Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Best qualities of a Spindle Gouge

Posts

Best qualities of a Spindle Gouge

#1

Best qualities of a Spindle Gouge

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Some of you know I have been producing bowl gouges but now it's time to make spindle gouges. If you could start from scratch what would you do. Example; flute shape, radius, depth, lenght etc. etc.

The stock on hand is 3/8, 1/2, 5/8 and 1 inch (the 1" is done). Would you make a 7/16 or 3/4?

I have my thoughts but...

Go for it...

Re: Best qualities of a Spindle Gouge

#2

Re: Best qualities of a Spindle Gouge

MIke from St. Clair Shores

>I like the sorby spindle master. It's flat on top with a round bottom. The front cutting edge is round with a fingernail grind. The grind is polished to a mirror finish. You can make many cuts with it, and they are clean and need very little sanding. Also cuts like a skew. The 1/2 is my favorite, but a 3/8 would also be nice.

Happy Holidays,

Mike

Re: Best qualities of a Spindle Gouge

#3

Re: Best qualities of a Spindle Gouge

GaryG in MD

>How does one maintain a mirror-polished bevel? ...Gary

Re: Best qualities of a Spindle Gouge

#4

Re: Best qualities of a Spindle Gouge

Gordon Seto

>Doug:

I would like to see something along the line of P&N detail gouges. Their shallow flute design allows them to be extended beyond the tool rest farther than other spindle gouges of the same diameter. That sets them apart from the rest when we can't bring the tool rest closer, especially when turning eccentric.

Gordon

Re: Best qualities of a Spindle Gouge

#5

Re: Best qualities of a Spindle Gouge

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Gordon, I never looked at a P&N spindle gouge before (I will) but the less steel milled away makes for a stronger tool. Flute/tool lenght?

Thank you,

Doug

Re: Best qualities of a Spindle Gouge

#6

Re: Best qualities of a Spindle Gouge

don lewonczyk

>Gary, you would use a leather strop with a very fine abrasive paste or as I do. I use a koch sharpenening felt wheel with a green block of abrasive material, I put that against the wheel while it is spinning to coat the wheel surface then put the tool to the wheel and keeping the proper edge angle rock the tool side to side but not keeping the tool in same spot or it will put a grove in the wheel. The heat from the metal against the wheel will cause a thermal reaction and the green stuff will turn black and you watch the edge and when it has a uniformed bead around the entire cutting egde your pretty much done. I do all my carving tools and a lot of my turning tools on that machine once you have the proper grind. I than polish them to a mirror finish in a few minutes and the are razor sharp, plus they stay sharper longer and you save metal on your tools and there isn't any burr to remove. Scrapers need the burr and other tools like that I do on the grinder. Hope I was clear enough to help, it's 4:45am and my head isn't fully awake yet, have a good one. DonL

Re: Best qualities of a Spindle Gouge

#7

Re: Best qualities of a Spindle Gouge

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>I have a "goto" spindle gouge I got from Alan Lacer. I think it only comes in 3/8 but I could be wrong. I would like to see a similar profile in some different sizes. I will send you some specs after the 1st.

Ray

Re: Best qualities of a Spindle Gouge

#8

Re: Best qualities of a Spindle Gouge

Ed Moore

>Mike,

I have found the Sorby Spindlemaster to be too light and flimsy and I don't recommend them to novice turners who come to the shop for help. I have two Packard Spindlemakers that are made from heavier stock and they are excellent tools.

My two "Go To" spindle gouges are from Hamlet, one is a standard 3/8" and the other is the 1/2" detail gouge. Actually, I have two of the detail gouges (2030 and 2060).

Ed

Re: Best qualities of a Spindle Gouge

#9

Re: Best qualities of a Spindle Gouge

john lucas

>I don't know the brand of one of my favorite spindle gouge but it looks a lot like the P@N only it's thinner. I've used the P@N 1/2" and think it's a great tool. I would certainly build one like that with a softly rounded fingernail shape.

My other favorite and probably the one I use the most since many of my projects are small is the 3/8" Packard. It kind of resembles a small bowl gouge and I sharpen it using the Wolverine. I think the flute is a little deep. I prefer a flatter flute for spindle gouges because a deep flute isn't needed and it leaves more steel under the flute making them stiffer. I also have an off brand that looks exactly like the Packard brand but I sharpen it closer to 35 degrees and with a more pointy point. This one is for deep details.

Re: Best qualities of a Spindle Gouge

#10

Re: Best qualities of a Spindle Gouge

Lan Brady

>Gary,,

Only/sharpen/polish the flat surface.

Lan

Re: Best qualities of a Spindle Gouge

#11

Re: Best qualities of a Spindle Gouge

John Kyler

>Ditto, that is what Sorby says.

Never sharpen the polished edge, only hone the flat top side.

Re: Best qualities of a Spindle Gouge

#12

Bowl Gouge TESTIMONIAL

Bernie

>I have used and purchased Doug's "Glaser style" bowl gouges

They are excellent with exceptional fit and finish and

his pricing is very fair. Contact Doug via email and

I know he would love to fill our bowl gouge needs.

Thanks Doug for the great gouges

I am really satisfied with them

Bernie

Re: Best qualities of a Spindle Gouge

#13

Sharp: Two intersecting surfaces, equally honed

Jerry Hall

>At the risk of getting into the obsessive compulsive stage, with bench chisels, plane blades, cabinet scrapers, carving tools, "sharp" is the intersection of two equally polished surfaces which can produce a polished cut. Maybe Sorby recommends honing only one surface because they want to preserve the geometry of the non-flat surface. And/or maybe that is the way they restore the sawtooth ground edge from the non honed surface quickly without needless and potentially destructive grinding. But if one is after the smoothest cut arguably you should hone both surfaces. Otherwise you have an 80 grit texturing tool! That said it won't make much difference after you put a fine piece of sandpaper on it.

Re: Best qualities of a Spindle Gouge

#14

Keith Tompkins

Re: Best qualities of a Spindle Gouge

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Doug, I have the Packard spindle and detail gouges...in 3/8 and 1/2. I use them constantly. I also have a Packard 1/4 spindle gouge...all ground with wings WAY back. This gives clearance in deep cuts, and allows using the tools for hollowing.

The p+n detail gouge is great, except I grind a long side grind on it as well... THEN it's a great hollower.

Re: Best qualities of a Spindle Gouge

#15

Thank you, Ray

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>

Re: Best qualities of a Spindle Gouge

#16

Re: Best qualities of a Spindle Gouge

GaryG in MD

>Thanks guys, I appreciate the tutorial. I learned something from this. ...Garly

Re: Best qualities of a Spindle Gouge

#17

Thank you Bernie

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>

Re: Best qualities of a Spindle Gouge

#18

Re: Best qualities of a Spindle Gouge

don lewonczyk

>Gary didn't ask how to sharpen the gouge, he asked how to maintain the mirror finish which I explained how I do it. How do you polish a mirror finish if for example you dropped yours on the cocrete floor and put a nice big ding in it? All I'm interested in is having a razor sharp tool whether for turning or carving and it has worked for me! Everyone does their own thing, that's what makes us tick and that's what makes us great. DonL

Re: Best qualities of a Spindle Gouge

#19

Re: Best qualities of a Spindle Gouge

John Kyler

>Sorry, I was telling how to keep the polished edge by sharpening it the way Sorby says. As some seem to be sharpening by grinding the polished edge. I use a Cratex wheel to polish surfaces as needed.