.

Re: Disc Sander of choice

#12

Re: Disc Sander of choice

Russ Fairfield

>In use with an angled fence that is set with a template that has been cut to the angle. It works.

Sanding is required when the segments are cut with a bandsaw. I prefer to use a miter saw or tablesaw with a sled because the cut is clean and there is no sanding.


img

Re: Disc Sander of choice

#13

15-in. Oliver

David

>This is a great disc sander I inherited from my father's shop, a Oliver that uses 24 grit discs 15" in diameter. I have rubbed away many parts of my fingers on this sander, but it is great for getting a lot of material off and when squared to the table is a great tool to sand boxes and cubes. Not your peel and stick type discs of today--I have to soak the platter in water for a day to get the old paper off and glue down a new disc with white glue, applying pressure evenly over the top of the disc until the white glue dries. Attach with three countersink bolts and you have a fresh disc ready to go. Watch out for your knuckles!

Re: Disc Sander of choice

#14

Forgot photo! 

David

>


img

Re: Disc Sander of choice

#15

Keith Tompkins

Re: skip the small stuff and go for 15" or bigger

Keith Tompkins

>Good post, Robin...gotta love that old industrial iron....

Re: Disc Sander of choice

#16

Re: Disc Sander of choice

Malcolm Tibbetts

>Jim, a good quality disc sander is perhaps the most important tool in a segmenter's shop. There are many uses besides just adjusting miter angles. Avoid the cheap options; you will regret wasting your money. Russ's solution is worth pursuing, especially if money is a big issue. I make my living assembling segmented constructions and I would quit doing what I do, if I had to give up my 20" sander. Good luck with your future segmentations.


img

Re: Disc Sander of choice

#17

Re: Disc Sander of choice

Jim O in Davenport IA

>Malcolm,

Received 'the art of segmented wood turning' for xmas. You helped to inspire me to try this out. Thanks!

Re: Disc Sander of choice

#18

Re: Disc Sander of choice - long

Mkauder, Phenix City, AL Paris france today

>As I often say at demos, "Get 4 segmented turners in a room, and you have at least 10 ways to make segmented bowls".

This is my opinion only - not the start of some argument:

If you are going to do alot of segmenting (it is 90% of what I do, and 100% of what Malcolm does) then a big 20" model is a good way to go - especially if you are going to do work larger than 12-14" in diameter.

IMHO - if you are going to be a sometime turner, not varying the number of segments in a ring, then building a dedicated TS sled is the way to go ONLY IF YOU ARE WILLING TO SPEND THE MONEY FOR A DECENT BLADE. Your Forrest WWII will not really cut it if you want to make really good joints. You need an "Ultra-fine crosscut" blade. 80-100 teeth (not a plywood blade) many of this blades are meant to cut veneers, composites, etc. They have only slicer teeth, no rakers. A cut from one of these blades leave a highly polished finish (when decently sharp) as good as most sanders. My fave is the Forrest Dura-line AT, cost's around $150, however, I have found that a $60 Rigid 90 tooth blade available at Home Depot does a pretty good job.

Having said all that - making a dedicated sled will cost you a 1/4 sheet of 1/2"-3/4" good quality (flat) plywood, and some time. I have sleds for 12, 24, 36, & 72 segments. After figeting with them over time, they cut perfectly (almost) everytime.

On the occasion the I have need to make an adjustment I do use a disk sander. All I can say is - 6" is better that 4", 10" is better than 6". 12" is better than 10" and so on. I have graduated though the sizes as I have improved my equipment. I currently use a Delta 12" stand-alone that I like very much. A newer version of the one that Kurt Theobald uses. I am sure that I will drool over the 20" Powermatic for a while, and hope to own one, one day.

You can do segmented work with whatever tools you have, and then expand as your interest increases.

Mark

Re: Disc Sander of choice

#19

Shooting Board?

Bob Fawcett

>Have any of you that do a lot of segmented work ever considered a shooting board and a hand plane?

Re: Disc Sander of choice

#20

Re: Shooting Board?

Malcolm Tibbetts

>Bob, it just wouldn't be practical. Segmented turnings can contain 100's or even 1,000's of pieces. The ability to quickly produce consistent quality glue joints is key. Mark's comments make a lot of sense for those that are just starting down this road. BTW, I have also found the Rigid blade to be a good value - I use the 12", 100 tooth model.

Re: Disc Sander of choice

#21

Re: Shooting Board?

Russ Fairfield

>Besides Malcolm's book, I recommend the one that Dale Nish wrote about Ray Allen. It shows the tools he used and how to make some of the jigs and fixtures he used for making duplicate pieces that are accurate and repeatable pieces. It is worth the price to the beginner for the patterns.

Re: Disc Sander of choice

#22

Re: Disc Sander of choice

Jim O in Davenport IA

>Thanks to all - appreciate your comments & tips.

I just ordered the Jet 12" Stationary Sander with integrated dust collection. Should be here next week sometime. Just can't justify space or $$$ for something bigger at this point. I'd rather put the $$$ towards a bigger lathe.