Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Dutchmen in a crack

Posts

Dutchmen in a crack

#1

Dutchmen in a crack

eliot d

>I recently had the opportunity to turn 450 year-old Maryland Wye oak. I turned a nice medium sized hollow vessel. But a significant crack, about 1/32 inch wide and about 2 inched long developed along the grain near the bottom. I'd like to salvage this particular vessel with several small dovetail-shaped dutchmen. They will be for show -- not really meant to hold anything together -- although they may actually help keep the crack from getting wider.

I'm confident about making the small dovetail-shaped inserts -- but not about cutting out the negative shapes along the crack and fitting the dutchmen into the cutout areas just right.

Has anyone ever tried this kind of decorative "repair'? I could use some help.

Re: Dutchmen in a crack

#2

Re: Dutchmen in a crack

Dale Cook

>Hi eliot, I have not repaired a crack in the way your thinking about but I have been able to fix some rather large cracks by soaking a paper towel in hot water and placing it over the cracked area. I cover the crack by a couple inches and put it in a plastic bag. I re-wet the towel twice a day until it swells back tight and then super glue it and let it dry. This works best with a finish like lacquer. So far I've had good luck with this.Good luck!

Re: Dutchmen in a crack

#3

Re: Dutchmen in a crack

eliot d

>Thanks Dale,

What I great idea! I definitely will try it. I'm going to do it right now.

Re: Dutchmen in a crack

#4

Re: Dutchmen in a crack

Doug Leite

>Is this what you refer to?

I have installed hundreds of these in Hawaiian Calabashes. The Hawaiian name for them is Peva. We also call them butterflies.

Aloha,

Doug

Re: Dutchmen in a crack

#5

Re: Dutchmen in a crack

Doug Leite

>Is this what you refer to?

I have installed hundreds of these in Hawaiian Calabashes. The Hawaiian name for them is Peva. We also call them butterflies.

Aloha,

Doug


img

Re: Dutchmen in a crack

#6

Re: Dutchmen in a crack

Bill Hale / Woodspinner

>Doug

I have no problem making the insert but how do you do the cut for the insert ? Also how thick is the insert ?

Bill in Casa Grande, AZ.

Re: Dutchmen in a crack

#7

Re: Dutchmen in a crack

eliot d

>I have already tried Dale's alternative, which is to apply moisture to the crack to make it swell together. But I'm still interested in how you do what you call , 'butterflies'. So I hope you can explain your technique.

Re: Dutchmen in a crack

#8

Re: Dutchmen in a crack

eliot d

>Dale, As I said, I tried it, and it worked fairly well. The sides of the piece did come together around the crack, thereby closing it up. The only problem is the sides didn't come together to form a level plane. ( There was a little"step", which I couldn't reach from the inside to put pressure on to level it out.) So I'll have to do a little sanding. All in all, it worked quite well. Thanks again.

Re: Dutchmen in a crack

#9

Re: Dutchmen in a crack

Parker Nicholson

>Like this?


img

Re: Dutchmen in a crack

#10

Re: Dutchmen in a crack *LINK*

david

>We had a short demonstration on butterfly patches at our last club meeting. A turner on Hawaii island has developed a method and is marketing it here:


Butterfly Patch Webpage

Re: Dutchmen in a crack

#11

Re: Dutchmen in a crack

Doug Leite

>At David's link, Mark explains it well enough. If you need further clarification, PM me and I can send an instruction sheet that I prepared years ago. Although Mark was not the originator of this process, he provides good templates and inserts.

Aloha, Doug

Re: Dutchmen in a crack

#12

Re: Dutchmen in a crack

Dale Cook

>Hi eliot,most of my pieces that I've fixed are from drying after rough turning. Most of them that creates the crack are large pieces with a fairly large tendon and that's where they crack. One I just repaired was 1/4 inch wide and about 3 inches long. It took about two weeks to close. Being it's only rough turned I can smooth every thing out and save a piece or two. I also started drilling holes in the bottom of the tendon to help relieve some pressure before drying.Good luck.

Re: Dutchmen in a crack

#13

Re: Thanks for the tip, Dale.

Allen Neighbors

>Drilling a hole in the bottom of the tenon to help prevent cracking on a drying rough-out. Good idea. Thanks.

Re: Dutchmen in a crack

#14

Re: Dutchmen in a crack

eliot d

>Dale, I never thought about drilling holes in the tenon. It sounds promising. Where, exactly do you drill the holes? I mean from what direction? Do you mean along the axis of the lathe in numerous places on the bottom -- or perpendicular to it around a circumference? I'm worried that there would still be thick portions of the bottom adjacent to thin portions where the form was already hollowed out, and that would still promote cracking. What diameter hole do you use?

Re: Dutchmen in a crack

#15

Re: Dutchmen in a crack

Dale Cook

>Hi Eliot, my tendon is usually around 4 inches in diameter and the distance from the bottom of the tendon to the bottom of the piece varies,but I'll drill some holes, 1 to 1 1/4, from the bottom up,usually 3 being careful not to go past where I'll part it off.A-lot of my large turnings are end-grain with the pith in the middle so I'll try to drill out some of the pith with one of the holes.It's mostly to remove some of the bulk of wood in that area. Merry Christmas and happy turning!