Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

How do you tell for certain it's sharp

Posts

How do you tell for certain it's sharp

#1

How do you tell for certain it's sharp

Jim Rutten

>Here's my question. Before Chistmas, I purchased a tormek at an auction. I love it, but one of the bowls I made out of cherry had terrible, and I mean horrible, tearout. I have made bowls before and none of them had tearout to even approach this. My first question is could this tear out be completely from my bad technique? My second question is how do you tell if your bowl gouge is really sharp. I know people say look at the edge and if you can't see on it's sharp. Well, I don't see an edge but that seems like an inexact methodology. So, there is my basic question. How do you tell if your bowl gouge is sharp. Thanks in advance for your learned responses.

Re: How do you tell for certain it's sharp

#2

Re: How do you tell for certain it's sharp

Dave Belser

>Jim when you are "looking at the edge" are you standing with a light behind you and trying to catch a glint off of the edge? If you do this properly you can see the tiniest of defects, it is actually of the best ways to look for defects in the edge.

- Dave

Re: How do you tell for certain it's sharp

#3

Re: How do you tell for certain it's sharp

john lucas

>Your right Jim I'm thinking right now and I'm not sure I know how to tell by simply looking. Put the gouge so the light is at an angle that would bounce off the edge like a mirror. If there are any reflections that one spot might be dull but the rest might be sharp. Of course if there's a huge long reflection then all of that area is dull.

You will often have a burr in the inside of the gouge that will cause a glint similar to an area that hasn't been sharpened. I use a diamond fish hook sharpening tool to remove this burr. It's a long skinny cone shaped tool with diamond dust on the outside. If you use something like this the no edge visual check might work.

You can't really slice newspaper or shave hair off your arm like I do with knives. I can usually tell by cutting some wood. A fresh edge cuts even the hardest wood like butter. Granted you can't push the tool as quickly through pecan as you can Cedar but it still cuts easily with very little pressure on the tool. Of course you could run your finger across the edge and see how deep it cuts but you really only want to do that once or twice by accident, it's not fun.

One way I can usually tell is to take a very light cut. If the tool skips out of the cut it's dull. A sharp tool will take and extremely thin cut without coming out as long as your doing your job right and staying on the bevel. That's usually how I tell when I use a students tool. I'll make a quick light cut and I can usually tell right then. I'll sharpen it and give it back to them and let them feel the difference.

How does a beginner tell.? Im not really sure other than what I've just mentioned. I will be very interested in the responses.

Re: How do you tell for certain it's sharp

#4

Steven Antonucci

in addition... the sound

steve antonucci

>A sharp gouge will not only cut as John has mentioned, but it makes a ver high pitch hissing sound through the cut. It's funny, but my 8 year old can hear the difference, and it's impossible to miss if you're listening. It should almost sound like a leaky tire.

Steve

Re: How do you tell for certain it's sharp

#5

Re: How do you tell for certain it's sharp

Jake Niedling

>Jim - First to address your question regarding tearout. Your problem could be technique, but here is the order I would put together regarding the potential for tearout ( Highest to lowest). 1. - wood type & condition, 2.- Wood grain orientation on lathe, 3.- Cutting Technique (cutting or scraping), 4.- Tool sharpness.

I usually tell if my tools are sharp when I go to use them and how much pressure it takes to make a cut. This assumes that I am just touching up the edges using my Wolervine jig and not regrinding for profile. When I have someone I am teaching how to grind, I always use a black sharpie pen and color the entire grinding edge. This makes it very easy to see what has been sharpen and what needs more work. If your setup is very repeatable and you sharpen often, it should just take a few seconds to put the sharp edge back on the tool. I usually only do heavy re-grinding when I buy a new tool to get it to my desired shape. Good luck.

Re: How do you tell for certain it's sharp

#6

Re: That's an excellent question Jim,...

Jamie Donaldson

>.. and I don't have a precise anwser for it?? We learn thru experience how a sharp edge feels, but hard to verbalize to a novice? The learning experience often involves the shedding of blood, but a bowl gouge is not easily tested other than by feel or visual inspection under a magnifier.

