Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Sanding question

Posts

Re: Sanding question

#26

Re: Sanding question

Mkauder, Phenix City, AL

>Keith,

I only have one thing to disagree with in your post. I think that a turned piece must finished far better than most furniture pieces. A table or chair, etc is seldom examined as closely as a bowl held in the hands. Small point, but something I believe.

I certainly agree with you about most people working on quantity, not quality.

Mark

Re: Sanding question

#27

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: Sanding question

Dennis in Southern Oregon

>Jim, you got a lot of good advice in response to your question. I would add one more bit of advice that I did not see mentioned. If the turning is important to you, use fresh paper at each grit step. Worn-out paper of any given grit will not remove the scratches from the previous grit in any reasonable amount of time. Dennis

Re: Sanding question

#28

Re: Sanding question

Malcolm Tibbetts

>Allen, this piece is fairly small, about 5" in diameter. During the handheld scraping the speed was probably around 1000 rpm's. One thing to remember with this technique is that without the use of a tool rest, the burr will ride the surface and remove more side-grain than end-grain. Therefore, the technique should be used very sparingly in order to avoid distroying the roundness of your turning.

Re: Sanding question

#29

Mike Stafford

Re: Sanding question

Mike Stafford

>Malcolm,how do you protect your hands from the heat? Do you wear gloves? I have not used a cabinet scraper on the lathe but in my flat work it can get mighty hot when I work fast. I cannot imagine working faster than applying one to a spinning piece on a lathe....

Re: Sanding question

#30

Re: Sanding question

Malcolm Tibbetts

>Mike, I only "scrape" for a few seconds, not minutes. I don't do any shaping, I only remove the last tool markings, so heat isn't a problem. Also, I probably mis-spoke when I wrote "1000 rpm's"; my lathe does not have a speed readout - I think my speed is probably closer to 500 rpm's.

Re: Sanding question

#31

Re: Thanks, Malcolm

Allen Neighbors

>

Re: Sanding question

#32

Keith Tompkins

Re: Sanding question

Keith Tompkins

>You've got a point Mark. I've examined your pieces, and they are indeed sanded much finer than the vast majority of furniture pieces I've seen. However, there are cabinetmakers who use no sandpaper whatsoever....razor sharp planes, then scrapers to finish smooth. The surface these guys can achieve is about as perfect as can be....they argue that a sanded surface cannot compare. In general I agree with you, sanding marks on a turning stand out far more than on a furniture piece.