Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Skew discussion

Posts

Skew discussion

#1

Skew discussion

john lucas

>I had a discussion with another club member last night and thought wit would be interesting here. What kind of skew do you have, oval, flat, how thick, high wide. Do you prefer curved or straight edge and why. How do you sharpen and how sharp.

My favorite skew is a 1" oval with a straight edge. It doesn't have to be oval my rectangular skew works just as well except it's high carbon steel so I don't use it as much as my HSS oval skew. I sharpen on the grinder to a hollow grind and then finish sharpening with diamond hones up to 1200 grit and then I use a strop. I think the skew works better when it's sharp enough to shave hair. In reality I don't usually keep it that sharp but shoot for that.

So what do you all use?

Re: Skew discussion

#2

Re: Skew discussion

Tony Reynolds somewhere near Newark, Ohio

>I use a 1" and 1/2" oval with straight edge and sharpen much the same way. I just purchased a new 1 3/8" by 1/4" thick Hamlet with a curved edge that I'm going try try out. I think I'll like the heavier weight. The oval Sorby's are so light.

Tony

Re: Skew discussion

#3

Re: Skew discussion

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>My new favorite is a 1/2" Kryo by Henry Taylor. I has rolled edges and a straight edge. I sharpen it with a hollow grind, then hone with an extrafine diamond card. I love it for turning pens and bottlestoppers.

I also have a 3//4" carbon straight edge and a 1" HSS straight edge.

keithz

Re: Skew discussion

#4

Re: Skew discussion

John Kyler

>I have both Lacer skews. I use the 5/8 the most of the two.

I also have a 1" traditional (straight) Sorby that I have ground/polished the bottom round and top softened like the Lacer's. That one I use the most of all three.

I have used the ovals and wont buy one. I would maybe use it to open paint cans.

To each their own. But I dont like the ovals.

John

Re: Skew discussion

#5

Re: Skew discussion

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>I have a couple skews and have been really striving to learn to get better at using them.

My favorite one is my new 1" Skew (Benjamin's Best from PSI). It has your standard grind on it. My next one is my old Sorby 3/4" Oval skew. I recently put a curved grind on it and have found it a bit more friendly. Not much, just a bit. I also have a 1/2" skew and a 1/4" round skew.

Of all of my Skews, I like using the 3 Point tool most of all. Yeah, I know. Once I found how easy it was to turn a bead with one of those 3 Point tools, I've been neglecting my skews. But I have given them all cool nick names.

I call the 1" skew "The Obsenity Generator". The 3/4" Skew is "Blank Destroyer". My 1/2" Skew I call "Kindling Maker". And finally cause it looks so nice and harmless, but is NEITHER I call my 1/4" round skew "Damien: Omen Too". As in "OH MAN! I ruined THIS blank TOO!

:>)

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: Skew discussion

#6

Steven Antonucci

Three different ones...

steve antonucci

>My main skew is a 1" flat Sorby that I sharpen with a concave profile on my Tormek. I like the rounded edge because it kept me out of trouble before I knew how to use a skew.

I also have a 1/4" flat Sorby that I have sharpened with a straight profile, since the edge is too small to effectively round.

Somewhere, I had a Craftsman 1/2" skew that I didn't use very much and I either gave it away or reground the end into a scraper or something... I don't recall. It may just be under a big pile of shavings somewhere, too. The world may never know.

All of my tools are stropped after I sharpen them on the Tormek. I'm too lazy to spend a lot of time on it, so I mostly just run them across a hand strop. Skews might get 3 passes either side, and then back to the lathe. I've cut myself something aweful on them, so I know they're sharp...

Re: Skew discussion

#7

Steven Antonucci

That's some funny stuff, Dom :-)

steve antonucci

>I would expect that you'll eventually rename one "The Spiral Maker" or the "Highly-Figured Expensive Pen Blank Exploder".

Like you, I reach for the point tool when that little voice starts talking about using a skew to turn a bead.

Re: Skew discussion

#8

Re: Skew discussion

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ont.

>Hi John,

I have 5 skews. I think I mostly use two of them, a 3/4 and a 1/2. Both are flat stock with a rounded heal, straing profile. Like you I hollow grind them then hone them on a fine diamond plate.

The other skews are two ovals that I do not use any more and another 3/4 that I have ground down so often it's at my knuckles...not sure what I can do with it...all my skews are Crown and I have found them to be fine for my work.

take care,

Jim

Re: Skew discussion

#9

Re: Skew discussion

Jorge Castaneda

>I grew in the faith of the skew, the skew and nothing but the skew,

so I have several, I used to have more but I am down to:1 3/4", 1 1/2" straight sides and straight edge, 1 1/4" straight sides and curved edge, it got that way after reading Raffan's book, 3/4" oval sides and straight edge, 1/2" japanese with straight sides and stright edge. I sharpen all with oil stones down to hard arkansas and get very sharp edges, the one with the curved edge is sharpened with the veritas jig.

