Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Turning Commission Success (long)

Posts

Turning Commission Success (long)

#1

Brad Vietje

Turning Commission Success (long)

Brad Vietje

>A while back, Hooligan started a good discussion that started about collar design, but ended up discussing the problems with taking on commission work.

I recently completed a commission job that went pretty well, but it did add stress to my life in terms of getting the design right, and getting the project done as discussed and on time. The gory details follow:

A friend approached me about making a 50th anniversary gift for his parents -- further complicated because it was to be a gift from him and his two brothers, who all live in different states. The problem was they wanted a functional flower vase, turned from an attractive wood. By functional, they meant cut flowers, which means water. Now I'm pretty strict about water and turned wood -- in my book they should only meet during wet sanding. So this was a challange.

I had formulated a few designs in my head an on napkins and such, then we sat down to come up with something my friend would like, that his brothers would like, and that his parents would like. This face-to-face meeting and discussion about the realities and design challanges was really critical -- some of their notions just wouldn't work. By the time I left, we had worked out a design that made everyone happy (subject to confirmation by e-mail of the other brothers over the next few days, of course -- engineers all...)

We ended up lifting a basic profile from Jules Tattersall as pictured in Woodturning Masterclass, by Tony Boase, with design modifications to accomodate water. The basic plan was a 10" - 12" tall Black Cherry hollow form, turned right on the pith and perforated both top and bottom, with a copper insert to contain the flowers and fluids. This was rough turned to 3/4" back in July, and finish turned to 1/2" a few weeks ago. The hole in the bottom was to let water and condensation out. The copper insert is a 1.5" copper pipe with an end cap at the bottom, and a flared top. The flared top is a 1.5" to 2" copper adaptor, cut off above the flare, and hammered to create both shape and texture. The insert is suspended on 3 small (1/4") black plastic bumpers at the top, and three small faucet washers glued onto the bottom of the insert to keep the copper from touching the wood. The insert sits in a recess turned into the inside of the base, and the base sits on three more little black plastic bumpers so it won't trap any fluid that drains down the inside. (For those of you in dry climates, a copper pipe filled with water will sweat quite a bit here in the humid Northeast during summer.) The whole works has 5 coats of spar varnish inside and out for water resistance.

Throughout this process, communication was essential for successful completion. The actual anniversary was in August, so right up front I had to establish a timeline that they could live with. I also photographed the progress, from log through rough turning to finished product, so my friend could hold back his impatient brothers with timely updates. This was a real technical challange (allowing for water) and my answer was a removable insert and "moisture management" by eliminating any contact between insert and wood, and getting the whole works up off the table just a bit. The finish is far glossier than I would prefer -- the first three coats were satin spar varnish, which looked terrible and wouldn't level out brush marks at all -- so I decided that glossy dipped-in-plastic was far better than dull and ugly dipped-in-plastic.

I presented the finished piece to my customer just before Thanksgiving, when the entire family would gather, and the gift would be presented. They were very happy with the end product, and I received the attached photo from the parents, who were thrilled with their new vase, which is shown in their home. The finished piece is 10" diameter and about 11" tall.

I'm generally reluctant to take on many of this sort of job, since I'd rather create what I want, and allow the customers to either buy it or not. However, it was a fun challange that I enjoyed a lot -- I hope you all have low-stress success with any commissions you take on, too.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT


img

Re: Turning Commission Success (long)

#2

Brad Vietje

Re: Turning Commission Success (long)

Brad Vietje

>Sitting on 685 pounds of mustard before final turning...


img

Re: Turning Commission Success (long)

#3

Re: Turning Commission Success (long)

RK in Milwaukee

>Brad, that is a beautiful job and a great solution to a problem. Thanks for sharing!

Ron Nelson

Re: Turning Commission Success (long)

#4

Good Job!!! That was a nice post.

MIke from St. Clair Shores

>

Re: Turning Commission Success (long)

#5

Way too much for me

gouge55

>Nice results with your piece Brad. The whole process sounds like way too much stress and trouble for me. I have been approached to do commissions a couple of times, but declined because I didn't want the stress of trying to meet someone else's expectations. I take the approach that I will make what suits me, if people like it and want to buy it that's great. I will change what I do, somewhat, to produce a product that seems to be more in demand, but I like to retain the artistic license.

I have done a couple of simple commissions that involved only a general direction to go (bowl, vase...) and option of material (which woods). Those went fine, and if the buyers did not like the results, it didn't bother me, as I could sell the piece elsewhere.

It takes real patience to let someone else dictate your work. My hat's off to you.

