Re: Disc Sander of choice - long
Mkauder, Phenix City, AL Paris france today
>As I often say at demos, "Get 4 segmented turners in a room, and you have at least 10 ways to make segmented bowls".
This is my opinion only - not the start of some argument:
If you are going to do alot of segmenting (it is 90% of what I do, and 100% of what Malcolm does) then a big 20" model is a good way to go - especially if you are going to do work larger than 12-14" in diameter.
IMHO - if you are going to be a sometime turner, not varying the number of segments in a ring, then building a dedicated TS sled is the way to go ONLY IF YOU ARE WILLING TO SPEND THE MONEY FOR A DECENT BLADE. Your Forrest WWII will not really cut it if you want to make really good joints. You need an "Ultra-fine crosscut" blade. 80-100 teeth (not a plywood blade) many of this blades are meant to cut veneers, composites, etc. They have only slicer teeth, no rakers. A cut from one of these blades leave a highly polished finish (when decently sharp) as good as most sanders. My fave is the Forrest Dura-line AT, cost's around $150, however, I have found that a $60 Rigid 90 tooth blade available at Home Depot does a pretty good job.
Having said all that - making a dedicated sled will cost you a 1/4 sheet of 1/2"-3/4" good quality (flat) plywood, and some time. I have sleds for 12, 24, 36, & 72 segments. After figeting with them over time, they cut perfectly (almost) everytime.
On the occasion the I have need to make an adjustment I do use a disk sander. All I can say is - 6" is better that 4", 10" is better than 6". 12" is better than 10" and so on. I have graduated though the sizes as I have improved my equipment. I currently use a Delta 12" stand-alone that I like very much. A newer version of the one that Kurt Theobald uses. I am sure that I will drool over the 20" Powermatic for a while, and hope to own one, one day.
You can do segmented work with whatever tools you have, and then expand as your interest increases.
Mark