Re: How do you tell for certain it's sharp

#7

Re: How do you tell for certain it's sharp

Sean Troy

>You know you had a perfect grind when you bump the tool off the lathe and it lands right on the point taking a chip out of it. LOL

Re: How do you tell for certain it's sharp

#8

When you slip and it goes 1/4" into your thumb...

Jay Kilpatrick in TX

>DAMHIKT...please!

Re: How do you tell for certain it's sharp

#9

Re: That's an excellent question Jim,...

Wilford Bickel

>Jamie, I finally figured out that sealing the cut up with CA glue was better than having to explain to the LOML how I cut my finger checking an edge AGAIN while going by her to get a bandaid!!!

Re: How do you tell for certain it's sharp

#10

Re: How do you tell for certain it's sharp

bob davis

>i think you know by feel.i decided that i might be able to call myself a woodturner when icould determine a tool needed sharpening

Re: How do you tell for certain it's sharp

#11

Re: How do you tell for certain it's sharp

Jim Rutten

>Your answers have caused me to think back to what I did and I just realized that I did all the hollowing on this 6" bowl in one sharpen. It probably would have been better to hit the Tormek again right before doing the last shaping and maybe again for my finishing cut. But it's stiil an interesting topic. Is there a way to quantify and measure sharpness? Do machine shops measure sharpness of their tools and if so how? How about industrial machining? Is there a way to build a jig to measure sharpness? It's just one area where I don't feel comfortable saying my tools are sharp. On a side note Jamie, you mentioned looking at it with a magnifying glass. What would you look for?

Re: How do you tell for certain it's sharp

#12

Re: Sharp tools cut, dull tools don't

Russ Fairfield

>

Re: How do you tell for certain it's sharp

#13

Truth is;

Reality Check

>The truth is:

Save your Tormek for your carving tools & spindle turning tools. There is no better edge to turn bowls and side grain than the micro serrated edge you get off a grinder. Kinda like trying to use a sharp smooth edge to cut soft bread, just can�t do it with out smashing and mangling the bread. Don�t believe me, I�m not a professional turner, but ask the real pro�s like Ellsworth & Jordan or any other pro out there(I have heard their answers about Tormek). The truth is, NONE of them use the Tormek for there general turning tools. Hit your gouge with the grinding wheel and watch most of the tear out go away. As fine as tool as the Tormek is: it has little practical use for the turning most of us do, it may have some benefits to those who spindle turn and for carving tools, and its great for sharpening scissors and pocket knives. For Bowls? I can do a whole pile a bowls by the time most get through messing around with the Tormek to sharpen their bowl gouge. I know most who invested in the Tormek will disagree�and that�s ok

Reality check

Re: How do you tell for certain it's sharp

#14

Re: That's an excellent question Jim,...

john lucas

>Wiford Then you have to explain why you have two fingers glued together but that might be less painful than living with the I told you so when she sees the cut.

Re: How do you tell for certain it's sharp

#15

Re: How do you tell for certain it's sharp

john lucas

>Sean you are so correct. A tool always lands on the sharpest area, that's a given.

Re: How do you tell for certain it's sharp

#16

Re: How do you tell for certain it's sharp

john lucas

>Jim Jamie brought up a really good way to tell. It's the same thing I mentioned, looking at the edge under reflected light. You should not be able to see the edge reflect any light. The idea is 2 planes comes together at a point which doesn't reflect light. A small hand loop would let you look closer. If you see any reflections, those areas haven't been hit by the grinder or hone.

Re: How do you tell for certain it's sharp

#17

Re: If you can see a light reflection....

Jamie Donaldson

>... from the edge of a cutting tool it indicates a flat or unsharp area. The edge is sharp if you can't see it without magnification. But that doesn't mean an invisible edge is sharp???

Re: How do you tell for certain it's sharp

#18

Re: Truth is;

Jim Rutten

>Please forgive me for sounding rude if I do, but I am much more inclined to believe someone who uses his name in this forum instead of a moniker. Thank you for your opinion, though.

Re: How do you tell for certain it's sharp

#19

For all practical purposes....

Dave Belser

>yes an invisible edge is sharp. Thats why looking for a glint off of the edge is actually a really good test. If there is still a burr on the edge from grinding or if the light angle is wrong it can be hard to look for the glint. I find it best to have a single source of light over your shoulder and to be looking at a darker background. But once you get used to the technique it's not hard to do.