Mike

Re: Turning Commission Success (long)

#6

JL

Re: Very nice!...

JL

>and an excellent story. Maybe a shop shots or an article about it?

Re: Turning Commission Success (long)

#7

Re: Turning Commission Success (long)

David Hammond, in Fayetteville at the moment

>Nice piece Brad, and an extra congrats goes to doing it as a commission. I know that must have added a lot of pressure, but you got a certain amount of satisfaction out of it that you wouldn't have otherwise.

Keep it up!

David

Re: Turning Commission Success (long)

#8

Re: Turning Commission Success (long)

George Van

>Thanks for the story Brad. I can see why they were so pleased!

Re: Turning Commission Success (long)

#9

Re: Turning Commission Success (long)

Allen Neighbors

>Brad, it's sure a fine piece of work! I too would like to read an article on the whole procedure. It would help some who may get into commission work later, to not make some bad mistakes.

Thanks for posting this interesting piece.

Re: Turning Commission Success (long)

#10

Re: Turning Commission Success (long)

Bob Fawcett

>Great looking piece Brad and a good story too.

You are to be commended on your patience. Thats got to be difficult enough to satisfy one customer, much less a whole family.

Re: Turning Commission Success (long)

#11

Brad Vietje

Re: Way too much for me

Brad Vietje

>Thanks, Mike. The key was taking enough time to make sure we were both pleased, so I could enjoy the process, too.

On another occasion I had minimal input, more like "...we trust your judgement, and we'll like what you come up with...be creative..." I'll never do that sort of thing again, since it is usually a recipe for failure. Now, if they say "hey, Brad, I'd love to see an Apple Hollow form, or a Lilac bottle stopper, then I can make them in my own sweet time, and call them to see if they're interested when they're finished -- or sell them to someone else, if not. I would retain the control to make what I liked, and when I felt like doing it.

Hope you're snug & warm up in Alaska, Mike -- it's +4F here right now... Sure makes me wish I had a real shop like yours !

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Turning Commission Success (long)

#12

Brad Vietje

Re: Very nice!...

Brad Vietje

>Thanks, JL. I'm sure that was plenty for people to read for now -- maybe a shorter, more general commentary on taking commissions -- what works and what doesn't. And better photos, too ! My camera has some better shots in it, but like a dodo I left it at my brother's at Thanksgiving, so I don't have better photos until I get it back.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Turning Commission Success (long)

#13

Brad Vietje

Re: Turning Commission Success (long)

Brad Vietje

>Thanks Ron, Mike and George. I hoped it might help people realize how much fuss can go into making something on commission -- especially a vase for which ceramics or glass might be a better medium. If everyone is real clear about the end result right up front, including how long it takes, things can go well.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Turning Commission Success (long)

#14

Keith Tompkins

Re: Turning Commission Success (long)

Keith Tompkins

>Well done as usual, Brad. You are certainly patient!

Re: Turning Commission Success (long)

#15

Re: Turning Commission Success (long)

Bill Hale / Woodspinner

>No that is one fine piece. I love the copper lip. very delicate

Bill in Casa Grande, AZ.

Re: Turning Commission Success (long)

#16

Brad Vietje

Re: Turning Commission Success (long)

Brad Vietje

>Thanks Guys, I appreciate the comments.

The copper insert was a lot of fun, especially since I have no metal-working tools here. I've seen a metal-spinner shape thin sheets of copper and other metals, so I figured I could just grab the 1-1/2" to 2" adaptor in the Stronghold chick and flare it outward... fat chance ! The copper fittings are much thicker than the thin sheets used for metal spinning, and a harder alloy, too. Try as I might, I could make very little progress other than cutting off the excess height. I also used the lathe to cut the pipe to length, since my pipe cutters only handle up to 1.25".

I turned a wooden plug, sorta like a chuck to fit the small end, and a cone that I thought I could pound into the wide end of the copper to flare it outward, but no way. Having no anvil or other forms to pound the adaptor onto or over, I hit upon an idea -- I placed a 14 pound sledge hammer handle-down on a sawhorse, with the handle running down between the paired 2 x 4 horizontals, and voila ! -- an anvil ! Using the wooden plug and a hammer, I pounded the open larger end of the copper piece down onto the beveled corner of the sledge hammer, while rotating the piece between each strike, which worked like a charm. Eventually I could use a ball-peen hammer to shape it to the desired curved flare. The entire process was a blast, I must say.

When my camera returns home, I'll try and post a pic of the copper rim at the top, which I had a lot of fun making.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT