Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

test finial

Posts

test finial

#1

test finial

john lucas

>This has been one of those disaster day. Remote switch went out on my Powermatic. Rewired that. My homemade wrench/allen wrench that use to adjust my hollowing tools broke. The elm piece I am turning started to check on the ends, (don't know why that happened unless it didn't like all air I was blowing in to clear the shavings out). Started up my propane heater and it died.

Could not hollow this piece all the way to the outer edges with the tools I have. I'll have to make or modify a tool if I do any more of these. I did get it down to 1/2" at the outer edges so I left the bottom around that dimension also.

Anyway, this all started because I was going to carve a bowl for one of our Fundraisers at work. The wood I was going to carve looked great on the outside. Sucked big time once I started carving. There's just no figure left at all. He won't like it. So I grabbed an old elm log and started hollowing. I like this piece but I'm severly limited on my good wood finial supply. Consequently I'm making test finials out of 2x4's and painting them to simulate the look and test the form. Here's the second one. I'll get your opinions. Let me know what I need to change. I'm not thrilled with this one. To many cove shapes I think. Anyway let me know what to change.


img

Re: test finial

#2

Keith Tompkins

Re: test finial

Keith Tompkins

>HI John, sorry you had such a bad day....Here's my re-do, eliminating some elements, and rounding over the others. Filets added to separate the elements that remain, then flow to the tip. I enlarged the tip a bit.

I reversed the curve on the rim to help tie things together...any help? Just a freehand sketch, but you get the idea.


img

Re: test finial

#3

Re: test finial

john lucas

>Keith That's a big help. I might leave out the lower cove on your design and just go straight to the ogee going into the finial. I'll try that tomorrow and see how it works. I'm going to have to sell this idea to my friend who thought I was carving a bowl.

Re: test finial

#4

Leo Van Der Loo

Sorry John, the HF looks great without the finial

Leo Van Der Loo

>just a small collar is all it needs, IMO, finial doesn't add to the total.

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: test finial

#5

Keith Tompkins

Re: test finial

Keith Tompkins

>I hope it helps JOhn, post a photo when done...that would be interesting. Finials aren't my "signature" thing, I just love to turn them....fun fun!

Re: test finial

#6

Re: test finial

eliot d

>I have ti agree with Leo; I think it's a fine looking vessel without the finial, no matter what you do with the finial.

Too bad about your bad day. Hope tomorrow is better!

Re: test finial

#7

Re: test finial

john lucas

>Keith I think I've decided on another style finial altogether. I'm going to make the top 2/3's somewhat icecream cone shaped and then carve flutes into it. I tried to scan the drawing but Apparently I've forgotten how to operate my scanner. Why do computer things have to be so complicated.

Re: test finial

#8

Re: test finial

john lucas

>Leo and eliot. Normally I like collars but my customer want's something special so I need to make it go beyond the ordinary and inject some of me into it. That's why I've decided to change the whole look of the finial. I may also add some texture to the vessel itself.

Re: test finial

#9

excellent decision, John : )

Ruth Niles

>

Re: test finial

#10

Jumping in here...

david

>John:

I will perhaps be the contrary voice here, but I say leave it just as it is! I think it is great! I know some say you should try to repeat the shape of the form somewhere in the finial, but just on proportion and eyeball, I really like what you came up with. If this is just a test finial, as you said, and need to make a final one any way...the only thing I would change is make the top form just slightly smaller. If you could use the finial as is, I would!