I use the large ones to remove a lot in a hurry but the 3/4" and 1/2" are by far the ones that the hand picks more often, the japanese takes a very keen edge and holds it. If by chance my 'scary sharp" set up is out, they get the initial steps with the wet dry sand papers,wet, but the final ones are always with the arkansas oil stones, hard black and translucent. I think that honing real good make sthe edge last longer and the cut is better.

$0.02

Jorge

Re: Skew discussion

#10

JL

Re: Skew discussion

JL

>My favorite is a 1 1/4" oval. I sharpen it with waterstones to 8000 grit. I then hone it with a leather wheel. I've got a 1" flat that I don't use much.

Re: Skew discussion

#11

Same here...

Scott Hurley in N. VA

>I've found the best use for my skew is to remove the bark from a piece of wet wood... (before I put it on the lathe)

Scott

Re: Skew discussion

#12

Re: Skew discussion

Hooligan

>I have three that are in use. 1/2" Flat, 5/8" Flat, and a 1 3/8" Flat. All are ground straight. All go from the 80 grit grinder wheel to a diamond file in extra fine, then are polished on some little leather honing contraption that goes in my drill press. They come off it like razors. It seems, as well, that I leave that leather disk in the drill press more than bits, I use skews a lot, and it takes 30 seconds to polish the edge.

Re: Skew discussion

#13

Re: Skew discussion

robo hippy

>I just got one of the Sorby Spindle masters, and like it better than my skews. I have an easier time cutting both coves and beads.

robo hippy

Re: Skew discussion

#14

Re: Skew discussion

Devon Palmer

>I have both of the Lacer skews as well, the 5/8's gets the most use - both ground with a dropped/rounded heel. I also have two sorby square skews. One is flat ground (1/2) that I use for pens, the other has a convex bevel.

The convex is sharpened on the grinder by running the skew up and down the wheel. Its VERY stable and I can plane/cut right up to the top tip without a problem of digging in - aka, the entire cutting surface is the sweet spot (unlike hollow ground). Only bad thing with this grind is that it stalls our on V cuts badly.

- Devon

Re: Skew discussion

#15

Re: Skew discussion *LINK*

Darrell Feltmate

>I have a 1" skew, a 3/4" that I ground from a parting tool that I never used, and a 1/4" round. They are used straight from the grinder and each has a straight grind. I have tried a curved edge and just do not like it although I can see how someone else would. I also have a 1" straight chisel that I use a lot for spindle work as well as a 3 point tool and a 1/4" skewchigouge.


Around the Woods

Re: Skew discussion

#16

Re: Skew discussion

john lucas

>Good discussion. I didn't mention all the other skews I have. I turn with a skew on almost every project. I have a really big 3" skew that's 3/8" thick. it's actually a little hard to use because it takes such a big bite. You have to really control it. If you've seen my mini goblets you know I have skews down to a little over 1/16".

I've played with a lot of grinds. I have skews sharpened from 20 to 45 degrees as measured from the center line of the skew (included angle is 40 to 90 as measured from bevel to bevel). I prefer around 25 degrees. My 90 degree is good for turning coves. The short bevel on this tool lets you make a fairly narrow cove or steeper Ogee's.

I tried the curved edge. I couldn't tell it made any difference to me. It was harder to see the toe when I used it toe down and it was harder to control at the bottom of a bead using the heel down. I also find it harder to grind the initial shape than a flat skew. That may just be me. If you like the round skew go for it, it just didn't work for me.

I've read several times about the oval skews being to light and vibrates. I haven't seen this. I've made thicker skews and don't see that they cut any different. I've turned large lamps and table legs using my "thin" oval skew with no problems. I certainly don't think a thicker bodied skew hurts. I turn mosly with the oval skew because I'm just used to it and it's my friend so I reach for that one most often.

I do recomment rounding the bottom non cutting edge of the skew. This makes it easier to slide on the tool rest and helps when cutting a bead.

I have several round skews. I like them a lot for smaller work. I find 3/8" is the practical large limit. The thickness of the skew on anything over 3/8" gets in the way when turing beads right beside each other.

I've used and owned a lot of the "skew" substitutes like the 3 point tool and the sorby thing that looks like a bowl gouge with no flute and the Dave Hout bowl skew. All work and in the hands of beginners are a little less catchy. They don't always cut as clean as the skew. Of course the Dave Hout bowl skew is designed for the inside of a bowl which you can't do with the skew. The

I have several round skews. I like them

Re: Skew discussion

#17

The skew is my friend, the skew is my....

