Re: Truth is;
Greg Haugen
>Ok, whoever Reality Check is does have a few points that are right. One thing first, you will get everybody to agree on a way to sharpen when everyone agrees on a certain grind angle is the right one and everything else is wrong. It won't happen. Jordan, Ellsworth, and Mahoney do like their gouges directly off of a grinder. The grits for these guys range from 50 to 100 for sharpening. So that is even different. The angles they use are also different, Jordan likes one in the 60 range, Ellsworth has his own, and Mahoney likes them in the 40-45 range. Bowl turners have one thought on sharpening. Spindle turners have another. Both works for what its being used for. Can a bowl gouge be razer sharp and polished inside and out and cut? Yes. Does it have to be, no. Alan Lacer, known for skews and spindles, diamond hones every surface on every tool. That's why the hone he sells from alanlacer.com has radiused sides on them. You also have to take into account the tools you use. What's the steel? The size of a tool, a 3/8" gouge will leave a better surface than a 1/2". Watch Mahoney's From the Tree to the Table video its great example of this. Also if a piece of wood is bone dry it will cut harder than an air dry "equalized" piece.
I do have a Tormek. I do love it. I'm also a spindle turner more than a bowl turner. Spindles pay better. :-) If I turn a bowl though I don't "always" use the Tormek on the gouge. I won't start sanding a bowl at 220 or above like I do most of my spindles. I know that because of the grain and cutting action. I will Tormek a gouge though if the bowl is a crotch piece. Sharper the better with chaotic grain like that.
Facts: the glint reflection off of the edge is an easy and painless way to check the sharpness. You can tell areas that aren't sharp and what is sharp. Cutting a piece of paper can hide a dull spot with sharp spots around it.
Will a Tormek work, yes. Will a dry grinder work without honing, yes, with honing yes.
When in doubt, grind and/or hone it again.
Greg