As John said, two planes will come together and form a line in a perfect geometrical sense. You should not be able to "see" (width) the line as it only has 2 dimensions.

- Dave

Re: How do you tell for certain it's sharp

#20

How long does it last?

Stuart Johnson

>Okay now that there is no glint what will one or two medium passes on say hard Maple do to that super fine edge? I am probably off base but it seems like spending that much time on the edge isn't that necessary until the single final pass. I don't mean using a dull tool but a quick swipe with the grinder whether freehand or with a jig should be all that is required.

Re: How do you tell for certain it's sharp

#21

Re: How long does it last?

john lucas

>I think were talking about 2 different things. One is to get an edge that doesn't have any dull areas. This can be done straight off the grinder. The other is honing an edge so the grooves left my the grinder are smaller. I personally don't hone anything but the skew unless I'm really having trouble with the wood. Then I might hone it to see if that helps. Usually it does. I just find for general turning straight off the grinder with a 60 or 80 grit wheel is fine.

Re: How do you tell for certain it's sharp

#22

I misunderstood

Stuart Johnson

>Sorry, I misunderstood and thought folks were talking about routinely using a grinder then honing to a super razor sharp edge.

Re: How do you tell for certain it's sharp

#23

Re: Truth is;

Skip Beardsley

>Alan Lacer says the tool is scary sharp when your finger starts to bleed when it get within one quarter inch of the tool

The best way I know to learn is to work with someone who really knows how to sharpen tools. Another way is to join AAW and get the cd they sent out last year. It did a lot for my understanding of the entire sharpening process.

Re: How do you tell for certain it's sharp

#24

Re: It's more feel than visual

Steve in NC

>Jim

I have not been at this long but every time I turn I learn more about proper sharpening and grinds.

Rather than using anything visual, I usually tell if a tool is sharp by the way it cuts. I keep my grinder next to my lathe and sharpen my tools as soon as I have to start to push a tool to get it to cut. The minute spent sharpening it time well spent.

A sharp tool feels and sounds "right". If after I sharpen a tool it does not cut as expected, I go right back to the grinder and try again. After a while it becomes instinct.

Happy Turning

Steve

Re: How do you tell for certain it's sharp

#25

Re: Truth is;

Greg Haugen

>Ok, whoever Reality Check is does have a few points that are right. One thing first, you will get everybody to agree on a way to sharpen when everyone agrees on a certain grind angle is the right one and everything else is wrong. It won't happen. Jordan, Ellsworth, and Mahoney do like their gouges directly off of a grinder. The grits for these guys range from 50 to 100 for sharpening. So that is even different. The angles they use are also different, Jordan likes one in the 60 range, Ellsworth has his own, and Mahoney likes them in the 40-45 range. Bowl turners have one thought on sharpening. Spindle turners have another. Both works for what its being used for. Can a bowl gouge be razer sharp and polished inside and out and cut? Yes. Does it have to be, no. Alan Lacer, known for skews and spindles, diamond hones every surface on every tool. That's why the hone he sells from alanlacer.com has radiused sides on them. You also have to take into account the tools you use. What's the steel? The size of a tool, a 3/8" gouge will leave a better surface than a 1/2". Watch Mahoney's From the Tree to the Table video its great example of this. Also if a piece of wood is bone dry it will cut harder than an air dry "equalized" piece.

I do have a Tormek. I do love it. I'm also a spindle turner more than a bowl turner. Spindles pay better. :-) If I turn a bowl though I don't "always" use the Tormek on the gouge. I won't start sanding a bowl at 220 or above like I do most of my spindles. I know that because of the grain and cutting action. I will Tormek a gouge though if the bowl is a crotch piece. Sharper the better with chaotic grain like that.

Facts: the glint reflection off of the edge is an easy and painless way to check the sharpness. You can tell areas that aren't sharp and what is sharp. Cutting a piece of paper can hide a dull spot with sharp spots around it.

Will a Tormek work, yes. Will a dry grinder work without honing, yes, with honing yes.

When in doubt, grind and/or hone it again.

Greg