Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Survey: Biggest challenges to getting "better"?

Posts

Survey: Biggest challenges to getting "better"?

#1

Steven Antonucci

Survey: Biggest challenges to getting "better"?

steve antonucci

>I've been kicking this around for a while, and I'm going to ask you all:

What is the biggest thing holding you back from being "better" as a woodturner? Answers I expect will vary from equipment to technique to ??? And as a follow-up, what are you doing to "fix the problem?"

My first knee jerk reaction to this is time. In the past, I've had way more "me time" than I do these days, and my time at the lathe was more valuable than my "finishing time". I've always enjoyed sending streams of wet wood in the air way more than sanding and my work shows it.

In an effort to produce higher quality work (in much less quantity), I've started spending more time on projects once they're off the lathe than time on the lathe. I sand, hand scrape, and wetsand until about 320 grit and I have seen a huge improvement in the final product. No more torn endgrain, or blotchy finishes. Baby butt smooth. By slowing down my process, I have actually learned to "like" sanding (ok, tolerate it :-) and I am much happier with my final product.

So what's your problem? Inquiring minds want to know.

Steve

Re: Survey: Biggest challenges to getting "better"?

#2

Time...or lack of.

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>I seem to have only sporadic sessions in my shop. An hour here....and hour there. Very rarely do I get an afternoon or a full uninterrupted evening in my shop to delve into my work. Seems like it's been more and more like that lately.

I would say TIME at the lathe which translates to PRACTICE, is the main thing holding me back.

Jen

Re: Survey: Biggest challenges to getting "better"?

#3

Re: Survey: Biggest challenges to getting "better"

Carole Valentine

>I would have to say wall thickness and consistency. I am much better at it than I used to be but not good enough to be completely satisfied or to turn very thin-walled hollow forms. I got some slightly better calipers than the ones I was using and that has helped a lot. I would like to have a laser system, but I don't use a hollowing rig since I always swivel my headstock for hollowing. I tried not swiveling the HS the other day and was very uncomfortable. How quickly we get spoiled! I bet if I could just get to AZ, Wally would have me turning super thin-walled vessels with confidence in no time!:))

Re: Survey: Biggest challenges to getting "better"?

#4

Re: Survey: Biggest challenges to getting "better"

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Thin walls are easy....just remove wood until it's thin!!

Wally

Re: Survey: Biggest challenges to getting "better"?

#5

Re: Time...or lack of.

Don in Central Illinis

>I agree. My biggest holdup is time and as Jennifer says equates to practice. Remember, practice does not make perfect, perfect practice make perfect!

Re: Survey: Biggest challenges to getting "better"?

#6

Re: Survey: Biggest challenges to getting "better"

Sean Troy

>Wally is right. It's only as hard as you think it is.

Re: Survey: Biggest challenges to getting "better"?

#7

Re: Survey: Biggest challenges to getting "better"

Carole Valentine

>Yeah, it's the stopping before they get non-existent that's the hard part!

Re: Survey: Biggest challenges to getting "better"?

#8

Re: Survey: Biggest challenges to getting "better"

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Carole, when the inside diameter is larger than the outside diameter you've gone too far.

Wally

Re: Survey: Biggest challenges to getting "better"?

#9

Biggest challenge: Wood

Rick Davenport

>Of course time to turn and practice and perfect is what we all need.

But developing an inventory of turning wood in various stages of seasoning is a huge challenge.

Once again it takes time: months and years.

I envy the long time turners who have tons of wood available to them to turn what they want, when they want.

R

Re: Survey: Biggest challenges to getting "better"?

#10

Re: Biggest challenge: Wood

Carole Valentine

>I know exactly what you mean, Rick. That's why I turn mostly minis and small pieces. It's easier for me to get (don't have anyone to help with big logs) and plus I had a lot of small blanks that folks from WC sent me last Valentine's day. Without that wood, I would really be hurting for turning stock. I did get a bunch of walnut from a big tree that fell at church - nearly killed my self getting it home. Every single piece of it developed ring shake! I have never seen that in Walnut. All that work for nothing. I don't even have a woodstove to burn it in! LOL If I come into a windfall, I will share with you. :)

Re: Survey: Biggest challenges to getting "better"?

#11

Re: Survey: Biggest challenges to getting "better"

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>In my case, it's probably motivation. It's easy to get in a rut. Lately I've been spending more time on enhancing work than on new forms etc. I end up tossing a piece once in a while because a new idea hasn't worked out well. Like a lot of us, I'm very critical of my own work. (I used to save discards to casually toss in the fireplace in front of guests. Sometimes caused quit a stir.)

I do a lot of teaching. I much prefer to teach advanced classes because I find that I learn a lot from working with the students when we're discussing and developing new ideas and techniques.

Wally

Re: Survey: Biggest challenges to getting "better"?

#12

Biggest challenges: speed + quality

Devon Palmer

>Steve,

Like you, I'm trying to improve my quality without the loss in productivity. I'm trying to focus on working smarter and with better technique along with learning new "disciplines" (Multi-axis/center, architechtural, segmented, etc.)

Its driven me to make a few changes like switch to M4 particle metals from M2/A11/V15 to get/maintain sharper edges (cut my sanding time significantly, can start at 120 grit or better), getting RID of my ellsworth grind, switching to 3m purple 5" Ceramic (SG) sanding disks (can sand a 15" bowl from 120-400, inside and out, 10 minutes), and making bowls with a catenary profile for strength and access with tooling.

