Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Need another tree identified

Posts

Need another tree identified

#1

Need another tree identified

Ray Johnson

>My neighbor took down a large tree a few days ago. It had three large trunks. He thought it was popular then yesterday he thought it was cottonwood although I don't remember seeing the white fluffy stuff that is normally with cottonwood in the summer. The wood is very wet more so than other fresh cut wood. Thanks.


img

Re: Need another tree identified

#2

Re: Need another tree identified

Del Williams

>Sort of looks like it might be sweetgum. The dark center of the bole and wet wood are both often found. Any hints from the leaves on the ground or last year's fruiting bodies? Sweetgum has spiny balls as fruits - pretty uncomfortable to step on barefoot.

Re: Need another tree identified

#3

Re: Looks like it's checking pretty

Allen Neighbors

>fast, too. Could it be black walnut?

Re: Need another tree identified

#4

Re: Need another tree identified

Mike Rubes, Apex, NC

>Hi Ray,

I am not sure what it is, but I am almost certain it isn't sweetgum. The insides can look stained like that, but the bark on yours is too smooth, I think, for sweetgum.

Give it a turn and see how it works!

Good luck,

Mike

"Me time" in the shop in Apex, NC...

Re: Need another tree identified

#5

Brad Vietje

I Love These Mysteries !

Brad Vietje

>...I just wish people would tell us where the tree comes from... If I see a post from Upstate NY, or Maine I can make a pretty good guess. I know nada about the trees of Nevada (are there trees in Nevada ?) or Alabama, so regional information would be real helpful.

Any additional information, like the leaves, or the little balls from the Sweet Gum, or if it was an ornamental planted for landscaping (could be from anywhere and naturalized for the landscape trade) could also help a lot.

BTW, with that strong sapwood contrast, it looks like a great wood for some natural-edge bowls -- have fun !

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Need another tree identified

#6

Re: I Love These Mysteries !

Bill Hale / Woodspinner

>Brad

I have said that over and over but nobody seems to listen.

WHERE THE HECK DID IT COME FROM ? WAS IT NATIVE ? DID IT LOSE ITS LEAVES ? AND ANYTHING ELSE YOU CAN TELL US ABOUT THE TREE.

Bill in Casa Grande, AZ.

Re: Need another tree identified

#7

Re: Need another tree identified

Mike Nelson

>With that bark, you can rule out Cottonwood. Does look a little like walnut but then again you have that smooth bark. Where's Leo?

Re: Need another tree identified

#8

Tree is from Washington State.

Ray Johnson

>There were three large trunks all about the same size. It was probably 40-50' tall. Neighbor said that it was there before he moved in 30 years ago. Can't remember what the leaves were like. Soil here is a nice loam - no rocks or clay. I will cut some blanks tomorrow. Need to get some alcohol so I can do the Dave Smith method of drying the blanks.


img

Re: Need another tree identified

#9

Re: Need another tree identified

RevDoug

>Your neighbor had it right the first time. It is black heart popular. Absolutely beautiful stuff.

Turn 'em round,

Re: Need another tree identified

#10

Re: Need another tree identified

Ed Karch

>Washington state is out of the natural range of sweetgum or poplar (Lyrodendron). Could be one of the west coast walnuts. Can't really tell from pictures of logs where the only real clue is bark.

Re: Need another tree identified

#11

Leo Van Der Loo

Black Cottonwood, aka Western Balsam poplar

Leo Van Der Loo

>That's not a for sure, but my best bet without any leaves or twigs

Re: Need another tree identified

#12

Amen, Rev Doug

Dave Smith, Longview, WA

>Hi Ray,

When you called me Thursday you said there was noting special about the wood. Now you show the whole world the nice looking color after I passed on it.

I agree with Rev Doug. Black Cottonwood, Populus trichocarpa. It is the common cottonwood in these here country.

Dave Smith

Planning to steal some cottonwood in Longview, WA

Re: Need another tree identified

#13

Come on up and get some!

Ray Johnson

>

Re: Need another tree identified

#14

Thanks for the responses

Ray Johnson

>

Re: Need another tree identified

#15

Re: Thanks for the responses

gtwilkins

>Black Cottonwood, lots of it in Southern B.C. if it is really fresh, hang shower curtains around the lathe cos you is going to get wet. Turns beautifully, dries well, super strong and light when dry!

Couple of tricks, if it is wet stand your blocks on end, if you leave them on one side the weight will be all on that side of the chunk and it becomes very apparent very quickly.

Do not try to hold either a tenon or recess in the sap wood anywhere near the sap/heart interface, it will let go and separate right down the line, don't ask how I learned this, my shoulder is still sore!

When finished roughing, turn the lathe speed up and if you have an air hose blow the free liquid out from the inside, it is amazing the amount of juice that flies out.

Trevor