Barry Irby

>friend, NOT.

I have a 1 1/4" Taylor Thai I hollow grind and have a curved edge. I have softened the corners on it because I finally realized I was never going to cut anything other than the rest with that particular steel. I have a half inch carbon steel one and a 1/4 round one.

I keep the big one at the lathe at all times in case the Ninjas attack while I am concentrating on master the bowl gouge. The quarter inch one is a great Icepick and the half inch one works great as a scraper for cutting a dovetail for chuck jaws.

What's the best video on mastering the skew. I want to master it. It really looks like the quintessential turning tool in the hands of someone who has whipped it. I've seen Raffin work with one and we have a guy in our club that will make you go Wow! Its my nest goal.

Re: Skew discussion

#18

Re: Skew discussion

John Kyler

>I guess I should say that I use my skew for most anything and on demos.

It is my go to tool, second only to my Pro PM 3/8 spindle with a fingernail grind. Then for bowls, I'm forced to set the skew down.

I watched Mr.Lacer's video and some instruction from my dad and love it.

Re: Skew discussion

#19

Re: The skew is my friend, the skew is my....

John Kyler

>Alan Lacer's videos are my choice.

There may be better, but I like the way he presents and explains what he is doing. Raffen is good with the skew, but Lacer is better.

MHO

Re: Skew discussion

#20

Re: The skew is my friend, the skew is my....

Tony Reynolds somewhere near Newark, Ohio

>I agree. I have the "Sweet side and the Dark side" Very good at showing the cuts. Of course the only way to master it isn't by watching the video. :)

Tony

Re: Skew discussion

#21

Re: The skew is my friend, the skew is my....

Bill White

>MIne is a "W. Butcher" cast steel, and it is very sharp. Flat ground, beautiful to look at, delightful to hold, and frightening to use. Maybe one day........

Bill

Re: Skew discussion

#22

Brad Vietje

Re: Skew discussion: slightly long response

Brad Vietje

>I use 3 skews pretty often:

3/4" wide, radiused with rounded corners both sides

1/2" wide straight, rounded corners on heel; square corners on toe

1" wide straight with square corners

I use the 3/4" the most. I like a gently curved skew a lot better than a straight edged one. I've recently been experimenting with Alan Lacer's new grind: straight across for 1/3, then a gentle curve for the rest. I'm not sure I like it better than a slight radius all the way across. He likes the small straight area for peeling cuts, which I found worked real well with a slight radius curve. I do not like making peeling cuts or sizing dovetail tenons with the straight angled skew -- MUCH more catchy. I also find that cutting a slight hollow across end grain, like the bottom of a box, is much easier with the curved skew, as the curve gives just enough clearance to make the hollow catch-free. If I pick up a straight skew and try the same cut, a catch is far more likely. A radiused edge also allows me to quickly shape the sides of a box a la Raffan, cutting with the curve and neither point touching, in a way I just can't do with a straight edge.

I started with the old 1" with square corners, which my dad got back in the 50's when he got his first lathe. I liked the square corners then because they had some bite on the rest, and didn't skid across when my technique lacked. Now I greatly prefer the rounded edges, having worked on my technique some, and have softened the square edges a bit.

The square cornered toe edge of the 1/2" works well for cutting across end grain with long point down.

My 3 cnets,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Skew discussion

#23

Lacer/Glaser

Greg Haugen

>I have two skews a "rolled edge" 1/2" Hamlet. And a custom made Lacer/Glaser 5/8" made by Alan Lacer with a Lacer turned 15" white oak handle and stainless steel ferrule. The Lacer/Glaser is my favorite tool next to my bowl gouge. It has a textbook Lacer grind on it, 1/3 flat then radius down, 70 degrees from point point. I grind it about once a month and the rest of the time I hone it with a Lacer diamond hone. Occasionally I do power hone it on a MDF wheel and white rogue running backwards.

Re: Skew discussion

#24

Re: Skew discussion

Ed in Sptbg.

>I'm surprised no one has mentioned using skews as scrapers (that is, flat on the tool rest). I use several sizes ground straight and curved that are invaluable for final shape refinement, end grain and side, of boxes and bottle stoppers. Using a light touch with a sharp edge leaves a surprisingly clean surface ready for light sanding.

Re: Skew discussion

#25

Re: Skew discussion

Bob Fawcett

>I have only one skew, a 3/4" Sorby oval I got when I started. I keep if flat ground, straight edge. I sharpen it on an extra fine diamond. Sometimes I hone it on a 8000 waterstone.

About the only cut I can make with a skew is a pommel. Sometimes I clean up by turning off the lathe and rotating the spindle by hand. If I keep the skew really sharp its almost like paring with a sharp chisel.