Keep in mind, when I grow up I wanna be a production turner like David Lancaster and spend some time "in the trenches". As I get better, I leverage the skills more creatively. Your work is spectacular, and you're talent is far beyond mine... I'll get there someday :)

Great discussion topic.

Re: Survey: Biggest challenges to getting "better"?

#13

Re: Time...or lack of.

bowlman

>From what I have seen of your work, whatever time you get to spend turning is well worth it. I personally think your work is on a par with the best out there! I can only guess what would happen if you could spend say 4 hours per day at the lathe. WOW!!!

Re: Survey: Biggest challenges to getting "better"?

#14

Steven Antonucci

Or when the negative space > positive space

steve antonucci

>

Re: Survey: Biggest challenges to getting "better"?

#15

Re: Survey: Biggest challenges to getting "better"

bowlman

>Hollow form turning ... I have not done much recently due to the stress on my joints. After blowing out my left rotator cuff I am VERY careful about such things. Maybe Santa will deliver one of those neat captive bar hollowing rigs and a Don Pencil or John Jordan hollowing tool. Hear me Santa? Listen up, fat man ... git 'er did!

Re: Survey: Biggest challenges to getting "better"?

#16

Re: Biggest challenges: speed + quality

Barry Irby

>I don't want to hijack the thread, but I am curious. Why did you get rid of your Ellsworth Grind and what did you replace it with? I like mine, but I was wondering what you have found that is better?

Re: Survey: Biggest challenges to getting "better"?

#17

Steven Antonucci

Thanks for the compliment-

steve antonucci

>but are you sure you've got the right Steve? I am getting better, but far from spectacular. Once in a while, I do something worthy of those accolades, but you should see my burn pile.

Now to a non turner, I am the end-all-be-all wood guy. You should see people fight over the burn pile. Go figure.

Steve

Re: Survey: Biggest challenges to getting "better"?

#18

Better?

John Lucas

>I depends on how you define Better. for me better means trying to speak with my turnings. I can turn most anything, and have (except for a Johann Michelson hat and I'll do that someday). My problems, besides having any time are finding a theme that I want to explore. I tend to bounce around all over the place. Mostly because I get stuck either making presents, doing commission work, or doing production products to make enough money to support this hobby.

To learn skill I think John Jordan said it best. Turn a 100 of anything. I think you could reduce this at first. just turn 10 of something. The more you turn the better you are at tool control and this lets you control the shape. Looking at 10 or more will teach you to refine the shape and then you start seeing other possibilities either related to that shape or you get ideas to advance from that basic shape.

Over the last 3 or 4 years we've gotten to watch some really interesting growth among some of the WC group. Carole's pieces have really refined shapes. Jennifer is moving in a really neat direction and I can't wait to see where they go. Molly found a style that is recognizeable and it's been really neat to see her pieces change. And of course we've seen Andi Wolfe just take off, each piece is an improvement over the last.

I think they all owe this to sticking with a style long enough to really explore it and see where it goes. I've sort of done that with Hand mirrors and christmas ornaments but there are so many more avenues I could explore with just these two subjects if I had time.

Re: Survey: Biggest challenges to getting "better"?

#19

Re: Biggest challenges: speed + quality

Tony Reynolds somewhere near Newark, Ohio

>Devon,

Sound like we have similar goals. Just curious as to why you don't like the swept back grind? We need to get together one of these days. We've already met over at WoodWerks when I was buying the Oneway vacuum chuck if you remember.

tony

Re: Survey: Biggest challenges to getting "better"?

#20

Rick, Where Do You Live?

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>

Re: Survey: Biggest challenges to getting "better"?

#21

JL

Re: 2nd the time...

JL

>Between my commute to and from work and my commute to the new house on weekends, I don't seem to have enough. When I go up to the mountains on weekends, I don't have a lathe and I do contstruction carpentry (and painting). I don't do hardly any bowls. I do mostly furniture. I've been exploring angles and form. I'm comfortable enough with bamboo style. The baluster globes and coves are getting better.

Re: Survey: Biggest challenges to getting "better"?

#22

Re: Time...or lack of.

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Mr. Gerard, you are a gem :)

Re: Survey: Biggest challenges to getting "better"?

#23

Time and wood

Bob Fawcett

>I either don't have as much time as I wish, or don't have the wood to turn what came to mind.

As an amateur and a beginner it is sometimes overwhelming. I have to make a living so time is limited. Where I live, woodselection is limited as far as local wood is concerned. I can get oak and ... not much else.

I am sure I could do better in both categories, I just haven't found the magic yet. Its out there. Wish I had a mentor.

Re: Survey: Biggest challenges to getting "better"?

#24

Heat

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ont.

>Well,

I do most of my turning in the late fall and into the winter in an unheated shop, I do have a small 4800 watt heater, but it takes a long time to heat up my shop, my tools are always cold..

Brrrrrrr

Take care,

Jim

Re: Survey: Biggest challenges to getting "better"?

#25

Re: Heat

Bob Fawcett

>I don't have that problem. Come on down here!

South Georgia is usually warm, but even what we call cold is probably not even close to yours.