Re: Explanation Plz For Non Canadians
Dinyar Chavda
>Peter, it does my heart good to know that there are still intelligent people who expect words to mean what the dictionary days they do.
I have come to the conclusion that any bill with a title (other than a number, or the names of the sponsors), be it domestic or international, is actually intended to do the exact opposite of what the title says. With regard to NAFTA, there are Americans who regard it with the same sentiment as you do, particularly in so far as the relationship between the US and Mexico is concerned.
Any such title is, imj (I got tired of "imo", and "judgement" soundsso much more weighty than "opinion"--can you tell my consulting roots run deep and not silent--that was blatant pandering to old movie buffs!), but I digress. Any such title is, imj, meant to hide the fact that theare are five real intentions of a title like Nafta.
One, no one would name a bill that is titled, WWTSU (We Want To Screw You)---it's unpronounceable (We Really Want To Screw You is only marginally better).
Secondly, neither party would agree to an international bill like that. Similarly, in a domestic bill, any such honesty is frowned upon rather severely.
Third, it provides material for negative ads in the next election, regardless of whether the elected official voted for it or against it.
Fourth, it is a way to get the electorate in favor of it, which only focuses on the catchy title, and never bothers to read any analysis of the true intent of the bill. (I know, I know, a "We Really Want to Screw You" also is appealing on that ground, but goes against self-perceptions of being civilized)
And fifth, it makes it easier to pass amendments and future adjustments that improve or correct the "Free Trade Agreement"!
However, as I said, earlier, it does that cynical heart good to remember when I, too, had a trusting, innocent perspective, and hopes for the dawning of the age of Aquarius.